CATA Questions Research Articles

Pomegranate Quality from Consumers' Perspective: Drivers of Liking, Preference Patterns, and the Relation between Sensory and Physico-Chemical Properties.

Acquiring information on consumer preferences for the sensory properties of pomegranates is a cue for breeding programmes to set their quality targets and promote the consumption of this particularly healthy fruit. In this study, a total of 12 pomegranate varieties were evaluated, including commercial (Valenciana, Illina, Tastem, Rugalate, Wonderful, Mollar 49 y Mollar 45) and new varieties (Ref 102, Ref 383, H3/27, and D27/12). For the first time, consumers not only scored their acceptance of different pomegranate varieties but also described their sensory properties using CATA questions. This approach allowed us to identify the main drivers of liking, preference patterns, and the relationship between sensory and physico-chemical properties. Of all the sensory attributes, acidity intensity was revealed as the main driver of liking/disliking, and two different consumer preference patterns were identified: 'low acid pomegranate lovers' and 'acid pomegranate lovers'. Seed properties like the intensity of woody flavour and seed/aril ratio were also key drivers for preferences. A relationship between sensory and physico-chemical properties was also established. Interestingly, sweetness perception correlated more strongly with low titratable acidity levels than with high total soluble solids levels, corroborating that acidity level is a key measurement for quality assessments. 'H3/27' was the most promising of the new varieties for having the well-appreciated internal properties of the 'Mollar' varieties and external and internal red colouration, which makes it much more appealing to consumers. This study shows that there is still room on the market for pomegranate varieties with very different sensory properties and highlights the need to develop sensory labels that help consumers make the right choices.

Use of face reading to measure oral processing behaviour and its relation to product perception

Food texture can influence sensory perception and eating behaviour; it can be managed to affect intake, by inducing higher expected satiety and satiation, and eventually reducing overeating. The objective of this work was to assess face reading as an automatic measure of oral processing behaviour of products with different texture modifications, aimed at reducing intake. Three oat breads with different textural properties were used as a case study. A trained panel used Temporal Dominance of Sensations to describe dynamic sensory profiles of the breads and were simultaneously video recorded; the videos were analysed by FaceReader (intake, chewing motions, chewing period). The parameters extracted through face reading showed significant differences among the breads in duration of chewing period and number of chewing motions, which can be interpreted together with the TDS results. A consumer test (n = 135) was conducted on the breads, where participants evaluated overall liking, expected satiation and satiety, and answered a Check-All-That-Apply question including sensory and non-sensory attributes. Results indicated that the samples were significantly different in terms of liking, expected satiation and satiety and that consumers described samples in CATA question in line with the panel. Results interpreted together allowed the identification of the dynamic textural properties responsible for enhancing satiety and satiation expectations. Methodological implications are discussed throughout the paper. The novelty of the study is to show that automatic measures of oral processing behaviour by face reading, can be linked to self-reported explicit measures of satiety, opening the door to larger studies, unfeasible using manual annotation.

Evaluation of the physicochemical and sensory characteristics of gluten-free cookies.

The increasing prevalence of celiac disease and gluten intolerance has led to an increased demand for gluten-free food products in Peru. The research objective was to develop gluten-free cookies from substitute flours, evaluating their physicochemical and sensory parameters. Eight formulations were developed using 100% broad bean, chickpea, pea, kiwicha, quinoa, lentil, corn, and bean flour. One hundred consumers participated in this evaluation (59% women and 41% men). A completely randomized design (CRD) and a randomized complete block design (RCBD) were used for physicochemical analysis and acceptability, respectively. To describe the sensory characteristics of the cookies, Cochran's Q-test and correspondence analysis (CA) were performed. From the results obtained, the lentil cookie presented the highest amount of protein and fiber but lower fat and carbohydrate contents compared to the other samples. In terms of color, the corn cookie was the lightest, with greater luminosity (L*), less redness (a*), and greater yellowness (b*). Regarding the sensory analysis, the CATA questions allowed us to form six groups, and the samples with the greatest acceptability were the corn and chickpea cookies, which were rated as "I like them." Lentil flour crackers are a nutritionally adequate option, and corn flour crackers are highly sensorially acceptable, suggesting commercial opportunities for softer and more flavorful gluten-free products. However, it is crucial to continue researching and developing innovative products to meet changing market demands and offer healthier and more attractive options to consumers.

Adding cricket (Gryllus assimilis) flour in hybrid beef patties: physicochemical, technological and sensory challenges

SummaryThe effect of replacing partially lean meat (21.7% protein, 4.5% fat) with cricket (Gryllus assimilis) flour (CF) in the physicochemical, technological and sensory properties of beef patties was evaluated. Four formulations were elaborated, a control with 66% w/w of beef (FC) and the others with substitution of the meat at 10 (F10%), 15 (F15%) and 20% w/w (F20%) levels with CF. Analysis of chemical composition, shrinkage, cooking yield, moisture and fat retention, pH, colour, lipid oxidation (TBARS), texture and sensory profile (Acceptance test and CATA questions) were performed. An increase in fat content, moisture and fat retention was observed in products with cricket flour. Adding CF resulted in softer meat products with lower shrinkage and cooking loss. FC was lighter and redder than products with CF. TBARS values were higher as CF addition increased, with no difference among FC and F10%. FC and F10% had greater sensory acceptance (scores above 8.0 and 7.0 for overall liking, respectively). By the CATA test consumers linked FC and F10% with the descriptors associated with overall liking, such as burger aroma, meat aroma and juicy and F15% and F20% were associated with undesirable descriptors such strange and unpleasant aroma, bad and dry appearance, sandy and crumbly. The results showed that cricket flour could replace beef by a fraction of up to 10%, obtaining a hybrid meat product with appropriate technological and sensory characteristics.

Acceptance, Sensory Characterization and Consumption Contexts for Dehydrated Persimmon Slices, Chips, Leathers and Powder: A Consumer Study.

Valorization of persimmon discards is a current challenge for the food industry. Obtaining dehydrated persimmon products can be a good option, but studies are necessary to predict consumer responses before placing new products on the market. In this study, we produced dried slices, chips, leathers and powder from persimmons that were discarded at harvest. A consumer study was performed with 100 participants. For a realistic context, the four products were presented to the participants in specifically designed packages to simulate commercial packages. The participants were asked about their interest in having each product available on the market. Then, they were asked to taste the samples and to state their acceptance and purchase intention. The participants characterized the main sensory properties of the samples using the CATA questions. The consumption contexts evoked by each product were also investigated based on the item-by-use method, plus the CATA questions. Our results revealed that, before tasting the samples, the participants showed special interest in having chips and slices available on the market. After tasting, the participants reported very good acceptance of chips, slices and powder, but leathers were less liked. According to the consumer characterizations, slices had the most intense persimmon taste and a succulent texture, while powder was characterized by its caramel taste. Chips were differentiated from the other samples, mainly for their crispy texture, while leathers were sticky and tasteless, which explained their poor acceptance. By evaluating the data on acceptance and the evoked consumption contexts together, we conclude that persimmon consumption could be enhanced by commercializing slices, chips and powder. The participants described chips and slices as healthy snacks in different daily situations, while powder could be used as a sweetener for yoghurts or hot drinks and as an ingredient for baking desserts. These are all contexts in which fresh persimmon would be not consumed as reported by the participants.

Exploring the perception and sensory acceptance of a Peruvian purple maize breakfast cereal by Brazilian consumers

This study aimed to explore the perception and sensory acceptance of Purple Maize (PM) breakfast cereals by a Brazilian panel. The extrudates were elaborated using 25%, 50%, 75%, and 100% PM in a commercial yellow corn base. A total of 117 consumers evaluated samples through an acceptability test (nine-point hedonic scale) followed by CATA questions (35 descriptive terms) and a market research questionnaire. The cereals formulated with 50% and 75% PM had the best scores (6) in color, aroma, texture, and overall liking during the acceptability test. Based on the penalty-lift analysis, Brazilian consumers' most important drivers of preference were the attractive color, crispy texture, and the natural and innovative purple color. In contrast, hard texture and brown color drivers negatively impacted the scores. In the market research, consumers indicated that they could eat the product both as a breakfast cereal and as a snack during the day; Likewise, they highlighted the possible health benefits, the innovative color, and the use of exotic raw materials as the best characteristics of the product. Therefore, using 50% PM or more allows for obtaining sustainable and nutritious breakfast cereals with characteristics of color, flavor, and texture well accepted by Brazilian consumers.

Sensory Characterization and Acceptability of a New Lulo (Solanum quitoense Lam.) Powder-Based Soluble Beverage Using Rapid Evaluation Techniques with Consumers.

Recently, the interest in tropical fruits has increased widely even beyond their production areas, but the perishable nature of these fruits makes their marketing difficult. However, due to its special sensory characteristics and nutritional value, lulo (Solanum quitoense Lam.) is a good candidate for product development to meet this ever-growing demand. Therefore, a lulo-powder-based soluble beverage was prepared according to previously established formulations. Thus, the aim of the present research was to obtain the sensory characterization, study consumers’ overall acceptability, and identify drivers of liking for the new beverage. Eight samples were prepared with lulo juice or pulp + stevia, or a sweetener blend (erythritol + xylitol + stevia). Maltodextrin or inulin, as a drying aid, was added to freeze-dry the samples. The freeze-dried samples were rehydrated for consumption. The sensory characterization of the new beverage was carried out by using CATA questions with consumers (n = 69). The most influential attributes that affected acceptability were identified by using ideal product characterization and hedonic scores of the samples. The beverage formulations with stevia alone had the lowest acceptability. Most sensory differences among samples were found between the visual attributes. The attributes “clean”, “homogeneous”, “fruity” and “citrus” odor, “just-right acidity”, “just-right sweetness”, and “fresh” were necessary to increase global acceptance in the juice-only beverages (Js), whereas “cloudy”, “off-odor”, and “very acidic” negatively impacted acceptance. For products with pulp (Ps), “citrus” and “tropical fruit” odors, “just-right acidity”, “just-right sweetness”, and “fresh” attributes were needed to increase acceptance, while “cloudy” and “chemical/artificial” flavors negatively impacted acceptance. The lulo-powder-based soluble beverage was accepted by consumers; however, there is still potential for the sensory-quality improvement of this product.

Understanding Young Taiwanese Consumers' Acceptance, Sensory Profile, and Drivers of Liking for GABA Oolong Tea Beverages with Cold Infusions.

The sensory qualities of Taiwanese teas are evaluated by the experts from the Tea Research and Extension Station (TRES) at tea competitions held annually. The prices of Taiwanese teas are also influenced by the results of these tea competitions. However, a tea winning an award and having a high sensory quality and price does not mean that it is liked by Taiwanese consumers. The check all that apply method (CATA) is a scientific method of sensory evaluation. It is able to evaluate the sensory characteristics with consumers and is cheap and time-saving. Twelve samples of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) Oolong tea made by the Taiwan Tea No. 12 cultivar were selected from the first Taiwanese GABA tea competition in 2020. The aim of this research was to study young Taiwanese consumers’ acceptability for GABA Oolong tea infusions, and their opinions towards the sensory qualities of teas through questionnaires composed of CATA questions and hedonic scales. Based on the results, the CATA method identified 21 important descriptive terms for GABA tea that were selected by over 20% of consumers. It was found that the consumers like GABA Oolong teas with 13 specific sensory characteristics, but dislike the ones with another 6 specific sensory characteristics. We conjecture that the different process of tea production will affect consumers’ preference for GABA Oolong tea. Overall, GABA Oolong tea has the same delightful sensory characteristics as traditional Taiwanese specialty Oolong teas, and is liked by the young Taiwanese consumers.

Understanding the sensory profile of cheese ripeness description by trained and untrained assessors

Cheese ripeness is an important step of cheese manufacturing that provides a kind of food with complex sensory characteristics and nuanced differences. The importance of generating rapid/easy consumer perception of a new product is without question. The aim was to evaluate the Santo Giorno cheese sensory profile, at different ripening times and with different starter cultures, evaluated by trained assessors and consumers using CATA questions. The two methods generated similar results. However, the results from CATA revealed that consumers are able to discriminate between cheeses with different ripening times but not describe them in detail. The application of the technique also made it possible to perceive that the two starter cultures used did not reflect different sensory elements and that the spicy and salty attributes are more easily perceived by consumers when evaluating ripened cheeses.

Perfil sensorial ideal para el cabanossi con carne de llama (Lama glama) de tres sistemas de alimentación usando el método CATA (Check-all-that-apply)

Food development involves the usage of rapid sensory tools that allows for exploring consumer perceptions. The ideal sensory profile of cabanossi with llama meat from three feeding systems (with natural hay, alfalfa and with vitamins) through the CATA method was determined in comparison with two commercial samples. Moisture, pH, water activity, color and texture were evaluated. Moisture and external and internal color were similar between llama cabanossi but different from commercial ones. The mechanical parameters (hardness and chewiness) were superior from the llama cabanossi samples. Eighty (80) consumers with an ideal profile based on CATA questions found significant differences in all of the used descriptors. The indispensable sensory attributes for their acceptability were: salty, characteristic smell/ sausage and chewiness. With regards to the penalty analysis, the positive attributes (chewiness, and bland/soft) and negative (hard, smell, smokey and brown color), which should be considered for product reformulation. The cabanossi from natural hay feeding system (CS1) was close to the ideal product. The use of the ideal profile constitutes an alternative to identifying the characteristics (sensory, physicochemical and mechanical) for the development of new foods based on the consumer´s idealized requirements.

Differences in citation proportions in CATA questions can be interpreted as differences perceived intensity of sensory attributes

AbstractCATA (check‐all‐that‐apply) questions enjoy high popularity for sensory product characterization with consumers. Amidst extensive methodological characterization, the meaning of term citation frequency has received modest attention only, possibly hindering further uptake. The present research performed a more detailed exploration of the relationship between CATA responses and perceived intensity of sensory attributes. In addition, the following question was addressed: How many consumers are necessary to interpret differences in CATA citation proportions as a proxy of differences in perceived intensity? The present research includes new empirical data from four consumer studies conducted in New Zealand and China under central location test conditions and a re‐analysis of one consumer study. When dealing with samples with clear differences, the percentage of consumers selecting a sensory term for describing samples tended to be linearly correlated to average intensity ratings. A median of 15 consumers was needed for CATA to show good linear correlations with average intensity ratings, and the minimum number of consumers needed to reach the threshold for a good correlation was generally lower than 30.Practical ApplicationsResults add to existing guidelines and say that for sets of sample sets with at least moderate differences in a specific attribute, a minimum of 50 consumers is necessary to obtain reliable sensory characterizations using CATA questions and interpret differences in citation proportions as a proxy for differences in the perceived intensity of that attribute. However, practitioners should be aware of the limitations of CATA questions for measuring attribute intensity, such as studies involving complex terms or samples with subtle intensity differences.

Consumers with high frequency of ‘just about right’ in JAR scales may use lower cognitive effort: Evidence from the concurrent 9-point hedonic scale and CATA question

JAR scales are widely used to evaluate the suitability of attributes and guide product optimization. However, the reliability and validity of the results from JAR scales had been widely doubted. In the current research, it was hypothesized that respondents with high just about right (jar) frequency may have more satisficers according to Krosnick’s survey satisficing theory, herein they were more likely to employ low cognitive effort in the tests. To search relevant evidence to prove this, a strategy of indirect method was employed that consumer with different jar frequencies may also perform differently in other concurrent tests such as hedonic scaling and CATA questions. A total of 716 consumers were recruited in four studies with four different sets of products involving coffee and chrysanthemum tea. These consumers were then divided into two groups in each study according to their jar frequency to examine the above hypothesis and their performance on the concurrent tests were compared between the two groups. It was found that consumers with high jar frequency tended to use a narrower range of scales on 9-point hedonic scale, and use terms more narrowly and repeatedly in CATA questions. This confirmed the above hypothesis. Meanwhile, the low cognitive effort could noticeably influence responses in other questions. For instance, it led to lower product discrimination based on hedonic scores when samples were similar and altered results of related to terms discrimination and term configurations in CATA questions. Thereby, survey satisficing problem should be taken seriously in both experimental design and statistical analysis in consumer testings.

The valence × arousal circumplex-inspired emotion questionnaire (CEQ): Effect of response format and question layout

Questionnaires are popular in food-related emotion research and exist in many forms. Adding to this multiplicity, a parsimonious circumplex-inspired single-response questionnaire with 12 pairs of emotion words that span the dimensions of pleasure and arousal was recently introduced [Jaeger et al., 2020, 103805]. It can be used with a wide range of stimuli and different stimuli formats to generate discriminative and stable product profiles. The present research advances methodological understanding of the valence × arousal circumplex-inspired emotion questionnaire (CEQ) by investigating its circular layout and single response characteristics. Four CEQ variants were compared, defined according to a 2 × 2 combinatorial which compared the single response format with a CATA question format (check-all-that-apply) and the CEQ’s circular structure with a conventional list format containing the same 12 pairs of emotion words. The empirical context was an online survey with 15 food names implemented as a between-subjects design. Product emotion profiles were highly similar for circular and list formats, indicating that the circular CEQ layout was of no particular benefit (nor hinderance). Compared to the single response variant, sample discrimination improved when multiple emotion words could be chosen for each food name. However, responses for all four variants were quite similar as assessed by RV coefficients. The research contributed to guidelines for implementation of the CEQ in product research and suggested that all variants were appropriate, but greater sample discrimination and descriptive detail may be gained when implementing the CEQ as a CATA question. Regardless of CEQ variant, samples were differentiated according to valence and arousal, and separation on the latter dimension was uncorrelated with degree of product liking/disliking.

Effect of an UV-C Light-Based Hurdle Strategy for Carrot-Orange Juice Processing on Candida parapsilosis Inactivation and Physiological State: Impact on Juice Sensory and Physicochemical Quality Parameters

In the past two decades, novel preservation technologies have been investigated to achieve sufficient microbial reduction while improving the quality of food and beverages. The effect of UV-C light (UV-C, 1720 mJ/cm2) assisted by mild heat (H, 50 °C) on the inactivation and the physiological state of Candida parapsilosis ATCC 22019 in a carrot-orange juice was studied by flow cytometry. Additionally, the juice samples processed or not (control) by the single (UV-C; H) and combined (UV-C/H) treatments were analyzed for total polyphenol content (TPC), total antioxidant activity (TAA), color, turbidity, °Brix, pH, and pectin methylesterase units (PME) along 13–24-day storage (4 °C). Consumer-profiling studies were conducted on UV-C/H and a pasteurized juice. UV-C/H was highly effective in reducing C. parapsilosis by 5.5 log cycles, whereas the single UV-C and H treatments induced 2.9 and 3.9 log reductions, respectively. Flow cytometry revealed a shift with time from cells with intact membrane and esterase activity to those with permeabilized membrane and without esterase activity, which was significantly higher for UV-C/H samples (98.0%) compared with the single treatments (12.0–46.2%). UV-C/H preserved juice color, pH, °Brix, and turbidity of the juice, which exhibited equal TAA (0.7 mg/mL) and higher TPC (302.1 μg/mL) than the control (TAA = 0.7 mg/mL/TPC = 205.0 μg/mL), remaining constant throughout storage. PME decreased 42–45% for the H and UV-C/H treatments, respectively. A cluster sensory analysis revealed that one group of consumers showed a remarkable interest in the UV-C/H juice, while the conjoint study showed that it was perceived as very healthy. The CATA question determined that the UV-C/H processing prevented the juice from being perceived too particulate or with cooked or artificial taste, as happened with the pasteurized juice.

Consumer Description by Check-All-That-Apply Questions (CATA) of the Sensory Profiles of Commercial and New Mandarins. Identification of Preference Patterns and Drivers of Liking.

In the last few years, the interest in developing new mandarin cultivars of superior quality has grown as a response to the increasing consumer demand of this appreciated fruit. This study evaluated the sensory profiles of five new late-season mandarin cultivars (‘Alborea‘, ’Coral‘, ’Omet‘, ’Matiz‘ and ’Tri-703‘) and six commercial cultivars found contemporarily in stores (‘Clemenules‘, ’Nova‘, ’Tango‘, ’Nadorcott‘, ‘Orri’ and ‘Ortanique’). The sensory profiles of the cultivars were described by consumers through CATA questions. Consumers’ acceptability and the main physico-chemical properties were also evaluated. Twenty-two out of 23 CATA terms differed significantly for the sensory profiles of the studied cultivars. The new cultivars shared a similar profile, described mainly as “very intense taste”, “refreshing taste”, “very aromatic” and “juicy”, and these characteristics were quite different from those of the commercial cultivars. By combining acceptability and CATA questions, drivers of liking for segments of consumers with different preference patterns were identified. This is the first time that the sensory profiles of mandarin cultivars have been described by consumers. A significant number of consumers preferred the new mandarin cultivars to the commercial ones, which allows them a promising introduction on the market.

Obtaining the ideal smoked bacon: What is the influence of the product space and multivariate procedure to construct the external preference mapping?

Identifying the ideal product is the most important step in new product development and improvement of existing ones. The aim of this study was to identify the ideal smoked bacon using PrefMFA and PrefMap considering three different sensory spaces obtained via descriptive analysis (DA), projective mapping (PM) and CATA questions. Six smoked bacons were characterized by ten trained assessors using DA, and by two consumers panel using PM (n=93) and CATA questions (n=100). Also, one hundred consumers indicated their overall liking using a nine-point hedonic scale. The results showed that both techniques identified an ideal product. However, the sensory method has a greater effect than the multivariate procedure to obtain the sensory spaces prior to the preference mapping. Subsequent studies with other food matrices are still necessary in order to generalize our results.

Development and quality assessment of a turbid carrot-orange juice blend processed by UV-C light assisted by mild heat and addition of Yerba Mate (Ilex paraguariensis) extract

Carrot-orange juice processed by UV-C (10.6 kJ/m2) assisted with mild heat (H, 50 °C) and yerba mate addition (E) was obtained. UV-C/H + E treated juice was examined for native flora, polyphenol content (PC), total antioxidant activity (TAA), colour, turbidity, °Brix and pH along storage (4 °C). Consumer profiling studies were performed. UV-C/H + E provoked 2.6–5.7 native flora log reductions, preventing from recovery during 24 day-storage. The UV-C/H + E juice exhibited a significant increase in PC (720.2 µg/mL) and TAA (5.5 mg/mL) compared to untreated (PC = 205.0 µg/mL/TAA = 0.7 mg/mL) and single treated juices (PC = 302.1–408.0 µg/mL/TAA = 0.7–2.4 mg/mL), remaining constant throughout storage. UV-C/H + E juice exhibited scarce changes in colour. Nevertheless, increases in °Brix and turbidity were observed compared to single treatments. A cluster sensory analysis revealed that one group showed a marked interest in UVC/H + E beverages with herbal taste and strong aroma. CATA question revealed that some improvements should be introduced in order to satisfy the consumers' ideally beverage.

CATA and RATA questions for product-focused emotion research: Five case studies using emoji questionnaires

Questionnaires are popular in product-focused emotion research with consumers. Ease of implementation is paramount in this regard, as is versatility. In the presented studies, focus is directed to scaling variations as an element of methodological versatility, and a comparison is performed of CATA and RATA question formats (check-all-that-apply and rate-all-that-apply, respectively). Five studies, with a range of tasted products and food/beverage names were conducted, involving 908 consumers in New Zealand, China and Korea. Emoji questionnaires, recently established as a methodological variant in product-elicited emotion research, were used. The average percentage of emoji used for describing samples was similar for CATA and RATA questions when used in Central Location Tests with tasted samples, but higher for RATA than CATA questions in online surveys. Discriminative ability of CATA and RATA questions was linked to the characteristics of the focal samples. The recommendation for method choice is to use CATA emoji-questions when samples have distinct emotional associations, whereas RATA seems better able to discriminate between samples with more similar emotional profiles. Neither CATA nor RATA emoji-questions were regarded by consumers as difficult or tedious.

White wines aroma recovery and enrichment: Sensory-led aroma selection and consumer perception

We developed a sensory-based methodology to aromatically enrich wines using different aromatic fractions recovered during fermentations of Sauvignon Blanc must. By means of threshold determination and generic descriptive analysis using a trained sensory panel, the aromatic fractions were characterized, selected, and clustered. The selected fractions were grouped, re-assessed, and validated by the trained panel. A consumer panel assessed overall liking and answered a CATA question on some enriched wines and their ideal sample. Differences in elicitation rates between non-enriched and enriched wines with respect to the ideal product highlighted product optimization and the role of aromatic enrichment. Enrichment with aromatic fractions increased the aromatic quality of wines and enhanced consumer appreciation.

Application of a Pivot Profile Variant Using CATA Questions in the Development of a Whey-Based Fermented Beverage

During the development of a food product, the application of rapid descriptive sensory methodologies is very useful to determine the influence of different variables on the sensory characteristics of the product under development. The Pivot profile (PP) and a variant of the technique that includes check-all-that-apply questions (PP + CATA) were used for the development of a milk drink fermented from demineralised sweet whey. Starting from a base formula of partially demineralised sweet whey and gelatin, nine samples were elaborated, to which various concentrations of commercial sucrose, modified cassava starch, and whole milk powder were added. Differences in sucrose content affected the sample texture and flavour and the modified starch was able to decrease the fluidity and increase the texture of creaminess and firmness, of the samples. The two applied sensory methodologies achieved good discrimination between the samples and very similar results, although the data analysis was clearly simplified in relation to the difficulty and time consumed in the PP + CATA variant.