Chronic Graft-versus-host Disease Consortium Research Articles

Study Protocol: Predicting the Quality of Response to Specific Treatments (PQRST) in Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease

BackgroundChronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) is a leading cause of late morbidity and mortality after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation. Despite significant progress in chronic GVHD therapies, challenges remain in understanding pleomorphic phenotypes and varying response to treatment. The goal of the Predicting the Quality of Response to Specific Treatments (PQRST) in chronic GVHD study is to identify predictors of treatment response. This report describing the study design seeks to raise awareness and invite collaborations with investigators who wish to access clinical data and research samples from this study. MethodsThis is a prospective, observational cohort study involving data collection from patients who are beginning first-, second-, or third-line systemic therapy for chronic GVHD with defined agents. Evaluable participants will have baseline assessments and research samples prior to starting the index therapy, and 1 month after starting treatment. Response assessments occur at 3 and 6 months after start of treatment, or if a new systemic therapy is started before 6 months. Target enrollment is approximately 200 patients at 8 institutions, with at least 6 months of follow up to determine response to index therapy. ResultsEnrollment started in July 2020 and was delayed due to the COVID-19 pandemic; as of 3/1/2024, 137 evaluable participants have been enrolled. DiscussionThe Chronic GVHD Consortium “PQRST” is a large longitudinal cohort study that aims to investigate predictors of treatment response by identifying biologically and clinically defined patient subgroups. We welcome investigators to collaborate in the use of these data.Trial registration: NCT04431479

Durable discontinuation of systemic therapy in patients affected by chronic graft-versus-host disease.

Successful treatment of chronic graft-versus-host disease (GvHD) often requires long-term systemic therapy (ST). Durable discontinuation of ST reflects the resolution of active chronic GvHD. We evaluated the factors associated with durable ST discontinuation, defined as cessation of all ST for ≥12 months, using data from two prospectively followed cohorts from the Chronic GvHD Consortium (n=684). Transplant sources were peripheral blood (89%), bone marrow (6.6%), and cord blood (4.4%) from HLA matched related (37.6%), HLA matched unrelated (45%), and other donor types (18%). Half of the patients received non-myeloablative conditioning. The median time from transplantation to chronic GvHD diagnosis was 7.7 months (range, 1.0-141.3) and the median time from chronic GvHD onset to enrollment into the cohorts was 0.9 months (range, 0.0-12.0). The cumulative incidence estimate of durable ST discontinuation was 32% (95% confidence interval: 28%-37%) at 10 years after enrollment into the cohort. Among patients who discontinued ST, the median time from chronic GvHD diagnosis to durable ST discontinuation was 3.6 years (range, 1.2-10.5). In multivariate analysis, patients who received myeloablative conditioning, had chronic GvHD manifested as moderate/severe lower gastrointestinal involvement, and had a higher (worse) Lee symptom overall score were less likely to attain durable ST discontinuation. In contrast, mild lower gastrointestinal involvement and cord blood (vs. peripheral blood) as the graft source were associated with a greater likelihood of ST discontinuation. Although a minority of patients can discontinue ST permanently, most patients require prolonged ST. Viewing chronic GvHD in this way has implications for management approaches.

Refined National Institutes of Health response algorithm for chronic graft-versus-host disease in joints and fascia

AbstractImplementation of the 2014 National Institutes of Health (NIH) response algorithm for joint/fascia graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) has identified real-world limits to its application. To refine the 2014 NIH response algorithm, we analyzed multicenter prospective observational data from the Chronic GVHD Consortium. The training cohort included 209 patients and the replication cohort included 191 patients with joint/fascia involvement during their course of chronic GVHD. Linear mixed models with random patient effect were used to evaluate correlations between response categories and clinician- or patient-perceived changes in joint status as an anchor of response. Analysis of the training cohort showed that a 2-point change in total photographic range of motion (P-ROM) score was clinically meaningful. The results also suggested that a change from 0 to 1 on the NIH joint/fascia score should not be considered as worsening and suggested that both the NIH joint/fascia score and total P-ROM score, but not individual P-ROM scores, should be used for response assessment. On the basis of these results, we developed an evidence-based refined algorithm, the utility of which was examined in an independent replication cohort. Using the refined algorithm, ∼40% of responses were reclassified, largely mitigating most divergent responses among individual joints and changes from 0 to 1 on the NIH joint/fascia score. The refined algorithm showed robust point estimates and tighter 95% confidence intervals associated with clinician- or patient-perceived changes, compared with the 2014 NIH algorithm. The refined algorithm provides a superior, evidence-based method for measuring therapeutic response in joint/fascia chronic GVHD.

Employment, Insurance, and Financial Experiences of Patients with Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease in North America

Understanding the socioeconomic impact of chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) on affected patients is essential to help improve their overall well-being. Using data from the Chronic GVHD Consortium, we describe the insurance, employment, and financial challenges faced by these patients and the factors associated with the ability to work/attend school and associated financial burdens. A 15-item cross-sectional questionnaire designed to measure financial concerns, income, employment, and insurance was completed by 190 patients (response rate, 68%; 10 centers) enrolled on a multicenter Chronic GVHD Consortium Response Measures Validation Study. Multivariable logistic regression models examined the factors associated with financial burden and ability to work/attend school. The median age of respondents was 56years, and 87% of the patients were white. A higher proportion of nonrespondents had lower income before hematopoietic cell transplantation and less than a college degree. All but 1 patient had insurance, 34% had faced delayed/denied insurance coverage for chronic GVHD treatments, and 66% reported a financial burden. Patients with a financial burden had greater depression/anxiety and difficulty sleeping. Nonwhite race, lower mental functioning, and lower activity score were associated with a greater likelihood of financial burden. Younger age, early risk disease, and higher mental functioning were associated with a greater likelihood of being able to work/attend school. In this multicenter cohort of patients with chronic GVHD, significant negative effects on finances were observed even with health insurance coverage. Future research should investigate potential interventions to provide optimal and affordable care to at-risk patients and prevent long-term adverse financial outcomes in this vulnerable group.

Impact of Psychological Distress on Quality of Life, Functional Status, and Survival in Patients with Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease

Data on psychological distress and its association with clinical outcomes in patients with chronic graft-versus-host-disease (GVHD) are lacking. We used data of patients with chronic GVHD (N = 482) from the Chronic GVHD Consortium, a prospective observational multicenter cohort. We examined the relationship between self-reported depression or anxiety symptoms (measured by the Lee Symptom Scale) and patients’ quality of life (QOL; measured by the Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-General [FACT-G] and the Physical Component Scale [PCS] of the 36-item Short-Form Health Survey), physical functioning (measured by the Human Activity Profile), functional status (measured by the 2-minute walk test), and overall survival (OS). Overall, 19.3% of patients (93/481) reported being moderately to extremely bothered by depression, and 22.8% (110/482) reported being moderately to extremely bothered by anxiety, with 14.1% (68/482) of those reporting being bothered by both. In multivariable models adjusted for clinical covariates, patients with self-reported depression had worse QOL (FACT-G: β = –23.09, P < .001; PCS: β = –4.94, P < .001), physical functioning (β = –8.31, P < .001), functional status (β = –37.21, P = .025), and lower OS (hazard ratio, 1.62; P = .020) compared with those with no depression symptoms. Patients who reported anxiety also had lower QOL (FACT-G: β = –19.47, P < .001; PCS: β = –3.91, P < .001), physical functioning (β = –6.69, P < .001), and functional status (β = –32.42, P = .036) but no difference in OS. Patients with chronic GVHD who report depression or anxiety symptoms have significantly compromised QOL and physical functioning. Self-reported depression is associated with lower OS. Patients with chronic GVHD and self-reported depression or anxiety represent a highly vulnerable population at risk for poor clinical outcomes and substantial morbidity from their illness.

Association of Socioeconomic Status with Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease Outcomes

Chronic graft-versus host disease (GVHD) is a chronic and disabling complication after hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). It is important to understand the association of socioeconomic status (SES) with health outcomes in patients with chronic GVHD because of the impaired physical health and dependence on intensive and prolonged health care utilization needs in these patients. We evaluated the association of SES with survival and quality of life (QOL) in a cohort of 421 patients with chronic GVHD enrolled on the Chronic GVHD Consortium Improving Outcomes Assessment study. Income, education, marital status, and work status were analyzed to determine the associations with patient-reported outcomes at the time of enrollment, nonrelapse mortality (NRM), and overall mortality. Higher income (P = .004), ability to work (P < .001), and having a partner (P = .021) were associated with better mean Lee chronic GVHD symptom scores. Higher income (P = .048), educational level (P = .044), and ability to work (P < .001) also were significantly associated with better QOL and improved activity. In multivariable models, higher income and ability to return to work were both significantly associated with better chronic GVHD Lee symptom scores, but income was not associated with activity level, QOL, or physical/mental functioning. The inability to return to work (hazard ratio, 1.82; P = .019) was associated with worse overall mortality, whereas none of the SES indicators were associated with NRM. Income, race, and education did not have statistically significant associations with survival. In summary, we did not observe an association between SES variables and survival or NRM in patients with chronic GVHD, although we found some association with patient-reported outcomes, such as symptom burden. Higher income status was associated with less severe chronic GVHD symptoms. More research is needed to understand the psychosocial, biological, and environmental factors that mediate this association of SES with major HCT outcomes.

Late acute graft-versus-host disease: a prospective analysis of clinical outcomes and circulating angiogenic factors

AbstractLate acute (LA) graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) is persistent, recurrent, or new-onset acute GVHD symptoms occurring >100 days after allogeneic hematopoietic cell transplantation (HCT). The aim of this analysis is to describe the onset, course, morbidity, and mortality of and examine angiogenic factors associated with LA GVHD. A prospective cohort of patients (n = 909) was enrolled as part of an observational study within the Chronic GVHD Consortium. Eighty-three patients (11%) developed LA GVHD at a median of 160 (interquartile range, 128-204) days after HCT. Although 51 out of 83 (61%) achieved complete or partial response to initial therapy by 28 days, median failure-free survival was only 7.1 months (95% confidence interval, 3.4-19.1 months), and estimated overall survival (OS) at 2 years was 56%. Given recently described alterations of circulating angiogenic factors in classic acute GVHD, we examined whether alterations in such factors could be identified in LA GVHD. We first tested cases (n = 55) and controls (n = 50) from the Chronic GVHD Consortium and then validated the findings in 37 cases from Mount Sinai Acute GVHD International Consortium. Plasma amphiregulin (AREG; an epidermal growth factor [EGF] receptor ligand) was elevated, and an AREG/EGF ratio at or above the median was associated with inferior OS and increased nonrelapse mortality in both cohorts. Elevation of AREG was detected in classic acute GVHD, but not chronic GVHD. These prospective data characterize the clinical course of LA GVHD and demonstrate alterations in angiogenic factors that make LA GVHD biologically distinct from chronic GVHD.

Translation, Cross-Cultural Adaptation, and Validation of the Lee Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease Symptom Scale in a Brazilian Population

The Lee Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease (GVHD) Symptom Scale is a patient-reported instrument developed and validated in English to measure the symptoms and functional impact of cGVHD. This tool has not yet been validated in a Latin American population, however. The Brazil-Seattle Chronic GVHD Consortium conducted a multicenter study at 5 Brazilian institutions to validate the Lee cGVHD Symptom Scale in adults with cGVHD. Study objectives included the translation and validation of the instrument in Brazilian Portuguese and evaluation of the correlation with other quality of life (QoL) tools, including the Medical Outcomes Study Short Form 36 (SF-36) and Functional Assessment of Chronic Illness Therapy with Bone Marrow Transplant subscale (FACT-BMT). Translation and validation were done according to the American Association of Orthopedic Surgeons Outcome Committee guidelines. Spearman's correlation coefficient was used to measure construct validity. Reliability was assessed using Cronbach's α and intraclass correlation coefficients. Between April 2011 and August 2012, 47 patients with cGVHD based on the 2005 National Institutes of Health criteria (29 males [62%], 18 females [38%]; median age, 48 years; range, 23 to 69 years) were enrolled in this study. The reliability of the Lee cGVHD Symptom Scale was adequate (Cronbach's α = 0.62 to 0.83). The correlations between similar domains of the Lee cGVHD Symptom Scale, SF-36, and FACT-BMT were moderate to high. Our data indicate that the Brazilian Portuguese version of the Lee cGVHD Symptom Scale is valid and reliable and can be used in clinical trials of cGVHD in Brazil.

Impact of Age on Quality of Life, Functional Status, and Survival in Patients with Chronic Graft-versus-Host Disease

Although older patients undergoing allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT) may experience higher morbidity, the impact of chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) on quality of life (QOL) and survival outcomes for older compared with younger patients is currently unknown. We utilized data of patients with moderate or severe chronic GVHD (N = 522, 1661 follow-up visits, a total of 2183 visits) from the Chronic GVHD Consortium, a prospective observational multicenter cohort. We examined the relationship between age group (adolescent and young adult, “AYA,” 18 to 40 years; “middle-aged,” 41 to 59 years; and “older,” ≥ 60 years) and QOL (Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy-Bone Marrow Transplantation [FACT-BMT]), physical functioning (Human Activity Profile [HAP]), functional status (2-minute walk test [2MWT]), nonrelapse mortality, and overall survival. Because of multiple testing, P values < .01 were considered significant. This study included 115 (22%) AYA, 279 (53%) middle-aged, and 128 (25%) older patients with moderate (58%) or severe (42%) chronic GVHD. Despite more physical limitations in older patients as measured by worse functional status (shorter 2MWT [P < .001] and lower HAP scores [P < .001]) relative to AYA and middle-aged patients, older patients reported better QOL (FACT-BMT, P = .004) compared with middle-aged patients and similar to AYA patients (P = .99). Nonrelapse mortality and overall survival were similar between the age groups. Therefore, despite higher physical and functional limitations, older patients who are selected to undergo HSCT and survive long enough to develop moderate or severe chronic GVHD have preserved QOL and similar overall survival and nonrelapse mortality when compared with younger patients. Therefore, we did not find evidence that older age is associated with worse outcomes in patients with moderate or severe chronic GVHD.

Do Older Patients With Moderate-Severe Chronic Graft-Versus-Host Disease Differ From Younger Patients?

IntroductionOlder patients undergoing allogeneic stem cell transplantation may experience a higher degree of morbidity and limitations from transplant related complications. Chronic graft-versus –host disease (GVHD) causes a significant reduction in patients' quality of life (QOL), physical functioning, and functional status. However, it is not known if moderate to severe chronic GVHD has a worse impact on QOL, or survival outcomes for older patients. MethodsWe analyzed data of patients with moderate or severe chronic GVHD (N=522, 1661 follow-up visits, a total of 2,183 visits) from the Chronic GVHD Consortium, a prospective observational multicenter cohort. Moderate or severe chronic GVHD was defined by the National Institutes of Health global severity score at the time of enrollment. We examined the relationship between age group (adolescent and young adult “AYA” 18-40, “middle-aged” 41-59, and “older” ≥ 60 years) and clinical manifestations of chronic GVHD, patient-reported outcomes, functional status, non-relapse mortality and overall survival. Clinical manifestations of chronic GVHD were determined by the clinician-reported individual organ scores. Patient-reported outcomes included (1) QOL as measured by Functional Assessment of Cancer Therapy Bone Marrow Transplantation (FACT-BMT) and the Medical Outcome Short-Form Health Survey (SF-36) (2) chronic GVHD symptom burden as measured by the Lee Symptom Scale; and (3) physical fitness as measured by the Human Activity Profile (HAP). Functional status was assessed using the 2-minute walk test (2MWT). Because of multiple testing, p-values <0.01 were considered significant. ResultsThere were 115 (22%) AYA, 279 (53%) middle-aged and 128 (25%) older patients with moderate (58%) or severe (42%) chronic GVHD included. At study enrollment, older patients (≥60) were similar to younger patients in sex, time from transplant (median 12 months), prior acute GVHD, percentage of severe chronic GVHD, and current co-morbidity scores but differed in disease distribution and conditioning regimen intensity. At enrollment, in unadjusted analyses using all available data, older patients had similar rates and severity of global and organ-specific manifestations of chronic GVHD compared to younger patients, except for genital involvement, which was more prevalent and severe in AYA patients. Although older patients reported worse physical functioning [SF-36 Physical Functioning (p=0.01)], shorter 2MWT (p=0.002), and lower HAP scores (p=0.001) than AYA and middle-aged patients suggesting they have more physical limitations, older patients had better QOL [FACT-BMT (p=0.01)] scores compared to middle-aged patients and similar to AYA patients. Older patients had better psychological [Lee Psychological Scale (p<0.001), SF-36 Mental Health (p=0.01)] and emotional functioning [FACT-Emotional Well-being (p=0.001)] and less pain [SF-36 Bodily Pain (p=0.006)] than AYA and middle-aged patients but similar chronic GVHD symptom burden [Lee Symptom Scale (p=0.47)]. In multivariable linear mixed models utilizing all visit data and adjusted for clinical covariates, older patients had QOL (FACT-BMT) that was comparable to AYA patients (estimate -0.04, p=0.99) and better than middle-aged patients (estimate 5.7, p=0.004), while the SF36 physical and mental component scores and symptom burden were not different between the groups. Non-relapse mortality and overall survival were similar between the age groups in unadjusted analyses (p=0.23, p=0.17) and after adjusting for clinical covariates (p=0.17, p=0.15) in Cox models. In a subgroup analysis, we found that there were no differences in overall and organ-specific chronic GVHD manifestations, QOL and survival between patients in the 60-64 (n=73), 65-70 (n=39), and >70 (n=16) age groups, except for more moderate-severe skin involvement in the 65-70 year olds. ConclusionDespite higher physical and functional limitations, older patients with moderate or severe chronic GVHD have preserved QOL, comparable disease manifestations and symptom burden, and similar overall survival and non-relapse mortality when compared to younger patients. Therefore we did not find evidence that older age itself is associated with worse QOL or survival in patients with moderate or severe chronic GVHD. Disclosures:No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.

Influence Of Organ Scores On Mortality In Chronic GVHD: Results From The Chronic GVHD Consortium

The global severity score (GS) was devised by experts during the 2005 NIH Consensus for chronic graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) to reflect the overall severity of chronic GVHD at any time point. According to this scale, overall involvement is categorized as mild, moderate or severe. Several studies demonstrated that the NIH GS was associated with subsequent mortality in patients with chronic GVHD. We used multivariate time-varying analysis accounting for longitudinal changes of severity in individual organs over time to try to develop a better global mortality score than the NIH GS. Methods Data were derived from the Chronic GVHD Consortium, a prospective, multicenter, longitudinal, observational study. A total of 2202 visits from 574 adult patients with systemically treated chronic GVHD through January 2013 were used for analysis. At follow-up visits every 3-6 months, clinicians reported standardized information including NIH organ severity scores. Objective medical data including laboratory and pulmonary function test results were abstracted through standardized chart review after each visit. Time-varying Cox models accounting for varied times of entry into the study and longitudinal changes in organ severity over time were used to correlate severity in individual sites with overall mortality. All models were adjusted for time after transplantation, study site and known chronic GVHD mortality risk factors. 424 randomly selected patients with 1602 visit ratings were used to develop a new global mortality score, and the remaining 150 patients with 600 visit ratings were used to validate the model. Risk stratification was compared between the final model and the NIH GS model. Results In the training phase, multivariate models showed that organ severity scores in skin, gastrointestinal tract, liver and lung were independently associated with overall mortality (Table 1), while scores in mouth, eyes, joint or fascia and genital tract were not. Mortality scores were assigned based on observed hazard ratios, and 3 risk groups were identified based on the total mortality score (Table 2). In the validation cohort (n=150), the intermediate (329 visit ratings, HR 3.7, p=0.05) and high-risk categories (89 visit ratings, HR 10.8, p=0.001) were associated with higher risk of overall mortality compared with the low-risk category (185 visit ratings). Using the NIH GS instead, the severe category (196 visit ratings, HR 3.1, p=0.01) was associated with higher risk of overall mortality compared with the mild or moderate category (22 plus 382 visit ratings). Although agreement in risk categories was slight (weighted kappa = 0.32), the two models did not differ statistically based on log likelihood ratios, showing that they performed equally well in identifying groups with different mortality risks. Conclusion The influence of organ scores on mortality differs according to individual sites, with the largest influence from lung followed by liver, skin and gastrointestinal tract. The model fitness did not differ statistically between the 2 models, suggesting that the NIH GS is an adequate model for risk stratification based on mortality in patients with chronic GVHD. Disclosures: No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.

Graft-versus-Host Disease: State of the Science

Despite concerted research efforts, prevention and treatment of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) have not changed significantly over the past 3 decades. The goal of this session is to provide an outline of the current state of the science with respect to the prevention, treatment, and evaluation of acute and chronic GVHD. In addition, we detail those strategies most likely to be at the forefront of clinical research in the upcoming years.

Impact of prior acute GVHD on chronic GVHD outcomes: a chronic graft versus host disease consortium study

Chronic graft-versus-host disease (CGVHD) is one of the most debilitating complications post hematopoietic cell transplant (HCT). Several studies have evaluated factors affecting survival in CGVHD,1–8 most utilizing the older definition of CGVHD where patients with any symptoms of GVHD (acute or chronic) may be classified as CGVHD if symptomatic beyond day 100 post HCT. However, the new NIH consensus guidelines have re-defined criteria for CGVHD diagnosis and staging9 based on actual symptoms at presentation and excludes patients with persistent, recurrent or late AGVHD who were previously considered to have CGVHD. The CGVHD consortium follows a large multi-center prospectively enrolled cohort of CGVHD patients utilizing NIH consensus guidelines for assessments.10 Several reports from this consortium have identified factors affecting survival including global severity, thrombocytopenia, KPS and the overlap syndrome.11,12 Prior AGVHD has been associated with a higher mortality in patients who develop CGVHD,1,3 indicating that these patients may be more debilitated and hence suffer worse outcome. However, the clinical and prognostic importance of prior AGVHD on subsequent CGVHD in the current era using NIH diagnostic and staging criteria is unknown. We evaluated the significance of prior AGVHD on CGVHD presentation, overall response and survival in a contemporary cohort of CGVHD patients prospectively enrolled by the CGVHD consortium. Cases enrolled in the consortium could be incident (enrollment < 3 months after diagnosis) or prevalent (enrollment ≥3 months after diagnosis).10 Detailed CGVHD assessments were performed reflecting the recommendations of the NIH Consensus Conference,9,13 and are published in the cohort study rationale and design summary.10 Prior AGVHD was considered present if maximum grade I-IV was reported. Comparisons were performed between two groups: Prior AGVHD and no prior AGVHD. Statistical comparisons between groups were made with the two-sample t-test for continuous variables, and chi-squared test for categorical variables. Spearman correlation coefficients (ρ, rho) and simple kappa statistics were used to describe rank correlation and agreement between acute and CGVHD overall severity scores and skin, GI, and liver severity. Survival was estimated by the Kaplan-Meier method.14 Overall survival was calculated from enrollment, and non-relapse mortality (NRM) was defined as death without prior relapse. Failure-free survival (FFS) was defined as survival without prior relapse or adding new systemic medications to treat CGVHD. Cox regression15 was used for multivariate analysis of survival relative to presence or absence of prior acute GVHD and other risk factors. The total cohort included 496 patients: 329 with prior AGVHD and 167 with no prior AGVHD (de-novo CGVHD) (table 1). The prior AGVHD and de-novo CGVHD groups did not differ with respect to time between HCT and CGVHD diagnosis, or time between HCT and enrollment. The proportion of patients with classic and overlap CGVHD and the distribution of CGVHD global severity (mild, moderate and severe CGVHD), using clinician or patient reported and NIH scores, was similar. These observations support the hypothesis that CGVHD in patients with prior AGVHD does not differ fundamentally from de-novo CGVHD. In particular, prior AGVHD was not associated with AGVHD manifestations at the time of CGVHD diagnosis (overlap syndrome). There were some differences between prior AGVHD and de-novo CGVHD groups: Myeloablative conditioning, a mismatched or unrelated donor, and thrombocytopenia were more frequent in those with prior AGVHD. No further differences were observed between the two groups, including frequency of organ involvement, functional assessments or patient reported outcomes. Table 1 Patient and CGVHD characteristics