Complete Medial Meniscectomy Research Articles

Poster 325: Untreated Ruptures of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament: a 54 Year Follow-Up Study

Poster 325: Untreated Ruptures of the Anterior Cruciate Ligament: a 54 Year Follow-Up Study

Surgical induced models of joint degeneration in the ovine stifle: Magnetic resonance imaging and histological assessment

BackgroundThe purposes of this study were to (1) validate and assess the reliability of a modified magnetic resonance semi-quantitative score (sheep Magnetic Resonance osteoarthritis Knee Score (sMOAKS)) to evaluate joint degeneration in the ovine knee and to (2) investigate whether the transection of the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL), isolated or in combination with meniscal injuries, reproduce the degenerative changes described in the meniscectomized sheep. MethodsTwenty sheep were randomly subjected to one of the following injuries to induce osteoarthritis (OA): ACL transection (ACLt), mid-body transection of the medial meniscus, ACLt combined with complete medial meniscectomy and complete medial meniscectomy. OA assessment was performed eight weeks postoperatively with sMOAKS, Mankin and Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) histological scores. ResultssMOAKS showed very good to excellent reliability (kappa=0.61 to 1.0) for the majority of features evaluated. sMOAKS revealed small differences between groups (p<0.05) being the ACLt group the most affected. We observed a strong positive correlation between the three scales in the evaluation of femoro-tibial articular cartilage (AC) (r=0.829, r=0.917, r=0.879). ConclusionssMOAKS is a reliable semi-quantitative Magnetic Resonance (MR) scale to evaluate and quantify the effect of different OA induction lesions in the ovine knee and presents a high correlation with Mankin and OARSI scales in the evaluation of femoro-tibial AC. Although minor differences were observed between the different surgical procedures for the induction of OA, ACLt proved to be the intervention that produced the highest amount of degeneration eight weeks postoperatively. Level of EvidenceII

Calcitonin delays the progress of early-stage mechanically induced osteoarthritis. In vivo, prospective study

Introducing new or testing existing drugs in an attempt to modify the progress of osteoarthritis (OA) is of paramount importance. This study aims to determine the effect exerted by Calcitonin on the progress of early-stage osteoarthritic lesions. We used 18, skeletally mature, white, female, New Zealand rabbits. OA was operatively induced in the right knee of each animal by the complete dissection of the anterior cruciate ligament, complete medial meniscectomy and partial dissection of the medial collateral ligament. Postoperatively, animals were divided into two groups. Starting on the ninth postoperative day and daily thereafter, group A animals (n=9) received 10IU oculus dexter (o.d.) of synthetic Calcitonin IntraMuscularly (I.M.); group B animals (n=9) received equal volume of saline o.d. Three animals from each group were sacrificed at 1, 2 and 3 months following treatment's initiation. The extent and the grade of OA were assessed macroscopically, histologically and by radiographs, Computed Tomography (CT) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI)-scans. The Osteoarthritis Research Society International (OARSI) score, incorporating histological and macroscopic information, was calculated for each knee. Osteoarthritic changes in group A animals were less severe and progressed less rapidly when compared with those of group B animals (sham). This difference was statistically significant in the first and second month (P=0.05), but not in the third month (P=0.513). I.M. administration of Calcitonin seems to delay the progress of early-stage osteoarthritic lesions induced by mechanical instability in a rabbit experimental model.

Chondroprotective effects of a polycarbonate-urethane meniscal implant: histopathological results in a sheep model

injury or loss of the meniscus generally leads to degenerative osteoarthritic changes in the knee joint. However, few surgical options exist for meniscal replacement. The goal of this study was to examine the ability of a non-degradable, anatomically shaped artificial meniscal implant, composed of Kevlar-reinforced polycarbonate-urethane (PCU), to prevent progressive cartilage degeneration following complete meniscectomy. the artificial meniscus was implanted in the knees of mature female sheep following total medial meniscectomy, and the animals were killed at 3- and 6-months post-surgery. Macroscopic analysis and semi-quantitative histological analysis were performed on the cartilage of the operated knee and unoperated contralateral control joint. the PCU implants remained well secured throughout the experimental period and showed no signs of wear or changes in structural or material properties. Histological analysis showed relatively mild cartilage degeneration that was dominated by loss of proteoglycan content and cartilage structure. However, the total osteoarthritis score did not significantly differ between the control and operated knees, and there were no differences in the severity of degenerative changes between 3 and 6 months post-surgery. current findings provide preliminary evidence for the ability of an artificial PCU meniscal implant to delay or prevent osteoarthritic changes in knee joint following complete medial meniscectomy.

FACTORS AFFECTING WIDTH OF THE CANINE FEMOROTIBIAL JOINT SPACE IN NONWEIGHT‐BEARING RADIOGRAPHS

Caudocranial stifle radiographs with variations in positioning were made in two greyhound cadavers. Radiographs were repeated after each of three interventions: cranial cruciate desmotomy; release of the caudal horn of the medial meniscus; complete medial meniscectomy. The joint space on medial and lateral aspects of the joint was measured by a observer who was unaware of positioning or intervention. One dog had significantly wider joint space than the other (1.0 vs. 1.5mm). The lateral aspect of the joint space was wider than the medial aspect (1.7 vs. 0.7 mm). Medial rotation of the stifle resulted in an increase of 0.4 mm in width of the lateral joint space, whereas lateral rotation of the stifle reduced the lateral joint space by an average of 0.4 mm. Decentering the X-ray beam had no significant effect on joint space width. Tension increased the width of the medial joint space by an average of 1.2 mm and the lateral aspect by an average of 1.3 mm. Cranial cruciate desmotomy resulted in an average 0.3 mm increase in width of the joint space, and medial meniscectomy with an average 0.2 mm reduction of the joint space. Although the femorotibial joint space was affected by iatrogenic stifle injuries and by medial or lateral rotation, these changes were less than the differences between the two dogs. Hence it seems unlikely that the small changes in joint space width associated with cruciate ligament desmotomy and medial meniscectomy will be detectable in clinical practice.

Effect of surgical technique on limb function after surgery for rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament in dogs

To determine the outcome and effect of surgical technique on limb function after surgery for rupture of the cranial cruciate ligament (RCCL) and injury to the medial meniscus in Labrador Retrievers. Prospective clinical study. 131 Labrador Retrievers with unilateral RCCL and injury to the medial meniscus and 17 clinically normal Labrador Retrievers. Affected dogs had partial or complete medial meniscectomy and lateral suture stabilization (LSS), intracapsular stabilization (ICS), or tibial plateau leveling osteotomy (TPLO). Limb function was measured before surgery and 2 and 6 months after surgery. Treated dogs were evaluated to determine the probability that they could be differentiated from clinically normal dogs and tested to determine the likelihood that they achieved improvement. No difference was found between LSS or TPLO groups, but dogs treated with ICS had significantly lower ground reaction forces at 2 and 6 months. Compared with clinically normal dogs only, 14.9% of LSS-, 15% of ICS-, and 10.9% of TPLO-treated dogs had normal limb function. Improvement was seen in only 15% of dogs treated via ICS, 34% treated via TPLO, and 40% treated via LSS. Surgical technique can influence limb function after surgery. Labrador Retrievers treated via LSS, ICS, or TPLO for repair for of RCCL and medial meniscal injury managed with partial or complete meniscectomy infrequently achieve normal function. Results of LSS and TPLO are similar and superior to ICS.

P255 Detailed mapping of OA lesions after complete medial meniscectomy

P255 Detailed mapping of OA lesions after complete medial meniscectomy

Trabecular bone strain changes resulting from partial and complete meniscectomy.

Previous studies have documented how partial and complete meniscectomy affect articular contact pressure, but changes in load transfer through the complete osteochondral structure of the proximal tibia after partial and complete meniscectomy are not well known. The current study measured trabecular bone strain changes in the medial tibial plateau resulting from partial and complete medial meniscectomy. Midcoronal sections were prepared from knees from cadavers. High quality digital images, made from contact radiographs of loaded samples, were compared with digital images of unloaded samples using in-house software to measure trabecular bone strain. Measurements were made on specimens with an intact medial meniscus, after removal of the inner (2/3) of the meniscus, and after complete meniscectomy. Partial meniscectomy caused minimal increases in trabecular bone strain throughout the proximal tibia. However specimens with complete meniscectomy had significant trabecular bone strain increases. Many patients sustaining meniscus tears are young, therefore, it is important to understand mechanical changes associated with partial meniscectomy. The data suggest partial meniscectomy causes little change in load transfer through the proximal tibia, supporting partial meniscectomy as a good surgical option for patients with meniscus tears.

Effects of postoperative rehabilitation on limb function after cranial cruciate ligament repair in dogs.

To determine the effects of early postoperative rehabilitation on limb function in dogs after surgery for ruptured cranial cruciate ligament (RCCL). Prospective clinical study. 51 client-owned dogs. Dogs weighing between 20 and 40 kg (44 to 88 lb) that had RCCL and medial meniscal injury were studied. After removal of the RCCL and complete medial meniscectomy, the stifle joint was stabilized by use of a lateral retinacular stabilization technique. Twenty-five dogs were included in a postoperative rehabilitation group, and 26 dogs were included in an exercise-restricted group. Limb function (peak vertical force [PVF] and vertical impulse [VI]) was determined before surgery and 6 months after surgery, using force platform gait analysis. Prior to surgery, mean PVF and VI in affected limbs were similar between groups. Six months after surgery, PVF and VI were significantly increased in dogs of both groups. However, PVF and VI in dogs in the rehabilitation group were significantly greater than those of dogs in the exercise-restricted group. At this time, differences in limb function (as measured by PVF and VI) between the repaired and normal limbs were not evident in dogs in the rehabilitation group. Conversely, limb function in the repaired limb of dogs in the exercise-restricted group was still significantly less than that of the normal limb. Dogs that have surgery for RCCL and a torn medial meniscus benefit from postoperative rehabilitation; rehabilitation should be considered part of the postoperative management of these patients.

Synovial fluid biomarker levels predict articular cartilage damage following complete medial meniscectomy in the canine knee

The purposes of this study were to document the histological changes present in the tibial plateaus 12 weeks after complete medial meniscectomy in dogs and to determine if synovial lavage fluid biomarker levels are predictive of the severity of joint damage. Twelve adult dogs underwent complete unilateral medial meniscectomy and synovial lavage fluid biomarker levels, including cartilage oligomeric matrix protein (COMP), keratan sulfate (5D4), 3B3(−), and 3B3(+), were measured serially at 4-week intervals. The dogs were euthanized 12 weeks after surgery and each medial and lateral tibial plateau from the meniscectomized and contralateral knees was graded histologically. Histological data were analyzed using principal components analysis, which resulted in 4 factors that explained 70% of the variation in the data. Factor 2 (weighted most heavily by subchondral bone thickness) and Factor 3 (representative of articular cartilage damage) were significantly affected by compartmental site ( P<0.01 for both). Both of these factors were highest in the medial tibial plateau of the meniscectomized knee, and Factor 3 was significantly higher in this site than in the medial tibial plateau of the contralateral knee ( P<0.01). Peak levels of all 4 synovial lavage fluid biomarkers occurred at 4 weeks post-meniscectomy and 4-week minus baseline levels of all biomarkers were significantly correlated with the Factor 3 scores. This study demonstrates that significant articular cartilage damage occurs relatively quickly following complete medial meniscectomy in dogs and establishes the content and criterion validity for these synovial fluid lavage biomarkers in canine meniscectomy as surrogate measures of articular cartilage damage.

Autologous perichondral tissue for meniscal replacement

Our aim was to examine the potential of autologous perichondral tissue to form a meniscal replacement. In 18 mature sheep we performed a complete medial meniscectomy. The animals were then divided into two groups: 12 had a meniscal replacement using strips of autologous perichondral tissue explanted from the lower rib (group G) and six (group C) served as a control group without a meniscal replacement. In all animals restriction from weight-bearing was achieved by means of transection and partial resection of tendo Achillis. Six animals (four from group G and two from group C) were each killed at 3, 6 and 12 months. The grafts and the underlying articular cartilage were removed and studied by gross macroscopic examination, light microscopy, SEM, polarised light examination, and by biomechanical tests. In all the transplanted animals a new perichondral meniscus developed. After three months the transplants resembled normal menisci in size and thickness, while in the control animals only small rims of spontaneously grown tissue were seen. Microscopically, the perichondral menisci showed a normal orientation of collagen fibres and normal cellular characteristics, but in the central region, areas of calcification disturbed the regular tissue differentiation. Healing tissue in control animals lacked the normal fibre orientation and cellularity. SEM of perichondral menisci showed surface characteristics similar to those of normal sheep menisci without fissures and lacerations; the control specimens had these defects. The femoral and tibial cartilage in contact with the new menisci had normal surface characteristics apart from one animal with slight surface irregularities. Control animals showed superficial lesions after three months which increased at six to 12 months postoperatively. Microangiography of the newly grown tissue demonstrated a less intense vascularisation after three months when compared with normal menisci. The failure stress and tensile modulus of perichondral menisci were significantly lower than those of normal contralateral menisci, and spontaneously regenerated tissue in meniscectomised animals had even lower values. There were no significant differences in values between newly grown perichondral menisci and spontaneously grown tissue.

Autologous perichondral tissue for meniscal replacement.

Our aim was to examine the potential of autologous perichondral tissue to form a meniscal replacement. In 18 mature sheep we performed a complete medial meniscectomy. The animals were then divided into two groups: 12 had a meniscal replacement using strips of autologous perichondral tissue explanted from the lower rib (group G) and six (group C) served as a control group without a meniscal replacement. In all animals restriction from weight-bearing was achieved by means of transection and partial resection of tendo Achillis. Six animals (four from group G and two from group C) were each killed at 3, 6 and 12 months. The grafts and the underlying articular cartilage were removed and studied by gross macroscopic examination, light microscopy, SEM, polarised light examination, and by biomechanical tests. In all the transplanted animals a new perichondral meniscus developed. After three months the transplants resembled normal menisci in size and thickness, while in the control animals only small rims of spontaneously grown tissue were seen. Microscopically, the perichondral menisci showed a normal orientation of collagen fibres and normal cellular characteristics, but in the central region, areas of calcification disturbed the regular tissue differentiation. Healing tissue in control animals lacked the normal fibre orientation and cellularity. SEM of perichondral menisci showed surface characteristics similar to those of normal sheep menisci without fissures and lacerations; the control specimens had these defects. The femoral and tibial cartilage in contact with the new menisci had normal surface characteristics apart from one animal with slight surface irregularities. Control animals showed superficial lesions after three months which increased at six to 12 months postoperatively. Microangiography of the newly grown tissue demonstrated a less intense vascularisation after three months when compared with normal menisci. The failure stress and tensile modulus of perichondral menisci were significantly lower than those of normal contralateral menisci, and spontaneously regenerated tissue in meniscectomised animals had even lower values. There were no significant differences in values between newly grown perichondral menisci and spontaneously grown tissue.

Graft-bone healing of a meniscus autograft anchored in bone tunnels.

This experiment was designed to histologically study the attachment process between a meniscus autograft and bone when the meniscus autograft is placed within bone at its anterior and posterior horns. In order to provide a time-sequenced histologic picture, a canine model was used. The study group consisted of eleven mature canines that underwent complete medial meniscectomy of the stifle joint followed by immediate replacement using an autogenous tissue meniscal scaffold fashioned from the lateral fascia of the thigh. The graft was fixed in bone tunnels at the anterior and posterior horns. One animal was sacrificed immediately after implantation, one at 10 days, three at 28 days, two at 3 months, two at 6 months, and two at nine months. Photographs were taken and histologic sections through bone tunnels were analyzed. The graft consisted of rolled tensor fascia and exogenous clot. The attachment process begins with the invasion of an interface of well vascularized, primitive mesenchymal cells between the soft-tissue graft and the host bone. Histologic evidence of collagenous attachment to bone is visible at one month after graft implantation. Collagen organization with increasing soft tissue attachment to bone is progressive throughout the nine months time frame of the study. The attachment points become increasingly more continuous from three to six months. By six months, the attachment points are confluent and continuous throughout the depths of the tunnel.

In vitro load transmission in the canine knee: the effect of medial meniscectomy and varus rotation.

The purpose of this study was to determine the in vitro load-transmission characteristics of the canine knee, paying particular attention to the positioning effect of the meniscus in the coronal plane. The intact joint was first loaded and then tested under two different loading conditions after a complete medial meniscectomy. The first set of test conditions attempted to simulate those used by previous investigators, by ignoring the spacer effect of the meniscus. The second set of tests were carried out following varus rotation of the joint (to account for the loss of the meniscal spacer) to assure initial contact in both tibiofemoral compartments at the start of test cycle. It is presumed that this varus realignment occurs during weight bearing following meniscectomy in vivo. As in previous studies, the joints experienced slightly larger displacements (although not statistically significant) and had lower stiffness values following medial meniscectomy than when intact. However, following varus realignment of the joint after meniscectomy, the displacement was markedly smaller (-35% to -49%; P < 0.01) and the structural stiffness was much greater (47-123%; P < 0.05) over the range of forces analyzed, compared with the intact joint. The ratio of dissipated to input energy was 42% for the intact joint, and increased following meniscectomy to 54% (P < 0.05) with realignment and 55% (P < 0.05) without realignment. Measured contact area decreased by 17% (P < 0.05) following meniscectomy alone, and by 12% (P < 0.05) following meniscectomy with realignment.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

The effect of medial meniscectomy and coronal plane angulation on in vitro load transmission in the canine stifle joint.

The purpose of this study was to determine the in vitro load transmission characteristics of the canine stifle joint, paying particular attention to the positioning effect of the meniscus in the coronal plane. The intact joint was first loaded, and then tested under two different loading conditions after a complete medial meniscectomy. The first set of test conditions attempted to simulate those used by previous investigators, by ignoring the spacer effect of the meniscus and not repositioning the joint after its removal. The second set of tests was carried out after the joint was repositioned in the coronal plane to allow initial contact to occur in both tibiofemoral compartments. It is presumed that this occurs subsequent to a meniscectomy in vivo, following the application of any weight-bearing load. As with previous investigators, it was found that after meniscectomy the joints produced slightly larger displacements and lower stiffnesses than when intact (no significant differences from intact). However, repositioning the meniscectomized joint produced markedly smaller displacements (35-49%, p less than 0.01) and greater stiffnesses (47-123%, p less than 0.05) over the range of forces analyzed, compared with the intact joint. The ratio of dissipated to input energy was 42% for the intact joint, and rose following meniscectomy to 54% (p less than 0.05) with repositioning and 55% (p less than 0.05) without repositioning. Measured contact area decreased by 17% (p less than 0.05) following meniscectomy alone, and by 12% (p less than 0.05) following meniscectomy with repositioning. Since repositioning of the joint subsequent to meniscectomy (accounting for the loss of the meniscal spacer) resulted in an increase in structural stiffness, it was concluded that the medial meniscus decreases the structural stiffness of the intact stifle joint. In addition, the meniscus has a role in elastic energy storage and increasing contact area. This study is intended to serve as a baseline comparison for future in vivo studies on meniscectomy, meniscal repair, and meniscal replacement, in addition to more fully elucidating the mechanism of load transmission. A model is presented to explain both the decrease in stiffness after meniscectomy without repositioning and the increase in stiffness after meniscectomy with repositioning, employing linear springs of unequal length and different stiffnesses. After removal of the softer meniscal element and allowing joint approximation to occur, loading of the stiffer articular element results in an initially stiffer preparation.

Symptomatic dislocation of the anterior horn of the medial meniscus

Anteromedial joint line pain of the knee represents both a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge. Dislocation of the anterior horn of the medial meniscus as a cause of anteromedial joint line pain is uncommon. O'Connor has reported this finding on internal and external rotation of the tibia during arthroscopy and Dashefsky has demonstrated a shadow sign associated with dislocating anterior horns. We have noted these findings plus anteromedial femoral condylar articular erosion associated with persistent anteromedial joint line pain in 13 patients. All 13 patients had persistent anteromedial joint line tenderness on physical examination present from 3 months to 3 years prior to surgery. Six of the 13 patients had a click in the knee with activity and only 4 of the 13 patients reported "giving away" episodes. Arthroscopic examination demonstrated a complete anterior horn dislocation of the medial meniscus as described by O'Connor and Dashefsky as well as degeneration of the anteromedial femoral condyle. Definitive treatment was performed in the 13 patients after arthroscopic confirmation of the diagnosis of dislocating anterior horn of the medial meniscus. The first four patients had traditional medial meniscectomies, the next four patients had repair of the anterior horn, and the last five patients had partial resection of the meniscus through the arthroscope. Excellent results occurred in three of four patients with repair of the anterior horn, and four of five patients with partial resection through the arthroscope. The one failure of repair subsequently underwent a complete medial meniscectomy with an excellent result.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)