You have accessJournal of UrologyProstate Cancer: Localized1 Apr 20111468 INTRAFASCIAL BILATERAL NERVE SPARING RADICAL PROSTATECTOMY: DOES THE ROBOTIC-ASSISTED APPROACH PREDISPOSE TO HIGHER RISK OF POSITIVE SURGICAL MARGINS? IMPORTANCE OF PATIENT SELECTION Nazareno Suardi, Andrea Gallina, Niccolò Buffi, Emanuele Scapaticci, Matteo Zanoni, Giulio Gadda, Giovanni Lughezzani, Aldo Bocciardi, Luciano Nava, Alberto Briganti, Andrea Cestari, Patrizio Rigatti, Giorgio Guazzoni, and Francesco Montorsi Nazareno SuardiNazareno Suardi milan, Italy More articles by this author , Andrea GallinaAndrea Gallina milan, Italy More articles by this author , Niccolò BuffiNiccolò Buffi milan, Italy More articles by this author , Emanuele ScapaticciEmanuele Scapaticci milan, Italy More articles by this author , Matteo ZanoniMatteo Zanoni milan, Italy More articles by this author , Giulio GaddaGiulio Gadda milan, Italy More articles by this author , Giovanni LughezzaniGiovanni Lughezzani milan, Italy More articles by this author , Aldo BocciardiAldo Bocciardi milan, Italy More articles by this author , Luciano NavaLuciano Nava milan, Italy More articles by this author , Alberto BrigantiAlberto Briganti milan, Italy More articles by this author , Andrea CestariAndrea Cestari milan, Italy More articles by this author , Patrizio RigattiPatrizio Rigatti milan, Italy More articles by this author , Giorgio GuazzoniGiorgio Guazzoni milan, Italy More articles by this author , and Francesco MontorsiFrancesco Montorsi milan, Italy More articles by this author View All Author Informationhttps://doi.org/10.1016/j.juro.2011.02.1403AboutPDF ToolsAdd to favoritesDownload CitationsTrack CitationsPermissionsReprints ShareFacebookTwitterLinked InEmail INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES The effect of the type of intrafascial approach (open vs robotic assisted) on the rate of positive surgical margins (PSM) has not been addressed yet. We hypothesized that RA intrafascial BNSRP might be associated with a higher risk of PSM due to a surgical dissection plane potentially closer to the prostatic capsule. METHODS Between 2004 and 2009, 501 consecutive patients underwent either open or RA intrafascial BNSRP for clinically localized PCa. Exclusion criteria for intrafascial approach were: clinical stage T3 disease, PSA>20 ng/ml or biopsy Gleason sum (GS) ≥8. Patients were stratified according to surgical approach (open vs RA). Uni and multivariable logistic regression models tested the association between surgical approach and the risk of positive surgical margins (PSM), after adjusting for PSA, biopsy GS, clinical stage and % of positive cores. The same analyses were repeated in patients with pre-operative very low-risk patients (PSA<10 ng/ml, clinical stage T1, biopsy GS≤ 6 and % positive cores ≤33%). RESULTS 293 (58.5%) and 208 (41.5%) patients were treated with open RP and RA BNSRP, respectively. Patients treated with RALP were younger (mean age: 60.1 vs. 63.5 yrs, p<0.001) and had lower PSA (6.1 vs. 7.1, p=0.008). Clinical stage (T2 in 34.6% vs. 16.7%;p<0.001) and Biopsy GS(7 in 28.6% vs. 7.7%) were higher in the open group (p<0.001). Patients in RALP group had significantly lower % of positive cores (35.7% vs. 28.4% respectively, p=0.02). The rate of PSM was higher in patients submitted to RA BNSRP in the overall population (22.1% vs. 12.5% respectively, p=0.005) as well as in patients with pathologically organ-confined disease (20.0 vs. 9.4%, respectively, p=0.02). At multivariable analyses, the surgical approach independently associated with PSM (p=0.01). Patients treated with RALP had a 2.8 fold increased risk of PSM as compared to open. However, when only patients with very low-risk disease were considered (n=84), patients treated with RALP had the same rate of PSM as compared to open(8.7 vs. 2.6% respectively, p=0.2). In this category, the surgical approach was not associated with a higher risk of PSM (p=0.3). CONCLUSIONS We demonstrated that patients treated with RA intrafascial BNSRP the has an higher risk of PSM. However, in patients with very low-risk disease open and RALP intrafascial BNSRP achieve the same PSM rates. Therefore, only highly selected patients (PSA<10 ng/ml, clinical stage T1, biopsy GS≤ 6 and 33% positive cores) should be candidated to intrafascial RA BNSRP. © 2011 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.FiguresReferencesRelatedDetails Volume 185Issue 4SApril 2011Page: e588 Advertisement Copyright & Permissions© 2011 by American Urological Association Education and Research, Inc.MetricsAuthor Information Nazareno Suardi milan, Italy More articles by this author Andrea Gallina milan, Italy More articles by this author Niccolò Buffi milan, Italy More articles by this author Emanuele Scapaticci milan, Italy More articles by this author Matteo Zanoni milan, Italy More articles by this author Giulio Gadda milan, Italy More articles by this author Giovanni Lughezzani milan, Italy More articles by this author Aldo Bocciardi milan, Italy More articles by this author Luciano Nava milan, Italy More articles by this author Alberto Briganti milan, Italy More articles by this author Andrea Cestari milan, Italy More articles by this author Patrizio Rigatti milan, Italy More articles by this author Giorgio Guazzoni milan, Italy More articles by this author Francesco Montorsi milan, Italy More articles by this author Expand All Advertisement Advertisement PDF DownloadLoading ...
Read full abstract