Abstract Specimen-based taxonomic research is essential for understanding diversity and setting management frameworks for threatened mammal faunas, and ancient DNA techniques are increasingly used to extract information from taxonomically relevant historical specimens. The largest survivors of the depleted Caribbean mammal fauna are hutias in the genus Capromys, which is usually interpreted as containing a single species, C. pilorides. Previous studies have demonstrated genetic differentiation of Capromys populations across Cuba, but infrageneric species diversity and nomenclature remain unclear. We conducted ancient DNA analysis of historical Capromys samples using cytochrome b and complete mitogenome data sets, and including the 19th-century holotypes of 2 species now considered synonyms, C. fournieri and C. geayi. Our analyses identify distinct western and central/eastern Capromys clades that diverged 1.75 Mya based upon mitogenome data. These clades are separated by the Havana–Matanzas Channel, which represented a barrier to dispersal throughout the Neogene–Quaternary. Divergence date comparisons with other hutia species provide support for interpreting divergence between Capromys populations as species-level differentiation. Although we were unable to yield amplifiable DNA from the C. fournieri holotype, our analyses confidently assign the C. geayi holotype to the western Capromys clade. We therefore recognize 2 extant Capromys species: C. geayi (western Cuba) and C. pilorides (central/eastern Cuba and Cayman Islands).
Read full abstract