Edgar Lee Masters: A Biography. By Herbert K. Russell (Champaign: University. of Illinois Press, 2001. Pp. X, 462. Illustrations, notes, index. Cloth $39.95.) Edgar Lee Masters' Spoon River Anthology (1915) was that rarity in America, a best-selling book of poetry: seven printings in seven months and nineteen printings in all before an augmented edition was printed in 1916, as Herbert K. Russell explains in a detail that is typical of his new biography of Masters. Spoon River Anthology, as much a work of drama as a poetic sequence, featured 214 dramatic monologues (Masters called them epitaphs) in which the dead in a small town cemetery speak in a dozen or two lines. Like his father, Masters had spent some years practicing law in the Menard County seat of Petersburg, and he knew that if the dead of a small town could talk they would have plenty to say about domestic violence, clandestine affairs, illegitimate children, under-the-table deals, and railroading those who were poor or powerless or just different. Sherwood Anderson's Winesburg, Ohio (1919) and Sinclair Lewis's Main Street (1920) found a wide readership as a result of Masters' pioneering work. The shock value of Masters' critique is now largely lost on us. If the contents of Spoon River were controversial, no less sensational was Masters' decision to let characters speak not in the rhyme-and-metered formalism that, as a matter of fact, he had previously practiced along with most other poets of his time, but in a loose free verse that permitted slang, shorthand phrasings and casual locutions of all kinds: When I went to the city, Mary McNeeley, I meant to return for you, yes I did. / But Laura, my landlady's daughter, Stole into my life somehow, and won me away (47). Until Spoon River, free verse was a controversial fad limited to a handful of avantgarde literary journals, and though it would remain controversial for decades more-the writer and critic Charles Russell Eaton reported with immense relief in 1928 that the emotional malaria of free verse had enjoyed its febrile exaltation and passed-Masters effectively demonstrated that a technique designed to amplify the individual voice could be ennobling. Indeed, he brought to the tangled anecdotes of the poor and the dispossessed the ear of a powerful defense attorney who represents his clients as persuasively as they would wish. Though Masters was in 1915 an attorney in Chicago in partnership with Clarence Darrow and earning a robust annual salary of $30,000, from his endorsement of this kind of demotic speech it would have been clear whose side Masters was on. Russell ponders why Masters was a one-book celebrity. Hardly inactive in the thirty years that followed his 1915 success, he published every year a book or two in any genre you could name- novels, historical fiction, memoirs, essays, dramatic poems, poetic dramas, historical biographies, literary biographies, autobiographies, and ever and always, more poems-with publishers as varied as Macmillan (commercial), Horace Liveright (adventurous), and James Decker's Prairie Press (small and distinguished). Russell concludes that Masters wrote too much too rapidly and too often managed to publish most of it. Not untypical is Russell's tale of Masters' April 1930 proposal for a biography of Lincoln for which he was at once able to obtain an advance of $1000 and a contract from Dodd, Mead. He was, in fact, nicely positioned to write a fresh version of the Lincoln story. His family had long been settled in the New Salem region, and his ancestors had crossed paths with Lincoln on several occasions. His grandfather, serving in the 1854 Illinois legislature, voted against Lincoln as senator, regarding with suspicion his role in the 1832 Black Hawk War (he thought Lincoln had picked up a taste for war as a militiaman). So comfortable was Masters with Lincoln stories that he had given Lincoln's law partner, William Herndon, his own monologue to speak in Spoon River Anthology -one of the few actual figures so distinguished (Anne Rutledge spoke another). …
Read full abstract