Cluster Systems In Early-type Galaxies Research Articles

The galactic acceleration scale is imprinted on globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies of most masses and on red and blue globular cluster subpopulations

Context. Globular clusters (GCs) carry information about the formation histories and gravitational fields of their host galaxies. It was found before that the radial profiles of the volume number density of GCs in GC systems (GCSs) follow broken power laws, while the breaks occur approximately at the a0 radii. These are the radii at which the gravitational fields of the galaxies equal the galactic acceleration scale a0 = 1.2 × 10−10 m s−2 known from the radial acceleration relation or the MOND theory of modified dynamics. Aims. Our main goals here are to explore whether the above results hold true for galaxies of a wider mass range and for the red and blue GC subpopulations. Methods. We exploited catalogs of photometric GC candidates in the Fornax galaxy cluster based on ground and space observations and a new catalog of spectroscopic GCs of NGC 1399, the central galaxy of the cluster. For every galaxy, we obtained the parameters of the broken power-law density by fitting the on-sky distribution of the GC candidates, while allowing for a constant density of contaminants. The logarithmic stellar masses of our galaxy sample span 8.0 − 11.4 M⊙. Results. All investigated GCSs with a sufficient number of members show broken power-law density profiles. This holds true for the total GC population and the blue and red subpopulations. The inner and outer slopes and the break radii agree well for the different GC populations. The break radii agree with the a0 radii typically within a factor of two for all GC color subpopulations. The outer slopes correlate better with the a0 radii than with the galactic stellar masses. The break radii of NGC 1399 vary in azimuth, such that they are greater toward and against the direction to NGC 1404, which tidally interacts with NGC 1399.

Scaling relations for globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies – III. The inner flattening of the radial distributions

ABSTRACT The current properties of globular cluster systems (GCSs) in the nearby Universe are a consequence of an evolutionary history ruled by accretion and disruption processes. The analysis of scaling relations for GCSs is crucial for understanding the relevance of different physical processes involved in their origin and subsequent survival. In this work, radial profiles are calculated for a sample of GCSs associated with nearby massive galaxies. This is supplemented with results from our previous papers, achieving a total sample of 53 GCSs with radial profiles homogeneously calculated, and spanning more than two orders of magnitude in stellar mass of the host galaxy. Scaling relations involving different parameters of the GCSs are obtained for the entire sample, and their significance in terms of different scenarios is considered. Finally, the results are analysed in the literature context.

Scaling relations for globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies – II. Is there an environmental dependence?

ABSTRACT The current properties of globular cluster systems (GCSs) are the result of the evolution experienced by their host galaxies, which shape the richness of the GCS as well as its spatial distribution, among other features. We carry out an analysis of the projected radial distribution of globular clusters for a sample of almost 30 early-type galaxies (ETGs) of intermediate and low luminosity, located in cluster environments (Virgo, Fornax, and Coma). We also include in the study six ETGs, for which the parameters of their GCS radial profiles are publicly available. The final analysis is performed on an enlarged sample (∼100 GCSs), by adding the GCSs of ETGs from our previous paper (Paper I). Scaling relations involving different parameters of the GCSs are obtained for the whole sample and complement those obtained in Paper I. Several of such relations point to a second-order dependence on the environmental density. Finally, the results are analysed in the literature context.

Scaling relations for globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies

ABSTRACT The formation and growth of globular cluster systems (GCSs) is closely related to the evolutionary processes experienced by their host galaxies. In particular, their radial distributions scale with several properties of the galaxies and their haloes. We performed a photometric study, by means of HST/ACS archival data of several intermediate luminosity galaxies located in low-density environments. It was supplemented with available photometric data of GCSs from the Virgo and Fornax clusters, resulting in a sample of almost 30 GCSs for which we fitted their radial profiles. The resulting overall properties agree with those from previous studies, as we found that the effective radius, extension, and concentration of the GCS radial profiles correlate with the stellar mass, effective radius, and number of globular clusters, presenting in some cases a bilinear relation. The extension also correlates with the central velocity dispersion for central galaxies, but not for satellites. From a statistical comparison with numerical simulations we obtained good agreement between the effective radius and extension of the GCS scale with the effective and virial radius of the haloes, respectively. Finally, we analysed these results in the literature context.

Study of gravitational fields and globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies

Context.Gravitational fields at the outskirts of early-type galaxies (ETGs) are difficult to constrain observationally. It thus remains poorly explored how well the ΛCDM and MOND hypotheses agree with ETGs.Aims.The dearth of studies on this topic motivated us to gather a large sample of ETGs and examine homogeneously which dark matter halos they occupy, whether the halos follow the theoretically predicted stellar-to-halo mass relation (SHMR) and the halo mass-concentration relation (HMCR), whether ETGs obey MOND and the radial acceleration relation (RAR) observed for late-type galaxies (LTGs), and finally whether ΛCDM or MOND perform better in ETGs.Methods.We employed Jeans analysis of radial velocities of globular clusters (GCs). We analysed nearly all ETGs having more than about 100 archival GC radial velocity measurements available. The GC systems of our 17 ETGs extend mostly over ten effective radii. A ΛCDM simulation of GC formation helped us to interpret the results.Results.Successful ΛCDM fits are found for all galaxies, but compared to the theoretical HMCR and SHMR, the best-fit halos usually have concentrations that are too low and stellar masses that are too high for their masses. This might be because of tidal stripping of the halos or because ETGs and LTGs occupy different halos. Most galaxies can be fitted by the MOND models successfully as well, but for some of the galaxies, especially those in centers of galaxy clusters, the observed GC velocity dispersions are too high. This might be a manifestation of the additional dark matter that MOND requires in galaxy clusters. Additionally, we find many signs that the GC systems were perturbed by galaxy interactions. Formal statistical criteria prefer the best-fit ΛCDM models over the MOND models, but this might be due to the higher flexibility of the ΛCDM models. The MOND approach can predict the GC velocity dispersion profiles better.

Metallicity gradients in the globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies: in situ and accreted components?

Massive early-type galaxies typically have two subpopulations of globular clusters (GCs) which often reveal radial colour (metallicity) gradients. Collating gradients from the literature, we show that the gradients in the metal-rich and metal-poor GC subpopulations are the same, within measurement uncertainties, in a given galaxy. Furthermore, these GC gradients are similar in strength to the {\it stellar} metallicity gradient of the host galaxy. At the very largest radii (e.g. greater than 8 galaxy effective radii) there is some evidence that the GC gradients become flat with near constant mean metallicity. Using stellar metallicity gradients as a proxy, we probe the assembly histories of massive early-type galaxies with hydrodynamical simulations from the Magneticum suite of models. In particular, we measure the stellar metallicity gradient for the in-situ and accreted components over a similar radial range as those observed for GC subpopulations. We find that the in-situ and accreted stellar metallicity gradients are similar but have a larger scatter than the metal-rich and metal-poor GC subpopulations gradients in a given galaxy. We conclude that although metal-rich GCs are predominately formed during the in-situ phase and metal-poor GCs during the accretion phase of massive galaxy formation, they do not have a strict one-to-one connection.

How large are the globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies and do they scale with galaxy halo properties?

Abstract The globular cluster (GC) systems of galaxies are well known to extend to large galactocentric radii. Here, we quantify the size of GC systems using the half number radius of 22 GC systems around early-type galaxies (ETGs) from the literature. We compare GC system sizes to the sizes and masses of their host galaxies. We find that GC systems typically extend to 4 times that of the host galaxy size; however, this factor varies with galaxy stellar mass from about 3 times for M* galaxies to 5 times for the most massive galaxies in the universe. The size of a GC system scales approximately linearly with the virial radius (R200) and with the halo mass (M200) to the 1/3 power. The GC system of the Milky Way follows the same relations as for ETGs. For ultra diffuse galaxies (UDGs), their GC system size scales with halo mass and virial radius as for more massive, larger galaxies. UDGs indicate that the linear scaling of GC system size with stellar mass for massive galaxies flattens out for low stellar mass galaxies. Our scalings are different to those reported recently by Hudson & Robison.

Globular cluster systems of early-type galaxies in low-density environments★

Deep images of 10 early-type galaxies in low-density environments have been obtained with the Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS) on the Hubble Space Telescope. The global properties of the globular cluster (GC) systems of the galaxies have been derived in order to investigate the role of the environment in galaxy formation and evolution. Using the ACS Virgo Cluster Survey (ACSVCS) as a high-density counterpart, the similarities and differences between the GC properties in high- and low-density environments are presented. We find a strong correlation of the GC mean colours and the degree of colour bimodality with the host galaxy luminosity in low-density environments, in good agreement with high-density environments. In contrast, the GC mean colours at a given host luminosity are somewhat bluer (\Delta(g-z) ~ 0.05) than those for cluster galaxies, indicating more metal-poor (\Delta[Fe/H] ~ 0.10-0.15) and/or younger (\Delta age > 2 Gyr) GC systems than those in dense environments. Furthermore, with decreasing host luminosity, the colour bimodality disappears faster, when compared to galaxies in cluster environments. Our results suggest that: (1) in both high- and low-density environments, the mass of the host galaxy has the dominant effect on GC system properties, (2) the local environment has only a secondary effect on the history of GC system formation, (3) GC formation must be governed by common physical processes across a range of environments.

Resolving Stellar Populations in Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems

Photometric studies on globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies are widely used to resolve stellar populations in these galaxies. The knowledge of the age and metalicity structure within the globular cluster systems allows to set constraints on the major star formation episodes in the galaxy. Here we present our method of detecting age sub-populations in globular cluster systems based on optical/near-infrared observations and Monte-Carlo simulations. It is based on the determination of the cumulative age distribution and its comparison to simulated globular cluster systems. On various galaxies we will demonstrate the ability of our method to detect age sub-populations and show how we use the derived age structure to find correlations between various galaxy parameters and the formation/evolution of a given galaxy.

The age structure of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies and its dependence on host galaxy properties

Aims. We present the results of an optical – near-infrared photometric survey of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies. Our project aims to study correlations between the age structure of the globular cluster systems and environmental as well as structural parameters of their host galaxies. Methods. To derive the age structure in globular cluster systems we use combined optical and near-infrared photometry. This combination facilitates the detection of young globular cluster sub-populations if their age differs significantly from the old (∼13 Gyr) population, i.e. if their age is <7 Gyr. We investigate globular cluster systems in galaxies located in the central regions of galaxy clusters (NGC 1399, M 87, NGC 4478), galaxies which are members of (sub-) groups (NGC 4365, NGC 5846) and isolated galaxies (NGC 3115 and NGC 7192). Further, we look for correlations between globular cluster system properties and structural parameters of the galaxies (velocity dispersion σ, color ((V − K), (B − V)), and luminosity MV ). For a quantitative analysis we define the “Methuselah” parameter, Mth – based on the fraction of young and old metal-rich globular clusters weighted by age, characterizing the age structure of a globular cluster system. Results. We find that, within our galaxy sample, group galaxies appear to host an intermediate-age globular cluster population, whereas the globular cluster systems in cluster galaxies and in rather isolated galaxies are dominated by an old globular cluster population. A weak correlation of Mth with the Hβ index of the integrated light of the host galaxies is the only trend found with respect to internal galaxy parameters.

Intermediate-age globular clusters in early-type galaxies: Better age determinations by addingU-band observations to theV,I,Kdatasets

This paper represents an extension to a series of publications on combined optical and near-infrared photometry of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies. Based on color-color diagrams the cumulative age distributions of their globular cluster systems have been derived and revealed intermediate age clusters in two galaxies, namely NGC 4365 and NGC 5846. The extension of this observations towards the blue wavelength range was performed in order to increase the age resolution of photometric studies. In this paper we present the results of U-band observations of NGC 4365 and NGC 5846 and their combination with previously obtained V, I and Ks-band photometry. (U − I )v s. (V − Ks) color-color diagrams are used to derive the cumulative age distribution. The later is compared to simulated globular cluster systems of known age and size composition in order to set constrains on relative ages and size of the sub-populations.

Extragalactic globular clusters in the near infrared III. NGC 5846 and NGC 7192

In this third paper of our series on near-IR and optical photometry of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies we concentrate on the photometric results for NGC 5846 and NGC 7192, two group ellipticals, and on a first comparison between the globular cluster systems investigated so far. In NGC 5846 the colour-colour diagram shows clear bi-modality in (V K), which is confirmed by a KMM test. The mean colour of both peaks were estimated to be (V K)blue=2.57±0.06 and (V K)red=3.18±0.06. The situation in NGC 7192 is different, in that the colour-colour diagram gives no evidence for a distinct second population of globular clusters. Using simulated colour distributions of globular cluster systems, we make a first step in quantifying the cumulative age distribution in globular cluster systems. Also here the result for NGC 5846 leads us to the conclusion that its metal-rich globular cluster population contains two globular cluster populations which differ in age by several Gyr. The age structure for NGC 7192 shows instead strong similarity with a single-age population.

Extragalactic Globular Cluster Systems in the Near-IR

Extragalactic Globular Clusters are useful tracers of galaxy formation and evolution. Photometric studies of globular cluster systems beyond the Local Group are still the most popular method to investigate their physical properties, such as their ages and metallicities. However, the limitations of optical photometry are well known. The better wavelength sampling of the underlying cluster's SED using K-band photometry combined with optical passbands allows us to create colors which reduce the age-metallicity degeneracy to the largest extent. Here we report on the very first results of our near-IR photometric survey of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies outside the Local Group.

Multivariate analysis of globular cluster systems in early-type galaxies

We use multivariate statistical analysis to study the relation between the globular cluster content of early-type galaxies and a number of their observed properties. The number of globular clusters scales non-linearly with galaxy luminosity and virial mass. Both the total number of clusters and their specific frequency correlate with metallicity, internal velocity anisotropy, isophotal shape parameters and, possibly, X-ray luminosity of the host galaxy. We observe that the properties of the globular cluster systems, to a large extent, are correlated with the so-called Fundamental Plane of early-type galaxies, although a residual amount of variability in the number and specific frequency of globulars remains