CK Vul Research Articles

Nova 1670 (CK Vulpeculae) was a merger of a red giant with a helium white dwarf

Context. Nova 1670 is a historical transient bearing strong similarities to a recently recognized type of stellar eruption known as the red nova, which is thought to be powered by stellar mergers. The remnant of the transient, CK Vul, is observable today mainly through cool circumstellar gas and dust, and recombining plasma, but we have no direct view on the stellar object. Aims. Within the merger hypothesis, we aim to infer the most likely configuration of the progenitor system that resulted in Nova 1670. Methods. We collected the literature data on the physical properties of the outburst and the remnant (including their energetics), and on the chemical composition of the circumstellar material (including elemental and isotopic abundances). These data, which result from optical and submillimeter observations of the circumstellar gas of CK Vul, are summarized here. We performed simple simulations to analyze the form and the level of mixing within the material associated with the merger. We identified products of nuclear burning, among which we find ashes of hydrogen burning in the CNO cycles and in the MgAl chain, as well as signs of partial helium burning. Results. Based primarily on the luminosity and chemical composition of the remnant, we find that the progenitor primary had to be an evolutionarily advanced red giant branch star of a mass of 1–2 M⊙. The secondary was either a very similar giant, or –more likely– a helium white dwarf. While the eruption event was mainly powered by accretion, we estimate that about 12% of total energy is likely to have come from helium burning activated during the merger. The coalescence of a first-ascent giant with a helium white dwarf created a star with a rather unique internal structure and composition, which resemble those of early R-type carbon stars. Conclusions. Nova 1670 is the result of a merger between a helium white dwarf and a first-ascent red giant and is likely now evolving to become an early R-type carbon star.

Spatiokinematic models of five nova remnants: correlations between nova shell axial ratio, expansion velocity, and speed class

ABSTRACT We present long-slit intermediate-dispersion spectroscopic observations and narrow-band direct imaging of four classical nova shells, namely T Aur, HR Del, DQ Her, and QU Vul, and the nova-like source CK Vul. These are used to construct models of their nebular remnants using the morphokinematic modelling tool shape to reveal their 3D shape. All these nova remnants but CK Vul can be described by prolate ellipsoidal shells with different eccentricity degree, from the spherical QU Vul to the highly elongated shell with an equatorial component HR Del. On the other hand, CK Vul shows a more complex structure, with two pairs of nested bipolar lobes. The spatiokinematic properties of the ellipsoidal nova shells derived from our models include their true axial ratios. This parameter is expected to correlate with the expansion velocity and decline time t3 (i.e. their speed class) of a nova as the result the interaction of the ejecta with the circumstellar material and rotation speed and magnetic field of the white dwarf. We have compared these three parameters including data available in the literature for another two nova shells, V533 Her and FH Ser. There is an anticorrelation between the expansion velocity and the axial ratio and decline time t3 for nova remnants with ellipsoidal morphology, and a correlation between their axial ratios and decline times t3, confirming theoretical expectations that the fastest expanding novae have the smallest axial ratios. We note that the high expansion velocity of the nova shell HR Del of 615 km s−1 is inconsistent with its long decline time t3 of 250 d.

Transients from the Cataclysmic Deaths of Cataclysmic Variables

Abstract We explore the observational appearance of the merger of a low-mass star with a white dwarf (WD) binary companion. We are motivated by recent work finding that multiple tensions between the observed properties of cataclysmic variables (CVs) and standard evolution models are resolved if a large fraction of CV binaries merge as a result of unstable mass transfer. Tidal disruption of the secondary forms a geometrically thick disk around the WD, which subsequently accretes at highly super-Eddington rates. Analytic estimates and numerical hydrodynamical simulations reveal that outflows from the accretion flow unbind a large fraction ≳90% of the secondary at velocities ∼500–1000 km s−1 within days of the merger. Hydrogen recombination in the expanding ejecta powers optical transient emission lasting about a month with a luminosity ≳1038 erg s−1, similar to slow classical novae and luminous red novae from ordinary stellar mergers. Over longer timescales the mass accreted by the WD undergoes hydrogen shell burning, inflating the remnant into a giant of luminosity ∼300–5000 L ⊙, effective temperature T eff ≈ 3000 K, and lifetime ∼104–105 yr. We predict that ∼103–104 Milky Way giants are CV merger products, potentially distinguishable by atypical surface abundances. We explore whether any Galactic historical slow classical novae are masquerading CV mergers by identifying four such post-nova systems with potential giant counterparts for which a CV merger origin cannot be ruled out. We address whether the historical transient CK Vul and its gaseous/dusty nebula resulted from a CV merger.

Molecular remnant of Nova 1670 (CK Vulpeculae)

CK Vul is the remnant of an energetic eruption known as Nova 1670 that is thought to be caused by a stellar merger. The remnant is composed of (1) a large hourglass nebula of recombining gas (of 71′′ in size), very similar to some classical planetary and pre-planetary nebulae (PPNe), and (2) a much smaller and cooler inner remnant that is prominent in millimeter-wave emission from molecules. We investigate the three-dimensional spatio-kinematic structure of both components. Our analysis of the hourglass structure yields a revised distance to the object of >2.6 kpc, at least 3.7 times greater than previously assumed. At this distance, the stellar remnant has a bolometric luminosity >12 L⊙ and is surrounded by molecular material with a total mass >0.8 M⊙ (the latter value has a large systematic uncertainty). We also analyzed the architecture of the inner molecular nebula using ALMA observations of rotational emission lines obtained at subarcsecond resolution. We find that the distribution of neutral and ionized gas in the lobes can be reproduced by several nested and incomplete shells or jets with different velocity fields and varying orientations. The analysis indicates that the molecular remnant was created in several ejection episodes, possibly involving an interacting binary system. We calculated the linear momentum (≈1040 g cm s−1) and kinetic energy (≈1047 erg) of the CK Vul outflows and find values that are within the limits typical for classical PPNe. Given the similarities of the CK Vul outflows to PPNe, we suggest there may be CK Vul analogs among wrongly classified PPNe with low intrinsic luminosities, especially among PPNe with post-red-giant-branch central stars.

Molecular remnant of Nova 1670 (CK Vulpeculae)

CK Vul erupted in 1670 and is considered a Galactic stellar-merger candidate. Its remnant, observed 350 yr after the eruption, contains a molecular component of surprisingly rich composition, including polyatomic molecules as complex as methylamine (CH3NH2). We present interferometric line surveys with subarcsec resolution with ALMA and SMA. The observations provide interferometric maps of molecular line emission at frequencies between 88 and 243 GHz that allow imaging spectroscopy of more than 180 transitions of 26 species. We present, classify, and analyze the different morphologies of the emission regions displayed by the molecules. We also perform a non-LTE radiative-transfer analysis of emission of most of the observed species, deriving the kinetic temperatures and column densities in five parts of the molecular nebula. Non-LTE effects are clearly seen in complex species including methanol absorption against the cosmic microwave background. The temperatures are about 17 K in the inner remnant and 14 K in the extended lobes, both higher than excitation temperatures estimated earlier in an LTE approach and based on single-dish spectra. We find total (hydrogen plus helium) densities in the range of 104 − 106 cm−3. The column densities provide rough relative abundance patterns in the remnant which currently are not understood. Attempts to derive elemental abundances within the assumption of a chemical equilibrium give only loose constraints on the CNO elements. That the formation of many of the observed molecules requires a major involvement of circumstellar shocks remains the preferred possibility. The molecular gas could have formed 350 yr ago or more recently. The molecules are well shielded from the interstellar radiation field by the circumstellar dust. Their presence alone indicates that the unobservable central star cannot be a hot object such as a white dwarf. This excludes some of the proposed scenarios on the nature of CK Vul. The general characteristics of the molecular environment of CK Vul derived in this study resemble quite well those of some pre-planetary nebulae and asymptotic giant branch stars, most notably that of OH231.8+4.2.

Near-infrared Spectroscopy of CK Vulpeculae: Revealing a Remarkably Powerful Blast from the Past

Abstract CK Vulpeculae (CK Vul), which erupted in AD 1670–71, was long considered to be a nova outburst; however, recent observations have required that alternative scenarios be considered. Long-slit infrared spectroscopy of a forbidden line of iron reported here has revealed high line-of-sight velocities (∼±900 km s−1) of the ansae at the tips of the bipolar lobes imaged in Hα in 2010. The deprojected velocities of the tips are approximately ±2130 km s−1 assuming the previously derived inclination angle of 65° for the axis of cylindrical symmetry of the bipolar nebula. Such high velocities are in stark contrast to previous reports of much lower expansion velocities in CK Vul. Based on the deprojected velocities of the tips and their angular expansion measured over a 10 yr baseline, we derive a revised estimate, with estimated uncertainties, of kpc for the distance to CK Vul. This implies that the absolute visual magnitude at the peak of the 1670 explosion was , indicating that the 1670 event was far more luminous than previous estimates and brighter than any classical nova or any Galactic stellar merger. We propose that CK Vul belongs to the class of intermediate-luminosity optical transients (ILOTs), objects which bridge the luminosity gap between novae and supernovae. While eruptions in lower luminosity ILOTs are attributed to merger events, the origin of the highly luminous ILOT outbursts is currently not known.

Erratum: ALMA reveals the aftermath of a white dwarf–brown dwarf merger in CK Vulpeculae

Erratum: ALMA reveals the aftermath of a white dwarf–brown dwarf merger in CK Vulpeculae

Elemental abundances in the remnant of the ancient eruption of CK Vulpeculae

CK Vulpeculae or Nova 1670 is an enigmatic eruptive object which underwent a stellar-merger event recorded by seventeenth-century observers. Its remnant was recently recovered at submillimeter wavelengths, revealing gas of an extraordinary isotopic composition indicative of past processing in the CNO cycles and partial He burning. Here, we present long-slit optical spectra of the remnant acquired with X-shooter at the Very Large Telescope (VLT) at an unprecedented sensitivity and spectral coverage. The spectra cover features of key elements, including H, He, C, N, and O, at ionization degrees I–III. A classical analysis of the spectra allowed us to identify several spatio-kinematic components in the probed part of the nebula at electron temperatures of 10–15 kK and densities of 200–600 cm−3. We find that the nebula is most likely excited by shocks rather than by direct radiation of the stellar remnant. We provide a detailed analysis of the elemental abundances in the remnant and find that helium is two times more abundant than in the Sun. Nitrogen is also overabundant with a N/O ratio ten times larger than the solar one. These anomalous abundances strongly indicate that the observed gas was processed in CNO cycles of H burning, consistent with the submillimeter studies. Additionally, sub-solar abundances of heavier elements, such as Ne, S, and Ar, suggest that the progenitor of CK Vul was formed from material poorer in metals than the Sun and was, therefore, an old stellar system before the 1670 eruption.

ALMA reveals the aftermath of a white dwarf–brown dwarf merger in CK Vulpeculae

We present Atacama Large Millimeter-Submillimeter Array (ALMA) observations of CK Vulpeculae which is identified with "Nova Vulpeculae 1670". They trace obscuring dust in the inner regions of the associated nebulosity. The dust forms two cocoons, each extending ~5 arcsec north and south of the presumed location of the central star. Brighter emission is in a more compact east-west structure (2 arcsec by 1 arcsec) where the cocoons intersect. We detect line emission in NH$_2$CHO, CN, four organic molecules and C$^{17}$O. CN lines trace bubbles within the dusty cocoons; CH$_3$OH a north-south S-shaped jet; and other molecules a central cloud with a structure aligned with the innermost dust structure. The major axis of the overall dust and gas bubble structure has a projected inclination of ~24 degrees with respect to a 71 arcsec extended "hourglass" nebulosity, previously seen in H alpha. Three cocoon limbs align with dark lanes in the inner regions of the same H alpha images. The central 2 arcsec by 1 arcsec dust is resolved into a structure consistent with a warped dusty disc. The velocity structure of the jets indicates an origin at the centre of this disc and precession with an unknown period. Deceleration regions at both the northern and southern tips of the jets are roughly coincident with additional diffuse dust emission over regions approximately 2 arcsec across. These structures are consistent with a bipolar outflow expanding into surrounding high density material. We suggest that a white dwarf and brown dwarf merged between 1670 and 1672, with the observed structures and extraordinary isotopic abundances generated as a result.

Astronomical detection of radioactive molecule 26AlF in the remnant of an ancient explosion

Decades ago, $\gamma$-ray observatories identified diffuse Galactic emission at 1.809 MeV originating from $\beta^+$ decays of an isotope of aluminium, $^{26}$Al, that has a mean-life time of 1.04 Myr. Objects responsible for the production of this radioactive isotope have never been directly identified, owing to insufficient angular resolutions and sensitivities of the $\gamma$-ray observatories. Here, we report observations of millimetre-wave rotational lines of the isotopologue of aluminium monofluoride that contains the radioactive isotope ($^{26}$AlF). The emission is observed toward CK Vul which is thought to be a remnant of a stellar merger. Our constraints on the production of $^{26}$Al combined with the estimates on the merger rate make it unlikely that objects similar to CK Vul are major producers of Galactic $^{26}$Al. However, the observation may be a stepping stone for unambiguous identification of other Galactic sources of $^{26}$Al. Moreover, a high content of $^{26}$Al in the remnant indicates that prior to the merger, the CK Vul system contained at least one solar-mass star that evolved to the red giant branch.

Organic molecules, ions, and rare isotopologues in the remnant of the stellar-merger candidate, CK Vulpeculae (Nova 1670)

CK Vul is a star whose outburst was observed in 1670-72. A stellar-merger event was proposed to explain its ancient eruption. Aims: We aim to investigate the composition of the molecular gas recently discovered in the remnant of CK Vul. Methods: We observed millimeter and submillimeter-wave spectra of CK Vul using the IRAM 30m and APEX telescopes. Radiative-transfer modeling of the observed molecular features was performed to yield isotopic ratios for various elements. Results: The spectra of CK Vul reveal a very rich molecular environment of low excitation ($T_{\rm ex} \lesssim$12 K). Atomic carbon and twenty seven different molecules, including two ions, were identified. They range from simple diatomic to complex polyatomic species of up to 7 atoms large. The chemical composition of the molecular gas is indicative of carbon and nitrogen-driven chemistry but oxides are also present. Additionally, the abundance of F may be enhanced. The spectra are rich in isotopologues that are very rare in most known sources. All stable isotopes of C, N, O, Si, and S are observed and their isotopic ratios are derived. Conclusions: The composition of the remnant's molecular gas is most peculiar and gives rise to a very unique millimeter and submillimeter spectrum. The observation of ions and complex molecules suggests the presence of a photoionizing source but its nature (a central star or shocks) remains unknown. The elemental and isotopic composition of the gas cannot be easily reconciled with standard nucleosynthesis but processing in hot CNO cycles and partial He burning can explain most of the chemical peculiarities. The isotopic ratios of CK Vul are remarkably close to those of presolar nova grains but the link of Nova 1670 to objects responsible for these grains is unclear.

CK Vul: a smorgasbord of hydrocarbons rules out a 1670 nova (and much else besides)

We present observations of CK Vul obtained with the Spitzer Space Telescope. The infrared spectrum reveals a warm dust continuum with nebular, molecular hydrogen and HCN lines superimposed, together with the "Unidentified Infrared" (UIR) features. The nebular lines are consistent with emission by a low density gas. We conclude that the Spitzer data, combined with other information, are incompatible with CK Vul being a classical nova remnant in "hibernation" after the event of 1670, a "Very Late Thermal Pulse", a "Luminous Red Variable" such as V838 Mon, or a "Diffusion-induced nova". The true nature of CK Vul remains a mystery.

Nuclear ashes and outflow in the eruptive star Nova Vul 1670.

CK Vulpeculae was observed in outburst in 1670-1672 (ref. 1), but no counterpart was seen until 1982, when a bipolar nebula was found at its location. Historically, CKVul has been considered to be a nova (Nova Vul 1670), but its similarity to 'red transients', which are more luminous than classical novae and thought to be the results of stellar collisions, has re-opened the question of CKVul's status. Red transients cool to resemble late M-type stars, surrounded by circumstellar material rich in molecules and dust. No stellar source has been seen in CKVul, though a radio continuum source was identified at the expansion centre of the nebula. Here we report that CKVul is surrounded by chemically rich molecular gas in the form of an outflow, as well as dust. The gas has peculiar isotopic ratios, revealing that CK Vul's composition was strongly enhanced by the nuclear ashes of hydrogen burning. The chemical composition cannot be reconciled with a nova or indeed any other known explosion. In addition, the mass of the surrounding gas is too large for a nova, though the conversion from observations of CO to a total mass is uncertain. We conclude that CKVul is best explained as the remnant of a merger of two stars.

OGLE-2002-BLG-360: from a gravitational microlensing candidate to an overlooked red transient

OGLE-2002-BLG-360 was discovered as a microlensing candidate by the OGLE-III project. The subsequent light curve however clearly showed that the brightening of the object could not have resulted from the gravitational microlensing phenomenon. We aim to explain the nature of OGLE-2002-BLG-360 and its eruption observed in 2002--2006. The observational data primarily come from the archives of the OGLE project, which monitored the object in 2001--2009. The archives of the MACHO and MOA projects also provided us with additional data obtained in 1995--99 and 2000--2005, respectively. These data allowed us to analyse the light curve of the object during its eruption, as well as the potential variability of its progenitor. In the archives of several infrared surveys, namely 2MASS, MSX, Spitzer, AKARI, WISE, and VVV, we found measurements of the object, which allowed us to study the spectral energy distribution (SED) of the object. We constructed a simple model of a star surrounded by a dusty envelope, which was used to interpret the observed SED. Our analysis of the data clearly shows that OGLE-2002-BLG-360 was most probably a red transient, i.e. an object similar in nature to V838 Mon, whose eruption was observed in 2002. The SED in all phases, i.e. progenitor, eruption, and remnant, was dominated by infrared emission, which we interpret as evidence of dust formation in an intense mass outflow. Since 2009 the object has been completely embedded in dust. We suggest that the progenitor of OGLE-2002-BLG-360 was a binary, which had entered the common-envelope phase a long time (at least decades) before the observed eruption, and that the eruption resulted from the final merger of the binary components. We point out similarities between OGLE-2002-BLG-360 and CK Vul, whose eruption was observed in 1670--72, and this strengthens the hypothesis that CK Vul was also a red transient.

CK Vul: evolving nebula and three curious background stars

We analyse the remnants of CK Vul (Nova Vul 1670) using optical imaging and spectroscopy. The imaging, obtained between 1991 and 2010, spans 5.6% of the life-time of the nebula. The flux of the nebula decreased during the last 2 decades. The central source still maintains the ionization of the innermost part of the nebula, but recombination proceeds in more distant parts of the nebula. Surprisingly, we discovered two stars located within 10 arcsec of the expansion centre of the radio emission that are characterized by pronounced long term variations and one star with high proper motion. The high proper motion star is a foreground object, and the two variable stars are background objects. The photometric variations of two variables are induced by a dusty cloud ejected by CK Vul and passing through the line of sight to those stars. The cloud leaves strong lithium absorption in the spectra of the stars. We discuss the nature of the object in terms of recent observations.

The diffusion-induced nova scenario: CK Vul and PB8 as possible observational counterparts

We propose a scenario for the formation of DA white dwarfs with very thin helium buffers. For these stars we explore the possible occurrence of diffusion-induced CNO- flashes, during their early cooling stage. In order to obtain very thin helium buffers, we simulate the formation of low mass remnants through an AGB final/late thermal pulse (AFTP/LTP scenario). Then we calculate the consequent white dwarf cooling evolution by means of a consistent treatment of element diffusion and nuclear burning. Based on physically sounding white dwarf models, we find that the range of helium buffer masses for these diffusion-induced novas to occur is significantly smaller than that predicted by the only previous study of this scenario. As a matter of fact, we find that these flashes do occur only in some low-mass (M < 0.6M) and low metallicity (Z_ZAMS <0.001) remnants about 10^6 - 10^7 yr after departing from the AGB. For these objects, we expect the luminosity to increase by about 4 orders of magnitude in less than a decade. We also show that diffusion-induced novas should display a very typical eruption lightcurve, with an increase of about a few magnitudes per year before reaching a maximum of M_V ~ -5 to -6. Our simulations show that surface abundances after the outburst are characterized by logNH/NHe ~ -0.15...0.6 and N>C>O by mass fractions. Contrary to previous speculations we show that these events are not recurrent and do not change substantially the final H-content of the cool (DA) white dwarf. (Abridged)

The enigma of the oldest ‘nova’: the central star and nebula of CK Vul

CK Vul is classified as, amongst others, the slowest known nova, a hibernating nova or a very late thermal pulse object. Following its eruption in ad 1670, the star remained visible for 2 yr. A 15-arcsec nebula was discovered in the 1980s, but the star itself has not been detected since the eruption. We here present radio images which reveal a 0.1-arcsec radio source with a flux of 1.5 mJy at 5 GHz. Deep Hα images show a bipolar nebula with a longest extension of 70 arcsec, with the previously known compact nebula at its waist. The emission-line ratios show that the gas is shock-ionized, at velocities >100 km s−1. Dust emission yields an envelope mass of ∼5 × 10−2 M⊙. Echelle spectra indicate outflow velocities up to 360 km s−1. From a comparison of images obtained in 1991 and 2004 we find evidence for expansion of the nebula, consistent with an origin in the 1670 explosion; the measured expansion is centred on the radio source. No optical or infrared counterpart is found at the position of the radio source. The radio emission is interpreted as thermal free–free emission from gas with Te∼ 104 K. The radio source may be due to a remnant circumbinary disc, similar to those seen in some binary post-AGB stars. We discuss possible classifications of this unique outburst, including that of a sub-Chandrasekhar mass supernova, a nova eruption on a cool, low-mass white dwarf or a thermal pulse induced by accretion from a circumbinary disc.

The Real-Time Evolution of Sakurai's Star (V4334 Sgr) and other (V)LTP Objects

We report on the progress of our on-going campaign to monitor the evolution of the VLTP objects V4334 Sgr and V605 Aql, as well as the suspected (V)LTP object CK Vul. V4334 Sgr does not show signs of increased ionization compared to our previous observations in 2004. We obtained the first radio detection of V605 Aql, indicating a strong increase in radio flux since 1987. We also present the first radio detection of CK Vul and discuss the expansion of the material ejected during the 1670 event.

CK Vul as a candidate eruptive stellar merging event

CK Vul (Nova Vul 1670) is one of the most mysterious objects among erupting stellar objects. Past studies have sug- gested that CK Vul is a final helium-flash object resembling V605 Aql and V4334 Sgr (Sakurai's object). The peculiar outburst light curve of CK Vul, however, had no similar counterpart among the known eruptive objects. Furthermore, the presence of hydrogen in the proposed remnant seems to contradict with the final helium-flash scenario. We propose that the peculiarities of CK Vul can be naturally understood if we consider a merging of main-sequence stars, following a new interpretation by Soker & Tylenda (2003) which was proposed to explain the peculiar eruptive object V838 Mon. In this case, the 1670 outburst of CK Vul may be best understood as a V838 Mon-like event which occurred in our vicinity.

CK Vul: reborn perhaps, but not hibernating

ABSTRA C T It has been claimed that CK Vul (the remnant of Nova Vul 1670) may be the oldest recovered ‘old nova’ and as such provides evidence in support of the hibernation scenario for classical nova systems. However this interpretation has been challenged. We present 450- and 850-mm photometry of CK Vul which cast further doubt on its old nova status. It displays a large far infrared-submillimetre flux excess, inconsistent with the properties of an old nova. Furthermore, IRAS images show that CK Vul is located in a ‘cavity’ in the infrared emission, a feature often associated with planetary nebulae. It seems more likely that CK Vul ‐ and hence Nova Vul 1670 ‐ is (like V605 Aql and V4334 Sgr) an evolved star in the throes of a final thermal pulse.