Chiral Gross-Neveu Model Research Articles

Anomalies and persistent order in the chiral Gross-Neveu model

We study the 2d chiral Gross-Neveu model at finite temperature T and chemical potential μ. The analysis is performed by relating the theory to a SU(N) × U(1) Wess-Zumino-Witten model with appropriate levels and global identifications necessary to keep track of the fermion spin structures. At μ = 0 we show that a certain ℤ2-valued ’t Hooft anomaly forbids the system to be trivially gapped when fermions are periodic along the thermal circle for any N and any T > 0. We also study the two-point function of a certain composite fermion operator which allows us to determine the remnants for T > 0 of the inhomogeneous chiral phase configuration found at T = 0 for any N and any μ. The inhomogeneous configuration decays exponentially at large distances for anti-periodic fermions while it persists for T > 0 and any μ for periodic fermions, as expected from anomaly considerations. A large N analysis confirms the above findings.

Gross-Neveu model with O(2)L×O(2)R chiral symmetry: Duality with Zakharov-Mikhailov model and large N solution

The two-flavor Gross-Neveu model with ${\mathrm{U}(2)}_{L}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathrm{U}(2{)}_{R}$ chiral symmetry in $1+1$ dimensions is used to construct a novel variant of four-fermion theories with ${\mathrm{O}(2)}_{L}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathrm{O}(2{)}_{R}$ chiral symmetry. The spontaneous breaking of the group O(2), a continuous group with two connected components (rotations and reflections), gives rise to new phenomena. It is ideally suited to describe a situation where two distinct kinds of condensation compete, in particular chiral symmetry breaking (particle-hole condensation) and Cooper pairing (particle-particle condensation). After solving the O(2) chiral Gross-Neveu model in detail, we demonstrate that it is dual to another classically integrable model due to Zakharov and Mikhailov. The duality enables us to solve the quantum version of this model in the large $N$ limit with semiclassical methods, supporting its integrability at the quantum level. The resulting model is the unique four-fermion theory sharing the full Pauli-G\"ursey symmetry with free, massless fermions (``perfect Gross-Neveu model'') and provides us with a solvable model for competing chiral and Cooper pair condensates, including explicit soliton dynamics and the phase diagram.

Tricritical curve of massive chiral Gross-Neveu model with isospin

We reconsider the two-flavor version of the massive, chiral Gross-Neveu model in 1+1 dimensions. Its phase diagram as a function of baryon chemical potential, isospin chemical potential and temperature has previously been explored. We recapitulate the results, adding the missing tricritical curves. They can be determined exactly by extending the standard stability analysis, using fourth order almost degenerate perturbation theory. Results for three different bare masses are presented and discussed.

Inhomogeneous Phase of the Chiral Gross-Neveu Model.

There is substantial evidence that the ground state of the 2D chiral Gross-Neveu model, in the presence of a U(1) fermion number chemical potential μ and in the large N limit, is given by a "chiral spiral" phase, namely an inhomogeneous phase with a chiral condensate having a spatially periodic phase. We show that the chiral spiral configuration persists at finite N and T=0 for any μ>0. Our analysis is based on nonabelian bosonization, that relates the model to a U(N)_{1} Wess-Zumino-Witten model deformed by current-current interactions. In this description, the appearance of the inhomogeneous phase is surprisingly simple. We also rederive the phase diagram of the large N chiral Gross-Neveu model via a direct diagrammatic computation, finding agreement with previous results in the literature.

Exact tricritical point from next-to-leading-order stability analysis

In the massive chiral Gross-Neveu model, a phase boundary separates a homogeneous from an inhomogeneous phase. It consists of two parts, a second order line and a first order line, joined at a tricritical point. Whereas the first order phase boundary requires a full, numerical Hartree-Fock calculation, the second order phase boundary can be determined exactly and with less effort by a perturbative stability analysis. We extend this stability analysis to higher order perturbation theory. This enables us to locate the tricritical point exactly, without need to perform a Hartree-Fock calculation. Divergencies due to the emergence of spectral gaps in a spatially periodic perturbation are handled using well established tools from many body theory.

The chiral Gross-Neveu model on the lattice via a Landau-forbidden phase transition

We study the phase diagram of the (1 + 1)-dimensional Gross-Neveu model with both {g}_x^2{left(overline{psi}psi right)}^2 and {g}_y^2{left(overline{psi}i{gamma}_5psi right)}^2 interaction terms on a spatial lattice. The continuous chiral symmetry, which is present in the continuum model when {g}_x^2={g}_y^2 , has a mixed ’t Hooft anomaly with the charge conservation symmetry, which guarantees the existence of a massless mode. However, the same ’t Hooft anomaly also implies that the continuous chiral symmetry is broken explicitly in our lattice model. Nevertheless, from numerical matrix product state simulations we find that for certain parameters of the lattice model, the continuous chiral symmetry reemerges in the infrared fixed point theory, even at strong coupling. We argue that, in order to understand this phenomenon, it is crucial to go beyond mean-field theory (or, equivalently, beyond the leading order term in a 1/N expansion). Interestingly, on the lattice, the chiral Gross-Neveu model appears at a Landau-forbidden second order phase transition separating two distinct and unrelated symmetry-breaking orders. We point out the crucial role of two different ’t Hooft anomalies or Lieb-Schultz-Mattis obstructions for this Landau-forbidden phase transition to occur.

Inhomogeneities in the two-flavor chiral Gross-Neveu model

We investigate the finite-temperature and -density chiral Gross-Neveu model with an axial U$_A$(1) symmetry in $1+1$ dimensions on the lattice. In the limit where the number of flavors $N_\mathrm{f}$ tends to infinity the continuum model has been solved analytically and shows two phases: a symmetric high-temperature phase with a vanishing condensate and a low-temperature phase in which the complex condensate forms a chiral spiral which breaks translation invariance. In the lattice simulations we employ chiral SLAC fermions with exact axial symmetry. Similarly to $N_\mathrm{f}\to\infty$, we find for $8$ flavors, where quantum and thermal fluctuations are suppressed, two distinct regimes in the $(T,\mu)$ phase diagram, characterized by qualitatively different behavior of the two-point functions of the condensate fields. More surprisingly, at $N_\mathrm{f}=2$, where fluctuations are no longer suppressed, the model still behaves similarly to the $N_\mathrm{f}\to\infty$ model and we conclude that the chiral spiral leaves its footprints even on systems with a small number of flavors. For example, at low temperature the two-point functions are still dominated by chiral spirals with pitches proportional to the inverse chemical potential, although in contrast to large-$N_\mathrm{f}$ their amplitudes decrease with distance. We argue that these results should not be interpreted as the spontaneous breaking of a continuous symmetry, which is forbidden in two dimensions. Finally, using Dyson-Schwinger equations we calculate the decay of the U$_A$(1)-invariant fermion four-point function in search for a BKT phase at zero temperature.

Kondo effect with Wilson fermions

We investigate the Kondo effect with Wilson fermions. This is based on a mean-field approach for the chiral Gross-Neveu model including four-point interactions between a light Wilson fermion and a heavy fermion. For massless Wilson fermions, we demonstrate the appearance of the Kondo effect. We point out that there is a coexistence phase with both the light-fermion scalar condensate and Kondo condensate, and the critical chemical potentials of the scalar condensate are shifted by the Kondo effect. For negative-mass Wilson fermions, we find that the Kondo effect is favored near the parameter region realizing the Aoki phase. Our findings will be useful for understanding the roles of heavy impurities in Dirac semimetals, topological insulators, and lattice simulations.

Solitons in lattice field theories via tight-binding supersymmetry

Reflectionless potentials play an important role in constructing exact solutions to classical dynamical systems (such as the Korteweg-de Vries equation), non-perturbative solutions of various large-N field theories (such as the Gross-Neveu model), and closely related solitonic solutions to the Bogoliubov-de Gennes equations in the theory of superconductivity. These solutions rely on the inverse scattering method, which reduces these seemingly unrelated problems to identifying reflectionless potentials of an auxiliary one-dimensional quantum scattering problem. There are several ways of constructing these potentials, one of which is quantum mechanical supersymmetry (SUSY). In this paper, motivated by recent experimental platforms, we generalize this framework to develop a theory of lattice solitons. We first briefly review the classical inverse scattering method in the continuum limit, focusing on the Korteweg-de Vries (KdV) equation and SU(N) Gross-Neveu model in the large N limit. We then generalize this methodology to lattice versions of interacting field theories. Our analysis hinges on the use of trace identities, which are relations connecting the potential of an equation of motion to the scattering data. For a discrete Schrödinger operator, such trace identities had been known as far back as Toda; however, we derive a new set of identities for the discrete Dirac operator. We then use these identities in a lattice Gross-Neveu and chiral Gross-Neveu (Nambu-Jona-Lasinio) model to show that lattice solitons correspond to reflectionless potentials associated with the discrete scattering problem. These models are of significance as they are equivalent to a mean-field theory of a lattice superconductor. To explicitly construct these solitons, we generalize supersymmetric quantum mechanics to tight-binding models. We show that a matrix transformation exists that maps a tight-binding model to an isospectral one which shares the same structure and scattering properties. The corresponding soliton solutions have both modulated hopping and onsite potential, the former of which has no analogue in the continuum limit. We explicitly compute both topological and non-topological soliton solutions as well as bound state spectra in the aforementioned models.

Asymptotic factorization of n-particle SU(N) form factors

We investigate the high energy behavior of the SU(N) chiral Gross-Neveu model in 1 + 1 dimensions. The model is integrable and matrix elements of several local operators (form factors) are known exactly. The form factors show rapidity space clustering, which means factorization, if a group of rapidities is shifted to infinity. We analyze this phenomenon for the SU(N) model. For several operators the factorization formulas are presented explicitly.

Critical exponent η at O(1/N3) in the chiral XY model using the large N conformal bootstrap

We compute the $O(1/N^3)$ correction to the critical exponent $\eta$ in the chiral XY or chiral Gross-Neveu model in $d$-dimensions. As the leading order vertex anomalous dimension vanishes, the direct application of the large $N$ conformal bootstrap formalism is not immediately possible. To circumvent this we consider the more general Nambu-Jona-Lasinio model for a general non-abelian Lie group. Taking the abelian limit of the exponents of this model produces those of the chiral XY model. Subsequently we provide improved estimates for $\eta$ in the three dimensional chiral XY model for various values of $N$.

Chiral spiral in the presence of chiral imbalance

The phase diagram of the two-dimensional Nambu-Jona-Lasinio (or chiral Gross-Neveu) model is characterized by an order parameter in the form of a chiral spiral. Its radius vanishes at a critical temperature, its period depends only on the chemical potential. We generalize these findings to chirally imbalanced systems by including a chiral chemical potential $\mu_5$. The relationship between the present, static approach and a previous, time dependent one is traced back to a half-local symmetry which the NJL$_2$ model shares with massless Dirac fermions, but which has been neglected so far. The structure of chiral spiral matter is further elucidated by computing fermion and antifermion momentum distribution functions, using a Bogoliubov transformation.

Tensorial Gross-Neveu models

We define and study various tensorial generalizations of the Gross-Neveu model in two dimensions, that is, models with four-fermion interactions and G3 symmetry, where we take either G = U(N) or G = O(N). Such models can also be viewed as two-dimensional generalizations of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, or more precisely of its tensorial counterpart introduced by Klebanov and Tarnopolsky, which is in part our motivation for studying them. Using the Schwinger-Dyson equations at large-N, we discuss the phenomenon of dynamical mass generation and possible combinations of couplings to avoid it. For the case G = U(N),we introduce an intermediate field representation and perform a stability analysis of the vacua. It turns out that the only apparently viable combination of couplings that avoids mass generation corresponds to an unstable vacuum. The stable vacuum breaks U(N)3 invariance, in contradiction with the Coleman-Mermin-Wagner theorem, but this is an artifact of the large-N expansion, similar to the breaking of continuous chiral symmetry in the chiral Gross-Neveu model.

Non-Abelian twisted kinks in chiral Gross-Neveu model with isospin

The two-dimensional, massless Gross-Neveu model with ${N}_{c}$ colors and SU(2) isospin is studied analytically in the large ${N}_{c}$ limit. The chiral $\mathrm{SU}(2{)}_{L}\ifmmode\times\else\texttimes\fi{}\mathrm{SU}(2{)}_{R}$ symmetry is broken spontaneously in the vacuum. Twisted kinks connecting two arbitrary points on the vacuum manifold ${S}^{3}$ are constructed, and their properties are explored. The phase diagram as a function of temperature and baryon and isospin chemical potential is discussed, with special emphasis on inhomogeneous phases. The preferred form of the condensate is a product of the real kink crystal and the chiral spiral. Kink-kink scattering is solved, using the general solution of the multicomponent Bogoliubov--de Gennes equation recently presented by Takahashi.

Free field representation and form factors of the chiral Gross-Neveu model

The free field representation of the Zamolodchikov-Faddeev algebra for the chiral Gross-Neveu model is analysed in detail, and used to construct an integral representation for form factors of the model.

Competing mechanisms of chiral symmetry breaking in a generalized Gross-Neveu model

Chiral symmetry of the 2-dimensional chiral Gross-Neveu model is broken explicitly by a bare mass term as well as a splitting of scalar and pseudo-scalar coupling constants. The vacuum and light hadrons - mesons and baryons which become massless in the chiral limit - are explored analytically in leading order of the derivative expansion by means of a double sine-Gordon equation. Depending on the parameters, this model features new phenomena as compared to previously investigated 4-fermion models: spontaneous breaking of parity, a non-trivial chiral vacuum angle, twisted kink-like baryons whose baryon number reflects the vacuum angle, crystals with alternating baryons, and appearance of a false vacuum.

Finite volume spectrum of 2D field theories from Hirota dynamics

We propose, using the example of the O(4) sigma model, a general method for solving integrable two dimensional relativistic sigma models in a finite size periodic box. Our starting point is the so-called Y-system, which is equivalent to the thermodynamic Bethe ansatz equations of Yang and Yang. It is derived from the Zamolodchikov scattering theory in the cross channel, for virtual particles along the non-compact direction of the space-time cylinder. The method is based on the integrable Hirota dynamics that follows from the Y-system. The outcome is a nonlinear integral equation for a single complex function, valid for an arbitrary quantum state and accompanied by the finite size analogue of Bethe equations. It is close in spirit to the Destri-deVega (DdV) equation. We present the numerical data for the energy of various states as a function of the size, and derive the general Luscher-type formulas for the finite size corrections. We also re-derive by our method the DdV equation for the SU(2) chiral Gross-Neveu model.

Inhomogeneous condensates in the thermodynamics of the chiralNJL2model

We analyze the thermodynamical properties, at finite density and nonzero temperature, of the ($1+1$) dimensional chiral Gross-Neveu model (the ${\mathrm{NJL}}_{2}$ model), using the exact inhomogeneous (crystalline) condensate solutions to the gap equation. The continuous chiral symmetry of the model plays a crucial role, and the thermodynamics leads to a broken phase with a periodic spiral condensate, the ``chiral spiral,'' as a thermodynamically preferred limit of the more general ``twisted kink crystal'' solution of the gap equation. This situation should be contrasted with the Gross-Neveu model, which has a discrete chiral symmetry, and for which the phase diagram has a crystalline phase with a periodic kink crystal. We use a combination of analytic, numerical, and Ginzburg-Landau techniques to study various parts of the phase diagram.

Phase structure of the massive chiral Gross-Neveu model from the Hartree-Fock approach

The phase diagram of the massive chiral Gross-Neveu model (the massive Nambu--Jona-Lasinio model in $1+1$ dimensions) is constructed. In the large $N$ limit, the Hartree-Fock approach can be used. We find numerically a chiral crystal phase separated from a massive Fermi gas phase by a 1st order transition. Using perturbation theory, we also construct the critical sheet where the homogeneous phase becomes unstable in a 2nd order transition. A tricritical curve is located. The phase diagram is mapped out as a function of fermion mass, chemical potential and temperature, and compared with the one of the discrete chiral Gross-Neveu model. As a by-product, we illustrate the crystal structure of matter at zero temperature for various densities and fermion masses.

Twisted kink crystal in the chiral Gross-Neveu model

We present the detailed properties of a self-consistent crystalline chiral condensate in the massless chiral Gross-Neveu model. We show that a suitable ansatz for the Gorkov resolvent reduces the functional gap equation, for the inhomogeneous condensate, to a nonlinear Schroedinger equation, which is exactly soluble. The general crystalline solution includes as special cases all previously known real and complex condensate solutions to the gap equation. Furthermore, the associated Bogoliubov-de Gennes equation is also soluble with this inhomogeneous chiral condensate, and the exact spectral properties are derived. We find an all-orders expansion of the Ginzburg-Landau effective Lagrangian and show how the gap equation is solved order by order.