Early leaf spot (caused by Passalora arachidicola) and late leaf spot (caused by Nothopassalora personata) are the most widespread, damaging foliar diseases of peanuts in the southeastern United States. When left nontreated, both diseases can prematurely defoliate peanuts and reduce peanut yields by up to 70%. Leaf spot diseases are primarily managed through a combination of fungicide applications and cultivar selection. In this study, six field experiments were conducted from 2021 to 2022 in Brewton, Headland, and Tallassee, Alabama, to evaluate the response of ten selected commercial peanut cultivars to various levels of leaf spot pressure as influenced by low- and high-input fungicide programs when compared to nontreated controls. The low input fungicide program included seven applications of chlorothalonil, whereas the high input fungicide program comprised of fluxapyroxad, pyraclostrobin, mefentrifluconazole, flutolanil, bixafen, flutriafol, tebuconazole, and/or chlorothalonil. Effects on leaf spot and pod yields were assessed. Leaf spot severity was higher for TUFRunner™ ‘297’, Georgia-16HO, and FloRun ‘331’, but was lower for AU-NPL 17, Georgia-06G, Georgia-12Y, and Georgia-14N. In terms of yield, leaf spot tolerant varieties showcased superior performance in high disease pressure, whereas susceptible varieties excelled in low disease pressure. Fungicides significantly enhanced the performance of susceptible cultivars under high leaf spot pressure, with marginal impact in low leaf spot pressure. These results highlight the importance of selecting cultivars and fungicide spray programs based on disease pressure to maximize profits.