In a hydrogen exchange-mass spectrometry (HX-MS) experiment, the enzymatic proteolysis of the deuterated protein is an essential step. Often the differences in the performance between different digestion protocols or between immobilized protease columns can be challenging to evaluate. To compare differences in the performance of immobilized protease columns, a new digestion efficiency metric known as digestible peptide scoring (DPS) was developed and is presented in this work. The measured response fraction of substance P peptide is used to assign a value between 0% and 100% based on the fraction of substance P digested by the enzyme, using angiotensin II as an undigested internal standard. In this work, the DPS approach was tested using multiple immobilized pepsin batches prepared using different protocols. The results demonstrate the repeatability of DPS values for batches prepared using the same conditions and the ability of the DPS evaluations to provide unique values when the immobilization conditions were altered. Protein digestions obtained with a higher scoring column were better than digestions obtained using a lower scoring column. The DPS evaluation is simple and quickly provides an unambiguous assessment which can be used to evaluate an immobilized enzyme column's suitability prior to performing an experiment, to track performance over a column's lifetime, to optimize protease immobilization protocols specifically for the quench conditions of a particular experiment, and to optimize the digestion conditions.