This hermeneutic interpretive phenomenological study explored the lived experiences of grade school teachers managing virtual classes during the COVID-19 pandemic at St. Paul University Surigao. Eleven teachers from various grade levels were interviewed, and data was analyzed using interpretative phenomenological analysis (IPA). Five emergent themes were identified: 1) Teachers’ perception of classroom management, 2) Teachers’ authority and management of virtual classes, 3) Benefits of online classes, 4) Challenges in conducting virtual classes, and 5) Best virtual classroom management practices. The study found that teachers demonstrated resilience and adaptability in transitioning to online teaching, while highlighting both the benefits (e.g., flexibility, cost savings) and challenges (e.g., internet connectivity, student engagement) of virtual classrooms. Based on these findings, a "Simulacrum" model of best practices for virtual classroom management, aligned with the university’s vision and values, was proposed. The study offers valuable insights for educators navigating online teaching and emphasizes the importance of continued support and professional development in this evolving landscape.