Catchlike Property Research Articles

The inclusion of interstimulus interval variability does not mitigate electrically-evoked fatigue of the knee extensors.

Transcutaneous electrical stimulation (TES) is used to activate muscles when volitional capacity is impaired but potential benefits are limited by rapid force loss (fatigue). Most TES fatigue protocols employ constant-frequency trains, with stimuli at a fixed interstimulus interval (ISI); however, a brief ISI between the first two pulses (variable-frequency train, VFT) to maximize the catchlike property of muscle can attenuate fatigue development. The purpose of this study was to investigate if a VFT that simulates intrinsic variability of voluntary motor unit discharge rates would also mitigate fatigue, owing to the sensitivity of muscle to acute activation history. On two visits, 24 healthy adults (25.3 ± 3.7years; 12 females) received 3min of intermittent TES to the quadriceps of the dominant leg. Trains of eight pulses at 10Hz were delivered with a constant (100ms) or variable ISI (80-120ms). Contractile impulse, rate of force development (RFD), and rate of relaxation (RFR) were determined for each tetanus RESULTS: During fatigue and recovery, contractile impulse did not differ between protocols (p ≥ 0.796) and sexes (p ≥ 0.493), with values of 77 ± 17% control at task end and 125 ± 19% control 2min later. RFD and RFR also showed no effect of the protocol (p ≥ 0.310) or participant sex (p ≥ 0.119). Both measures slowed (38 ± 23% and 33 ± 22%, respectively) but dissociated during recovery as RFD remained 16 ± 18% below control at 5min, whereas RFR recovered to control by 30s (101 ± 22%). Contrary to expectations, the VFT protocol did not attenuate fatigue development, which suggests no benefit to mimicking the inherent variability of motor unit discharge rates.

Comparison of the ballistic contractile responses generated during microstimulation of single human motor axons with brief irregular and regular stimuli.

Ballistic contractions are induced by brief, high-frequency (60-100 Hz) trains of action potentials in motor axons. During ramp voluntary contractions, human motoneurons exhibit significant discharge variability of ∼20% and have been shown to be advantageous to the neuromuscular system. We hypothesized that ballistic contractions incorporating discharge variability would generate greater isometric forces than regular trains with zero variability. High-impedance tungsten microelectrodes were inserted into human fibular nerve, and single motor axons were stimulated with both irregular and constant-frequency stimuli at mean frequencies ranging from 57.8 to 68.9 Hz. Irregular trains generated significantly greater isometric peak forces than regular trains over identical mean frequencies. The high forces generated by ballistic contractions are not based solely on high frequencies, but rather a combination of high firing rates and discharge irregularity. It appears that irregular ballistic trains take advantage of the "catchlike property" of muscle, allowing augmentation of force. Muscle Nerve 56: 292-297, 2017.

Interaction of posttetanic potentiation and the catchlike property in mouse skeletal muscle.

Posttetanic potentiation (PTP) and the catchlike property (CLP) enhance contractile function in skeletal muscle. We investigated the CLP during dynamic performance in mouse hindlimb muscles with (wild-type) and without (skMLCK(-/-) ) the primary mechanism for PTP (myosin phosphorylation) (in vitro, 25°C). Extensor digitorum longus muscles of both genotypes were stimulated with constant frequency and catchlike trains (CFT and CLT), before and after a potentiating stimulus (PS). Before the PS, the CLT increased concentric force/work relative to the CFT, but this effect was greater for skMLCK(-/-) than wild-type muscles. After the PS, the catchlike effect was reduced in wild-type muscles but unchanged in skMLCK(-/-) muscles that did not display PTP. These data suggest that PTP interferes with the CLP during concentric force development at moderate speeds of shortening. We conclude that the physiological utility of each mechanism and their interactions provide important modulations to fast skeletal muscle function. Muscle Nerve 54: 308-316, 2016.

The Catchlike Property in Skeletal Muscle: Influence of Contraction and Muscle‐Type on Augmented Contractile Function

In slow and fast motor units of skeletal muscle, discharge rates are modulated to match and preserve target force levels. Although relatively constant patterns in firing rates are most common, two or more closely-spaced pulses at the onset of activation may appear in both human and mammalian skeletal muscles. The outcome of this aberration in motor unit firing pattern has been shown to increase both the rate and extent of force development; an effect referred to as the catchlike property (CLP). The purpose of this study was to explore the contraction (i.e. isometric vs. concentric) and muscle-type (fast vs. slow twitch) dependence of the CLP in extensor digitorum longus (EDL) and soleus muscles of the mouse (n=10 for all data). The addition of a single pulse 10ms at the onset of an otherwise constant frequency train (CFT) was utilized to augment force and work output of the contractile event, referred to as the catchlike-inducing train (CLT). When compared to the CFT, the peak force during the CLT of soleus muscles was increased to 1.15±0.03 and 1.39±0.03 during isometric (ISO) and concentric (CON) contractions, respectively. In EDL muscles, however, forces were increased to 1.47±0.05 and 1.20±0.04 for ISO and CON contractions; demonstrating a muscle and contraction-type dependence (p <0.05). Similarly, the work done and/or force-time integral increased to 1.34±0.03 and 1.21±0.03 (soleus), and 1.43±0.05 and 1.18±0.02 (EDL), for ISO and CON contractions, respectively. However, when normalized for the number of pulses within each contraction, no net increase in work was evident. Therefore, the catch-like property may serve primarily as a mechanism for augmenting initial force levels rather than as a modulator of contractile efficiency within skeletal muscle.

Catchlike property in human adductor pollicis muscle

The “catchlike” property is defined as the dramatic force increase in skeletal muscles when a single pulse is added at the onset of a sub-tetanic low-frequency stimulation train. This property has been observed in single motor units, whole animal and human muscles. It is an inherent property of muscle fibres and is not related to an increase in motor unit recruitment. Despite an abundance of observations, its origin remains unclear. The aim of this study was to induce the catchlike property in human adductor pollicis and identify its possible origin. Thumb adduction forces were measured using ulnar nerve electrical stimulation at 10Hz for reference trains (RTs) with one extra pulse 8ms after the first stimulation pulse for the experimental trains (ETs). Tests were performed at two muscle length and three stimulation levels and muscle stiffness and potentiation were quantified for all test conditions. The ETs showed higher forces and greater rates of force increase than the RTs. In addition, force increase was more pronounced at short compared to long muscle length, but no differences were found in force increase for the three stimulation levels. Furthermore, potentiation and stiffness were similar across all experimental conditions. Together, these results suggest that the increase in force associated with the catchlike property is neither caused by an increased proportion of attached cross-bridges nor potentiation of the muscle, but appears to be muscle length dependent and present in both slow and fast motor units.

Effect of Intermittent Electrical Stimulation on Low‐Frequency Muscle Fatigue

Skeletal muscles exposed to sustained, low-frequency (LF) stimulation experience a long-lasting reduction in force production known as low-frequency fatigue (LFF). The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect on LFF of a single high-frequency (100 Hz) pulse (i.e., doublet), added to the beginning of repeated, LF (20 Hz)) trains of pulses. Paired sartorii muscles (60–70 mg) from male R. pipiens (N=10) were dissected-free and vertically-mounted in water-jacketed chambers containing oxygenated (100%), Ringer solution (25°C; pH 7.2). One muscle from each animal was stimulated using individual trains of supramaximal, square-wave pulses (20 Hz, 0.2 ms) of 4 sec. duration. Twenty such trains were repeated with a duty-cycle of 4 sec. on/5 sec. off. The remaining muscle was treated identically except that a high-frequency (HF) pulse (100 Hz) was inserted prior to every 4th pulse of the 4 sec. train. Average tension (AT) for each train was determined and normalized relative to the first train. Analysis indicated a −76.4% overall decrease in AT in response to repeated LF stimulation. By comparison, the addition of a single HF pulse at the beginning of each 4 sec. train resulted in a significantly (p<.01) lesser decline (−35.7%). These results suggest that LFF could perhaps be mediated by a manipulation of the neural activation pattern to include intermittent HF and LF components. This result may be due to a catch-like property in skeletal muscle, as original described by Burke et al. (Science, 173:372–376, 1970).

Effects of activation pattern on nonisometric human skeletal muscle performance

During volitional muscle activation, motor units often fire with varying discharge patterns that include brief, high-frequency bursts of activity. These variations in the activation rate allow the central nervous system to precisely control the forces produced by the muscle. The present study explores how varying the instantaneous frequency of stimulation pulses within a train affects nonisometric muscle performance. The peak excursion produced in response to each stimulation train was considered as the primary measure of muscle performance. The results showed that at each frequency tested between 10 and 50 Hz, variable-frequency trains that took advantage of the catchlike property of skeletal muscle produced greater excursions than constant-frequency trains. In addition, variable-frequency trains that could achieve targeted trajectories with fewer pulses than constant-frequency trains were identified. These findings suggest that similar to voluntary muscle activation patterns, varying the instantaneous frequency within a train of pulses can be used to improve muscle performance during functional electrical stimulation.

Augmentation of the contraction force of human thenar muscles by and during brief discharge trains

We investigated the influence of the history of activity on the contractile properties of abductor pollicis brevis (APB) to define how the forces produced by individual stimuli change within a stimulus train, with a view to clarifying the optimal discharge frequency for force production in brief trains. Supramaximal electrical stimuli were delivered to the median nerve at the wrist singly or in trains of 2-5 at various interstimulus intervals (ISIs). The force and electromyographic (EMG) responses to trains of n stimuli were defined by online subtraction of the responses to n - 1 stimuli. The force attributable to the nth stimulus was normalized to that produced by a single stimulus. The contraction force produced by 2 stimuli exceeded the force expected with linear summation of 2 single twitches by 30-40% at ISIs of 2-100 ms. Increasing the number of stimuli resulted in less augmentation of the force produced by the last stimulus in the train for ISIs up to 20 ms, but greater augmentation for ISIs of 50-100 ms. At ISIs of less than 10 ms, the time to peak force produced by the last stimulus in a 5-pulse train was delayed by approximately 100 ms, the peak force produced by that stimulus was less than that produced by a single stimulus, and it occurred on the falling phase of the overall contraction. These properties are best explained by the catchlike property of muscle. This implies that the augmentation of contraction force due to this property can increase throughout a stimulus train, and is not restricted to the doublet discharges that have conventionally been studied. We conclude that, with brief discharge trains, maximal forces occur at ISIs of 56-75 ms, intervals that are longer than those conventionally associated with the catchlike property. Discharge rates of 15-20 HZ appear to be optimal for force generation by APB during steady contractions.

Reduction of muscle fatigue by catchlike-inducing intermittent electrical stimulation in rat skeletal muscle

Catchlike property is the force enhancement produced when a brief, high-frequency burst of pulses is added to a constant low-frequency stimulation. In functional electrical stimulation, constant low-frequency stimulation of approximately 20 Hz has primarily been used to reduce muscle fatigue. The purpose of this study was to investigate the effects of catchlike-inducing intermittent stimulation on muscle fatigue in relation to continuous intermittent low-frequency stimulation. Twenty-two adult male Wistar ST rats were randomly assigned into the constant frequency stimulation (CFS) group or the catchlike-inducing stimulation (CIS) group. In the CFS group, constant low-frequency stimulation of 20 Hz was applied intermittently (4 seconds "ON"/15 seconds "OFF"). In the CIS group, a single electrical burst of 100 Hz was applied at the start of the every 4-second period of stimulation. The muscle fatigue test lasted for 16 min and isometric muscle force, muscle fatigue, and muscular workload were evaluated. CIS significantly increased the maximum muscular force (under fatigued condition) and workload, and significantly decreased muscle fatigue (p < 0.05). The results of this study suggest that catchlike-inducing intermittent electrical stimulation is useful in the clinical administration of functional electrical stimulation.

Catchlike property of skeletal muscle: Recent findings and clinical implications

The catchlike property of skeletal muscle is the force augmentation produced by the inclusion of an initial, brief, high-frequency burst of two to four pulses at the start of a subtetanic low-frequency stimulation train. Catchlike-inducing trains take advantage of the catchlike property of skeletal muscle and augment muscle performance compared with constant-frequency trains, especially in the fatigued state. Literature spanning more than 30 years has provided comprehensive information about the catchlike property of skeletal muscle. The pattern of the catchlike-inducing train that maximizes muscle performance is fairly similar across different muscles of different species and under various stimulation conditions. This review summarizes the mechanisms of the catchlike property, factors affecting force augmentation, techniques used to identify patterns of catchlike-inducing trains that maximize muscle performance, and potential clinical applications to provide a historical and current perspective of our understanding of the catchlike property.

Associations between force and fatigue in fast-twitch motor units of a cat hindlimb muscle

Associations were quantified between the control force and fatigue-induced force decline in 22 single fast-twitch-fatigable motor units of 5 deeply anesthetized adult cats. The units were subjected to intermittent stimulation at 1 train/s for 360 s. Two stimulation patterns were delivered in a pseudo-random manner. The first was a 500-ms train with constant interpulse intervals. The second pattern had the same number of stimuli, mean stimulus rate, and stimulus duration, but the stimulus pulses were rearranged to increase the force produced by the units in the control (prefatigue) state. The associations among the control peak tetanic force of these units, 3 indices of fatigue, and total cumulative force during fatiguing contractions were dependent, in part, on the stimulation pattern used to produce fatigue. The associations were also dependent, albeit to a lesser extent, on the force measure (peak vs. integrated) and the fatigue index used to quantify fatigue. It is proposed that during high-force fatiguing contractions, neural mechanisms are potentially available to delay and reduce the fatigue of fast-twitch-fatigable units for brief, but functionally relevant, periods. In contrast, the fatigue of slow-twitch fatigue-resistant units seems more likely to be controlled largely, if not exclusively, by metabolic processes within their muscle cells.

Effects of fatigue on the catchlike property in a turtle hindlimb muscle

The purpose of this report was to test for the possibility that a catchlike, force-enhancing property, attributable to a particular stimulation pattern, could be evoked in non-mammalian turtle muscle, just as it has been shown in mammalian muscle. We tested for the presence of this property in dynamic lengthening and shortening contractions, as well as in the more commonly studied isometric contractions. A second aim was to note the effects of fatigue on the catchlike property, if the latter was present. The force response of the external gastrocnemius muscle in the adult turtle, Pseudemys ( Trachemys) scripta elegans, was compared for a control, constant-frequency 10 Hz, 1-s duration stimulation pattern using 0.1-ms pulses vs. the same pattern, but with two additional pulses within the first 100-ms interspike interval of the control stimulus train. This latter train produced a pronounced and prolonged enhancement of muscle force, which was attributed to a catchlike effect. It was greatly increased when the muscle was in a fatigued state. The extent of this force enhancement was significantly different for the three contraction types, and generally in the order: isometric>lengthening>shortening contraction. These differences were greater in fatigued vs. fresh muscle. Comparative aspects and potential mechanisms underlying the catchlike effect are discussed.

Effect of potentiation on the catchlike property of human skeletal muscles.

The catchlike property of skeletal muscle is the force enhancement produced when a brief, high-frequency burst of pulses (two to four pulses) is added to a subtetanic train of pulses. Stimulation trains that take advantage of the catchlike property have been shown to produce greater forces than trains commonly used during clinical application of functional electrical stimulation (FES). We recently showed, however, that there was no force enhancement observed with the catchlike property when muscles were nonfatigued and highly potentiated. Thus, understanding the relationship between the force augmentations produced by the catchlike property and potentiation may provide insight into the physiological conditions that best take advantage of the catchlike property. The goal of this study was to explore quantitatively the effect of potentiation on the catchlike property of the muscle. Isometric data were collected from human quadriceps femoris muscles. A negative linear relationship between the force augmentation produced by the catchlike property and the amount of potentiation was observed. These data showed that for nonfatigued muscles, the catchlike property would be most beneficial at the onset of activation, when muscles are the least potentiated. These results should help to guide clinicians to design stimulation protocols that optimize performance during FES.

Activation of human quadriceps femoris muscle during dynamic contractions: effects of load on fatigue.

Muscle fatigue is both multifactorial and task dependent. Electrical stimulation may assist individuals with paralysis to perform functional activities [functional electrical stimulation (FES), e.g., standing or walking], but muscle fatigue is a limiting factor. One method of optimizing force is to use stimulation patterns that exploit the catchlike property of skeletal muscle [catchlike-inducing trains (CITs)]. Although nonisometric (dynamic) contractions are important parts of both normal physiological activation of skeletal muscles and FES, no previous studies have attempted to identify the effect that the load being lifted by a muscle has on the fatigue produced. This study examined the effects of load on fatigue during dynamic contractions and the augmentation produced by CITs as a function of load. Knee extension in healthy subjects was electrically elicited against three different loads. The highest load produced the least excursion, work, and average power, but it produced the greatest fatigue. CIT augmentation was greatest at the highest load and increased with fatigue. Because CITs were effective during shortening contractions for a variety of loads, they may be of benefit during FES applications.

Effects of length on the catchlike property of human quadriceps femoris muscle: Lee SCK, Gerdom ML, Binder-Macleod SA. Phys Ther 1999;79:738–748

Effects of length on the catchlike property of human quadriceps femoris muscle: Lee SCK, Gerdom ML, Binder-Macleod SA. Phys Ther 1999;79:738–748

Catchlike property of rat diaphragm: subsequent train frequency effects in variable-train stimulation.

A high-frequency burst of pulses at the onset of a subtetanic train of stimulation allows skeletal muscle to hold force at a higher level than expected from the extra pulses alone because of the catchlike property of muscle. The present study tested the hypothesis that the presence and degree of force increase induced by a high-frequency burst are strongly modulated by the subsequent train frequency. Rat diaphragm muscle strips (studied in vitro at 37 degrees C) underwent two-, three-, or four-pulse bursts [interpulse interval (IPI) of 5 or 10 ms] at the onset of 10- to 50-Hz subtetanic trains. Force was quantified during the train with respect to its peak value (F(peak)), mean value (F(mean)), and force-time integral (F(area)), and it was compared with that produced during subtetanic trains of an equal number of pulses without preceding pulse bursts (Diff-F(peak), Diff-F(mean), Diff-F(area)). F(peak) and F(mean) increased with two-, three-, and four-pulse bursts, and Diff-F(peak) and Diff-F(mean) increased progressively with decreasing frequency of the subtetanic train. F(area), the best reflection of catchlike force augmentation, was increased mainly by the four-pulse bursts with an IPI of 10 ms, and Diff-F(area) was maximal at subsequent train frequencies of 15-25 Hz. The use of incorrect patterns of burst stimulation could also precipitate F(area) decreases, which were observed with the four-pulse, 5-ms IPI paradigm. The time required to reach 80% of maximal force (T(80%)) became shorter for each of the pulse burst stimulation patterns, with maximal reduction of Diff-T(80%) occurring at a subsequent train frequency of 20 Hz in all cases. These data indicate that extra-pulse burst stimulation paradigms need to incorporate the optimal combinations of extra-pulse number, IPI, and the frequency of the subsequent subtetanic train to take greatest advantage of the catchlike property of muscle.

Effects of Length on the Catchlike Property of Human Quadriceps Femoris Muscle

Recent reports have suggested that electrical stimulation trains that take advantage of the catchlike property of skeletal muscle can produce higher forces from skeletal muscle than traditionally used constant-frequency trains. This study investigated the effects of catchlike-inducing trains on human quadriceps femoris muscles while the kneejoint was held at 15 degrees of flexion. Subjects (N=12) were tested with constant-frequency trains that had interpulse intervals ranging from 10 to 160 milliseconds and comparable catchlike-inducing trains. Data were collected during the control condition (1 train every 10 seconds) and during repetitive contractions (1 train per second). During control and repetitive activation conditions, catchlike-inducing trains produced approximately 5% to 110% greater peak forces than comparable constant-frequency trains, depending on the frequencies being compared. Total forces produced (ie, force-time integrals) were increased up to 59% and 49% during the control and repetitive activation conditions, respectively. These results support earlier findings that catchlike-inducing trains may be advantageous in functional electrical stimulation applications.

Variable‐frequency trains offset low‐frequency fatigue in human skeletal muscle

Variable-frequency trains that exploit the catchlike property of skeletal muscle can augment force production in fatigued skeletal muscle. The present study is the first to examine the effect of such trains during recovery. The quadriceps femoris muscles of 12 healthy individuals were fatigued using six-pulse, 14.3-Hz trains delivered at a rate of 1/s for 3 min. The force-generating ability of the muscle was tested with several constant-frequency trains (8.3–100 Hz) and a variable-frequency train before and after fatigue and at 2, ∼13, and ∼38 min of recovery. The variable-frequency train produced significant augmentation of force versus the best constant-frequency train (12.5 Hz) in acute fatigue and during recovery. The fatiguing protocol also induced low-frequency fatigue (LFF); the time courses of the degree of LFF and the amount of variable-frequency train force augmentation were inversely related (r = 0.629; F = 38.024; P ≤ 0.001), suggesting a common mechanism between the two phenomena. These results suggest that clinical use of variable-frequency trains (e.g., functional electrical stimulation) will enable the muscle to generate more force during acute fatigue and offset, at least partially, the long-term effects of LFF. © 1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Muscle Nerve 22: 874–882, 1999

Effects of activation pattern on human skeletal muscle fatigue

Variable-frequency stimulation trains (VFTs) that take advantage of the catchlike property of skeletal muscle have been shown to augment the force production of fatigued muscles compared with constant-frequency trains (CFTs). The present study is the first to report the force augmentation produced by VFTs after fatiguing the muscle with VFTs versus fatiguing the muscle with CFTs. Data were obtained from the human quadriceps femoris muscles of 12 healthy subjects. Each subject participated in three experimental sessions. Each session fatigued the muscle with one of three protocols: CFTs with 70-ms interpulse intervals (CFT70); CFTs with 55.5-ms interpulse intervals (CFT55.5); or VFTs. Following each fatiguing protocol the muscles were tested with all three stimulation patterns (i.e., CFT55.5, CFT70, and VFT). At the end of the fatiguing protocol the VFT produced force-time integrals and peak forces approximately 18% and 32% greater than the CFT70, respectively. The testing trains showed that the VFT produced approximately 25-35% greater force-time integrals than either CFT and approximately 35-47% greater peak forces than the CFT70. For each testing train, approximately 10-15% greater force-time integrals were seen when the muscles were fatigued with the CFTs than when fatigued with the VFTs. These results support suggestions that VFTs may be useful during clinical applications of electrical stimulation.

Reduction of the fatigue-induced force decline in human skeletal muscle by optimized stimulation trains

Objective: To identify the stimulation pattern that optimizes the force-time integral produced during isometric contractions of fatigued human skeletal muscle. Design: Twelve healthy subjects with no history of lower extremity orthopedic problems voluntarily participated. Results: The primary findings were that (1) the optimized trains showed augmentation only from fatigued muscles and (2) a simple stimulation pattern, containing one brief (5msec) initial interpulse interval, produced the greatest force-time integrals and rates of rise of force. With muscle fatigue, the rate of rise of force of the constant-frequency train slowed, whereas the rate of rise of force of the optimized trains remained unchanged. This difference in the rate of rise of force may explain why the optimized trains, which take advantage of the catchlike property of skeletal muscle, are able to augment forces from fatigued muscles when compared with the constant-frequency train. Conclusions: These results may have important clinical implications when using brief trains of electric stimulation to aid patients in performing functional movements and contribute to our understanding of the relationship between the activation pattern of a muscle and the force output produced.