Palliative Care Competencies Research Articles

Palliative neurology

Palliative medicine represents the holistic multiprofessional treatment of severely and incurably ill people and their relatives, addressing their complex physical, psychological, social and spiritual needs. The central therapeutic goals are the quality of life and alleviation of suffering. In the course of many neurological diseases, high symptom burden, long and variable trajectories and unfavorable prognosis at times create aneed for palliative care even at an early stage, which is currently still inadequately met. This can be countered by qualified neuropalliative care. In addition to intensifying interdisciplinary collaboration, this requires neurologists to have core competencies in palliative care. These include ateam-oriented attitude, communication skills, expertise in symptom control and knowledge of biomedical ethics including palliative options at the end of life.

Palliative care in advanced pulmonary fibrosis.

Updated clinical practice guidelines for pulmonary fibrosis recommend early integrated palliative care using a primary palliative approach. Clinicians need to be aware of the various palliative interventions in order to implement guidelines' recommendations. This review provides an update on evidence-based palliative therapies. Literature review indicates early integration of palliative care in pulmonary fibrosis is feasible and meets patient needs. Key components of a primary palliative approach include comprehensive symptoms and needs screening, systematic symptom management using nonpharmacologic interventions, supplemental oxygen and opioids for dyspnea and cough. Patient-centered communication is essential for successful integration of palliative care. Early, iterative advance care planning in clinic to understand patient goals, values and preferences for current and future care, improves patient care and satisfaction. Prioritizing caregiver inclusion in clinics can address their needs. Collaborating with a multidisciplinary allied team facilitates integration of palliative care and supports patients throughout the disease course. Different models of palliative care delivery exist and can be adapted for local use. The use of artificial intelligence algorithms and tools may improve care and continuity. Clinicians must develop competency in palliative care. Organizational and policy support is essential to enable seamless integration of palliative care throughout the care continuum.

Enhancing Primary Palliative Care Competency With Graduate Nursing Students.

Enhancing Primary Palliative Care Competency With Graduate Nursing Students.

Increasing interprofessional collaboration in community-based palliative care: a pilot study of the CAPACITI education program for primary care providers

ABSTRACT Interprofessional collaboration in palliative care is essential to ensuring high-quality care for seriously ill patients. Education interventions to increase competency in palliative care should incorporate team-building skills to encourage an interprofessional approach. We developed and piloted a virtual educational program named CAPACITI for interprofessional teams to promote a community palliative approach to care. Primary care teams from across Ontario, Canada, participated in CAPACITI which consisted of 10 facilitated sessions that emphasized how to operationalize a palliative care approach as a team. Pre- and post-study questionnaires were completed by each team, including the AITCS-II, a validated instrument that measures interprofessional collaboration. We analyzed individual paired differences in summary scores and in each of three subdomains of the AITCS-II questionnaire: partnership, cooperation, and coordination. Seventeen teams completed the AITCS-II post survey, representing 133 participants. Teams varied demographically and ranged from 5 to 16 members. After CAPACITI, the overall mean AITCS-II summary score among teams increased to 96.0 (SD = 10.0) for a significant paired mean difference increase of 9.4 (p = .03). There were also significant increases in the partnership (p = .01) and in the cooperation subdomains (p = .04). CAPACITI demonstrated the potential for improving collaboration among primary care teams, which can lead to improved provider and patient outcomes in palliative care.

Palliative neurology

Palliative medicine represents the holistic multiprofessional treatment of severely and incurably ill people and their relatives, addressing their complex physical, psychological, social and spiritual needs. The central therapeutic goals are the quality of life and alleviation of suffering. In the course of many neurological diseases, high symptom burden, long and variable trajectories and unfavorable prognosis at times create aneed for palliative care even at an early stage, which is currently still inadequately met. This can be countered by qualified neuropalliative care. In addition to intensifying interdisciplinary collaboration, this requires neurologists to have core competencies in palliative care. These include ateam-oriented attitude, communication skills, expertise in symptom control and knowledge of biomedical ethics including palliative options at the end of life.

Knowledge and training among nursing students regarding the conspiracy of silence in palliative care: A participatory action research

AimTo develop and implement specific training based on the knowledge and management of conspiracy of silence among nursing students. BackgroundConspiracy of silence refers to the concealment of information from a patient on the family’s request, under the influence of a paternalistic culture that seeks to protect the patient. DesignParticipatory action research. MethodsWas conducted in the following stages: reconnaissance (focus groups); planning, action and observation (theoretical sessions); and reflection (analysis of care plans). The focus group consisted of six fourth year and eight second-year students. The intervention was conducted with 42 s-year students and a total of 93 s-year students participated in the resolution of the clinical case. The study was conducted between October 2022 and June 2023 at the Faculty of Nursing, University of Valencia. For data analysis, the process described by Carrillo et al. (2011) was followed, involving coding and the creation of categories and subcategories. ResultsThe focus group deficiencies were detected in the students' learning of palliative care competence, breaking bad news and the conspiracy of silence (reconnaissance stage). Therefore, an intervention was conducted to reinforce these knowledge areas, specifically addressing the conspiracy of silence (planning, action and observation stages). The resolution of the case showed how students with training approached the situation more comprehensively, including the family and proposed activities that were consistent with managing the situation (reflection stage). ConclusionsAn active feedback process was successfully established, where the students' feedback helped create specific training on oncological palliative care and provided the students with tools to manage the conspiracy of silence. The results underscore the importance of providing students with training in palliative care and managing conspiracy of silence, through therapeutic communication training, active training or enhancing emotional intelligence. This training is essential for cultivating the attitudes and skills required to deliver high-quality palliative care.

Living and dying between cultural traditions in African & Caribbean Heritage families: a constructivist grounded theory

BackgroundEthnic differences influence end-of-life health behaviours and use of palliative care services. Use of formal Advance care planning is not common in minority ethnic heritage communities. Older adults expect and trust their children to be their decision makers at the end of life. The study aim was to construct a theory of the dynamics that underpin end-of-life conversations within families of African and Caribbean heritage. This is a voice not well represented in the current debate on improving end-of-life outcomes.MethodsUsing Charmaz’s constructivist grounded theory approach, a purposive sample of elders, adult-children, and grandchildren of African and Caribbean Heritage were recruited. In-person and online focus groups were conducted and analysed using an inductive, reflexive comparative analysis process. Initial and axial coding facilitated the creation of categories, these categories were abstracted to constructs and used in theory construction.ResultsElders (n = 4), adult-children (n = 14), and adult grandchildren (n = 3) took part in 5 focus groups. A grounded theory of living and dying between cultural traditions in African and Caribbean heritage families was created. The constructs are (a) Preparing for death but not for dying (b) Complexity in traditions crosses oceans (c) Living and dying between cultures and traditions (d) There is culture, gender and there is personality (e) Watching the death of another prompts conversations. (f) An experience of Hysteresis.DiscussionAfrican and Caribbean cultures celebrate preparation for after-death processes resulting in early exposure to and opportunities for discussion of these processes. Migration results in reforming of people’s habitus/ world views shaped by a mixing of cultures. Being in different geographical places impacts generational learning-by-watching of the dying process and related decision making.ConclusionsRecognising the impact of migration on the roles of different family members and the exposure of those family members to previous dying experiences is important. This can provide a more empathetic and insightful approach to partnership working between health care professionals and patients and families of minority ethic heritage facing serious illness. A public health approach focusing on enabling adult-children to have better end of life conversations with their parents can inform the development of culturally competent palliative care.

Palliative care competence development through simulation: Excellence & innovation to meet the AACN essentials

BackgroundThe updated American Association of Colleges of Nursing: The Essentials: Core Competencies for Professional Nursing Education (2021) outlines competence requirements for entry-to-practice nurses. Hospice and palliative care (PC) are identified as one of four spheres of care, emphasizing that nursing knowledge and proficiency in primary PC are critical for all nurses. PurposeThis article identifies key elements for nursing educators to consider when adopting, adapting, or designing practical primary PC simulations to meet The AACN Essentials. MethodsUsing Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice™ (HSSBP) as a framework, a panel of nursing education researchers identified and compared key elements of four PC simulations from varied evidence-based exemplars across the U.S. ResultsOverarching elements in simulation development include choosing modalities, assessing resources, and simulation logistics, creating opportunities for difficult conversations with interprofessional team engagement, and validating scenarios with expert input. Simulation implementation should include tailored pre-briefing to address psychological safety in caring for the dying patient, piloting scenarios, and maximizing observer/vicarious learner roles. Finally, evaluation is vital for competency assessment, scenario enhancement, and logistical changes.Limitations included variability in PC simulation scenarios, learners/learner level, curricula, and geography across selected exemplars, which may affect the general applicability of these findings. ConclusionsSimulations developed according to HSSBP™ provide effective practical experience in PC, affording active and vicarious learners the knowledge and skills essential for baseline nursing competence.

Design, Creation, and 13-Month Performance of a Novel, Web-Based Activity for Education in Primary Cardiology Palliative Care

Cardiovascular disease (CVD) clinicians who care for seriously ill patients frequently report that they do not feel confident nor adequately prepared to manage patients’ palliative care (PC) needs. With the goal, therefore, of increasing PC knowledge and skills amongst interprofessional clinicians providing CVD care, the ACC's PC Workgroup designed, developed, and implemented a comprehensive PC online educational activity. This paper describes the process and 13-month performance of this free, online activity for clinicians across disciplines and levels of training, “Palliative Care for the Cardiovascular Clinician” (PCCVC). A key component of PCCVC is that it is tailored to the lifelong learner; users can choose and receive credit for the activities that meet their individual learning needs. This webinar series was well-subscribed, and upon completion of the modules, learners reported better self-perceived abilities related to palliative care competencies. We propose PCCVC as a model for primary PC education for clinicians caring for individuals with other serious or life-shortening illnesses.

Core competencies among nurses engaged in pallative care: A scoping review.

To synthesize available evidence about core competencies for nurses engaged in palliative care. A scoping review conducted according to the framework from Joanna Briggs Institute. The Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews checklist was adopted to report this scoping review. The PubMed, Web of Science, Embase, ScienceDriect, CNKI, WangFang, VIP and Sinomed databases were used to systematically search for published studies from their inception to December 2023. Two researchers independently screened and selected relevant studies and performed the data charting. Twenty-six studies were included in this scoping review. Among these, 14 studies identified core competency assessment instruments among nurses engaged in palliative care, with the Palliative Care Core Competence Questionnaire was used most frequently; 13 studies investigated the status of core competencies of nurses engaged in palliative care, the majority of included studies indicated that nurse's core competencies were at moderate levels; 11 studies explored the factors influencing the core competencies of the nurses engaged in palliative care, which were classified as sociodemographic-related factors, palliative care education-related factors, death attitude, palliative care practice-related experience and others. This scoping review offers a comprehensive overview of the current landscape of core competencies among nurses in palliative care. Findings suggested that the clinical nursing leaders need to develop tailored strategies and interventions to address specific factors and promote the continuous development of nurses' competencies in palliative care. Core competency assessment instruments equip nurses and healthcare organizations with a range of validated tools for evaluating their proficiency in palliative care. Targeted core competency enhancement programmes need to be developed to foster a nursing workforce better equipped to improve the quality of life of end-of-life patients and their families. No patient or public contribution.

Spiritual Care[Givers] Competence in Palliative Care: A Scoping Review.

To deliver spiritual care, professionals must be skilled in physical, mental, social, and spiritual care. Spiritual care competence includes knowledge, behaviors, attitudes, and skills that enable successful or efficient care. This review aims to identify the scope of competence and the specific skills, knowledge, and attitudes used in providing spiritual care to people needing palliative care, and the main challenges and facilitators. A scoping review was developed using the Joanna Briggs Institute methodology. Six databases (Web of Science; MEDLINE/Pubmed; Scopus; CINAHL; MedicLatina and SciELO) were searched in September 2023, with an update in January 2024. The resulting 30 articles were analyzed using a content analysis approach. Information was categorized into three domains: cognitive, affective, and functional (based on three personal resources: intrapersonal, interpersonal, and transpersonal). Palliative care professionals face a lack of training and insufficient preparation to deliver spiritual care. Spiritual care competence depends on professional spiritual development and experience, spiritual intelligence (cognitive), spiritual humility (affective), and having a critical and reflexive mind (functional). In the future, palliative care should seek to improve competent spiritual care. This review could help clarify the real configuration of competent spiritual care and lead to improvements in a professional's empowerment when delivering effective spiritual care to patients and families.

Measurement of palliative care competencies using PALCOM instrument

Introduction: An essential component of any profession is competent and confident staff. In palliative care, a wellrounded approach and versatile knowledge of staff and students are of great importance. Measuring these competencies is very important for the development of palliative care and health care. Methods: Measurement of competencies in palliative care by analyzing existing instruments and questions in palliative care. Process of developing a new instrument for measurement of competencies in palliative care PALCOM, using cross-sectional methodology with nurses from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Results: The results are presenting findings of research done with nurses from BIH using two main variables: Years of work experience and level of education of the participants. Main difference is between the two competencies: Pain assessment and management, education, and care for the patient’s family regarding the level of education. Conclusion: The need for measuring competencies is evident in the daily evolution of palliative care, community-based palliative care, hospice care, and subspecialized palliative care. There is no questionnaire that can measure all competencies, but the use of the general competencies in the PALCOM questionnaire can cover this area with the measurement of different domains and the competencies specific to these domains.

Core competencies in palliative care among oncology nurses: An observational study

BACKGROUND: Palliative care requires a collaborative approach from a multidisciplinary team, incorporating nurses with ethical, clinical, communicative-relational, psychosocial, and teamwork skills. However, many professionals feel unprepared to face end-of-life challenges, highlighting a lack of skills, especially regarding psychosocial and spiritual aspects. AIM: The purpose of this study is to explore nurses' self-perception of competencies in palliative care. METHODS: A single-center descriptive observational study was conducted among palliative and non-palliative care nurses at the Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori in Milan (INT), using the short Italian version of the Professional Competence Scale (PCSQ). The Kruskal-Wallis test was used along with multivariate ANOVA for statistical analysis. RESULTS: 122 nurses participated (response rate: 52%), predominantly women (78%), aged 25-34 (50%), with a degree (46%) and over 10 years of experience (41%). The majority had no experience (71%) in palliative care, while 16% were currently working in this field. Statistical analysis revealed no significant correlations between educational level and responses. The Kruskal-Wallis test showed that experience in palliative care significantly influenced self-assessment scores, such as in activating non-pharmacological management strategies (p=0.004). CONCLUSIONS: Nurses perceive high competence in ethical and clinical decision-making in palliative care, influenced more by experience than by training. Addressing patients' subjective needs and using non-pharmacological interventions remain a challenge for nurses not working in palliative care settings.

Level of competency in palliative care nursing in the preparation to nurse certification of the Department of Health

Level of competency in palliative care nursing in the preparation to nurse certification of the Department of Health

Core Palliative Care Competencies for Undergraduate Nursing Education: International Multisite Research Using Online Nominal Group Technique.

Background: Nurses should have appropriate education and required competencies to provide high-quality palliative care. The aim of this international multisite study was to list and evaluate core palliative care competencies that European nurses need to achieve in their education to provide palliative care. Methods: The Nominal Group Technique (NGT) was used as a data collection method. NGT meetings were organized in four European countries. Targeted groups of palliative care professionals with diverse contextual and professional backgrounds participated in the NGTs. The research question was: "What are the core competencies in palliative care that need to be achieved during undergraduate nursing education?" Data analysis was done in two stages: grouping the top 10 answers based on similarities and thematic synthesis based on all the ideas produced during the NGTs. Results: Palliative care core competencies based on the research were (1) competence in the characteristics of palliative care; (2) competence in decision-making and enabling palliative care; (3) symptom management competence in palliative care; (4) competence in holistic support in palliative care; (5) active person- and family-centered communication competence in palliative care; (6) competence in empathy in palliative care; (7) spiritual competence in palliative care; (8) competence in ethical and legal issues in palliative care; (9) teamwork competence in palliative care; and (10) self-awareness and self-reflection competence in palliative care. Conclusions: It was possible to find differences and similarities in the top 10 palliative care core competencies from different countries. Thematic synthesis of all the data showed that there were various competencies needed for nursing students to provide quality palliative care.

Implementing advance care planning in palliative and end of life care: a scoping review of community nursing perspectives

BackgroundAdvance care planninganning (ACP) is a priority within palliative care service provision. Nurses working in the community occupy an opportune role to engage with families and patients in ACP. Carers and family members of palliative patients often find ACP discussions difficult to initiate. However, community nurses caring for palliative patients can encourage these discussions, utilising the rapport and relationships they have already built with patients and families. Despite this potential, implementation barriers and facilitators continue to exist. To date, no research synthesis has captured the challenges community nurses face when implementing ACP, nor the facilitators of community nurse-led ACP. Considering this, the review question of: 'What factors contribute to or hinder ACP discussion for nurses when providing care to palliative patients?’ was explored.MethodTo capture challenges and facilitators, a global qualitative scoping review was undertaken in June 2023. The Arksey and O’Malley framework for scoping reviews guided the review methodology. Six databases were searched identifying 333 records: CINAHL (16), MEDLINE (45), PUBMED (195), EMBASE (30), BJOCN (15), IJOPN (32). After de-duplication and title and abstract screening, 108 records remained. These were downloaded, hand searched (adding 5 articles) and subject to a full read. 98 were rejected, leaving a selected dataset of 15 articles. Data extracted into a data extraction chart were thematically analysed.ResultsThree key themes were generated: ‘Barriers to ACP’, ‘Facilitators of ACP’ and ‘Understanding of professional role and duty’. Key barriers were – lack of confidence, competence, role ambiguity and prognostic uncertainty. Key facilitators concerned the pertinence of the patient-practitioner relationship enabling ACP amongst nurses who had both competence and experience in ACP and/or palliative care (e.g., palliative care training). Lastly, nurses understood ACP to be part of their role, however, met challenges understanding the law surrounding this and its application processes.ConclusionsThis review suggests that community nurses' experience and competence are associated with the effective implementation of ACP with palliative patients. Future research is needed to develop interventions to promote ACP uptake in community settings, enable confidence building for community nurses and support higher standards of palliative care via the implementation of ACP.

Consenso Delphi sobre la formación de grado en medicina paliativa (EDUPAL-Ar)

Palliative care is an “ethical responsibility of healthcare systems”. The WHO proposes undergraduate and postgraduate medical education as one dimension to assess its development in a country. In Latin America, 15% of medical schools have an undergraduate palliative care course. In Argentina, there is still no consensus on the essential content of undergraduate medical curricula. MethodThis study sought to reach a consensus on what an undergraduate curriculum in palliative medicine should look like in Argentina using the Delphi methodology (2019–2020). Sociodemographic data, profession, years of experience, university education, thematic content, pedagogical modality, study plan and hourly load were collected. Quantitative analysis was performed using percentages and mean values to indicate the level of agreement on 5-point scales. Interquartile ranges were calculated to provide indicators of agreement and consensus. Thematic content analysis was carried out. ResultsTwo hundred fifty experts were convened, of whom 85 responded to two rounds of consultation. A high degree of agreement was reached on ten general, dynamic, and flexible recommendations adapted to different contexts. 98% considered it necessary to teach palliative care transversally and suggested a specific course contextualised to chronic patients and end-of-life situations. However, there was a tension between the traditional training model and competency-based education. Experiential learning is appropriate, but linking theory and practice was recommended. ConclusionFor the first time in Argentina, a consensus of experts was reached, which defined a set of recommendations on content, teaching methodology, academic cycle and competencies in palliative care.

Towards a set of competencies in palliative care nursing in Spain: what’s getting in the way of consensus?

BackgroundSpain currently lacks a competency framework for palliative care nursing. Having such a framework would help to advance this field in academic, governmental, and health management contexts. In phase I of a mixed-methods sequential study, we collected quantitative data, proposing 98 competencies to a sample of palliative care nurses. They accepted 62 of them and rejected 36.MethodsPhase II is a qualitative phase in which we used consensus techniques with two modified nominal groups to interpret the quantitative findings with the objective of understanding of why the 36 competencies had been rejected. Twenty nurses from different areas of palliative care (direct care, teaching, management, research) participated. We conducted a thematic analysis using NVivo12 to identify meaning units and group them into larger thematic categories.ResultsParticipants attributed the lack of consensus on the 36 competencies to four main reasons: the rejection of standardised nursing language, the context in which nurses carry out palliative care and other factors that are external to the care itself, the degree of specificity of the proposed competency (too little or too great), and the complexity of nursing care related to the end of life and/or death.ConclusionsBased on the results, we propose reparative actions, such as reformulating the competencies expressed in nursing terminology to describe them as specific behaviours and insisting on the participation of nurses in developing institutional policies and strategies so that competencies related to development, leadership and professional commitment can be implemented. It is essential ​​to promote greater consensus on the definition and levels of nursing intervention according to criteria of complexity and to advocate for adequate training, regulation, and accreditation of palliative care expert practice. Locally, understanding why the 36 competencies were rejected can help Spanish palliative care nurses reach a shared competency framework. More broadly, our consensus methodology and our findings regarding the causes for rejection may be useful to other countries that are in the process of formalising or reviewing their palliative care nursing model.

Mapping an undergraduate medical education curriculum against national and international palliative care reference learning objectives

BackgroundThe teaching of palliative care competencies is an essential component of undergraduate medical education. There is significant variance in the palliative care content delivered in undergraduate medical curricula, revealing the utility of reference standards to guide curricular development and assessment. To evaluate our university’s undergraduate palliative care teaching, we undertook a curriculum mapping exercise, comparing official learning objectives to the national Educating Future Physicians in Palliative and End-of-Life Care (EFPPEC) and the international Palliative Education Assessment Tool (PEAT) reference objectives.MethodsMultiple assessors independently compared our university’s UGME learning objectives with EFPPEC and PEAT reference objectives to determine the degree-of-coverage. Visual curriculum maps were created to depict in which part of the curriculum each objective is delivered and by which medical specialty.ResultsOf 122 EFPPEC objectives, 55 (45.1%) were covered fully, 42 (34.4%) were covered partially, and 25 (20.5%) were not covered by university objectives. Of 89 PEAT objectives, 40 (44.9%) were covered fully, 35 (39.3%) were covered partially, and 14 (15.7%) were not covered by university objectives.ConclusionsThe majority of EFPPEC and PEAT reference objectives are fully or partially covered in our university’s undergraduate medical curriculum. Our approach could serve as a guide for others who endeavour to review their universities’ specialty-specific medical education against reference objectives. Future curriculum development should target the elimination of identified gaps and evaluate the attainment of palliative care competencies by medical learners.

Implementation of remote home care: assessment guided by the RE-AIM framework

BackgroundWelfare technology interventions have become increasingly important in home-based palliative care for facilitating safe, time-efficient, and cost-effective methods to support patients living independently. However, studies evaluating the implementation of welfare technology innovations are scarce, and the empirical evidence for sustainable models using technology in home-based palliative care remains low. This study aimed to report on the use of the Reach Effectiveness Adoption Implementation Maintenance (RE-AIM) framework to assess the implementation of remote home care (RHC) a technology-mediated service for home-living patients in the palliative phase of cancer. Furthermore, it aimed to explore areas of particular importance determining the sustainability of technologies for remote palliative home-based care.MethodsA secondary analysis of data collected by semi-structured interviews with patients with cancer in the palliative phase, focus groups, and semi-structured interviews with healthcare professionals (HCPs) experienced with RHC was performed. A deductive reflexive thematic analysis using RE-AIM dimensions was conducted.ResultsFive themes illustrating the five RE-AIM dimensions were identified: (1) Reach: protective actions in recruitment - gatekeeping, (2) Effectiveness: potential to offer person-centered care, (3) Adoption: balancing high touch with high tech, (4) Implementation: moving towards a common understanding, and (5) Maintenance: adjusting to what really matters. The RE-AIM framework highlighted that RHC implementation for patients in the palliative phase of cancer was influenced by HCP gatekeeping behavior, concerns regarding abandoning palliative care as a high-touch specialty, and a lack of competence in palliative care. Although RHC facilitated improved routines in patients’ daily lives, it was perceived as a static service unable to keep pace with disease progression.ConclusionsA person-centered approach that prioritizes individual needs and preferences is necessary for providing optimal care. Although technologies such as RHC are not a panacea, they can be integrated as support for increasingly strained health services.