Adipocyte dysfunction is a hallmark of systemic insulin resistance. Insulin-responsive glucose transporter 4 (GLUT4) is downregulated in the insulin resistant state, and cellular insulin responsiveness varies depending on fat depot origin and degree of adipose expansion. Here, we have resolved factors limiting cellular insulin responsiveness, by examining adipocyte function and traits related to glucose transport at the cellular level. Subcutaneous (inguinal) and visceral (epididymal) adipocytes were isolated from C57BL/6J mice fed either chow or high-fat diet. Cell size was determined using coulter counter method, glucose uptake and cytosolic volume were assessed using glucose tracer assays. Total and GLUT4 protein content expressions were determined by Western blot. We found that basal glucose uptake per cell was preserved independent of diet or fat depot origin. Insulin-stimulated glucose uptake per cell was sustained in visceral adipocytes but decreased with adipose expansion in subcutaneous adipocytes. In parallel, the cytosolic space and total protein increased proportionally to total cellular volumetric expansion in visceral, but not in subcutaneous, adipocytes, whereas GLUT4 content decreased exclusively in expanding subcutaneous adipocytes. Together, these data support the existence of distinct phenotypic adipocyte traits that could limit cellular insulin responsiveness. Potentially, these characteristics account for fat depot-specific differences related to glucose transport capacity.NEW & NOTEWORTHY This work illustrates that adipocyte characteristics related to fat depot origin rather than adipocyte size per se limit cellular insulin responsiveness and glucose uptake in male C57BL/6J mice. These findings contribute to the overall understanding of factors limiting adipocyte function and how adipose progression affects insulin response and glucose transport capacity differently in diverse fat depots. Future studies examining whether the proposed characteristics hold true in adipocytes derived from female mice or human origin are needed.