Singlet Charge-transfer States Research Articles

Electron Spin Polarization in the Triplet State of Methoxy-substituted Phosphorus(V) Tetraphenyl Porphyrins

Photoexcited triplet states of porphyrins are of great relevance in various applications due to their high yield, long lifetime, and strong electron spin polarization. This study delves into properties and spin dynamics of the triplet state of a series of hypervalent phosphorus(V) porphyrins. Transient Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (TrEPR) measurements, supported by quantum chemical calculations as well as by optical absorption/luminescence experiments, reveal that, unlike singlet states, the lowest triplet state does not exhibit charge-transfer (CT) character upon photoexcitation. However, the presence of excited CT singlet states alters the intersystem crossing in phosphorus(V) porphyrins, leading to a sign change in the initial multiplet polarization of the photoexcited triplet state. TrEPR results further demonstrate that significant net polarization develops in the triplet states of the phosphorus(V) porphyrins due to the dynamic Jahn-Teller effect. Yet, this effect remains largely unaffected by differences in their molecular structures.

Tracking the Early Stage of Triplet-Induced Photodamage in a DNA Dimer and Oligomer Containing 5-Methylcytosine.

Methylation at the C5 position of cytosine, a naturally occurring epigenetic modification on DNA, shows a high correlation with mutational hotspots in disease such as skin cancer. Due to its essential biological relevance, numerous studies were devoted to confirming that the methylated sites favor the formation of the cyclobutane pyrimidine dimer (CPD), a well-known UV-induced lesion. However, photophysical and photochemical properties of dinucleotides and polynucleotides containing 5-methylcytosine (5mC) remain elusive. Herein, a charge transfer (CT) triplet state, generated via intersystem crossing (ISC) from a CT singlet state that enhanced after methylation on cytosine, is directly observed by using femtosecond transient absorption (TA) and time-resolved mid-infrared (TRIR) spectroscopy together with quantum chemical calculations for the first time in the T5mC dimer. Such an ISC process is quenched due to limitations of the ground-state geometries in 5mC-containing single-strand oligomer d(T5mC)9. This mechanistic information is important for understanding the early stage of triplet state-induced CPD formation in 5mC containing DNA.

Balanced Energy Gaps as a Key Design Rule for Solution-Phase Organic Room Temperature Phosphorescence.

Metal-free organic emitters that display solution-phase room temperature phosphorescence (sRTP) remain exceedingly rare. Here, we investigate the structural and photophysical properties that support sRTP by comparing a recently reported sRTP compound (BTaz-Th-PXZ) to two novel analogous materials, replacing the donor group by either acridine or phenothiazine. The emissive triplet excited state remains fixed in all three cases, while the emissive charge-transfer singlet states (and the calculated paired charge-transfer T2 state) vary with the donor unit. While all three materials show dominant RTP in film, in solution different singlet-triplet and triplet-triplet energy gaps give rise to triplet-triplet annihilation followed by weak sRTP for the new compounds, compared to dominant sRTP throughout for the original PXZ material. Engineering both the sRTP state and higher charge-transfer states therefore emerges as a crucial element in designing emitters capable of sRTP.

Donor, Acceptor, and Molecular Charge Transfer Emission All in One Molecule.

The molecular photophysics in the thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) spiro-acridine-anthracenone compound, ACRSA, is dominated by the rigid orthogonal spirocarbon bridging bond between the donor and acceptor. This critically decouples the donor and acceptor units, yielding photophysics, which includes (dual) phosphorescence and the molecular charge transfer (CT) states giving rise to TADF, that are dependent upon the excitation wavelength. The molecular singlet CT state can be directly excited, and we propose that supposed "spiro-conjugation" between acridine and anthracenone is more accurately an example of intramolecular through-space charge transfer. In addition, we show that the lowest local and CT triplet states are highly dependent upon spontaneous polarization of the environment, leading to energy reorganization of the triplet states, with the CT triplet becoming lowest in energy, profoundly affecting phosphorescence and TADF, as evident by a (thermally controlled) competition between reverse intersystem crossing and reverse internal conversion, i.e., dual delayed fluorescence (DF) mechanisms.

Detection of the Dark States in Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence (TADF) Process of Electron Donor-Acceptor Dyads: Insights from Optical Transient Absorption Spectroscopy.

The photophysical processes involved in the electron donor-acceptor thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) emitters are complicated and controversial. The recent consensus is that at least three states are involved, i. e. the singlet charge transfer state (1 CT), the triplet localized excited state (3 LE) and the triplet CT state (3 CT). It is clear the very often used steady state and time-resolved luminescence spectroscopic methods are unable to present direct evidence for the dark states, i. e. the 3 LE and 3 CT states, as well as the interconversion of these states. Concerning this aspect, the femtosecond-nanosecond transient absorption spectroscopic methods are in particular interests. Both the emissive state and the dark state can be detected in these spectra, and interconversion of the states involved in TADF process can be also revealed. This review article focuses on the recent development of using the transient absorption spectra to study the photophysics of the TADF emitters.

Spin-orbit charge-transfer intersystem crossing in heavy-atom-free orthogonal covalent boron-dipyrromethene heterodimers.

Boron-dipyrromethene (BODIPY) derivatives are prospective organic-based triplet photosensitizers. Since the triplet generation yield of the parent BODIPY is low, heavy atoms are widely used to improve the triplet yield. However, the dimerization of BODIPYs can also significantly improve their ability to produce triplets. Through a comparative study of the triplet formation dynamics of two heavy-atom-free orthogonal covalent BODIPY heterodimers that differ in their dihedral angles, we have demonstrated that the mechanism of spin-orbit charge-transfer intersystem crossing (SOCT-ISC) promotes the triplet generation of BODIPY heterodimers in solution. Different from the general understanding of SOCT-ISC, the heterodimer with a smaller dihedral angle and low structural rigidity showed better triplet generation due to (a) the stronger inter-chromophoric interaction in the heterodimer, which promoted the formation of a solvent-stabilized charge-transfer (CT) state, (b) the more favorable energy level alignment with sizeable spin-orbit coupling strength, and (c) the balance between the stabilized singlet CT state and limited direct charge recombination to the ground state in a weakly polar solvent. The complete spectral characterization of the triplet formation dynamics clarified the SOCT-ISC mechanism and important factors affecting the triplet generation in BODIPY heterodimers.

Fine‐Tuning the Photophysics of Donor‐Acceptor (D‐A3) Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Emitters Using Isomerisation

AbstractHere two D–A3 regioisomers, comprising three dibenzothiophene‐S,S‐dioxide acceptor units attached to a central triazatruxene core, are studied. Both molecules show thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF), however, the efficiency of the TADF mechanism is strongly affected by the D–A substitution position. The meta‐ substituted emitter (1 b) shows a slightly higher‐lying singlet charge transfer state and a lower‐lying triplet state than that observed in the para‐ substituted emitter (1 a), resulting in a larger singlet–triplet splitting (ΔEST) of 0.28 eV compared to only 0.01 eV found in 1 a. As expected, this ΔEST difference strongly impacts the reverse intersystem crossing (rISC) rates and the para‐ isomer 1 a exhibits a much faster delayed fluorescence emission. Calculations show that the triplet energy difference between the two isomers is due to steric hindrance variances along the donor–acceptor rotation axis in these molecules: as 1 b is less restricted, rotation of its acceptor unit leads to a lower T1 energy, further away from the region of high density of states (the region where larger vibronic coupling is found, favouring rISC). Therefore, our results show how the substitution pattern has a marked effect on triplet state energies and character, verifying the key structural designs for highly efficient TADF materials.

Efficient Charge Dissociation of Triplet Excitons in Bulk Heterojunction Solar Cells

Understanding the sources of energy loss in bulk heterojunction (BHJ) solar cells is of outstanding importance for increasing power conversion energy. Herein, we employ a full quantum mechanics approach to determine the rates of charge transfer processes at the acceptor–donor interface for a prototypical BHJ blend. It is shown that charge recombination of a singlet charge transfer (CT) state at the acceptor/donor (A/D) interface is very fast, being the most effective process which prevents efficient charge migration toward the electrodes. Triplet CT states can also undergo charge recombination by fast decay to a low lying triplet state of the donor and/or of the acceptor, but the backward process is also fast enough to allow efficient charge dissociation. Slowing down the fast decay process of singlet CT states appears to be hardly practicable, since it would reflect either on a reduced spectral absorption window or on a slow rate of photoinduced electron transfer, so that an alternative and possibly more viable route for increasing organic solar cell efficiency could be that of favoring the formation of triplet CT states over singlet ones.

Modeling of Multiresonant Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Emitters─Properly Accounting for Electron Correlation Is Key!

With the surge of interest in multiresonant thermally activated delayed fluorescent (MR-TADF) materials, it is important that there exist computational methods to accurately model their excited states. Here, building on our previous work, we demonstrate how the spin-component scaling second-order approximate coupled-cluster (SCS-CC2), a wavefunction-based method, is robust at predicting the ΔEST (i.e., the energy difference between the lowest singlet S1 and triplet T1 excited states) of a large number of MR-TADF materials, with a mean average deviation (MAD) of 0.04 eV compared to experimental data. Time-dependent density functional theory calculations with the most common DFT functionals as well as the consideration of the Tamm-Dancoff approximation (TDA) consistently predict a much larger ΔEST as a result of a poorer account of Coulomb correlation as compared to SCS-CC2. Very interestingly, the use of a metric to assess the importance of higher order excitations in the SCS-CC2 wavefunctions shows that Coulomb correlation effects are substantially larger in the lowest singlet compared to the corresponding triplet and need to be accounted for a balanced description of the relevant electronic excited states. This is further highlighted with coupled cluster singles-only calculations, which predict very different S1 energies as compared to SCS-CC2 while T1 energies remain similar, leading to very large ΔEST, in complete disagreement with the experiments. We compared our SCS-CC2/cc-pVDZ with other wavefunction approaches, namely, CC2/cc-pVDZ and SOS-CC2/cc-pVDZ leading to similar performances. Using SCS-CC2, we investigate the excited-state properties of MR-TADF emitters showcasing large ΔET2T1 for the majority of emitters, while π-electron extension emerges as the best strategy to minimize ΔEST. We also employed SCS-CC2 to evaluate donor-acceptor systems that contain a MR-TADF moiety acting as the acceptor and show that the broad emission observed for some of these compounds arises from the solvent-promoted stabilization of a higher-lying charge-transfer singlet state (S2). This work highlights the importance of using wavefunction methods in relation to MR-TADF emitter design and associated photophysics.

Singlet–triplet splitting energy management for thermally activated delayed fluorescence emitters: up-conversion of acceptor triplet into charge transfer singlet state

Energetic proximity between charge transfer singlet (1CT) and a local exciton triplet (3LE) is critical to facilitate reverse intersystem crossing rate and thus ultimately TADF.

“On-off” switch between red thermally activated delayed fluorescence and conventional fluorescence by isomeric regulation

Marching toward highly efficient long-wavelength organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) is paramount but formidable challenge, and rational manipulation of molecular configuration and excited state dynamic processes are of great importance to harvest dark triplet exciton and suppress non-radiative transition for excellent light emission properties. Herein, we introduced a novel electron acceptor 11H-indeno [1,2-b] quinoxalin-11-one (IQ) as a building-block to construct two bright red light-emitting regioisomers of IQ-oTPA and IQ-pTPA, which exhibit entirely different exciton dynamic processes of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) and conventional fluorescence (CF) respectively. According to theoretical calculation and photophysical characterization, the energy gap, energy level alignment and spin–orbit coupling (SOC) effects of charge-transfer singlet state (1CT), local excited triplet state (3LE) and charge-transfer triplet state (3CT) together with the molecular geometry rigidity play a critical role in the triplet exciton up-conversion processes. Maximum external quantum efficiencies of 20.6% and 3.5% with emission peaks of 604 and 642 nm were achieved for the proof-of-concept electroluminescent devices based on IQ-oTPA and IQ-pTPA respectively, which are among the state-of-the-art performance for red-emission TADF and CF OLEDs and provide new insights for the molecular design tactic of high-performance red OLEDs.

Efficient blue thermally activated delayed fluorescence emitters showing very fast reverse intersystem crossing

We report a highly efficient blue thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) emitter, namely, MCz-TXO. MCz-TXO exhibits close energy level matching of the three states: charge transfer (CT) and locally excited triplet states, and a CT singlet state. Owing to the good energy level matching and heavy atom effect of sulfur in the molecular structure, MCz-TXO shows very large experimental rate constant of reverse intersystem crossing (k RISC) of ∼2 × 108 s−1. This is one of the largest k RISC values among all reported pure organic TADF emitters. The MCz-TXO based organic light-emitting diodes exhibit blue emission with maximum external quantum efficiency of 17.4%.

On the intersystem crossing rate in a Platinum(II) donor-bridge-acceptor triad.

The rates of ultrafast intersystem crossing in acceptor-bridge-donor molecules centered on Pt(II) acetylides are investigated. Specifically, a Pt(II) trans-acetylide triad NAP--Pt--Ph-CH2-PTZ [1], with acceptor 4-ethynyl-N-octyl-1,8-naphthalimide (NAP) and donor phenothiazine (PTZ), is examined in detail. We have previously shown that optical excitation in [1] leads to a manifold of singlet charge-transfer states, S*, which evolve via a triplet charge-transfer manifold into a triplet state 3NAP centered on the acceptor ligand and partly to a charge-separated state 3CSS (NAP--Pt-PTZ+). A complex cascade of electron transfer processes was observed, but intersystem crossing (ISC) rates were not explicitly resolved due to lack of spin selectivity of most ultrafast spectroscopies. Here we revisit the question of ISC with a combination and complementary analysis of (i) transient absorption, (ii) ultrafast broadband fluorescence upconversion, FLUP, which is only sensitive to emissive states, and (iii) femtosecond stimulated Raman spectroscopy, FSR. Raman resonance conditions allow us to observe S* and 3NAP exclusively by FSR, through vibrations which are pertinent only to these two states. This combination of methods enabled us to extract the intersystem crossing rates that were not previously accessible. Multiple timescales (1.6 ps to ∼20 ps) are associated with the rise of triplet species, which can now be assigned conclusively to multiple ISC pathways from a manifold of hot charge-transfer singlet states. The analysis is consistent with previous transient infrared spectroscopy data. A similar rate of ISC, up to 20 ps, is observed in the trans-acetylide NAP--Pt--Ph [2] which maintains two acetylide groups across the platinum center but lacks a donor unit, whilst removal of one acetylide group in mono-acetylide NAP--Pt-Cl [3] leads to >10-fold deceleration of the intersystem crossing process. Our work provides insight on the intersystem crossing dynamics of the organo-metallic complexes, and identifies a general method based on complementary ultrafast spectroscopies to disentangle complex spin, electronic and vibrational processes following photoexcitation.

The Leap from Organic Light-Emitting Diodes to Organic Semiconductor Laser Diodes

In recent years, organic light-emitting device technology has expanded from organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) to organic semiconductor laser diodes (OSLDs) with the progress of sophisticated mo...

Decoding Charge Recombination through Charge Generation in Organic Solar Cells

The in‐depth understanding of charge carrier photogeneration and recombination mechanisms in organic solar cells is still an ongoing effort. In donor:acceptor (bulk) heterojunction organic solar cells, charge photogeneration and recombination are inter‐related via the kinetics of charge transfer states—being singlet or triplet states. Although high‐charge‐photogeneration quantum yields are achieved in many donor:acceptor systems, only very few systems show significantly reduced bimolecular recombination relative to the rate of free carrier encounters, in low‐mobility systems. This is a serious limitation for the industrialization of organic solar cells, in particular when aiming at thick active layers. Herein, a meta‐analysis of the device performance of numerous bulk heterojunction organic solar cells is presented for which field‐dependent photogeneration, charge carrier mobility, and fill factor are determined. Herein, a “spin‐related factor” that is dependent on the ratio of back electron transfer of the triplet charge transfer (CT) states to the decay rate of the singlet CT states is introduced. It is shown that this factor links the recombination reduction factor to charge‐generation efficiency. As a consequence, it is only in the systems with very efficient charge generation and very fast CT dissociation that free carrier recombination is strongly suppressed, regardless of the spin‐related factor.

Realizing 22.5% External Quantum Efficiency for Solution-Processed Thermally Activated Delayed-Fluorescence OLEDs with Red Emission at 622 nm via a Synergistic Strategy of Molecular Engineering and Host Selection.

Developing high-efficiency solution-processable thermally activated delayed-fluorescence (TADF) emitters, especially in longer wavelength regions, is a formidable challenge. Three red TADF emitters, namely NAI_R1, NAI_R2, and NAI_R3, are developed by phenyl encapsulation and tert-butyl substitution on a prototypical 1,8-naphthalimide-acridine hybrid. This design strategy not only grants these molecules high solubility, excellent thermal stability, and good film-forming ability, but also pulls down their charge-transfer (CT) energy levels excited states. Furthermore, dispersing these emitters into two different host materials of mCP and mCPCN finely tailors their CT-state energy levels. More importantly, a synergistic combination of molecular engineering and host selection can effectively manipulate the competition between the radiative and nonradiative decay rates of the CT singlet states of these emitters and the reverse intersystem crossing from their triplet to singlet states. Consequently, the optimal combination of NAI_R3 emitter and mCP host successfully results in a state-of-the-art external quantum efficiency (EQE) of 22.5% for solution-processed red TADF organic light-emitting diodes (OLEDs) with an emission peak above 620 nm. This finding demonstrates that a synergistic strategy of molecular engineering and host selection with TADF emitters could provide a new pathway for developing efficient solution-processable TADF systems.

Donor-Acceptor Fluorophores for Energy-Transfer-Mediated Photocatalysis.

Triplet-triplet energy transfer (EnT) is a fundamental activation pathway in photocatalysis. In this work, we report the mechanistic origins of the triplet excited state of carbazole-cyanobenzene donor-acceptor (D-A) fluorophores in EnT-based photocatalytic reactions and demonstrate the key factors that control the accessibility of the 3LE (locally excited triplet state) and 3CT (charge-transfer triplet state) via a combined photochemical and transient absorption spectroscopic study. We found that the energy order between 1CT (charge transfer singlet state) and 3LE dictates the accessibility of 3LE/3CT for EnT, which can be effectively engineered by varying solvent polarity and D-A character to depopulate 3LE and facilitate EnT from the chemically more tunable 3CT state for photosensitization. Following the above design principle, a new D-A fluorophore with strong D-A character and weak redox potential is identified, which exhibits high efficiency for Ni(II)-catalyzed cross-coupling of carboxylic acids and aryl halides with a wide substrate scope and high selectivity. Our results not only provide key fundamental insight on the EnT mechanism of D-A fluorophores but also establish its wide utility in EnT-mediated photocatalytic reactions.

Theoretical insights into the excited-state properties of room-temperature phosphorescence-emitting N-substituted naphthalimides.

The optical absorption, fluorescence, and phosphorescence properties along with the intersystem crossing (ISC) rate constants of a series of N-substituted naphthalimides (NNIs), which can be used as organic emitters, were calculated using density functional theory (DFT) and time-dependent DFT (TDDFT). The calculated absorption, fluorescence, and phosphorescence energies as well as the fluorescence and ISC rate constants were found to be in good agreement with available experimental data. According to the calculations, the first excited singlet and first excited triplet states are π-π* in nature, and 1π-π*→3n-π* is the dominant ISC channel for 1,8-naphthalimide (NI) and N-methyl-1,8-naphthalimide (Me-NI). Intermolecular charge-transfer (CT) states are observed in the energy region between the 1π-π* and 3π-π* states for NNIs with an electron-donating group. The presence of these CT states leads to a reduction in the S1-state and T1-state energy splitting in NNIs with an electron-donating group compared to the energy splitting observed in NI and Me-NI. The singlet CT state (1CT) has very weak emission oscillator strength, so it is nonemissive. For NNIs with an electron-donating group, the 1CT→3π-π* transition was found to be the dominant ISC channel. Our results indicate that for NNIs with an electron-donating group, the nonemissive S1 state (1CT) transits to the T1 state (3π-π*) via ISC. The 1CT→3π-π* transition increases the population of the T1 state and thus the phosphorescence quantum yield at room temperature, even in the absence of a heavy atom. Graphical Abstract The S1 state (1CT), which is nonemissive, transits to the T1 state (3π-π*) via intersystem crossing and increases the population of the T1 state in N-substituted naphthalimides with an electron-donating group.

Achieving Efficient Triplet Exciton Utilization with Large Δ EST and Nonobvious Delayed Fluorescence by Adjusting Excited State Energy Levels.

Enhancing the rate of reverse intersystem crossing ( krisc) and the rate of radiative transition ( kr) has been regarded as the key to improve molecular design strategy in the field of thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) materials. Herein, two sky-blue donor-acceptor (D-A)-type TADF materials, namely, CzDCNPy and tBuCzDCNPy, were designed following a strategy of controlling the energy difference among the charge-transfer singlet state (1CT), local exciton triplet state (3LE), and charge-transfer triplet state (3CT). Significantly different from most previously reported TADF materials, large values of kr and krisc and a nearly 100% exciton utilization efficiency were simultaneously achieved despite nonobvious delayed fluorescence and a large value of the singlet-triplet energy difference (Δ EST) being observed. This work presents a view that photoinduced delayed fluorescence and a small Δ EST are sufficient but not necessary for TADF materials. It also provides a reference that the high-energy 3LE state plays a key role in the RISC process in electroluminescence.

Donor-σ-Acceptor Motifs: Thermally Activated Delayed Fluorescence Emitters with Dual Upconversion.

A family of organic emitters with a donor-σ-acceptor (D-σ-A) motif is presented. Owing to the weakly coupled D-σ-A intramolecular charge-transfer state, a transition from the localized excited triplet state (3 LE) and charge-transfer triplet state (3 CT) to the charge-transfer singlet state (1 CT) occurred with a small activation energy and high photoluminescence quantum efficiency. Two thermally activated delayed fluorescence (TADF) components were identified, one of which has a very short lifetime of 200-400 ns and the other a longer TADF lifetime of the order of microseconds. In particular, the two D-σ-A materials presented strong blue emission with TADF properties in toluene. These results will shed light on the molecular design of new TADF emitters with short delayed lifetimes.