p-Hydroxybenzoate hydroxylase (PHBH) catalyzes the ortho-hydroxylation of 4-hydroxybenzoate (4-HB) to protocatechuate (PCA). PHBHs are commonly known as homodimers, and the prediction of pyridine nucleotide binding and specificity remains an ongoing focus in this field. Therefore, our study aimed to determine the dimerization interface in AspPHBH from Arthrobacter sp. PAMC25564 and identify the canonical pyridine nucleotide-binding residues, along with coenzyme specificity, through site-directed mutagenesis. The results confirm a functional dimeric assembly from a tetramer that appeared in the crystallographic asymmetric unit identical to that established in previous studies. Furthermore, AspPHBH exhibits coenzyme versatility, utilizing both NADH and NADPH, with a preference for NADH. Rational engineering experiments demonstrated that targeted mutations in coenzyme surrounding residues profoundly impact NADPH binding, leading to nearly abrogated enzymatic activity compared to that of NADH. R50, R273, and S166 emerged as significant residues for NAD(P)H binding, having a near-fatal impact on NADPH binding compared to NADH. Likewise, the E44 residue plays a critical role in determining coenzyme specificity. Overall, our findings contribute to the fundamental understanding of the determinants of PHBH's active dimeric conformation, coenzyme binding and specificity holding promise for biotechnological advancements.