Collective Wisdom Research Articles

Dynamic fractal organizations—A boundaries based‐view of knowledge

AbstractCollective phronesis is the collection of the best‐distributed phronesis of humans and is also integrated phronesis for all management that combines the collective wisdom of individuals within and even between organizations. In a good organization, rather than only certain heroes with phronesis creating new knowledge, phronesis is organized to realize innovation by bringing together the high‐quality wisdom and practical power of various practitioners at all levels of the organization, as well as in its customers and partners. This makes it possible to build dynamic fractal organizations – tough collectives that can respond creatively and with agility in real‐time, no matter what occurs, including rapid changes in the environment. However, little is known from previous studies regarding the formation mechanisms of collective phronesis and dynamic fractal organizations. In this paper, we present a new theoretical model of the formation mechanism of collective phronesis, and dynamic fractal organizations based on inductive research through field surveys and in‐depth case studies, expanding on the concept of boundaries knowledge, which has been explored in existing research.

Content validation of the nursing diagnosis “ineffective protection” in the context of adolescents with cancer

ObjectiveTo analyze the relevance of a set of clinical elements to represent the content domain of the nursing diagnosis Ineffective Protection. Design and methodsThis study employed content validation, using expert judgment to assess the appropriateness of clinical indicators, etiological factors, and conceptual and operational definitions, integrating the collective wisdom framework, the theory of predictive diversity, and the determination of rater skill level. ResultsFrom the middle range theory, 28 clinical indicators and 17 etiological factors were identified, which were rated by 34 raters. The analysis showed that the clinical indicators restlessness and insomnia and the etiological factors ambient temperature and humidity were not considered relevant for the nursing diagnosis of Ineffective Protection, because the median content validity index was lower than 0.9. ConclusionsContent validation verified that most of the components of the nursing diagnosis of Ineffective Protection were considered relevant by judges. Practical implicationsIt is believed that the data obtained can help nurses to more easily evaluate the related factors and clinical indicators of Ineffective Protection presented by adolescents with cancer, which favors the process of diagnostic inference.

Evaluation of a public health workplace staff psychosocial risk assessment and wellbeing initiative

Abstract Adverse psychosocial work environments can have a detrimental effect on staff wellbeing causing chronic stress leading to burnout. Despite legislation mandating regular risk assessments, only one third of workplaces assess psychosocial risks. A 2020 European report identified one of the main barriers being a reluctance to talk openly about psychosocial issues. This paper describes an evaluation of a staff psychosocial risk assessment and wellbeing initiative in a Public Health Department in Ireland. The initiative commenced in October 2022 during a period of major health service organisational change. Informed by positive organisational psychology conceptual frameworks, guided by the European Psychosocial risk assessment framework (PRIMA-EF) and utilising the HSE Work Positive (CI) survey tool it was possible to constructively identify and categorise psychosocial risks across the Public Health team. In the evaluation, a mixed methods approach was used based on Donabedian’s structures, processes and outcomes overarching framework and Nielsen’s Model of Process Evaluation Framework. The first three iterative quality improvement cycles of the intervention were reviewed. The evaluation demonstrated that all of Nielson’s three indicators for a successful organisational level staff wellbeing intervention had been met: there was evidence of improvement in both working conditions and staff wellbeing; iterative quality improvement cycles including appreciative inquiry staff collaborative engagement ensured staff views and key learning was captured; new organisational structures within the Department enabled the sustainability of this process. The evaluation indicates that the staff psychosocial risk assessment process is beneficial for staff wellbeing and that the methods used are appropriate. The resources used in this process continue to be readily available within the health service organisation. The evaluation supports continuation of this process in its present form. Key messages • This evaluation supports staff psychosocial risk assessment and mitigation processes and provides a framework for healthcare managers to implement such processes and comply with legislation. • This evaluation indicates that effective and sustainable collaborative staff engagement can be achieved using a positive focus which builds on team strengths and harnesses collective wisdom.

Predicting and assessing the impacts of COVID-19 disruption on marine science and sectors in Australia

AbstractBy March 2020 coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) was anticipated to present a major challenge to the work undertaken by scientists. This pandemic could be considered just one of the shocks that human society has had and will be likely to confront again in the future. As strategic thinking about the future can assist performance and planning of scientific research in the face of change, the pandemic presented an opportunity to evaluate the performance of marine researchers in prediction of future outcomes. In March 2020, two groups of researchers predicted outcomes for the Australian marine research sector, and then evaluated these predictions after 18 months. The self-assessed coping ability of a group experienced in ‘futures studies’ was not higher than the less-experienced group, suggesting that scientists in general may be well placed to cope with shocks. A range of changes to scientific endeavours (e.g., travel, fieldwork) and to marine sectors (e.g., fisheries, biodiversity) were predicted over the first 12–18 months of COVID-19 disruption. The predicted direction of change was generally correct (56%) or neutral (25%) for predictions related to the scientific endeavour, and correct (73%) or mixed (9%) for predictions related to sectors that are the focus of marine research. The success of this foresighting experiment suggests that the collective wisdom of scientists can be used by their organisations to consider the impact of shocks and disruptions and to better prepare for and cope with shocks. Graphical abstract Word cloud analysis of free text responses to questions about expected impact of COVID-19 on the activities associated with marine science

From Wet to Protective: Film Formation in Waterborne Coatings.

The importance of anticorrosive coatings cannot be overstated, as they play a vital role in safeguarding assets and infrastructure across various industries. Within this context, the emergence of waterborne (WB) coatings stands out for their paramount significance, offering a sustainable alternative to traditional solvent-based (SB) coatings and addressing pressing environmental concerns. Despite their eco-friendliness, the complexity of their film formation mechanism and the lack of understanding present challenges in enhancing the performance of waterborne coatings for corrosion protection. These coatings are created by dispersing polymers in water, which then form a protective film on a substrate. The process involves stages like water evaporation, particle packing, and polymer interdiffusion, often leading to films with defects and inferior protection against extremely corrosive environments compared to SB coatings. This Review scrutinizes the interplay of factors affecting film formation in application, including coalescing agents, environmental factors, and application conditions. A comparative analysis between SB and WB coatings is also featured to shed light on the performance gap under harsh conditions. This Review discusses analytical techniques for studying film formation, aiming to guide future research toward improving WB coatings' durability and effectiveness. In compiling this collective wisdom, this Review emphasizes the translation of theoretical understanding into practical knowledge, equipping formulators with actionable insights to optimize WB coatings for real-world application and performance.

Collective Impact-Strengthening the Science and Practice of Implementation Support: Evaluating the Effectiveness of Training and Technical Assistance Centers.

We introduce the second of two special issues that examine the science and practice of implementation support with takeaways for training and technical centers (TTACs). Major goals of both issues were to provide: rationale, concepts, and tools for evaluating training and technical assistance (TTA); an evidence-base for TTACs; and greater understanding of what is required to close the research-practice gap. To achieve these ambitious goals, we encouraged submissions from a broad array of individuals and groups involved in TTA. The seven articles in this second issue were written by a diverse mix of individuals affiliated with TTACs, federal agencies, research-oriented think tanks, and implementation scientists whose focus is on advancing the TTA literature. We felt that the collective wisdom garnered from their experiences would complement the first issue (June 2024) and collectively forge ahead and provide a vision of what is to come. We also thought it would be useful to provide perspectives on what it looks like when readers could examine both issues as a whole. Therefore, we included five commentaries-from the two editors and esteemed colleagues-who help provide a holistic perspective on the present and future of the science and practice of implementation support.

Народный делиберативный конституционализм как коллективная мудрость: понятие и предназначение в российской и сравнительной конституционной юриспруденции

The article identifies the ideological sources of collective wisdom, the doctrinal and normative foundations of popular deliberative constitutionalism, some aspects of the inclusive constitutional paradigm, procedures, and technologies for the participation of citizens and civil society institutions in constitutional modernization and constitutional changes in the context of Russian and comparative experience. The article considers popular deliberative constitutionalism as a meta-concept that can be used to analyze prescriptive requirements and promising principles in the constitutional modernization of the state and society, forms and procedures for citizen participation in constitutional changes, processes of preparation and implementation of constitutional changes in the modern period. Popular constitutionalism in scientific works develops as a special doctrinal, normative, and procedural basis for the implementation of the principle of popular sovereignty, the constituent power of the people, the involvement of citizens and civil society institutions in the process of constitutional changes. The author concludes that constitutional collective wisdom in the information age arises as a result of the use of both analog and digital technologies, classical procedures for discussion and the use of aggregated preferences, and a combination of natural and artificial intelligence.

Collective Wisdom in Constitutional, Informational and Digital Dimensions: on the Concept and Nature of Popular Deliberative Constitutionalism for Public Law

The article discusses the scientific and intellectual origins of collective wisdom in the constitutional, information and digital dimensions, reveals the doctrinal approaches and normative foundations of popular deliberative constitutionalism, the development of an inclusive constitutional paradigm and its significance for the use of procedures and technologies for citizen participation, expert opinion and civil society institutions in the constitutional development, in social transformations, in constitutional changes brought to life by the needs of society and the state. Popular deliberative constitutionalism is identified in the article as a public legal meta-concept that explains the process and need for constitutional involvement of citizens. The author concludes that popular deliberative constitutionalism allows us to better understand the problems of implementing the principle of popular sovereignty in modern democratic states, create an optimal model and consider the forms of exercising the constituent power of the people when implementing constitutional changes. In the article, the author notes that the future of democratic constitutionalism is associated with the creation and use of collective intelligence technologies in the public legal sphere, which, in the context of the development of an algorithmic and information society, combine classical procedures for discussing constitutional issues and the use of aggregated preferences. The practical application of the achievements of natural and artificial intelligence is intended to discuss and resolve issues of public legal significance, is based on co-evolutionary development and leads to the emergence of mini-publics, civil assemblies, and constitutional crowdsourcing.

Enhancing group decision-making: Maximum consensus aggregation for fuzzy cross-efficiency under hesitant fuzzy linguistic information

Group decision-making (GDM) is essential as it recognizes the inherent complexity of many decision scenarios, which frequently require the collective wisdom and knowledge of multiple decision-makers (DMs) to be effectively resolved. The proposed method aims to develop fuzzy data envelopment analysis (DEA) cross-efficiency models tailored to address GDM challenges, wherein attribute values are provided by DMs using hesitant fuzzy linguistic term sets (HFLTSs). For this purpose, we initially transform HFLTSs into their corresponding fuzzy envelopes, defined as trapezoidal fuzzy numbers (TrFNs). This conversion strategy effectively minimizes the loss in assessments based on HFLTSs while retaining the inherent ambiguity of the original information. Building upon this foundation, we develop fuzzy cross-efficiency models by leveraging the α-level sets of fuzzy envelopes. These models are designed to handle fuzzy input and output variables under various α-level sets, which are capable of considering all possible attribute values for each alternative. Following this, we implement a maximum consensus model using fuzzy cross-efficiency to assign weights to DMs. These weights facilitate the aggregation of individual fuzzy cross-efficiency intervals obtained from DMs’ assessments into collective ones, which serve to rank alternatives. Finally, we showcase the effectiveness and superiority of our proposal through numerical validation and comparative analysis.

Heteronomy, Repression, and Collective Wisdom

One of the most controversial notions in Herbert Marcuse’s One-Dimensional Man is the distinction between true and false needs. In this commentary, I suggest that Marcuse’s distinction is ambiguous between two readings, which I term the Repression Reading and the Heteronomy Reading, respectively. I argue that considerations from Maiese and Hanna’s (2019) notion of the Mind Shaping Thesis can help to see why we ought to reject the Heteronomy Reading in favor of the Repression Reading of false needs. I then suggest that the Repression Reading of false needs can, in turn, reveal some weaknesses in Maiese and Hanna’s theory of collectively wise social institutions.

Философские и религиозно-этические аспекты прав интеллектуальной собственности

In the articlethe progression of intellectual property in contemporary society, delving into its philosophical and religious-ethical dimensionswereexplored. It traces the origins of copyright and highlights the crucial role intellectual property plays in safeguarding intellectual achievements that influence numerous aspects of life, effectively representing the collective wisdom of humanity. The intellectual realm is integral to societal development and well-being, making it imperative for all participants in social interactions to engage with in-tellectual property tofoster their progress and growth. Despite efforts to elucidate, analyze, and establish the intellectual property framework, these attempts have been inadequate. Although definitions are available, there remains a lack of comprehensive understanding withinsociety regarding the nature of intellectual prop-erty and how to effectively manage it. This gap in comprehension may overlook the complexity and distinc-tiveness of intellectual property. The primary goal of this study is to examine the perspectives of scholars and thinkers on intellectual property, aiming to grasp the breadth and importance of scientific endeavors neces-sary for its advancement.

LINGUOCULTURAL ANALYSIS OF PAREMIOLOGICAL DICTIONARIES IN KARAKALPAK AND ENGLISH LANGUAGES

Language is a powerful tool that reflects the cultural identity and worldview of its speakers. Proverbs, in particular, are rich linguistic expressions that encapsulate the collective wisdom, traditions, and values of a culture. The study of proverbs, known as paremiology, provides invaluable insights into the way different societies perceive the world and convey their experiences. In this article, we will conduct a linguocultural analysis of paremiological dictionaries in the Karakalpak and English languages. Paremiological dictionaries serve as vital resources for documenting and preserving the proverbial wisdom of a culture. Through a comparative approach, this study will examine the linguistic features and cultural meanings embedded in the proverbs of both languages, highlighting how proverbs function as a bridge between language and culture. The Karakalpak and English languages represent two distinct linguistic and cultural traditions. By analyzing proverbs from these two languages, we aim to uncover the similarities and differences in how they express values, beliefs, and social norms.

Multiple financial analyst opinions aggregation based on uncertainty-aware quality evaluation

Financial analysts’ opinions are pivotal in investment decision-making, as they provide valuable expert knowledge. Aggregating these opinions offers a promising way to unlock their collective wisdom. However, existing opinion aggregation methods are hindered by their inability to effectively assess differences in opinion quality, resulting in suboptimal outcomes. This Study introduces a novel model called SmartMOA, which addresses this limitation by automatically evaluating the quality of each opinion and integrating this evaluation into the aggregation process. Our model begins with a novel Bayesian neural network that leverages the implicit knowledge embedded in the interactions between analysts and stock characteristics. This methodology produces an assessment of individual opinions that accounts for uncertainties. We then formulate a bi-objective combinatorial optimization problem to determine optimal weights for combining multiple analysts’ opinions, simultaneously minimizing the error and uncertainty of the aggregated outcome. Therefore, SmartMOA systematically highlights high-quality opinions during the aggregation process. Using a real dataset spanning eight years, we present comprehensive empirical evidence that demonstrates the superior performance of SmartMOA in heterogeneous analyst opinion aggregation.

Evidence-based social science: why, what, and future implications

Mankind has always relied on “practical wisdom” in the sense of Aristotle to change people and society. However, practical wisdom is difficult to accumulate and pass on from generation to generation. Therefore, although “natural engineering” that is consistent with “natural technology” can be used effectively to transform the natural world, using “practical wisdom” to change people and society remains difficult. Solving this dilemma requires an effective means to separate “social science”, “social technology”, and “social engineering” to accumulate and inherit “knowledge of changing people and society” similar to other types of scientific knowledge. Today, the prevailing evidence-based social science is the opposition and unity of laws of nature and free will, truth-seeking and goodness-pursuing, individual wisdom and collective wisdom, autonomy and supervision, the universal and the special in practice. The emergence of this concept allows for the possibility to enhance the effectiveness of social science practice.

The Impact of Heterogeneous Forms for the Same Subject on the Professional Development of English Teachers

As an educational research method, heterogeneous forms for the same subject cannot only help teachers accelerate the internalization of teaching concepts in a short period of time, but also highlight the social value of individual teachers and generate collective wisdom, which can effectively and quickly promote the professional development of English teachers. This paper expounds the related concepts of heterogeneous forms for the same subject and English teachers' professional development, and basically illustrates that heterogeneous forms for the same subject is one of the effective ways to promote the professional development of high school English teachers.

Toward a new clinical pragmatism: method in clinical ethics consultation.

In this paper, I leverage the pragmatist tradition in philosophy, the collective wisdom of scholarship in clinical ethics consultation, and earlier attempts to apply pragmatism in clinical ethics to develop a new vision of clinical ethics practice called New Clinical Pragmatism. It argues that clinical ethics methodology, from the New Clinical Pragmatist's perspective, amounts to the recommendation that consultants should customize a methodological approach, drawing on the various available methods, depending on the demands of the specific case, and should avoid attempts to identify a 'true' methodology but to the incoherence and inevitable failure of those attempts. I argue that pragmatism's emphasis on practical wisdom and experimentation allow the New Clinical Pragmatist to do this while avoiding irrationality in choosing methods. I discuss how the New Clinical Pragmatist gives a unique, constructive perspective on key aspects of clinical ethics consultation such as the choice of common morality vs. internal morality of medicine approaches, process standards, bioethics mediation, and narrative ethics, and suggest how New Clinical Pragmatism's relaxed approach to choice of methodology encourages consultants to balance attention to the particulars of the case with knowledge of what the many insightful scholars of clinical ethics methodology have found useful in the past. I also argue that New Clinical Pragmatism is consistent with efforts to professionalize clinical ethics consultation.

Emerging Agricultural Engineering Sciences, Technologies, and Applications

The closing Editorial of this comprehensive special collection presents the journey from this project’s inception to the publication of around five dozen outstanding studies that have been a testament to the dedication, innovation, and collective wisdom of the global agricultural engineering community [...]

Collective Wisdom: Collecting in the Early Modern Academy ed. by Anna Marie Roos and Vera Keller (review)

Collective Wisdom: Collecting in the Early Modern Academy ed. by Anna Marie Roos and Vera Keller (review)

Syair in the Life of Contemporary Malays in Singapore

Syair, a form of traditional Malay poetry believed to have been adapted from the Persian or Arab civilization, has been a popular performative art in the Malay world, including Singapore. It has evolved since its first introduction to the Malay Archipelago with the coming of Islam, and what constitutes as syair today is a culmination of its language structure, aesthetics, and depth of author’s insights as a form of the Malay community’s creative art. Once prevalent amongst the Malays until the 1970s, syair has significantly declined in popularity with the emergence of modern poetry and printed prose, and modern-day forms of entertainment, among other things, though it is still familiar to the urban and contemporary Malays in Singapore. Based on the data collected from a research project (2018 to 2020) in Singapore, this paper demonstrates that syair in the form of rare hikayat (tales) texts and manuscripts are still kept as personal collection and family heirloom. Albeit dwindling in number, the art of syair recital is slowly eroding if not for individuals who perceive the preservation of syairtexts and the art of syair recital as their honourable responsibility, akin to preserving the Malays’ social memory and collective wisdom.

Collective Wisdom: Collecting in the Early Modern Academy, by Anna Marie Roos and Vera Keller, eds.

Collective Wisdom: Collecting in the Early Modern Academy, by Anna Marie Roos and Vera Keller, eds.