Classroom Practice Research Articles

Technical Properties of the ClassMaps Survey

More than a decade after two comprehensive examinations of the technical properties of the ClassMaps Survey (CMS), this study reexamined the structure and internal consistency of the scale and, for the first time, examined its measurement invariance across gender and school levels. Participants were 1,083 elementary and middle level students from a diverse northeastern school district. Students had completed the CMS as part of their district’s evaluation of its bullying prevention program; the deidentified results were shared with researchers with approval of the district school board. Results of a seven-factor confirmatory factor analysis showed that all items loaded on their respective subscale, exhibited adequate model fit (CFI = 0.91; RMSEA = .04; SRMR = .07), and communicated good internal consistency (α = .78 to .92). Partial strong invariance was demonstrated across gender groups and school level groups. Gender effects, school level effects, and gender by school level interactions were demonstrated for some subscales. The collective results support the use of the CMS to support planning and refining classroom routines and practices that promote students’ classroom autonomy and effective relationships.

Fostering Critical Thinking About the Critique of Religion: An Empirical Multi-Case Analysis

Having the right to criticize religion is important for healthy democracies. However, much critique of religion has led to increased levels of polarization. This article explores how religious education can help facilitate critical thinking regarding the critique of religion. By analyzing actual teaching practices about the critique of religion, this article contributes to the field of religious education research in three ways. First, it contributes empirically to the field of religious education, which to a limited degree has studied authentic classroom practices through observations. Second, it contributes theoretically to the field by analyzing which contextual dependencies of teaching facilitate critical thinking about the critique of religion. Third, this study builds on and adds to the prior research about the critique of religion within religious education, which has mainly been theoretical.

Transition space: navigating dilemmas between mainstream and minority language classrooms

Abstract From policymaking to classroom practices, educational language policy implementation is a complex process filled with a cacophony of voices. This article examines policy implementation as it unfolds in micro-level transitions between mainstream classrooms and lessons in Sámi, Kven, or Finnish as a second language (SKF) in Norway. In such situations, SKF pupils need to leave their mainstream classes to receive their language instruction. To examine these transitions, I draw primarily from ethnographic data (e.g., classroom observations and semi-structured interviews) collected over several months in public schools in a town in Northern Norway. The findings suggest that organizational circumstances construct an in-between space, which I refer to as transition space, in which classroom actors can or need to negotiate and make choices about which of the theoretically co-available classes/activities will be chosen at which times. Such choices involve dilemmas and consequences on different scales. In this study, (1) I demonstrate how (non)movements between mainstream and SKF classes are made in time and space, and (2) I propose transition space as a new conceptualization for researching micro-level transitions in educational settings.

THE USE OF DICTATION METHOD IN ENGLISH WRITING ACHIEVEMENT AT SMP NEGERI 31 PALEMBANG

This study examined the implementation and effectiveness of the Dictation Method in enhancing English writing achievement among seventh-grade students at SMP Negeri 31 Palembang. The research addressed two main questions: first, how students respond to the Dictation Method in their English learning; and second, how teachers implemented this method in classroom practice. Data were collected through surveys administered to 132 students across four classes, employing Likert scale analysis to gauge student perceptions. Results indicated overwhelming student approval (96%) of the Dictation Method, This study examined the implementation and effectiveness of the Dictation Method in enhancing English writing achievement among seventh-grade students at SMP Negeri 31 Palembang. The research addressed two main questions: first, how students respond to the Dictation Method in their English learning; and second, how teachers implemented this method in classroom practice. Data were collected through surveys administered to 132 students across four classes, employing Likert scale analysis to gauge student perceptions. Results indicated overwhelming student approval (96%) of the Dictation Method.

Science teachers' beliefs about teaching and learning related to content and procedural goals

AbstractScience teachers' beliefs about teaching and learning are a vital component of teachers' professional competence and are often assumed to impact classroom practice. To date, these beliefs have been predominantly investigated regarding teaching and learning in general or for a particular science subject (e.g., physics). It remains to be determined whether these beliefs are similar across different goals within a subject. The study reported addresses this question by investigating and comparing beliefs about teaching and learning regarding two prominent main goals of science education: content goals that refer to scientific phenomena, laws, theories, and disciplinary core ideas and procedural goals that refer to scientific procedures and practices. To that end, data from 170 German teachers were collected in 2019 and 2020 with an online questionnaire. After modeling the data and assessing the quality of measurement via Rasch analysis techniques, subsequent t‐tests were employed to compare beliefs. Results reveal that science teachers' beliefs vary between both main goals. For instance, teachers believe that achieving procedural goals requires primarily doing science with lesser relevance of discussing and elaborating with students explicitly the rules and strategies for engaging appropriately in scientific practices (e.g., control of variables strategy). In contrast, teachers believe that for achieving content goals, explicit instruction about corresponding conceptual knowledge is of higher relevance. Furthermore, the analysis reveals differences in teachers' beliefs about their own abilities. Teachers typically believe they are more able to teach and deal with content goals compared with procedural goals. The differences reported may help to understand research on teachers' classroom practice and can inform teacher training and professional development.

Reimagining early childhood education and school readiness through the perspectives of historically marginalized families living in a rural community

Given opportunities for early childhood education (ECE) expansion in the US, we seek to explore and elevate the perspectives of historically marginalized families, from an understudied rural community, to inform future local and state action involving public pre-kindergarten (pre-K) and kindergarten (K) provision. In partnership with a state Department of Education (DOE) and local district, we conducted two culturally responsive focus groups to investigate how such caregivers conceptualize ECE and school readiness, identify barriers with the current system, and pinpoint potential solutions to improve public pre-K and K. Participants included eight female caregivers, three of whom identified as Black, two as Hispanic, and three as White. All families met the DOE's eligibility requirements to attend public preschool. Through two 90-minute focus groups, we found families conceptualized ECE as a time for humanizing and hands-on classroom practices. They questioned the concept of school readiness, instead advocating for ways that schools can be ready for their children. Furthermore, families identified accountability culture (testing, standardization of curricula, narrow focus on core academic content, etc.), as a problem, particularly upon kindergarten entry. Solutions to improve pre-K and K included representative curricula, more equitable funding, and opportunities for collaboration across education interest-holders (e.g., teachers, families, administration, etc.) at school, district, and state levels.

Examining Teachers’ Professional Learning in an Online Asynchronous System: Personalized Supports for Growth and Engagement in Learning to Teach Statistics and Data Science

Teachers’ professional learning often includes online components. This study examined how a case of 37 teachers utilized a specific online asynchronous professional learning platform designed to support teachers’ growth in learning to teach statistics and data science in secondary schools in the United States. The platform’s features and learning materials were designed based on effective online learning designs, supports for self-guided learning, and research on the teaching and learning of statistics and data science. We paid particular attention to the features we designed into the platform to support self-regulation and personalizing the experiences to meet their preferred learning goals such as allowing for free choice of learning materials, flexibility of when and how long to engage, providing personal recommendations based on user input, internal systems to track progress, and generating certificates of completion. In this study, we used a case study with both quantitative and qualitative data to examine whether teachers had gains in meeting learning goals related to their development in teaching statistics and data science, had sustained engagement, and found the features for personalization supportive for their learning. Results showed, overall, positive growth towards meeting learning goals and making small changes towards improved classroom practice. Most teachers were generally engaged in sustained ways across the study period, though we found six different patterns of completion that highlight ways in which teachers’ goal-directed and self-regulated learning occurred within the busy schedules of educators. Several personalized features, especially the recommendations and tracking system, were highly utilized and perceived as supportive of teachers’ learning.

Teachers’ Mixed Implementation of Mindset Mathematics Practices During and After a Novel Approach to Teacher Learning

Supporting teachers to transfer their learnings from innovative professional development settings to the classroom is challenging. In this paper, we investigate a novel approach to teacher learning, in which teachers from seven US districts taught in a mathematics summer camp using a research-based curriculum centered on student reasoning and mindset messages. We examined the practices teachers did and did not implement in their camp and school-year classrooms, as well as the possible reasons for the greater or lesser changes in practice. Through analysis of classroom video, teacher artifacts, and teacher interviews, we found that teachers implemented several important practices in both camp and school-year classrooms, namely posing open tasks, giving students ample time to collaborate, and asking questions that pushed students to reason. Interview analysis revealed that the act of centering students’ reasoning and witnessing their subsequent engagement seemed to motivate teacher uptake of these practices. At the same time, however, teachers less frequently integrated mindset messaging directly into their teaching and gave space for the exploration of students’ mistakes and struggles. These findings suggest implications for innovative professional development efforts outside of the school year, as well as incremental approaches.

The interplay of teachers' positive beliefs and practices: an exploratory study through the lens of positive psychology

PurposeThe impact of teachers' positive psychology (PP) beliefs on their practices and the consequential influence on teaching processes and learning outcomes has been widely acknowledged. In line with PP in education, this research endeavors to examine the interconnectedness of Iranian English as a Foreign Language (EFL) teachers’ beliefs and their classroom practices regarding establishing a positive classroom environment.Design/methodology/approachUsing a purely qualitative approach, this study utilizes interviews and classroom observations as methods of data collection. To explore the beliefs of six female teachers and a number of their students, the researchers adapted selected prompts from the “What is happening in this class?” questionnaire developed by Fraser et al. (1996) into interview questions. The researchers also conducted classroom observations to gather information on the teachers' implementation of practices that contribute to a positive classroom environment.FindingsBy triangulating the interview data with the qualitative observations, the findings revealed a discrepancy between the teachers' cognition and their actual classroom practices concerning the establishment of a positive classroom environment. Students’ interviews also revealed the teacher participants' actual practices did not align with their cognitive beliefs.Originality/valueThe findings have significant implications for creating a positive environment in the post-pandemic era, suggesting a need for professional development and support for teachers in aligning their beliefs on positive psychology with their practices through qualitative enquiry.

An Analysis on the Path of Integrating Lei Feng Spirit into High School Ideological and Political Lessons

Lei Feng spirit, as one of the first great spirits to be included in the spiritual pedigree, contains rich spiritual connotation and educational value. High school ideological and political course is the key course to carry out the fundamental task of moral education. The integration of Lei Feng spirit into high school ideological and political lessons is conducive to the implementation of the fundamental task of moral education, is conducive to promoting the high-quality development of high school ideological and political teaching, and is also conducive to training good young people in the new era. Therefore, this paper puts forward practical approaches from three aspects of teachers, classroom and after-class practice, namely, improving teachers' literacy and carrying out teaching research activities; Grasping the main channel of classroom, innovating teaching links; Connect the second class and create an extra-curricular learning atmosphere.

National STEM Education Framework: Teachers’ Perspectives on the 2015-2022 Curriculum Cycle

Throughout the world, nations are busy investing in Science, Technology, Engineering and Mathematics (STEM) to prepare innovative minds that can spearhead the development and sustainable growth of their economies. Zimbabwe’s participation in the global economy is premised on the preference for STEM education system. The introduction of the Competence-Based Curriculum (CBC) in Zimbabwe meant a shift in the general aims and objectives of the education system. The transformation meant a move from an academic oriented and content-focused curriculum to one that is skills-based, giving prominence to continuous assessment over final examinations. To explore classroom practitioners’ perceptions of the first cycle of the CBC, 20 purposively selected STEM teachers participated in the study. A qualitative research approach and case study design were adopted as study methodology. Thematically analysed data were collected through focus group interviews with participants. The study focused on support systems available for STEM education in secondary schools and how the absence of the national framework affects its implementation. The study found that there were limited support systems for STEM education as some schools did not have adequate facilities and equipment such as science laboratories, apparatus, science consumables, computer laboratories, computer hardware and software among others. It came out from the study that the absence of national framework had negative effect on the implementation of STEM education in secondary schools. The study concluded that though the secondary schools experienced constraints in implementing STEM education there were noticeable pockets of good practices in some schools, for example, learners graduating with competences for life skills. The study recommended that the schools should engage stakeholders for support in provision of required resources. The Ministry of Primary and Secondary Education should expedite the development of a national framework for the effective implementation of STEM education.

Teachers’ Competencies in Digital Integration of Learning Contents in Dynamic Classroom Practices: A Review of Teacher Professional Development Needs

Abstract Introduction: Integrating digital tools and resources into classroom instruction has become increasingly essential in modern education. As technology advances, teachers face the challenge of effectively integrating digital learning content into dynamic classroom practices. This paper explores the competencies teachers require for this task, aiming to contribute to understanding teacher professional development needs in digital integration. Purpose: This study aims to investigate the competencies required by teachers for the successful integration of digital tools and resources into classroom practices. Methods: A comprehensive literature review was conducted using the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) diagram flow to address this aim. A total of 84 articles published from 2000 to 2024 were systematically reviewed, focusing on publications in English that addressed the professional development of teachers, technology integration into classroom practices, and digital competencies. Articles that did not meet these criteria were excluded from the analysis. Results: The synthesis of findings from the literature review highlighted the knowledge base of teachers’ professional development needs in digital integration. The review identified critical competencies for successful digital integration, including technological proficiency, pedagogical knowledge, and content expertise. Additionally, theoretical frameworks such as Technological Pedagogical Content Knowledge (TPACK) and the SAMR model guided the exploration of teachers’ competencies and their implications for instructional practices. Discussion: The implications of the study’s findings extend to educational policy, teacher training programs, and classroom practices. By identifying critical competencies for successful digital integration, this study provides insights into areas for further research and teacher professional development. Moreover, the discussion delves into how these findings can inform the design of effective teacher training programs and support the development of pedagogical practices that leverage digital tools to enhance student learning outcomes. Limitations: Despite the thoroughness of the literature review process, it is essential to acknowledge certain limitations. The study focused primarily on articles published in English, potentially excluding relevant research published in other languages. Additionally, while the PRISMA diagram flow facilitated a systematic review, some relevant articles may need to be noticed. Conclusions: In conclusion, this study contributes to understanding teacher competencies required for effective digital integration of learning contents in dynamic classroom practices. The study identifies critical competencies and highlights areas for further research and teacher professional development by synthesising findings from relevant empirical studies and theoretical contributions. Ultimately, the findings have implications for educational policy, teacher training programs, and instructional practices to enhance student learning outcomes in the digital age.

TECHNOLOGIES FOR DEVELOPING STUDENTS' PHRASEOLOGICAL COMPETENCE IN ENGLISH LANGUAGE LESSONS (BASED ON EXAMPLES FROM GRADES 5-9)

This article explores the significance of developing phraseological competence in English language lessons for students in grades 5-9. It highlights the importance of idiomatic expressions, collocations, and fixed phrases in achieving effective communication and language proficiency. The article presents various technological tools, including interactive learning platforms, digital storytelling tools, online phraseology resources, video and multimedia resources, and mobile applications, that can enhance students’ understanding and use of phraseological units. Practical classroom examples illustrate how these technologies can be integrated into lesson plans to foster engagement and collaboration among students. Ultimately, the article underscores the role of educators in equipping students with the necessary skills to navigate the complexities of the English language, preparing them for success in diverse contexts.

Effects of the Tools for Getting Along Curriculum on Teachers’ Reports of Elementary Students’ Executive Functions, Social-Emotional Skills, and Behavior Problems

In this study, we examined the effectiveness of Tools for Getting Along (TFGA) on teachers’ reports of executive functioning (EF), social-emotional, and behavioral skills of upper elementary school students. TFGA is a classroom-level prevention curriculum that teaches students a sequence of empirically based problem-solving steps to apply in emotionally charged situations. We randomly assigned 52 elementary schools in California, Oklahoma, and Kentucky to the treatment (n = 26) or comparison (n = 26) condition, with study participants including 135 grade 4 teachers and their 1,713 students. Multilevel analyses revealed that relative to those in the comparison group, students who participated in TFGA had significantly better social skills (effect size = 0.12) and higher levels of behaviors associated with EFs (effect size = 0.11), as reported by their teachers. Further, students whose teachers reported as having higher internalizing and externalizing behaviors, lower competence, and weaker behaviors associated with EFs at baseline experienced greater improvements in these skills after participating in TFGA than their counterparts with relatively stronger skills in the comparison group. We discuss educational implications of this study to promote and scale evidence-based, social-emotional practices in elementary school classrooms.

Investigating the Implementation of English as the Medium of Instruction Policy at the Lower Primary Level: A Case of Nyabihu District in Rwanda

This study investigated the implementation and effectiveness of the English as the Medium of Instruction (EMI) policy in Rwanda's lower primary education system, specifically from primary one to primary three. The introduction provides a context for Rwanda's language-in-education policy, which mandates English as the primary instructional language. The study aimed to assess whether this policy is followed in practice and to identify challenges and pedagogical practices associated with its implementation. The theoretical framework was based on Krashen's comprehensible input hypothesis, emphasizing the importance of using the target language in classroom interactions to aid language acquisition. The research design adopted was a qualitative case study focusing on Nyabihu District, involving a study population of lower primary school teachers and students. Purposive sampling was the method employed in order to use a small population to gain a thorough understanding of the case. Teachers with at least two years of experience in the classroom were used in the study. The researcher needed teachers who were familiar with the language policy of instruction in Rwandan schools and had firsthand experience with the phenomenon, so this was necessary. The study involved 75 participants in total, including 25 teachers and 50 students or pupils. Data were collected through classroom observations, interviews, and analysis of policy documents. Data analysis revealed a significant gap between the theoretical policy and actual classroom practices. Despite the policy, teachers frequently used both Kinyarwanda (L1) and English (L2) in their instruction due to students' limited English proficiency. The study identified several challenges, including lack of policy enforcement, the monolingual nature of classrooms, and teachers' preference for using the Rwandan language. Common pedagogical practices included safe talk, code-switching, simultaneous use of both languages, and translation. Key findings indicated that the EMI policy is not strictly adhered to in practice, and several factors hinder its effective implementation. The study recommends stricter policy enforcement, improvements in English language instruction, increased use of L1 as the medium of instruction, and the creation of an English-friendly learning environment to enhance English usage at the lower primary level. The study's findings provide valuable insights for educators and policymakers, highlighting the need for practical solutions to address the challenges of implementing EMI in Rwanda's lower primary education system.

Grammar in ELT and ELT Materials: Evaluating its History and Current Practice (Second Language Acquisition, 164) (Book Review)

The teaching of grammar in ELT has evolved from the grammar-translation method to communicative language teaching, where the focus of grammar teaching is not entirely on language forms, but rather involves learners in the pragmatic and functional uses of authentic language for meaningful purposes (Brown & Lee, 2015). Despite its evolution, exact rules on what grammatical structures to teach and the order in which they should be taught have never been fully addressed due to a lack of consensus from experts in the field. English language teachers may then rely on intuitions about what grammatical point is important without any empirical evidence. In response, Graham Burton’s book Grammar in ELT and ELT materials investigates the current and historical practice of pedagogical grammar in ELT and ELT materials, especially for general English teaching. The book also presents interviews with ELT authors and publishing professionals to explore evidence on how learners use grammar and current classroom practices. [First Paragraoph of Reviw]

Use of Learner Engagement Analytics to empower medical educators to make data-informed decisions

Learner Engagement Analytics (LEA) has enabled Higher Education Institutions (HEIs) to identify learners who are not engaging with their studies and provide targeted support and help (Naeem and Bosman, 2023). It has also allowed educators to make data-informed decisions to inform their curriculum design and classroom practice (Cogliano et al., 2022). The LEA data is captured from a wide range of sources related to teaching and learning which offer meaningful insights into a learner’s learning habits (Eady et al., 2021). Previous research suggests that providing learning analytics to educators in Higher Education Institutions can improve learning outcomes for students (Aslan et al., 2019). At Queen Mary University of London, a multidisciplinary team was formed of medical educators, LEA experts, learning technologists, and learning innovation professionals to investigate how LEA can inform curriculum redesign in the early phase of the medical curriculum. Through a series of scholarship meetings on LEA using data dashboards from the Virtual Learning Environment (VLE), the team analysed learners’ engagement with the virtual pre-sessional resources. The VLE interactive resources were designed to allow medical learners to develop clinical interpretation skills during practical sessions, as recommended by the General Medical Council (GMC, 2018). However, medical educators lacked the metrics to evaluate learners’ interaction with these virtual resources. Therefore, it was inevitable to train educators on how to use LEA to optimise students’ learning. The team assessed the learners' engagement on the VLE, quantified engagement scores, and evaluated the results against key outcomes, including the learners' performance. The LEA data offered further insights into virtual engagement across multiple modules in the medical curriculum. Effectively, the outcome of this work empowered medical educators to make informed decisions regarding the future use of VLE resources in curriculum design and develop virtual resources to increase students’ engagement and enhance their learning.

Translanguaging for learning in selected English First Additional Language secondary school classrooms

Background: The unequal learning outcomes and achievement gaps in language and literacy, particularly affecting poor and working-class children in South African schools, are longstanding issues. These disparities were highlighted once again in the poor literacy results of PIRLS 2021, indicating systemic challenges within the education system.Objectives: This article emanates from a Languaging-for-Learning (L4L) project, which holistically used approaches to integrate isiXhosa home language and English to validate and engage with the learners’ linguistic repertoires to open more opportunities to learn and read multilingually.Method: The research was conducted in two Western Cape township high schools with bilingual isiXhosa and English-speaking teachers and emergent bilingual learners. Five Grade 9 teachers’ English First Additional Language (EFAL) lessons were observed and recorded in 2023. The case study focused on shifts in teachers’ take-up of translanguaging strategies in EFAL lessons and their effective pedagogical use, especially in written form.Results: The findings revealed that bilingual teachers creatively incorporated teaching practices that allowed learners to transition between languages while learning EFAL. The study further indicates that bilingual education has the potential to be a valuable pedagogical strategy in contexts where exclusive use of English impedes effective learning.Conclusion: Yet again, the findings of this study accentuate the importance of incorporating and utilising learners’ home languages into the education process. A bilingual or multilingual pedagogical approach not only enriches the learning experiences but also acknowledges the linguistic diversity within the classroom, thereby making way for more effective and inclusive education practices.Contribution: This study contributes to the understanding of how a bilingual or multilingual teacher intervention can impact English teachers’ classroom practices positively. It emphasises the importance of recognising and embracing the language resources that learners bring to the classroom, highlighting the value of a bilingual pedagogical approach in promoting effective learning outcomes.

Indonesian Teachers’ Perspectives on Gender Representation in EFL Textbook Visual Images for Elementary Schools

Background: The use of gendered visual imagery in English as a Foreign Language (EFL) textbooks has raised concerns about perpetuating gender stereotypes and the potential effect on students' conceptions of gender roles. Despite the widespread use of mandated textbooks in primary classrooms in Indonesia, less is known about instructors' perceptions of gendered visual imagery. Methodology: This qualitative research employed a mixed-methods approach, incorporating quantitative and qualitative data collection and analytic methodologies. An investigation was conducted in Samarinda East Kalimantan to collect the perspectives of 41 teachers who teach English in elementary school regarding the gendered visual representations present in the mandatory EFL textbooks. Furthermore, 12 teachers were chosen to partake in exhaustive interviews to present more informed and profound perspectives. Findings: They merely focused on how to teach the materials rather than scrutinizing the gender bias represented through texts and visual images. The study revealed that a significant proportion of teachers (80%) believed that gendered visual imagery in textbooks was not impartial and could influence the gender roles of pupils. Furthermore, a significant majority (75%) said they often adjusted or avoided using these pictures in their teaching methods. The interviews highlighted the teachers' concern about the possible negative impact of these pictures on students' social relationships and self-image. However, they merely focused on how to teach the materials rather than scrutinizing the gender bias represented through texts and visual images Conclusion: The findings suggest that elementary school teachers in Indonesia know the potential negative repercussions of gendered visual images in EFL textbooks and have implemented measures to mitigate these effects. The study underscores the importance of incorporating diverse and inclusive visual materials into educational resources to promote gender equality and positive gender representations. This concept is new to them. They agree that gender equality needs to be addressed and discussed as part of the content in classroom practices to raise students’ awareness of gender bias. Originality: Previous studies have investigated the frequency and occurrence of gender bias in textbooks, found in images and texts. However, there is a lack of investigation into teachers' awareness of gender stereotypes in textbooks. This study enhances the existing corpus of literature by examining the perspectives of teachers on the use of gendered visual images in EFL textbooks in elementary schools in Indonesia. It emphasizes the importance of teachers and policymakers advocating for more inclusive educational resources and considering the impact of visual materials on students' gender perceptions

How Economically-Marginalized Adolescents of Color Negotiate Critical Pedagogy in a Computing Classroom

Background & Context: With the growing movement to adopt critical framings of computing, scholars have worked to reframe computing education from the narrow development of programming skills to skills in identifying and resisting oppressive structures in computing. However, we have little guidance on how these framings may manifest in classroom practice. Objectives: To better understand the processes and practice of critical pedagogy in a computing classrooms, we taught a critically conscious computing elective within a summer academic program at a northwest United States university targeted at secondary students (ages 14-18) from low-income backgrounds and would be the first in their families to pursue a postsecondary education (i.e. first-generation). We investigated: (1) our participants’ initial perceptions of and attitudes toward the benefits and perils of computing, and (2) potential tensions that might emerge when secondary students negotiate the integration of critical pedagogy in a computing classroom. Methods: We qualitatively coded participant work from a critically conscious computing course within a summer academic program in the United States focused on students from low-income backgrounds or would be the first in their family to pursue a post-secondary education. Findings: Our participants’ initial attitudes towards technology were mostly positive, but exhibited an awareness of its negative impacts on their lives and society. Throughout the course, while participants demonstrated a rich social consciousness around technology, they faced challenges in addressing hegemonic values embedded in their programs, designs, and other classwork. Implications: Our findings revealed tensions between our participants’ computing attitudes, knowledge, self-efficacy, and social consciousness, suggesting pathways for scaffolding the critical examination of technology in secondary education. This study provides insights into the pedagogical content knowledge necessary for critical computing education.