AbstractDespite the significant burden of chronic pain in sickle cell disease (SCD), nonpharmacological approaches to manage pain in SCD are lacking. Behavioral interventions incorporating digital cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) for pain should be compared with available education efforts. This multisite randomized comparative effectiveness trial aimed to compare a CBT intervention tailored for adults with SCD with a digital pain/SCD educational intervention (“Education”) in terms of improving pain and associated symptoms. Participants were recruited virtually from 7 comprehensive SCD centers and community organizations in the United States. Adults (aged ≥18 years) with SCD-related chronic pain and/or daily opioid use were randomly assigned to CBT or Education. Over 12 weeks, the CBT arm received an app-based intervention for pain management; the Education arm received digital pain/SCD education. Both groups received interactive chatbot lessons plus personalized health coach support. Changes in the pain interference scale (primary outcome) and other patient-reported secondary outcomes, including pain intensity, depression, anxiety, quality of life, and self-efficacy, were assessed over 6 months. Of the 453 participants who completed screening, 359 (79%) were randomly assigned to CBT (n = 181) or Education (n = 178), 332 (92%) were Black African American, and 238 were (66.3%) female. At 6 months, 250 (70%) participants (n = 125 per arm) completed follow-up assessments, 93 (26%) missed their follow-up window, and 16 (4%) withdrew. Engagement with the chatbot content was variable (76% connected, 48% completed ≥1 lesson). However, 80% of participants completed ≥1 session with a health coach via phone, video, or text. The 6-month change in pain interference in the CBT (−2.13; 95% confidence interval [CI], −3.42 to −0.84) and Education (−2.66; 95% CI, −3.97 to −1.36) groups was not significantly different (mean difference, 0.54; 95% CI, −1.30 to 2.37; ∗P = ∗.57). Daily pain intensity ratings did not change for either group. There were no between-arm differences in depression, anxiety, quality of life, or the effect of the intervention on pain and mental health in SCD when combined with health coaching. Variable engagement with digital components and high engagement with health coaching may explain the lack of between-group differences, but these findings also provide insights into delivering digital interventions in racial minority and difficult-to-reach populations. This trial was registered at www.clinicaltrials.gov as #NCT04419168.
Read full abstract