Most older adults with lesbian, gay, bisexual, queer, questioning, transgender, and related identities (LGBTQ+) are concerned about receiving lower-quality care and/or being mistreated in nursing homes. Older LGBTQ+ Veterans may have additional reservations about receiving care in Veterans Affairs (VA) nursing homes [Community Living Centers (CLCs)] because of experience with past discriminatory military policies (eg, bans on participating in military service, Don't Ask Don't Tell). The Human Rights Campaign developed the Long-Term Care Equality Index (LEI) as a facility benchmarking tool to support more inclusive environments for LGBTQ+ residents and employees. The LEI offers 4 evaluation criteria: (1) Non-Discrimination and Staff Training; (2) LGBTQ+ Resident Services and Support; (3) Employee Benefits and Policies; and (4) Resident and Community Engagement. Facilities receive ratings based on the number of requirements achieved in each criteria category. This article describes one of the first VA CLCs to participate in the LEI self-assessment and the formative evaluation process used to identify opportunities for growth. Older LGBTQ+ Veterans, current CLC residents, interdisciplinary CLC providers and leadership, and national Geriatrics and Extended Care program managers collaborated to pilot the LEI and develop tools and materials to support other VA facilities' participation in the LEI. Results of qualitative interviews with Veterans and CLC residents supported inclusion of gender identity and sexual orientation in resident handbooks, discussions about person-centered care, and opportunities for additional staff training and community engagement (eg, observing Pride Month in June). Resources to support other VA long-term care facilities' participation in the LEI were developed and are discussed. The LEI offers a structured approach to identifying areas for improvement in providing high-quality and equitable care in long-term care settings. We offer 6 practical suggestions for CLCs and other nursing home settings considering the LEI for the first time.