Co-fractionation Mass Spectrometry Research Articles

Discovery and significance of protein-protein interactions in health and disease.

The identification of individual protein-protein interactions (PPIs) began more than 40 years ago, using protein affinity chromatography and antibody co-immunoprecipitation. As new technologies emerged, analysis of PPIs increased to a genome-wide scale with the introduction of intracellular tagging methods, affinity purification (AP) followed by mass spectrometry (MS), and co-fractionation MS (CF-MS). Now, combining the resulting catalogs of interactions with complementary methods, including crosslinking MS (XL-MS) and cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM), helps distinguish direct interactions from indirect ones within the same or between different protein complexes. These powerful approaches and the promise of artificial intelligence applications like AlphaFold herald a future where PPIs and protein complexes, including energy-driven protein machines, will be understood in exquisite detail, unlocking new insights in the contexts of both basic biology and disease.

Profiling Protein-Protein Interactions in the Human Brain by Refined Cofractionation Mass Spectrometry.

Proteins usually execute their biological functions through interactions with other proteins and by forming macromolecular complexes, but global profiling of protein complexes directly from human tissue samples has been limited. In this study, we utilized cofractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) to map protein complexes within the postmortem human brain with experimental replicates. First, we used concatenated anion and cation Ion Exchange Chromatography (IEX) to separate native protein complexes in 192 fractions and then proceeded with Data-Independent Acquisition (DIA) mass spectrometry to analyze the proteins in each fraction, quantifying a total of 4,804 proteins with 3,260 overlapping in both replicates. We improved the DIA's quantitative accuracy by implementing a constant amount of bovine serum albumin (BSA) in each fraction as an internal standard. Next, advanced computational pipelines, which integrate both a database-based complex analysis and an unbiased protein-protein interaction (PPI) search, were applied to identify protein complexes and construct protein-protein interaction networks in the human brain. Our study led to the identification of 486 protein complexes and 10054 binary protein-protein interactions, which represents the first global profiling of human brain PPIs using CF-MS. Overall, this study offers a resource and tool for a wide range of human brain research, including the identification of disease-specific protein complexes in the future.

Mapping protein states and interactions across the tree of life with co-fractionation mass spectrometry

We present CFdb, a harmonized resource of interaction proteomics data from 411 co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) datasets spanning 21,703 fractions. Meta-analysis of this resource charts protein abundance, phosphorylation, and interactions throughout the tree of life, including a reference map of the human interactome. We show how large-scale CF-MS data can enhance analyses of individual CF-MS datasets, and exemplify this strategy by mapping the honey bee interactome.

Next-generation proteomics for quantitative Jumbophage-bacteria interaction mapping

Host-pathogen interactions are pivotal in regulating establishment, progression, and outcome of an infection. While affinity-purification mass spectrometry has become instrumental in characterizing such interactions, it suffers from limitations in scalability and biological authenticity. Here we present the use of co-fractionation mass spectrometry for high throughput analysis of host-pathogen interactions from native viral infections of two jumbophages (ϕKZ and ϕPA3) in Pseudomonas aeruginosa. This approach enabled the detection of > 6000 unique host-pathogen interactions for each phage, encompassing > 50% of their respective proteomes. This deep coverage provided evidence for interactions between KZ-like phage proteins and the host ribosome, and revealed protein complexes for previously undescribed phage ORFs, including a ϕPA3 complex showing strong structural and sequence similarity to ϕKZ non-virion RNA polymerase. Interactome-wide comparison across phages showed similar perturbed protein interactions suggesting fundamentally conserved mechanisms of phage predation within the KZ-like phage family. To enable accessibility to this data, we developed PhageMAP, an online resource for network query, visualization, and interaction prediction (https://phagemap.ucsf.edu/). We anticipate this study will lay the foundation for the application of co-fractionation mass spectrometry for the scalable profiling of host-pathogen interactomes and protein complex dynamics upon infection.

Dynamic remodeling of Escherichia coli interactome in response to environmental perturbations.

Proteins play an essential role in the vital biological processes governing cellular functions. Most proteins function as members of macromolecular machines, with the network of interacting proteins revealing the molecular mechanisms driving the formation of these complexes. Profiling the physiology-driven remodeling of these interactions within different contexts constitutes a crucial component to achieving a comprehensive systems-level understanding of interactome dynamics. Here, we apply co-fractionation mass spectrometry and computational modeling to quantify and profile the interactions of ∼2000 proteins in the bacterium Escherichia coli cultured under 10 distinct culture conditions. The resulting quantitative co-elution patterns revealed large-scale condition-dependent interaction remodeling among protein complexes involved in diverse biochemical pathways in response to the unique environmental challenges. The network-level analysis highlighted interactome-wide biophysical properties and structural patterns governing interaction remodeling. Our results provide evidence of the local and global plasticity of the E. coli interactome along with a rigorous generalizable framework to define protein interaction specificity. We provide an accompanying interactive web application to facilitate the exploration of these rewired networks.

Integration of data-independent acquisition (DIA) with co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) to enhance interactome mapping capabilities.

Proteomics technologies are continually advancing, providing opportunities to develop stronger and more robust protein interaction networks (PINs). In part, this is due to the ever-growing number of high-throughput proteomics methods that are available. This review discusses how data-independent acquisition (DIA) and co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) can be integrated to enhance interactome mapping abilities. Furthermore, integrating these two techniques can improve data quality and network generation through extended protein coverage, less missing data, and reduced noise. CF-DIA-MS shows promise in expanding our knowledge of interactomes, notably for non-model organisms (NMOs). CF-MS is a valuable technique on its own, but upon the integration of DIA, the potential to develop robust PINs increases, offering a unique approach for researchers to gain an in-depth understanding into the dynamics of numerous biological processes.

Don't let go: co-fractionation mass spectrometry for untargeted mapping of protein-metabolite interactomes.

The chemical complexity of metabolomes goes hand in hand with their functional diversity. Small molecules have many essential roles, many of which are executed by binding and modulating the function of a protein partner. The complex and dynamic protein-metabolite interaction (PMI) network underlies most if not all biological processes, but remains under-characterized. Herein, we highlight how co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS), a well-established approach to map protein assemblies, can be used for proteome and metabolome identification of the PMIs. We will review recent CF-MS studies, discuss the main advantages and limitations, summarize the available CF-MS guidelines, and outline future challenges and opportunities.

High-Throughput Proteome Profiling of Plasma and Native Plasma Complexes Using Native Chromatography.

We describe a high-throughput method for co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) profiling for native plasma protein profiling. CF-MS allows the profiling of endogenous protein complexes between samples. Proteins often interact with other proteins and form macromolecular complexes that are different in disease states as well as cell states and cell types. This protocol describes an example for the sample preparation of 954 individual size exclusion chromatography (SEC) fractions, derived from 18 plasma samples that were separated into 53 fractions. Eighteen plasma samples were chosen based on the TMTpro multiplexing, but this methodology can be adapted for fewer or larger numbers of samples as appropriate. Our automated sample preparation method allows for high-throughput native plasma profiling, and we provide detailed methods for both a label-free and an isobaric labeling approach, discuss the merits of each approach, and detail the advantages of combining these strategies for comprehensive native plasma proteome profiling.

Rewiring of the protein–protein–metabolite interactome during the diauxic shift in yeast

In budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, the switch from aerobic fermentation to respiratory growth is separated by a period of growth arrest, known as the diauxic shift, accompanied by a significant metabolic rewiring, including the derepression of gluconeogenesis and the establishment of mitochondrial respiration. Previous studies reported hundreds of proteins and tens of metabolites accumulating differentially across the diauxic shift transition. To assess the differences in the protein–protein (PPIs) and protein–metabolite interactions (PMIs) yeast samples harvested in the glucose-utilizing, fermentative phase, ethanol-utilizing and early stationary respiratory phases were analysed using isothermal shift assay (iTSA) and a co-fractionation mass spectrometry approach, PROMIS. Whereas iTSA monitors changes in protein stability and is informative towards protein interaction status, PROMIS uses co-elution to delineate putative PPIs and PMIs. The resulting dataset comprises 1627 proteins and 247 metabolites, hundreds of proteins and tens of metabolites characterized by differential thermal stability and/or fractionation profile, constituting a novel resource to be mined for the regulatory PPIs and PMIs. The examples discussed here include (i) dissociation of the core and regulatory particle of the proteasome in the early stationary phase, (ii) the differential binding of a co-factor pyridoxal phosphate to the enzymes of amino acid metabolism and (iii) the putative, phase-specific interactions between proline-containing dipeptides and enzymes of central carbon metabolism.

PROMIS: Co-fractionation Mass Spectrometry for Analysis of Protein-Metabolite Interactions.

The roles of small molecules in every aspect of life have been gaining increased recognition. Many are known to exert their effect by binding proteins-but a comprehensive overview of protein-metabolite interactions (PMIs) is missing. Recently we devised a non-targeted method for detecting PMIs using size-exclusion chromatography followed by proteomic and metabolomic analysis: PROMIS. Under test this method was able to identify known PMIs such as enzyme-cofactor complexes as well as novel ones.

Scalable multiplex co-fractionation/mass spectrometry platform for accelerated protein interactome discovery

Co-fractionation/mass spectrometry (CF/MS) enables the mapping of endogenous macromolecular networks on a proteome scale, but current methods are experimentally laborious, resource intensive and afford lesser quantitative accuracy. Here, we present a technically efficient, cost-effective and reproducible multiplex CF/MS (mCF/MS) platform for measuring and comparing, simultaneously, multi-protein assemblies across different experimental samples at a rate that is up to an order of magnitude faster than previous approaches. We apply mCF/MS to map the protein interaction landscape of non-transformed mammary epithelia versus breast cancer cells in parallel, revealing large-scale differences in protein-protein interactions and the relative abundance of associated macromolecules connected with cancer-related pathways and altered cellular processes. The integration of multiplexing capability within an optimized workflow renders mCF/MS as a powerful tool for systematically exploring physical interaction networks in a comparative manner.

A co-fractionation mass spectrometry-based prediction of protein complex assemblies in the developing rice aleurone-subaleurone.

Multiprotein complexes execute and coordinate diverse cellular processes such as organelle biogenesis, vesicle trafficking, cell signaling, and metabolism. Knowledge about their composition and localization provides useful clues about the mechanisms of cellular homeostasis and system-level control. This is of great biological importance and practical significance in heterotrophic rice (Oryza sativa) endosperm and aleurone-subaleurone tissues, which are a primary source of seed vitamins and stored energy. Dozens of protein complexes have been implicated in the synthesis, transport, and storage of seed proteins, lipids, vitamins, and minerals. Mutations in protein complexes that control RNA transport result in aberrant endosperm with shrunken and floury phenotypes, significantly reducing seed yield and quality. The purpose of this study was to broadly predict protein complex composition in the aleurone-subaleurone layers of developing rice seeds using co-fractionation mass spectrometry. Following orthogonal chromatographic separations of biological replicates, thousands of protein elution profiles were subjected to distance-based clustering to enable large-scale multimerization state measurements and protein complex predictions. The predicted complexes had predicted functions across diverse functional categories, including novel heteromeric RNA binding protein complexes that may influence seed quality. This effective and open-ended proteomics pipeline provides useful clues about system-level posttranslational control during the early stages of rice seed development.

Separated together: prediction of native protein complexes in rice aleurone via co-fractionation mass spectrometry.

Separated together: prediction of native protein complexes in rice aleurone via co-fractionation mass spectrometry.

Meta-analysis defines principles for the design and analysis of co-fractionation mass spectrometry experiments.

Co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) has emerged as a powerful technique for interactome mapping. However, there is little consensus on optimal strategies for the design of CF-MS experiments or their computational analysis. Here, we reanalyzed a total of 206 CF-MS experiments to generate a uniformly processed resource containing over 11 million measurements of protein abundance. We used this resource to benchmark experimental designs for CF-MS studies and systematically optimize computational approaches to network inference. We then applied this optimized methodology to reconstruct a draft-quality human interactome by CF-MS and predict over 700,000 protein-protein interactions across 27 eukaryotic species or clades. Our work defines new resources to illuminate proteome organization over evolutionary timescales and establishes best practices for the design and analysis of CF-MS studies.

PrInCE: an R/Bioconductor package for protein-protein interaction network inference from co-fractionation mass spectrometry data.

We present PrInCE, an R/Bioconductor package that employs a machine-learning approach to infer protein-protein interaction networks from co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) data. Previously distributed as a collection of Matlab scripts, our ground-up rewrite of this software package in an open-source language dramatically improves runtime and memory requirements. We describe several new features in the R implementation, including a test for the detection of co-eluting protein complexes and a method for differential network analysis. PrInCE is extensively documented and fully compatible with Bioconductor classes, ensuring it can fit seamlessly into existing proteomics workflows. PrInCE is available from Bioconductor (https://www.bioconductor.org/packages/devel/bioc/html/PrInCE.html). Source code is freely available from GitHub under the MIT license (https://github.com/fosterlab/PrInCE). Support is provided via the GitHub issues tracker (https://github.com/fosterlab/PrInCE/issues). Supplementary data are available at Bioinformatics online.

PROMISed: A novel web-based tool to facilitate analysis and visualization of the molecular interaction networks from co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS) experiments

Co-fractionation mass spectrometry (CF-MS)-based approaches enable cell-wide identification of protein-protein and protein-metabolite complexes present in the cellular lysate. CF-MS combines biochemical separation of molecular complexes with an untargeted mass-spectrometry-based proteomics and/or metabolomics analysis of the obtained fractions, and is used to delineate putative interactors. CF-MS data are a treasure trove for biological discovery. To facilitate analysis and visualization of original or publically available CF-MS datasets, we designed PROMISed, a user-friendly tool available online via https://myshiny.mpimp-golm.mpg.de/PDP1/ or as a repository via https://github.com/DennisSchlossarek/PROMISed. Specifically, starting with raw fractionation profiles, PROMISed (i) contains activities for data pre-processing and normalization, (ii) deconvolutes complex fractionation profiles into single, distinct peaks, (iii) identifies co-eluting protein–protein or protein–metabolite pairs using user-defined correlation methods, and (iv) performs co-fractionation network analysis. Given multiple CF-MS datasets, for instance representing different environmental condition, PROMISed allows to select for proteins and metabolites that differ in their elution profile, which may indicate change in the interaction status. But it also enables the identification of protein–protein and protein–metabolite pairs that co-elute together across multiple datasets. PROMISed enables users to (i) easily adjust parameters at each step of the analysis, (ii) download partial and final results, and (iii) select among different data-visualization options. PROMISed renders CF-MS data accessible to a broad scientific audience, allowing users with no computational or statistical background to look for novel protein–protein and protein–metabolite complexes for further experimental validation.

Analytical Guidelines for co-fractionation Mass Spectrometry Obtained through Global Profiling of Gold Standard Saccharomyces cerevisiae Protein Complexes

Co-fractionation MS (CF-MS) is a technique with potential to characterize endogenous and unmanipulated protein complexes on an unprecedented scale. However this potential has been offset by a lack of guidelines for best-practice CF-MS data collection and analysis. To obtain such guidelines, this study thoroughly evaluates novel and published Saccharomyces cerevisiae CF-MS data sets using very high proteome coverage libraries of yeast gold standard complexes. A new method for identifying gold standard complexes in CF-MS data, Reference Complex Profiling, and the Extending 'Guilt-by-Association' by Degree (EGAD) R package are used for these evaluations, which are verified with concurrent analyses of published human data. By evaluating data collection designs, which involve fractionation of cell lysates, it is found that near-maximum recall of complexes can be achieved with fewer samples than published studies. Distributing sample collection across orthogonal fractionation methods, rather than a single high resolution data set, leads to particularly efficient recall. By evaluating 17 different similarity scoring metrics, which are central to CF-MS data analysis, it is found that two metrics rarely used in past CF-MS studies - Spearman and Kendall correlations - and the recently introduced Co-apex metric frequently maximize recall, whereas a popular metric-Euclidean distance-delivers poor recall. The common practice of integrating external genomic data into CF-MS data analysis is also evaluated, revealing that this practice may improve the precision and recall of known complexes but is generally unsuitable for predicting novel complexes in model organisms. If studying nonmodel organisms using orthologous genomic data, it is found that particular subsets of fractionation profiles (e.g. the lowest abundance quartile) should be excluded to minimize false discovery. These assessments are summarized in a series of universally applicable guidelines for precise, sensitive and efficient CF-MS studies of known complexes, and effective predictions of novel complexes for orthogonal experimental validation.

A Pan-plant Protein Complex Map Reveals Deep Conservation and Novel Assemblies

Plants are foundational for global ecological and economic systems, but most plant proteins remain uncharacterized. Protein interaction networks often suggest protein functions and open new avenues to characterize genes and proteins. We therefore systematically determined protein complexes from 13 plant species of scientific and agricultural importance, greatly expanding the known repertoire of stable protein complexes in plants. By using co-fractionation mass spectrometry, we recovered known complexes, confirmed complexes predicted to occur in plants, and identified previously unknown interactions conserved over 1.1 billion years of green plant evolution. Several novel complexes are involved invernalization and pathogen defense, traits critical for agriculture. We also observed plant analogs ofanimal complexes with distinct molecular assemblies, including a megadalton-scale tRNA multi-synthetasecomplex. The resulting map offers a cross-speciesview of conserved, stable protein assemblies shared across plant cells and provides a mechanistic, biochemical framework for interpreting plant genetics and mutant phenotypes.

Identifying direct contacts between protein complex subunits from their conditional dependence in proteomics datasets

Determining the three dimensional arrangement of proteins in a complex is highly beneficial for uncovering mechanistic function and interpreting genetic variation in coding genes comprising protein complexes. There are several methods for determining co-complex interactions between proteins, among them co-fractionation / mass spectrometry (CF-MS), but it remains difficult to identify directly contacting subunits within a multi-protein complex. Correlation analysis of CF-MS profiles shows promise in detecting protein complexes as a whole but is limited in its ability to infer direct physical contacts among proteins in sub-complexes. To identify direct protein-protein contacts within human protein complexes we learn a sparse conditional dependency graph from approximately 3,000 CF-MS experiments on human cell lines. We show substantial performance gains in estimating direct interactions compared to correlation analysis on a benchmark of large protein complexes with solved three-dimensional structures. We demonstrate the method’s value in determining the three dimensional arrangement of proteins by making predictions for complexes without known structure (the exocyst and tRNA multi-synthetase complex) and by establishing evidence for the structural position of a recently discovered component of the core human EKC/KEOPS complex, GON7/C14ORF142, providing a more complete 3D model of the complex. Direct contact prediction provides easily calculable additional structural information for large-scale protein complex mapping studies and should be broadly applicable across organisms as more CF-MS datasets become available.