Rotting wood is widely recognized as an important feature for bryophyte diversity in forest ecosystems but forest management practices, focused on high yields, have led to widespread reductions in the quantity and quality of coarse woody debris (CWD). As a result, many epixylic specialists are now uncommon or threatened throughout much of their former ranges. How much CWD is required to maintain desirable biodiversity, and which qualities of CWD do this most effectively is still to be answered. To address this, we analyzed two datasets from mid-rotation and mature plantations from the same landscape to better understand how the epixylic community varies with stand age, wetness, silvicultural treatment, and the abundance and type of CWD. Mature stands were either partially cut with a strip-cut treatment or were untreated. Mid-rotation plantations had a higher richness of non-Sphagnum mosses and liverworts than mature plantations. Both plantation types had a similar Simpson’s diversity indices, but these were lower than those of treated and untreated mature white cedar stands and untreated mature softwood stands. While composition of both plantation types was similar, only mature plantations differed significantly from other stand types. We speculate that this discrepancy between mid-rotation plantations and mature plantations was due to better soil drainage and a longer duration of intensive management in mature plantations, leading to reduced CWD abundance, and therefore to reduced bryophyte diversity. Our results revealed a clear positive relationship between total CWD surface area and liverwort richness and diversity in xeric sites while no relation was detected in mesic sites. More CWD is better in the case of xeric sites, where apparent asymptote of diversity is near the maximum total CWD detected in these stands. Because canopy composition and humidity also had a significant influence on bryophyte diversity and composition, further studies are needed to clearly identify thresholds of CWD surface area that take into account different stand types, soil moisture, fertility regimes, or with regards to the ecosystem in which the managed stands occurs.