To the Editor: Historically, the specific diagnosis of cicatricial alopecia using histology alone has remained elusive or impossible.1Mirmirani P. Willey A. Headington J.T. Stenn K. McCalmont T.H. Price V.H. Primary cicatricial alopecia: histopathologic findings do not distinguish clinical variants.J Am Acad Dermatol. 2005; 52: 637-643Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (115) Google Scholar Acne keloidalis (AK) is a form of primary cicatricial alopecia, characterized by a mixed (lymphocytic and neutrophilic) infiltrate centered in the follicular isthmus. With time, there is thinning of the isthmic follicular epithelium and, eventually, clinically keloidal scarring associated with a foreign body granulomatous reaction, that is secondary to follicular destruction. Patients with AK exhibit features overlapping with other forms of alopecia.2Olsen E.A. Bergfeld W.F. Cotsarelis G. et al.Summary of North American Hair Research Society (NAHRS)-sponsored workshop on cicatricial alopecia, Duke University Medical Center, February 10 and 11, 2001.J Am Acad Dermatol. 2003; 48: 103-110Abstract Full Text Full Text PDF PubMed Scopus (291) Google Scholar In their recent AK series, Cheng et al3Cheng A.Y. Lee C.N. Hsieh F.N. et al.“Spade sign” and inflammation/fibrosis limited to the upper and mid-dermis as the pathognomonic features of acne keloidalis.J Dermatol. 2020; 47: 41-46Crossref PubMed Scopus (3) Google Scholar proposed that the spade sign (SS) is a pathognomonic histopathologic feature. They defined the SS as a spade-shaped space (resembling the spade symbol in playing cards) created by the dilated and thinned follicular epithelium in the lower isthmus. They also coined the term “balloon sign” (BS) as a variant, identical to SS, except for its round shape. The required presence of trichilemmal keratinization is characterized by the presence of isthmic follicular keratinocytes with pale eosinophilic cytoplasm and by abrupt keratinization, forming compact eosinophilic orthokeratin. To evaluate the sensitivity and specificity of the SS in a clinically relevant differential diagnosis, we performed a case control study to search for the SS in a spectrum of clinically confirmed cases of cicatricial alopecia from the teaching files of the senior author (Dr Fung). The vertical sections of hematoxylin-eosin–stained specimens were analyzed for the presence of the SS or BS. Thirty-three specimens from different patients were assessed. The diagnoses included AK (9 patients), folliculitis decalvans (6 patients), central centrifugal cicatricial alopecia (4 patients), dissecting cellulitis (4 patients), lichen planopilaris (6 patients), frontal fibrosing alopecia (2 patients), traction alopecia (1 patient), and discoid lupus (1 patient). The SS was found in 3 (3/9, 33%) AK specimens (Fig 1). Two specimens had the SS and BS in different affected follicles, whereas the third case had only the SS. The SS or BS was not present in the other cases. Upon comparing AK with all other forms of cicatricial alopecia, the sensitivity and specificity of the SS or BS for AK was found to be 33% and 100%, respectively. A single structure in 1 case of frontal fibrosing alopecia was classified as “pseudo-SS.” Although the follicular epithelium was dilated and thinned, it was located superficially and contained basket-weave orthokeratin. This superficial milia-type plugging, containing basophilic orthokeratin, may be seen in patients with frontal fibrosing alopecia and should not be confused with the SS (Fig 2).Fig 2Pseudospade sign or pseudo-balloon sign in a case of frontal fibrosing alopecia. The more superficial location of this structure is associated with epidermal keratinization in its superior portion, including a granular layer and loose, basophilic orthokeratin content, as is characteristic of comedones, milia, and epidermal inclusion cysts. (Original magnification: ×100).View Large Image Figure ViewerDownload Hi-res image Download (PPT) Our study suggests that the SS or BS is a highly specific feature of AK. Cheng et al3Cheng A.Y. Lee C.N. Hsieh F.N. et al.“Spade sign” and inflammation/fibrosis limited to the upper and mid-dermis as the pathognomonic features of acne keloidalis.J Dermatol. 2020; 47: 41-46Crossref PubMed Scopus (3) Google Scholar also identified the SS or BS in exactly 33% (5/15) of their cases. The low sensitivity of the SS may reflect the fact that the SS or BS may only be appreciated during subacute AK, prior to follicular destruction. Although we have tended to regard AK and folliculitis decalvans as very similar histologically, we did not encounter SS in our folliculitis decalvans cases. Whether this represents an artifact of insufficient numbers of cases or a true difference in diagnostic specificity warrants further study. Our source of cases may represent a limitation because the teaching cases might have been biased toward more representative features than randomly selected cases. In summary, our findings support the fact that the SS is a highly specific or pathognomonic histopathologic feature of AK. Although the absence of the SS does not argue against AK, the presence of the SS supports its diagnosis. None disclosed. The authors thank Dr María Rashidi Springall, PhD, for assistance with the statistical analysis.
Read full abstract