Thinning and prescribed fire are often used to promote oak recruitment into the canopy; however, little is known about the longevity of resprouting oak seedlings and how age affects growth response to these treatments. We investigated this by excavating 180 chinkapin oak seedlings (Quercus muehlenbergii) from an eastern Kansas upland hardwood forest study area divided into different combinations of burning and thinning treatments: control, burn only, burn and thin to 7 m2/ha, burn and thin to 14 m2/ha, thin to 7 m2/ha, and thin to 14 m2/ha. In each treatment, approximately three years post-treatment, we aged the seedlings at the root collar (“root age”) and the base of the current aboveground shoot using tissue staining and microscopy techniques. Annual shoot growth rate was calculated for each individual based on the age of the shoot and its total height. We compared these shoot growth rates in height across treatments and investigated this relationship as a function of plant age using the root age. The oldest root age was 48 yr, and 20% of the roots were ≥ 18 yr. Mean root age of advance reproduction was 11.8 years, while mean age of associated aboveground stems was 4.1 yr, with the oldest age structure belonging to treatments without any burn with the control being the oldest. The majority (90%) of the mismatch between root and shoot age was associated with burn treatments. Root age had a strong positive correlation with shoot growth rate in the burn + thinning treatments and also the untreated control, suggesting that age becomes an influence on growth when resprouting under adequate light conditions but also when individuals experience low competition. Further determination of root age structures, such as along gradients of site productivity, would likely aid in further understanding regeneration dynamics and management for sustaining oaks.
Read full abstract