The objective of this study was to evaluate changes in longissimus dorsi muscle depth (LDD) across lactation (0 to 300 DIM) and identify the impact of low versus high muscle reserves immediately after parturition on body weight and body reserve changes as well as production variables across a 300-d lactation. Forty multiparous cows were classified as high muscle (HM; LDD > 5.0 cm; n = 18) or low muscle (LM; LDD ≤ 5.0 cm; n = 22) based on LDD measurements collected within 24 h of parturition. Body weights (BW) and ultrasound scans to assess LDD and back fat depth (BFD) were collected monthly from parturition until 300 DIM. Ultrasound scans captured and measured using available software. Blood samples were taken at 7, 150 and 300 DIM, and plasma was analyzed for markers of metabolic status by measuring insulin, nonesterified fatty acids (NEFA), creatinine, and 3-methylhistidine (3-MH). Milk yield was recorded daily and milk components were analyzed monthly. Data analysis was performed and the statistical models included the fixed effect of muscle group, time, their interaction, and the random effect of cow nested within muscle group with repeated measures using a first-order autoregressive covariance structure. Muscle group was not related with BW or BFD for any of the time points measured. Cows lost BW from 0 to 60 DIM and gained weight from 60 to 300 DIM. Similarly, BFD decreased between 0 to 90 DIM and increased BFD after 90 DIM until 300 DIM. A muscle group by time interaction was observed for LDD. The HM cows had more muscle at 0 DIM, indicative of treatment assignment (1.34 cm more), and 300 DIM (0.78 cm more) and tended to have more muscle at 60 DIM (0.66 cm more) compared with LM. After 240 DIM, both muscle groups began net accretion of muscle reserves until 300 DIM. No differences were observed for blood metabolites measured based on muscle group. However, there were significant time effects for creatinine, 3-MH, and NEFA concentrations, which reflected the observed changes in BFD and LDD measured in ultrasound scans. For statistical analysis of daily milk production, observations were grouped into 3 stages of lactation, early (0-60 DIM), mid (60-240 DIM), and late lactation (240-300 DIM). There was a muscle group by stage of lactation interaction, where in early and mid-lactation, HM cows produced, on average, 1.9 kg more milk/d; however, in late lactation, LM cows produced 1.8 kg more milk/d. Our results indicate that muscle reserves are depleted in early lactation, and accreted in late lactation, whereas BW and BFD started to increase by 90 DIM. Data also supports that cows with more extensive muscle depletion in early lactation had greater milk production, however, substantial muscle accretion in late lactation may result in reduced milk production.