Solubility Of Chromatin Research Articles

A0427 - Sequential analysis of macro molecules accessibility unveils altered chromatin solubility patterns and epigenomic dysfunction in prostate cancer

A0427 - Sequential analysis of macro molecules accessibility unveils altered chromatin solubility patterns and epigenomic dysfunction in prostate cancer

Re-evaluating the Localization of Sperm-Retained Histones Revealed the Modification-Dependent Accumulation in Specific Genome Regions

The question of whether retained histones in the sperm genome localize to gene-coding regions or gene deserts has been debated for years. Previous contradictory observations are likely caused by the non-uniform sensitivity of sperm chromatin to micrococcal nuclease (MNase) digestion. Sperm chromatin has a highly condensed but heterogeneous structure and is composed of 90%∼99% protamines and 1%∼10% histones. In this study, we utilized nucleoplasmin (NPM) to improve the solubility of sperm chromatin by removing protamines invitro. NPM treatment efficiently solubilized histones while maintaining quality and quantity. Chromatin immunoprecipitation sequencing (ChIP-seq) analyses using NPM-treated sperm demonstrated the predominant localization of H4 to distal intergenic regions, whereas modified histones exhibited a modification-dependent preferential enrichment in specific genomic elements, such as H3K4me3 at CpG-rich promoters and H3K9me3 in satellite repeats, respectively, implying the existence of machinery protecting modified histones from eviction.

Incorporating DNA shearing in standard affinity purification allows simultaneous identification of both soluble and chromatin-bound interaction partners

Affinity purification coupled to mass spectrometry (AP-MS) is an effective means of identifying protein-protein interactions to better understand biological functions. However, issues associated with sample preparation still limit the success of AP-MS for specific classes of proteins, including those associated with chromatin that exhibit overall poor solubility in the protocols normally used for AP-MS analysis. Here, we wanted to provide a generally applicable method to simultaneously identify interactors for the chromatin-bound and the soluble fractions of a given bait protein. Using four FLAG-tagged canonical histone proteins (H2A, H2B, H3.1 and H4) we demonstrate that the chromatin solubility issue can be robustly alleviated by fragmenting DNA prior to AP-MS using a combination of sonication and nuclease treatment. We show that - in comparison to a commonly used AP-MS method - our optimized protocol greatly improves the recovery of chromatin-associated interactors for core histones. Critically, this is achieved while preserving the interaction partners associated with the soluble portion of the histones. Detailed protocols amenable to the study of both histone and non-histone baits are presented here. This manuscript describes workflow improvements to enable the recovery of chromatin-bound interactors by affinity purification coupled to mass spectrometry (AP-MS). This is significant, as most of the high-throughput studies to date can only monitor protein-protein interactions for soluble (not bound to chromatin) components. By consequence, we still poorly understand how protein complexes form on chromatin, which greatly hampers our understanding of gene expression. Using core histones as test cases, we show here a simple and universally applicable workflow that permits the identification of chromatin-bound protein-protein interactions. As exemplified in our manuscript, this revised protocol should result in a much deeper understanding of chromatin biology. This article is part of a Special Issue: Can Proteomics Fill the Gap Between Genomics and Phenotypes?

Phosphorylation of Histone H2A.X by DNA-dependent Protein Kinase Is Not Affected by Core Histone Acetylation, but It Alters Nucleosome Stability and Histone H1 Binding

Phosphorylation of the C-terminal end of histone H2A.X is the most characterized histone post-translational modification in DNA double-stranded breaks (DSB). DNA-dependent protein kinase (DNA-PK) is one of the three phosphatidylinositol 3 kinase-like family of kinase members that is known to phosphorylate histone H2A.X during DNA DSB repair. There is a growing body of evidence supporting a role for histone acetylation in DNA DSB repair, but the mechanism or the causative relation remains largely unknown. Using bacterially expressed recombinant mutants and stably and transiently transfected cell lines, we find that DNA-PK can phosphorylate Thr-136 in addition to Ser-139 both in vitro and in vivo. Furthermore, the phosphorylation reaction is not inhibited by the presence of H1, which in itself is a substrate of the reaction. We also show that, in contrast to previous reports, the ability of the enzyme to phosphorylate these residues is not affected by the extent of acetylation of the core histones. In vitro assembled nucleosomes and HeLa S3 native oligonucleosomes consisting of non-acetylated and acetylated histones are equally phosphorylated by DNA-PK. We demonstrate that the apparent differences in the extent of phosphorylation previously observed can be accounted for by the differential chromatin solubility under the MgCl(2) concentrations required for the phosphorylation reaction in vitro. Finally, we show that although H2A.X does not affect nucleosome conformation, it has a de-stabilizing effect that is enhanced by the DNA-PK-mediated phosphorylation and results in an impaired histone H1 binding.

Reconstitution of Yeast Silent Chromatin: Multiple Contact Sites and O-AADPR Binding Load SIR Complexes onto Nucleosomes In Vitro

At yeast telomeres and silent mating-type loci, chromatin assumes a higher-order structure that represses transcription by means of the histone deacetylase Sir2 and structural proteins Sir3 and Sir4. Here, we present a fully reconstituted system to analyze SIR holocomplex binding to nucleosomal arrays. Purified Sir2-3-4 heterotrimers bind chromatin, cooperatively yielding a stable complex of homogeneous molecular weight. Remarkably, Sir2-3-4 also binds naked DNA, reflecting the strong, albeit nonspecific, DNA-binding activity of Sir4. The binding of Sir3 to nucleosomes is sensitive to histone H4 N-terminal tail removal, while that of Sir2-4 is not. Dot1-mediated methylation of histone H3K79 reduces the binding of both Sir3 and Sir2-3-4. Additionally, a byproduct of Sir2-mediated NAD hydrolysis, O-acetyl-ADP-ribose, increases the efficiency with which Sir3 and Sir2-3-4 bind nucleosomes. Thus, in small cumulative steps, each Sir protein, unmodified histone domains, and contacts with DNA contribute to the stability of the silent chromatin complex.

Demonstration of a DNase-sensitive network associated with the nuclear pore complexes in rat liver nuclei.

Rat liver nuclei have been studied by transmission electron microscopy after resuspension in a phosphate-buffered salt solution containing SO2-4 as the quantitatively dominant anion. Owing to the high solubility of chromatin in the presence of SO2-4 instead of Cl- at isotonicity, nuclei are depleted for chromatin by DNase I digestion in this buffer, eliminating the need for high-salt extraction. This shows that at least 75% of the nuclear pore complexes are associated with fibrogranular structures, which ramify as a network throughout the nucleus, interconnecting the nuclear lamina, interchromatin granule clusters and nucleoli. Perichromatin granules are located in this material proximal to the nuclear pore complexes. Most of the chromatin is removed without major impact on the network, but below a level of 25% residual chromatin there is a considerable reduction of this material, and only about 15% of the connections to the nuclear pore complexes are resistant to digestion with DNase I or streptodornase A and B. The percentage of nuclear pore complexes connected to the network is further reduced by salt extraction and RNase treatment. These results suggest that DNA is an integral part of the network, which presumably plays a role in nucleo-cytoplasmic transport of RNA and protein.

Effect of organic effectors on chromatin solubility, DNA-histone H1 interactions, DNA and histone H1 structures.

We have extended our previous investigations on the effect of organic osmolytes (glycine, proline, taurine, mannitol, sorbitol and trimethylammonium oxide (TMAO)) on chromatin solubility, to the study of their influence on DNA stability and DNA-histone interactions. Our aim was to understand the molecular origin of the protection effects observed. To this end, we determined the amount of histone H1 required to precipitate DNA or H1-depleted chromatin, at various salt concentrations, in the presence of the above mentioned organic compounds. We found a shift of the H1/DNA ratio required to reach 50% precipitation, towards higher values. Taurine was the most efficient compound followed by mannitol and glycine, then sorbitol and proline. On the contrary, TMAO favoured the precipitation process. We attempted to interpret these results on the basis of Manning's counterion condensation theory. Changes in histone H1 structure folding and in DNA melting temperature Tm were also analyzed. Glycine, taurine, sorbitol and TMAO increased the degree of secondary structure folding of the protein while mannitol and sorbitol had no effect. Taurine, glycine and proline decreased the Tm of DNA, TMAO largely destabilized DNA, but mannitol and sorbitol had no effect. Measurements of NaCl activity in the presence of organic osmolytes did not reveal sufficiently large changes to account for their protection effect against chromatin precipitation. The osmotic coefficient j of the organic effectors solutions increased in the order: taurine < glycine < sorbitol < mannitol < proline << TMAO. For the two latter compounds, the j values increased above 1 at high concentration. We consider that the organic compounds investigated may be classified into three categories: (i) class I (zwitterionic compounds: glycine, proline, taurine) would produce sodium ions release from the DNA surface; (ii) class II (the very polar molecule TMAO) would increase sodium counterions condensation on DNA together with histone H1 folding; (iii) class III compounds (mannitol and sorbitol) would possibly produce a modification of NaCl activity but no definite explanation could be found for the complex behavior of these compounds.

Histone acetylation reduces H1-mediated nucleosome interactions during chromatin assembly

During chromatin replication and nucleosome assembly, newly synthesized histone H4 is acetylated before it is deposited onto DNA, then deacetylated as assembly proceeds. In a previous study (Perry and Annunziato, Nucleic Acids Res. 17, 4275 [1989]) it was shown that when replication occurs in the presence of sodium butyrate (thereby inhibiting histone deacetylation), nascent chromatin fails to mature fully and instead remains preferentially sensitive to DNaseI, more soluble in magnesium, and depleted of histone H1 (relative to mature chromatin). In the following report the relationships between chromatin replication, histone acetylation, and H1-mediated nucleosome aggregation were further investigated. Chromatin was replicated in the presence or absence of sodium butyrate; isolated nucleosomes were stripped of linker histone, reconstituted with H1, and treated to produce Mg 2+-soluble and Mg 2+-insoluble chromatin fractions. Following the removal of H1, all solubility differences between chromatin replicated in sodium butyrate for 30 min (bu-chromatin) and control chromatin were lost. Reconstitution with H1 completely restored the preferential Mg 2+-solubility of buchromatin, demonstrating that a reduced capacity for aggregation/condensation is an inherent feature of acetylated nascent nucleosomes; however, titration with excess H1 caused the solubility differences to be lost again. Moreover, when the core histone N-terminal “tails” (the sites of acetylation) were removed by trypsinization prior to reconstitution, H1 was unable to reestablish the altered solubility of chromatin replicated in butyrate. Thus, the core histone “tails,” and the acetylation thereof, not only modulate H1-mediated nucleosome interactions in vitro, but also strongly influence the ability of H1 to differentiate between new and old nucleosomes. The data suggest a possible mechanism for the control of H1 deposition and/or chromatin folding during nucleosome assembly.

Dynamically acetylated histones of chicken erythrocytes are selectively methylated

The relationship between histone acetylation and methylation in chicken immature erythrocytes was investigated. Previous studies have shown that transcriptionally active/competent gene-enriched chromatin fragments are enriched in newly methylated histones H3 and H4. Moreover, newly methylated histone H4 is hyperacetylated. Here, we show that dynamically acetylated histone H4 is selectively engaged in ongoing methylation. While sodium butyrate (an inhibitor of histone deacetylase) does not inhibit ongoing histone methylation, it does affect the acetylation state of newly methylated histone H4 when chicken immature erythrocytes are incubated in its presence or absence. Only one rate of acetylation of labelled newly methylated unacetylated histone H4 with a t1/2 of 8 min is observed. Previous studies have shown that the solubility of transcriptionally active/competent gene chromatin fragments in 0.15 M-NaCl is dependent upon the level of acetylated histone species, with induction of hyperacetylation increasing the solubility of this gene chromatin. Here, we show that the low salt solubility of chromatin fragments associated with newly methylated histones H3 and H4 is also dependent upon the level of acetylated histones. These results provide further support for the hypothesis that histones participating in ongoing methylation are associated with transcriptionally active/competent chromatin and suggest that the processes of histone H4 methylation and dynamic acetylation are partially coupled in terminally differentiated erythrocytes.

Cation-dependent solubilization of rat thymocyte chromatin is closely related to decondensation of the nuclei

The cation-dependent solubilization of rat thymocyte chromatin has been compared with decondensation of the nuclei as a function of sodium phosphate-mediated changes in the concentration of Mg 2+ and Na +. After digestion of the nuclei with DNase I or Micrococcus nuclease for a time just sufficient to permit extraction of a maximal amount of chromatin (minimum digestion), solubilization of most of the chromatin was found to occur with the same cation dependency as decondensation of untreated nuclei, while further digestion changed the ionic requirements for solubilization. The cation-dependency of the chromatin solubility and of the nuclear decondensation also exhibited the same variations with temperature. The chromatin in the nuclei became up to 4-times more sensitive to DNase I by decondensation, which also induced a shift in the DNase I cleavage mode from a 200 bp to a 100 bp repeat pattern. In contrast, the sensitivity to Micrococcus nuclease appeared to be nearly unchanged. These results suggest that solubilization of chromatin prepared by a mild endonuclease treatment occurs as a direct consequence of structural changes in the chromatin which take place during decondensation of the nuclei.

Human chorionic gonadotropin increases chromatin solubility in isolated bovine and human luteal nuclei.

We have previously demonstrated that bovine and human luteal nuclei contain human chorionic gonadotropin/luteinizing hormone (hCG/LH) receptors and that these gonadotropins can directly stimulate nuclear membrane enzyme activity (nucleoside triphosphatase) involved in messenger ribonucleic acid (mRNA) transport from the nucleus to the cytoplasm. The present studies were undertaken to investigate the effect or hCG on chromatin solubility, reflecting perhaps synthesis and transport of RNA, in isolated bovine and human luteal nuclei. hCG increased chromatin solubility in a concentration-dependent manner. This hCG effect is either blocked or substantially reduced by the addition of hCG antiserum; denatured hCG had no effect and cyclic adenosine 3',5'-monophosphate could not mimic the hCG response. hCG had no effect on chromatin solubility in bovine liver or kidney nuclei and hormones other than hCG, human LH, or the beta subunit of hCG had no effect on chromatin solubility in bovine luteal nuclei, demonstrating the tissue and hormone specificity of the response. These findings further strengthen the concept of direct gonadotropin regulation of nuclear functions of luteal cells.

Chicken erythrocyteβ-globin chromatin: enhanced solubility is a direct consequence of induced histone hyperacetylation

Chicken immature red blood cells were incubated for 1 hour in Swim's medium containing 3H-acetate and 10 mM n-butyrate. During the incubation period, the small percentage of dynamically acetylated and deacetylated histone is radiolabeled and hyperacetylated. A second effect of the n-butyrate incubation is to shift a small subset of nucleohistone into a soluble form. This chromatin is predominantly polynucleosome size (approximately dimer to pentamer) and can be separated from soluble mononucleosomes by 5-30% sucrose gradient centrifugation. The soluble polynucleosomes are 25-30 fold enriched for adult beta-globin (beta A) DNA and contain the hyperacetylated histones. We have tested whether histone hyperacetylation is responsible for the enhanced beta-globin chromatin solubility by in vitro deacetylation of the soluble chromatin histones. This procedure converts the beta-globin polynucleosomes to an insoluble form, demonstrating that histone hyperacetylation is in fact directly responsible for the increased solubility of the beta A chromatin.

Exchange of H1 histone depends on aggregation of chromatin, not simply on ionic strength.

Chromatin solubility was observed at several concentrations of various cations. Spermine and spermidine precipitated (50%) chromatin at about 0.2 mM, Ca2+ and Mg2+ at about 1-2 mM, and Na+ at about 100 mM. Further increases in cation concentration induced more aggregation, but eventually excess cation increased chromatin solubility so that 50% solubility was observed again at 60 mM Mg2+ and 180 mM Na+. H1 histone was 50% released by 80 mM MgCl2 or 425 mM NaCl. Combinations of MgCl2 and NaCl showed that Mg2+ and Na+ are synergistic in the induction of aggregation in lower concentrations (less than 2 mM) of Mg2+ but antagonistic at higher concentrations, and a similar effect of NaCl on spermidine-induced precipitation was shown below and above about 0.2 mM spermidine. At 5 mM, MgCl2 proved capable of precipitating chromatin depleted of H1 histone, but no concentration of NaCl was capable of doing so. These phenomena can be rationalized by supposing that neutralization of chromatin by any cation (including H1 histone) favors aggregation and also that cross-linking of chromatin fibers by multivalent cations (including H1 histone) is also critically important. The exchange of H1 histone between chromatin fragments was tested in various concentrations of different salts. H1 exchange was correlated with chromatin aggregation rather than with ionic strength and thus appears to depend on fiber to fiber contact. Under conditions where H1 exchanges between chromatin fibers that are permitted to make contact with each other, no H1 exchange occurred between chromatin inside the nucleus and chromatin outside, even though H1 histone is capable of passage through the nuclear membrane.

The beta-globin domain in immature chicken erythrocytes: enhanced solubility is coincident with histone hyperacetylation.

A 60 minute exposure of chicken immature erythrocytes to n-butyrate shifts actively acetylated and deacetylated histones to hypermodified forms. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of nuclei from n-butyrate treated cells and subsequent fractionation of the chromatin releases 40-45% of the adult beta-globin (beta A) nucleohistone into a soluble fraction. This is an eleven fold enrichment over the soluble chromatin from untreated cells (Ferenz and Nelson (1985) Nucleic Acids Res. 13, 1977-1995). The enhanced beta A chromatin solubility and induced histone hyperacetylation are coincident. Removal of n-butyrate from the cell incubation medium allows rapid histone deacetylation and a striking reduction in beta A chromatin solubility. Chromatin from cells incubated in the absence of n-butyrate, or in medium containing 10 mM NaCl or 2% dimethylsulfoxide, does not exhibit histone hyperacetylation, or the acquired solubility of beta A chromatin. We show that the H4 histone co-isolated with the beta A DNA is in a hyperacetylated state and present evidence that the n-butyrate incubation increases the solubility of both coding and noncoding chromatin regions in the beta-globin domain.

Copper-rich nucleoprotein generated by micrococcal nuclease

Nuclei from calf thymus tissue digested with micrococcal nuclease under nonchelating conditions yielded soluble nucleoprotein enriched in copper. Following limited digestion, the ratio of μg Cu:mg DNA was inversely related either to percent solubility of chromatin or to levels of enzyme maintaining an enzyme:A 260 ratio of 0.059. The enzyme appeared to cleave preferentially regions of chromatin where copper is localized, releasing no additional metal upon further digestion. Moreover, the highest copper: DNA ratio was always associated with the least-digested sample.The distribution between copper and angiotensin II (AII) in chromatin fragments following slight nuclease digestion suggests a possible link between copper and nuclear AII binding. When nuclei are incubated with AII prior to digestion and dialysis, solubilized chromatin contained about three times more copper than buffer control. Metal profiles generated from gel (A-5 M) chromatography for these samples were distinctive: copper peaks appeared near or adjacent to linker DNA regions, and in the case of AII, coincided with fragments containing specific AII receptors; thus, there appears to be an enrichment of copper in these active nucleoprotein fragments.

Poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation of chromatin: kinetics of relaxation and its effect on chromatin solubility.

We have studied the kinetics of relaxation of poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated polynucleosomes produced by endogenous enzyme activity by comparing the generation of hyper(ADP-ribosyl)ated histone H1 and its effect on the chromatin structure as revealed by electron microscopy. A correlation can be established between the appearance of histone H1 modified forms and the localized relaxation of the chromatin. We have also noticed, in parallel, that poly(ADP-ribosyl)ated chromatin showed increased solubility in the presence of Mg2+ and 0.2 M NaCl. Electron microscopic examination of the solubilized chromatin produced by poly(ADP-ribosyl)ation shows polynucleosomes exhibiting more relaxed conformation, whereas an increasing amount of hyper(ADP-ribosyl)ated histone H1 is found in the pellet, as shown by acid-urea-polyacrylamide electrophoretic separation of histone extracts.

Fractionation of micrococcal nuclease-digested chromatin solubilized at physiologic ionic strength

When mouse brain nuclei are optimally digested with micrococcal nuclease, most of the chromatin is soluble in a 180 mM salt/1 mM EDTA buffer [1]. At this ionic concentration, chromatin maintains its native structure [2]. In attempt to selectively extract different fractions of chromatin from digested nuclei, we have examined the differential solubility of chromatin in the 180 mM salt buffer containing concentrations of MgCl 2 ranging from 2 to 0 mM. The results suggest that digested chromatin may be fractionated into specific soluble chromatin fractions which correspond to nuclease-sensitive chromatin, bulk chromatin, and heterochromatin. These soluble fractions have a high molecular weight (up to 20 kbp), and contain a full complement of histones as well as a complex assortment of non-histone proteins. The residual insoluble fraction may be equivalent to a native, nuclear matrix-bound chromatin fraction.

Nuclear-hormone mediated changes in chromatin solubility

Rat liver nuclei were incubated with either thyroid hormone or angiotensin (AII) at varying concentrations or with buffer (control) prior to digestion with micrococcal nuclease. Concentrations of hormones greater than 10 −10M were effective in increasing the solubilization of chromatin with physiological levels (10 −9M) of AII showing an approximate 2.4 fold increase over control. Nuclei were also isolated from animals treated in- vivo with either AII or buffer (control) and chromatin solubility was increased in the AII treated nuclei even prior to the addition of exogenous nuclease, presumably from the action of endogenous nucleases. The data suggest that hormone-induced increases in solubility are a reflection of structural changes in chromatin which enhance the accessibility of DNA to endonuclease attack.

Histone acetylation increases the solubility of chromatin and occurs sequentially over most of the chromatin. A novel model for the biological role of histone acetylation.

The effect of histone acetylation on chromatin solubility has been studied. Nucleosome cores are fairly soluble over a range of Mg2+ and Na+ concentrations. Increasing the amount of Na+ relative to a fixed concentration of Mg2+ leads to increased solubility. Although the effect is not large, acetylated cores are more soluble than control cores, all other factors being equal. Acetylated oligonucleosomes are vastly more soluble than control oligonucleosomes with the greatest differential seen in the presence of Mg2+ at low ionic strengths. Solubility of acetylated oligonucleosomes is favored when the majority of the histones in the nucleosomes are all highly acetylated. Contiguous highly acetylated nucleosomes are enriched in the rapid kinetic form of histone acetylation after short term exposure to butyrate. These observations have been exploited in a fractionation scheme for chromatin based on the levels of hyperacetylation attained after varied times of exposure to sodium butyrate. Essentially all DNA sequences in an unsynchronized cell population are associated with rapidly acetylated histones. Since it is highly unlikely that each cell has its own discrete set of sequences bound to acetylated histone and since the amount of rapidly acetylated histone in a single cell is relatively small (approximately 10% of total histone), we surmise that rapid acetylation migrates throughout much of the chromatin, perhaps in a sequential and highly organized manner. We postulate that the biological role of histone acetylation is to provide a means for sequentially exposing the entire chromatin for surveillance for DNA damage and possibly for recognition of different regions of the DNA by specific (regulatory?) proteins.

The effect of histone hyperacetylation on the nuclease sensitivity and the solubility of chromatin.

We have examined the effects of histone hyperacetylation upon nuclease digestion of nuclei and subsequent fractionation of chromosomal material in the presence of MgCl2. DNase I shows a maximum sensitivity towards hyperacetylated nuclei at somewhat elevated ionic strengths (150-200 mM NaCl), whereas micrococcal nuclease exhibits no specificity for acetylated nuclei over a broad range of ionic strengths. Fractionation in the presence of MgCl2 of hyperacetylated nuclei digested with micrococcal nuclease results in a substantial increase in the amount of soluble chromatin relative to that obtained with control nuclei. This increased yield of Mg2+-soluble chromatin results from the recruitment into this fraction of oligonucleosomes containing extremely hyperacetylated histones. These results suggest that contiguous nucleosomes containing highly acetylated histones may be altered in their ability to interact with themselves and with other nucleosomes.