Color Doppler Twinkling Research Articles

Factors Associated With Ultrasound Color Doppler Twinkling by Breast Biopsy Markers: In Vitro and Ex Vivo Evaluation of 35 Commercially Available Markers.

BACKGROUND. Targeted axillary lymph node dissection after neoadjuvant systemic therapy (NST) for breast cancer depends on identifying marked metastatic lymph nodes. However, ultrasound visualization of biopsy markers is challenging. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of our study was to identify biopsy markers that show actionable twinkling in cadaveric breast and to assess the association of actionable twinkling with markers' surface roughness. METHODS. Commercial breast biopsy markers were evaluated for twinkling artifact in various experimental conditions relating to scanning medium (solid gel phantom, ultrasound coupling gel, cadaveric breast), transducer (ML6-15, 9L, C1-6), and embedding material (present vs absent). Markers were assigned twinkling scores from 0 (confident in no twinkling) to 4 (confident in exuberant twinkling); a score of 3 or greater represented actionable twinkling (sufficient confidence to rely solely on twinkling for target localization). Markers were hierarchically advanced to evaluation with increasingly complex media if showing at least minimal twinkling for a given medium. A 3D coherence optical profiler measured marker surface roughness. Mixed-effects proportional odds regression models assessed associations between twinkling scores and transducer and embedding material; Wilcoxon rank sum test evaluated associations between actionable twinkling and surface roughness. RESULTS. Thirty-five markers (21 with embedding material) were evaluated. Ten markers without embedding material advanced to evaluation in cadaveric breast. Higher twinkling scores were associated with presence of embedding material (odds ratio [OR] = 5.05 in solid gel phantom, 9.84 in coupling gel) and transducer (using the C1-6 transducer as reference; 9L transducer: OR = 0.36, 0.83, and 0.04 in solid gel phantom, ultrasound coupling gel, and cadaveric breast; ML6-15 transducer: OR = 0.07, 0.18, and 0.00 respectively; post hoc p between 9L and ML6-15: p < .001, p = .02, and p = .04). In cadaveric breast, three markers (Cork, Professional Q, MRI [Flex]) exhibited actionable twinkling for two or more transducers; surface roughness was significantly higher for markers with than without actionable twinkling for C1-6 (median values: 0.97 vs 0.35, p = .02) and 9L (1.75 vs 0.36; p = .002) transducers. CONCLUSION. Certain breast biopsy markers exhibited actionable twinkling in cadaveric breast. Twinkling was observed with greater confidence for the C1-6 and 9L transducers than the ML6-15 transducer. Actionable twinkling was associated with higher marker surface roughness. CLINICAL IMPACT. Use of twinkling for marker detection could impact preoperative or intraoperative localization after NST.

Using Ultrasound Color Doppler Twinkling to Identify Biopsy Markers in the Breast and Axilla

In breast radiology, ultrasound detection of biopsy markers or clips for localization purposes is often challenging, especially in the axilla. The purpose of this research was to test the hypothesis that the surface roughness of biopsy clips would elicit a twinkling signature on color Doppler, making them more readily identifiable by ultrasound. Ultrasound color Doppler imaging of 12 biopsy markers was performed and consensus scoring of the degree of twinkling (0 [no twinkling] to 4 [exuberant twinkling]) was obtained for each of the markers. The surface roughness characteristics of the markers were measured using 3-D coherence scanning interferometry. The 3 markers scoring at least 3 for twinkling in vitro were cork, Q and Vision. Of these 3 markers, only the cork marker scored a 4 ex vivo and in cadaveric tissue. Surface roughness metrics demonstrated a positive estimated correlation with the twinkling scores (rho = 0.33, 95% CI = [–0.48 to 0.84]). Of the 12 markers tested, the markers that twinkled corresponded to surface roughness measured with non-contact 3-D optical imaging. Qualitatively, lower color scales and color frequencies optimized twinkling, but the most specific qualitative predictor of confidence in twinkling was insensitivity to changes in color scale and color frequency values.

Relation of Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact and Scale or Pulse Repetition Frequency.

Objective:The aim of this study is to determine the effect of scale/pulse repetition frequency (PRF) on the appearance of color Doppler twinkling artifact.Materials and Methods:We commenced this cross-sectional study for 20 months from November 2014 to July 2016. During routine ultrasound examination, we observed multiple case of twinkling artifact produced by renal stones, calcifications in the thyroid nodules, bony fragments and intestinal gases, etc., We observed twinkling artifact with low- and high-PRF settings in 500 different structures. A total of 500 other structures were included wherein there was no Doppler twinkling artifact produced by them, with usual optimum PRF settings. These structures were also evaluated with low- and high-PRF to determine the effect of PRF on twinkling artifact effectively. All the patients were examined according to the AIUM guideline for appropriate examination protocol. Data were collected from the observation of twinkling artifact with low- and high-PRF/scale and evaluated with the help of IBM SPSS 24 package, the results were summarized as follow.Results:Change in scale/PRF could not affect the twinkling artifact. The twinkling artifact observed with low-PRF was the same as seen with high-PRF. There was a significant agreement between low- and high-PRF in the production of color twinkling artifact. The kappa value of agreement was estimated as 0.96, whereas the Pearson's correlation was significant with the value of 0.001. Same twinkling artifact was created with low- and high-PRF, with no significant variation.Conclusion:Twinkling artifact is independent of PRF/Scale.

Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact in Diagnosis of Tuberculous Pleuritis: A Comparison with Gray-Scale Ultrasonography and Computed Tomography

The aim of this study was to determine whether twinkling artifact (TA) detected on color Doppler ultrasonography can effectively determine the presence of pleural calcification compared with computed tomography (CT) and differentiate tuberculous pleuritis (TP) and cancerous pleuritis (CP). One hundred six cases of TP and 26 cases of CP were scanned using gray-scale ultrasonography (GSU) and TA to determine the presence of pleural calcification. With CT as the reference standard, 63.3% and 79.6% of patients with pleural calcification were identified with GSU and TA, respectively. The detection rate of TA was higher than that of GSU (p = 0.039). For the whole study population, 37.1% were identified as having pleural calcification with CT, significantly higher than the proportion detected with GSU (25.8%, p = 0.001), but not different from that detected with TA (41.7%, p = 0.327). The sensitivity, specificity, accuracy, positive predictive value and negative predictive value of TA were 79.6%, 80.7%, 80.3%, 70.9% and 87.0%, respectively. The detection rate of TA was significantly higher than that of GSU (p < 0.001). When GSU was combined with TA (GSUTA), the positive rate in the TP group was significantly higher than that in the CP group (χ2 < 0.001). In conclusion, TA is comparable to CT and more sensitive than GSU in the detection of pleural calcification. Evaluation for GSUTA on pleura may help to differentiate TP from CP.

An In vitro Study of Guidewire-Related Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts in Echocardiography.

Purpose:This study sought to determine the association between twinkling artifacts on color Doppler ultrasound and different types of guidewires.Materials and Methods:Twenty-two commonly used guidewires were classified into three groups according to decreasing diameter (Group 1, 0.035”; Group 2, 0.018”; and Group 3, 0.014”) and tested in vitro. Severity of twinkling was visually graded into four categories (0–3, from weak to strong).Results:The percentages (tips/shafts) of twinkling artifacts were 100%/100% for Group 1; 0%/33.3% for Group 2; and 18.8%/31% for Group 3. The mean scores (tips/shafts) were 2.3/2.7 for Group 1; 0/0.3 for Group 2; and 0.3/0.4 for Group 3. Among them, both two guidewires with strong twinkling artifacts (score = 3) exhibited extensive rough surfaces on microscopic pictures.Conclusion:The twinkling artifacts were more likely to present in guidewires with larger diameters (from 0.014” to 0.035”) in our study settings. The surface roughness may be the contribution to the twinkling artifact. Internal heterogeneities, such as types of material, types of coating, tip loading, and spring coil length, do not show influence on the twinkling artifact.

Noninvasive Prediction of Renal Stone Surface Irregularities by Numerical Analysis of the Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact: An Ex Vivo Study.

The physical structures of renal stones are highly correlated with their breakability. Noninvasive estimation of stone roughness will be beneficial for management. The intensity of the twinkling artifact appearing at the site of renal stones on Doppler ultrasound imaging is also influenced by the stone's roughness level. This article proposes a quantitative method for roughness prediction of ex vivo renal stones based on a twinkling analysis of their color Doppler images. Twenty surgically removed renal stones were first spatially modeled by an optical method, and 12 standard roughness measures were extracted from them. Stones were then embedded in an agar-based phantom and Doppler imaged with a calibrated ultrasound system. The images were preprocessed, and 11 twinkling intensities were measured numerically. The twinkling data along with the roughness labels were then analyzed by multiple linear regressions, and finally, a linear roughness predictor was trained for renal stones. The core height measure of roughness had the best linear fit to the twinkling data among other roughness parameters. The results of the multiple linear regression analysis indicated a strong linear relationship between twinkling data and stones' roughness, with an R2 value of 83.29% and high statistical significance of F(11,868) = 393.36 and P < .001. It was possible to predict the core roughness of renal stones using the proposed method and the twinkling artifact data acquired from the color Doppler images ex vivo.

A Novel Approach for Quantification and Analysis of the Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact With Application in Noninvasive Surface Roughness Characterization

The twinkling artifact is an undesired phenomenon within color Doppler sonograms that usually appears at the site of internal calcifications. Since the appearance of the twinkling artifact is correlated with the roughness of the calculi, noninvasive roughness estimation of the internal stones may be considered as a potential twinkling artifact application. This article proposes a novel quantitative approach for measurement and analysis of twinkling artifact data for roughness estimation. A phantom was developed with 7 quantified levels of roughness. The Doppler system was initially calibrated by the proposed procedure to facilitate the analysis. A total of 1050 twinkling artifact images were acquired from the phantom, and 32 novel numerical measures were introduced and computed for each image. The measures were then ranked on the basis of roughness quantification ability using different methods. The performance of the proposed twinkling artifact-based surface roughness quantification method was finally investigated for different combinations of features and classifiers. Eleven features were shown to be the most efficient numerical twinkling artifact measures in roughness characterization. The linear classifier outperformed other methods for twinkling artifact classification. The pixel count measures produced better results among the other categories. The sequential selection method showed higher accuracy than other individual rankings. The best roughness recognition average accuracy of 98.33% was obtained by the first 5 principle components and the linear classifier. The proposed twinkling artifact analysis method could recognize the phantom surface roughness with average accuracy of 98.33%. This method may also be applicable for noninvasive calculi characterization in treatment management.

Correlation Between Twinkling Artifact and Color Doppler Carrier Frequency: Preliminary Observations in Renal Calculi

Color Doppler twinkling is a well-defined but not well-understood phenomenon that may assist in the detection of renal calculi. However, the relationship between the appearance of color Doppler twinkling and color Doppler carrier frequency has not been described systematically. To evaluate this relationship, a retrospective review was performed on 20 cases of renal calculi detected by twinkling on renal color Doppler sonography and confirmed with unenhanced computed tomography. The variable strength of twinkling at and behind renal calculi was observed with color Doppler carrier frequencies ranging from 1.75–4.0 MHz. All 20 calculi (100%) demonstrated twinkling when a low color Doppler carrier frequency, 1.75 or 2 MHz, was applied, whereas 12 of 20 cases (60%) were absent of twinkling when the highest carrier frequencies tested—3.5 or 4 MHz—were used. Quantitatively, there was a significant correlation between the amount of twinkling and carrier frequency (p = 0.002102). Hence, we conclude that the strength of the twinkling is color Doppler carrier frequency–dependent. The strength of the twinkling significantly increased when the color carrier frequency used for imaging decreased. Therefore, to improve renal calculi detection by enhancing the strength of the twinkling, the use of a lower color Doppler carrier frequency is recommended.

Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts from Gallbladder Adenomyomatosis with 1.8 MHz and 4.0 MHz Color Doppler Frequencies

The purpose of this study was to investigate the diagnostic value of color Doppler twinkling artifacts (CDTAs) in the evaluation of gallbladder adenomyomatosis with differently colored Doppler frequencies. An ultrasound was performed by an experienced radiologist in 17 patients with typical gallbladder adenomyomatosis. Two abdominal radiologists retrospectively evaluated the anatomic locations, the intensity of 69 CDTAs on 1.8 MHz and 4.0 MHz Doppler frequencies, and the intensity of the corresponding comet-tail artifacts. Statistical analysis was performed using the Friedman and Kruskal-Wallis test. The intensity of the CDTAs was significantly greater than that of the comet-tail artifacts, regardless of the color Doppler frequency and anatomic location (p < 0.001). The intensity of the CDTAs on 1.8 MHz was significantly higher than that on 4.0 MHz color Doppler frequency (p < 0.05). In conclusion, CDTAs may be useful in recognizing gallbladder adenomyomatosis, and 1.8 MHz color Doppler frequency is more highly recommended than 4.0 MHz for the visualization of CDTAs.

Value of Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts from Gallbladder Adenomyomatosis

Value of Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts from Gallbladder Adenomyomatosis

Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact of Calcified Cardiac Valves In Vitro: A Not Well Known Phenomenon in Echocardiography

The color Doppler twinkling artifact manifests as a rapidly changing mixture of red and blue colors behind strongly reflective structures. The twinkling artifact occurs behind diseased cardiac valves, although the phenomenon is not well described. This study sought to determine the presence of the color Doppler twinkling artifact in calcified cardiac valves in vitro using soft tissue radiography for reference. Seventeen specimens of diseased cardiac valves from patients undergoing valve replacement surgery were studied. The overall sensitivity and specificity for the detection of calcifications using the presence of the twinkling artifact were 66.7% and 81.8%, respectively. If valves with only microcalcifications or smooth calcifications were eliminated from the analysis, all (100%) of the three valves with irregular macrocalcifications exhibited the twinkling artifact. It is important to recognize this artifact because it may lead to misdiagnosis of vascular flow in echocardiography. (E-mail: antrouble@yahoo.com.tw)

Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts from Gallstones: In Vitro Analysis Regarding their Compositions and Architectures

The purpose of our study was to investigate the relationship between a twinkling artifact and the biochemical compositions of gallstones in phantom experiments. Fifty-two gallstones surgically extracted from 26 patients (26 cholesterol, 12 brown pigment and 14 black pigment stones) were included in the phantom study. Color Doppler sonography was performed to evaluate the occurrence of a twinkling artifact behind the stones. The artifacts were graded from grade 0 (no artifact) to grade 3 (very strong artifact). Micro computed tomography (CT) images were obtained to analyze the internal architecture and external surface of the stones. A total of 20 of 26 cholesterol stones (77%) produced grade 2 or 3 artifacts, whereas almost all the black pigment stones and more than half of the brown pigment stones produced no artifacts or grade 1 artifacts ( p = 0.0010). The sensitivity and specificity of grade 2 or greater artifacts for cholesterol stones were 76.9% and 76.9%, respectively. The composition of the stones was strongly correlated with the internal shape on the micro CT image. Cholesterol stones with rough surfaces did not show stronger intensities of the artifacts than those with smooth surfaces ( p > 0.05). In conclusion, most of the prominent artifacts arose from cholesterol stones having radial or radial-concentric internal architectures, whereas the black pigment stones mostly produced little artifact. (E-mail: leejy4u@snu.ac.kr)

Color Doppler Twinkling Artifacts in Various Conditions During Abdominal and Pelvic Sonography

The aims of this study were to describe the mechanisms likely to be responsible for color Doppler twinkling artifacts and their associated machine factors and to illustrate the various conditions that cause twinkling artifacts and those pitfalls. We evaluated various sonographic machine-associated factors that influence artifact appearance and identified various conditions that display twinkling artifacts during abdominal and pelvic sonography. The presence of twinkling artifacts was found to be dependent on focal zones, gray scale gains, color write priorities, and pulse repetition frequencies. Twinkling artifacts were found to be associated with calcified lesions in the liver, gallbladder adenomyomatosis, hepatic bile duct hamartoma, gallstones and choledocholithiasis, chronic pancreatitis, urinary stones, encrusted indwelling urinary stents, bowel gas, and metallic foreign bodies. However, some of the twinkling artifacts were found to be associated with false-negative and -positive results. Color Doppler twinkling artifacts are additional useful sonographic signs in the diagnosis of calcified lesions, urinary and biliary stones, gallbladder adenomyomatosis, and some miscellaneous conditions.

1054: Clinical Applications of the Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact in Abdominal and Pelvic Sonography: An Illustrative Review

1054: Clinical Applications of the Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact in Abdominal and Pelvic Sonography: An Illustrative Review

Correlation Study of the Strength of the Color Doppler Twinkling Artifact with the Roughness of the Reflecting Surface and the Doppler Angles

Background The color Doppler twinkling artifact is manifested as a rapidly changing mixture of red and blue colors behind a strongly reflecting structure. The effects of the roughness of the reflecting surface and the Doppler angle on the intensity of the twinkling artifact have never been quantitatively reported before. In this study, a simple in vitro system with reproducible results was established to observe the effects of these two factors on the strength of the twinkling artifact. Materials and Methods Six different grits of water sandpapers were simultaneously scanned in a water bath with a fixed probe. In part 1, the computer calculated the pixels of color Doppler twinkling artifact behind each water sandpaper. In part 2, the signals of twinkling artifacts with different sandpaper sizes and different Doppler angles were recorded and analyzed. Results In part 1, the twinkling artifact was identified persistently and more intensely behind water sandpapers that had greater surface roughness. In part 2, different Doppler angles revealed less obvious effects on the strength of the twinkling artifacts in a certain range of angles, but would drastically decrease the intensity in the steeper angles. Conclusions We have established a simple model system with water sandpapers for the evaluation of the twinkling artifact. Our data confirmed the assumption that the roughness of the reflecting surface is directly related to the strength of the twinkling artifact. In addition, the Doppler angle affects the intensity of the artifact, but only in the steeper angles.

Color and power Doppler twinkling artifacts from urinary stones: clinical observations and phantom studies.

The purpose of this study was to determine whether color and power Doppler twinkling artifacts could be considered an additional diagnostic sonographic feature of urinary stones. A prospective study was performed in 32 patients with 20 renal stones and 16 ureteral stones to assess how often urinary stones show twinkling artifacts on Doppler sonography. Gray-scale images and color, power, and spectral Doppler images were obtained in all patients. All sonographic examinations were performed with a 3.5- or 5-MHz curvilinear phased array probe. The images were then analyzed for the presence, appearance, and intensity of the artifacts. Phantom experiments were performed with various kinds of urinary stones with high-megahertz linear phased array probes. The effects on the artifacts of the composition of the stones, of the Doppler velocity scale, and of the focal zone were investigated. Thirty (83%) of 36 urinary stones showed color and power Doppler twinkling artifacts, which appeared as a rapidly changing color complex seen persistently behind stones like a comet's tail. Twenty-two of 30 stones with the twinkling artifacts showed strong intensity artifacts. Spectra with saturated amplitude were obtained from all 30 stones showing color Doppler artifacts. In phantom experiments, the artifacts originated from all stones. The velocity range did not affect the artifacts, whereas focal zone did. Color Doppler twinkling artifacts from urinary stones occur frequently and may be considered an additional sonographic feature of urinary stones. The observation of these artifacts may be helpful in determining the presence of urinary stones.