Carcinogenic Potency In Rodents Research Articles

Mechanisms of Nitrosamine Mutagenicity and Their Relationship to Rodent Carcinogenic Potency.

A thorough literature review was undertaken to understand how the pathways of N-nitrosamine transformation relate to mutagenic potential and carcinogenic potency in rodents. Empirical and computational evidence indicates that a common radical intermediate is created by CYP-mediated hydrogen abstraction at the α-carbon; it is responsible for both activation, leading to the formation of DNA-reactive diazonium species, and deactivation by denitrosation. There are competing sites of CYP metabolism (e.g., β-carbon), and other reactive species can form following initial bioactivation, although these alternative pathways tend to decrease rather than enhance carcinogenic potency. The activation pathway, oxidative dealkylation, is a common reaction in drug metabolism and evidence indicates that the carbonyl byproduct, e.g., formaldehyde, does not contribute to the toxic properties of N-nitrosamines. Nitric oxide (NO), a side product of denitrosation, can similarly be discounted as an enhancer of N-nitrosamine toxicity based on carcinogenicity data for substances that act as NO-donors. However, not all N-nitrosamines are potent rodent carcinogens. In a significant number of cases, there is a potency overlap with non-N-nitrosamine carcinogens that are not in the Cohort of Concern (CoC; high-potency rodent carcinogens comprising aflatoxin-like-, N-nitroso-, and alkyl-azoxy compounds), while other N-nitrosamines are devoid of carcinogenic potential. In this context, mutagenicity is a useful surrogate for carcinogenicity, as proposed in the ICH M7 (R2) (2023) guidance. Thus, in the safety assessment and control of N-nitrosamines in medicines, it is important to understand those complementary attributes of mechanisms of mutagenicity and structure-activity relationships that translate to elevated potency versus those which are associated with a reduction in, or absence of, carcinogenic potency.

Mechanistic QSAR of aromatic amines: New models for discriminating between homocyclic mutagens and nonmutagens, and validation of models for carcinogens

Because of its environmental and industrial importance, the aromatic amines are the single chemical class most studied for its ability to induce mutations and cancer. The large database of mutagenicity and carcinogenicity results has been studied with Quantitative Structure-Activity Relationship (QSAR) approaches by several authors, leading to models for the following: (a) the mutagenic potency in Salmonella thyphimurium; (b) the carcinogenic potency in rodents; and (c) the discrimination between rodent carcinogens and noncarcinogens. However, satisfactory models for the discrimination between mutagens and nonmutagens are lacking. The present work provides new QSARs for mutagenic/nonmutagenic homocyclic aromatic amines in S. typhimurium strains TA98 and TA100. The two new models are validated by checking their ability to predict the mutagenicity of further aromatic amines not included in the training set, and not used to generate the QSAR models. In addition, we also validated previous QSAR models for the carcinogenicity/noncarcinogenicity of the aromatic amines with external data. The mechanistic implications of the models are discussed in light of the other QSARs for the aromatic amines. The results of the analysis point to two QSAR models (one for mutagenicity and one for rodent carcinogenicity) as reliable tools for the in silico characterization of the risk posed by the aromatic amines.

Tumor profiles and carcinogenic potency in rodents and humans: Value for cancer risk assessment

Tumor profiles and carcinogenic potency in rodents and humans: Value for cancer risk assessment Romualdo Benigni a & Alessandro Giuliani b a Laboratory of Comparative Toxicology and Ecotoxicology , Istituto Superiore di Sanita’ , Viale Regina Elena 299, Rome, 00161, Italy E-mail: b Laboratory of Comparative Toxicology and Ecotoxicology , Istituto Superiore di Sanita’ , Viale Regina Elena 299, Rome, 00161, Italy Published online: 19 Nov 2008.

Germ cell mutagenesis in Drosophila: multiple endpoint analysis.

Genotoxic carcinogens, able to damage DNA by alkylation reactions, represent a very diverse class of agents which are capable of producing a wide range of DNA modifications. The mechanisms leading to genetic changes as a result of exposure to alkylating agents (AAs) have been studied in male germ cells of Drosophila using a structure-activity relationship approach (SAR). The analytical tools available concern both genetic and molecular assays. The genetic tests enable to quantify excision repair and clastogenic potency of the AA after treatment of post-meiotic male germ cells and to determine the degree of germ-cell specificity, i.e., the mutagenic effectiveness in post- versus premeiotic cell stages. For a selected group of alkylating agents the molecular spectra have been studied in post-meiotic cell stages. On the basis of these descriptors clear SAR's between genotoxic activity in germ cells and physico-chemical parameters (s-values and O6/N7-alkylguanine adducts) and carcinogenic potency in rodents became apparent, resulting in five distinct classes of alkylating agents so far. These classes are: 1) SN2-type monofunctional AAs, 2) SN1-type monofunctional AAs, 3) polyfunctional AAs, 4) agents able to form etheno-DNA adducts, and 5) aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) a bulky-adduct forming agent. The recent finding that the molecular data obtained with Drosophila and data of the specific locus tests in male mice show remarkable similarities for most genotoxic agents supports the view that Drosophila is a useful model system for the study of transgenerational damage.

Pesticide residues in food: investigation of disparities in cancer risk estimates.

Much of the public perceives that exposure to synthetic pesticide residues in the diet is a major cause of cancer. The National Research Council (NRC), in a 1987 report, Regulating Pesticides in Food: The Delaney Paradox, evaluated cancer risks for 29 pesticides that are rodent carcinogens and estimated that the risks for 23 were greater than one-in-a-million. In contrast, our group has ranked possible carcinogenic hazards from a variety of human exposures to rodent carcinogens using the HERP (Human Exposure/Rodent Potency) index, and found that dietary residues of synthetic pesticides ranked low. This paper evaluates the disparities in these analyses by examining the two components of risk assessment: carcinogenic potency in rodents and human exposure. Potency estimates based on rodent bioassay data are shown to be similar whether calculated, as in the NRC report, as the regulatory q1* or as TD50. In contrast, estimates of dietary exposure to residues of synthetic pesticides vary enormously, depending on whether they are based on the Theoretical Maximum Residue Contribution (TMRC) calculated by the Environmental Protection Agency vs. the average dietary residues measured by the Food and Drug Administration in the Total Diet Study (TDS). The TMRC is the theoretical maximum human exposure anticipated under the most severe field application conditions, which are far greater than dietary residues measured in the TDS. Several independent exposure studies suggest that the FDA dietary residues are reasonable estimates of average human exposures, whereas TMRC values are large overestimates. Using standard methodology and measured dietary residues in the TDS, the estimate of excess cancer risk from average lifetime exposure to synthetic pesticide residues in the diet appears to be less than one-in-a-million for each of the ten pesticides for which adequate data were available.

Relevance of different biological assays in assessing initiating and promoting properties of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons with respect to carcinogenic potency

The results from assays that describe biological effects of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH) were explored using multivariate methods. Based on the availability of data, 29 PAH were included in the study. Five variables described the carcinogenic potency in rodents of the PAH. Biological effects were assayed using 14 variables. These included bacterial mutagenicity, enhancement and inhibition of bacterial mutagenicity, Ah receptor (AhR) affinity, and induction of enzymes that bioactivate many PAH to proximal bacterial mutagens. A principal components analysis (PCA) showed that the highest correlations with the cancer data were observed for variables describing AhR affinity, whereas bacterial mutagenicity data were poorly correlated with cancer data. When a partial least squares (PLS) regression analysis was applied, only one bacterial mutagenicity variable, but all AhR affinity variables were statistically relevant to describe carcinogenic potency. The latter variables were also correlated with the inhibition of bacterial mutagenicity of benzo[ a]pyrene. It was concluded that structural requirements for AhR affinity are the same as those required for metabolism by enzymes that bioactivate benzo(a)pyrene. Negative correlations between mutagenicity and induction of enzymes were observed. The roles of cancer initiation and cancer promotion are discussed regarding the biological properties studied. It is proposed that bacterial mutagenicity reflects the cancer initiation potency, whereas the AhR affinity reflects the promotive effect of some PAH at the high doses applied in rodent carcinogenicity tests. It is thus indicated that initiation and promotion are provoked by different chemical species: reactive metabolites and the parent hydrocarbons, respectively. At doses reflecting a normal human exposure situation the effects of initiation may be more important in the course of chemical carcinogenesis. The mechanisms of cancer initiation and cancer promotion should therefore be studied in more detail for reliable quantitative risk assessments.

DNA damage, and repair in mutagenesis and carcinogenesis: implications of structure-activity relationships for cross-species extrapolation

Previous studies on structure-activity relationships (SARs) between types of DNA modifications and tumour incidence revealed linear positive relationships between the log TD 50 estimates and s-values for a series of mostly monofunctional alkylating agents. The overall objective of this STEP project was to further elucidate the mechanistic principles underlying these correlations, because detailed knowledge on mechanisms underlying the formation of genotoxic damage is an absolute necessity for establishing guidance values for exposures to genotoxic agents. The analysis included: (1) the re-calculation and further extension of TD 50 values in mmol/kg body weight for chemicals carcinogenic in rodents. This part further included the checking up data for Swain-Scott s-values and the use of the covalent binding index (CBI); (2) the elaboration of genetic toxicity including an analysis of induced mutation spectra in specific genes at the DNA level, i.e., the vermilion gene of Drosophila, a plasmid system (pX2 assay) and the HPRT gene in cultured mammalian cells (CHO-9); and (3) the measurement of specific DNA alkylation adducts in animal models (mouse, rat, hamster) and mammalian cells in culture. The analysis of mechanisms controlling the expression of mammalian DNA repair genes (alkyltransferases, glycosylases) as a function of the cell type, differentiation stage, and cellular microenvironment in mammalian cells. The 3 classes of genotoxic carcinogens selected for the project were: (1) chemicals forming monoalkyl adducts upon interaction with DNA; (2) genotoxins capable of forming DNA etheno-adducts; and (3) N-substituted aryl compounds forming covalent adducts at the C8 position of guanine in DNA. In general, clear SARs and AARs (activity-activity relationships) between physiochemical parameters ( s-values, 0 6/ N7-alkylguanine ratios, CBI), carcinogenic potency in rodents and several descriptors of genotoxic activity in germ cells (mouse, Drosophila) became apparent when the following descriptors were used: TD 50 estimates (lifetime doses expressed in mg/kg b.wt. or mmol/kg b.wt.) from cancer bioassays in rodents; the degree of germ-cell specificity, i.e., the ability of a genotoxic agent to induce mutations in practically all cell stages of the male germ-cell cycle of Drosophila (this project) and the mouse (literature search), as opposed to a more specific response in postmeiotic stages of both species; the M exr−/M exr+ hypermutability ratio, determined in a repair assay utilizing Drosophila germ cells; mutation spectra induced at single loci (the 7 loci used in the specific-locus test of the mouse (published data), and the vermilion gene of Drosophila); and doubling doses (DD) in mg/kg (mmol/kg) for specific locus test results on mice. By and large, the TD 50 values, the inverse of which can be considered as measures of carcinogenic potency, were shown to be predictable from knowledge of the in vivo doses associated with the absorbed amounts of the investigated alkylators and with the second-order constant, k c, reaction at a critical nucleophilic strength, n c. For alkylating agents k c can be expressed as the second-order rate constant for hydrolysis, k H 2O , and the substrate constant s: k H 2O TD 50 is a function of a certain accumulated degree of alkylation, here given as the (average) daily increment, a c, for 2 years exposure of the rodents. The TD 50 in mmol/kg × day) could then be written: T−fsD 50 ∗= a c×λ k H 2O ×10 nc s . This expression would be valid for monofunctional alkylators provided the reactive species are uncharged. This is the case for most S N2 reagents. Although it appears possible to predict carcinogenic potency from measured in vivo doses and from detailed knowledge of reaction-kinetic parameter values, it is at present not possible to quantify the uncertainty of such predictions. One main reason for this is the complication due to uneven distribution in the body, with effects on the dose in target tissues. The estimation can be improved by considering the distribution of dose in the body. In the present analysis, direct-acting alkylators were studied. It is evident that dosimetry and reaction-kinetic characterization of genotoxic metabolites would render it possible to predict the potency of precarcinogens as well.

Heterocyclic amines formed by cooking food: comparison of bioassay results with other chemicals in the Carcinogenic Potency Database.

Results in the Carcinogenic Potency Database (CPDB) on 11 mutagenic heterocyclic amines (HA) tested for carcinogenicity in rats, mice and cynomolgus monkeys are compared to results for other chemicals. An analysis of strength of evidence of carcinogenicity for HA vs. other mutagenic carcinogens and vs. all rodent carcinogens, indicates strong carcinogenicity of HA in terms of positivity rates and multiplicity of target sites. The liver is the most frequent target site in each species. Despite several target sites in each species, concordance in target sites between rats and mice is restricted to the liver for each HA except one. In cynomolgus monkeys, liver tumors have been induced rapidly by 2-amino-3-methylimidazo[4,5-f]quinoline (IQ). Human exposures to HA in cooked animal foods are small, in the low ppb range. A comparison of possible carcinogenic hazards from a variety of exposures to rodent carcinogens in the American diet is presented, using an index (Human Exposure/Rodent Potency, HERP) that relates human exposure to carcinogenic potency in rodents. Results indicate that there is a large background of exposures to naturally-occurring rodent carcinogens in typical portions of common foods, and that possible hazards from HA rank below those of most natural pesticides and products of cooking or food preparation; synthetic pesticide residues also rank low.

Quantitative correlation of mutagenic and carcinogenic potencies for heterocyclic amines from cooked foods and additional aromatic amines

Aromatic amines have long been recognized as animal and human carcinogens. Recently heterocyclic aromatic amines (thermic amines) have been found in small amounts in cooked foods, primarily meats, and have proven to be potent mutagens and rodent carcinogens. Availability of quantitative databases for mutagenic potency in Salmonella and for carcinogenic potency in rodents has made possible a study of ten heterocyclic thermic amines and 24 aromatic amines. Potencies on mutagenic and carcinogenic scales were significantly correlated. By multiple linear regression analysis and multivariate analysis of variance, two descriptive structural factors were found to modulate the two modes of biological response. These factors were number of rings and methyl substitution at carbon atoms. The quantitative correlation between mutagenic and carcinogenic potencies and the modulating structural factors suggest a significant similarity of molecular mechanisms and support the utility of the short-term bacterial assay in evaluating hazard levels.

Genotoxic potency of monofunctional alkylating agents in E. coli: comparison with carcinogenic potency in rodents

A quantitative correlation between carcinogeneity and genotoxicity was investigated by a comparison between the carcinogenic potency in rodens and mutagenic (M), recombinogenic (R) and SOS-inducting (I) potencies in a bacterial test ( E. coli multitest) for 9 monofunctional alkylating agents: N-methylurethane, N-nitroso- N-ethylrurea, epichlorohydrin, N-nitroso- N-methylurea, N-nitroso- N-methyl- N′- nitroguanidine, methyl methanesulfonate, diethylsulfate, ethyl methanesulfonate. A significant positive correlation between the carcinogenic potency and the product of the mutagenic and recombigenic potencies was found for all tested compounds. Thus, the E. coli multitest may be used as a simple test to search for correlations between carcinogenicity and genotoxicity of DNA-damaging agents.

Quantitative relationship between mutagenic potency in the Ara test of Salmonella typhimurium and carcinogenic potency in rodents. A study of 11 direct-acting monofunctional alkylating agents

This work attempted to derive a quantitative relationship between mutagenicity and carcinogenicity by examining the association between mutagenic potency in the Ara test of Salmonella typhimurium and carcinogenic potency in rodents. Mutagenesis was monitored by selecting forward mutations to L-arabinose resistance. Lethality was measured at equivalent experimental conditions to those of mutant yield by using a mixed population of a pair of isogenic strains distinguished by their differential nutritional requirements. The study was carried out with a group of 11 direct-acting monofunctional alkylating agents, which failed to show any quantitative correlation in the histidine reverse-mutation test. Our data suggest that the mutagenic efficiency of the compounds is directly proportional to the magnitude of the maximum yield of L-arabinose resistance mutants and inversely proportional to the dose and the number of lethal hits at which the maximum yield occurs. A highly significant correlation (r10 = 0.86, P less than 0.01) was found between the mutagenic efficiencies of the compounds in the Ara test and their carcinogenic potencies in rodents, expressed as TD50 ('tumor dose' 50) values. The result suggests that the Ara forward-mutation test of S. typhimurium might be capable of reflecting the relative potency of animal carcinogens, at least when confined to particular chemical classes. A more generic and definitive conclusion about the predictive value of the Ara test would require this analysis to be extended to other types of genotoxic carcinogens.

Nucleophilic selectivity of alkylating agents and their hypermutability in Drosophila as predictors of carcinognic potency in rodents

The nucleophilic selectivity (Swain-Scott s constant or initial 7-alkylguanine/O6-alkylguanine ratio in DNA) of 60 alkylating agents, mostly monofunctional or cross-linking was compared to their carcinogenic potency in rodents (median TD50 estimates) and to two genotoxicity indices in Drosophila: (i) hypermutability, measured by the increased frequency of induced sex-linked recessive lethal mutations (SLRL) in a strain defective in DNA excision repair (exr-), as compared to the wild-type (exr+); (ii) relative clastogenic efficiency, expressed by the ratio of chromosomal aberrations (ring-X loss) to SLRL determined in the exr+ strain. For a subset of direct-acting, monofunctional alkylating agents, nucleophilic selectivity and TD50 values or hypermutability indices were linearly correlated. In addition, the hypermutability indices in Drosophila by methylating or ethylating procarcinogens were similar to the corresponding values of their ultimate metabolites. In contrast, cross-linking agents, including antitumour drugs, did not show these positive correlations. The relative clastogenic efficiencies in Drosophila of 26 direct-acting, alkylating carcinogens increased with both their cross-linking activity and nucleophilic selectivity. By analyzing mutational spectra in Drosophila induced in the vermilion gene by four monofunctional alkylating agents with contrasting s values, critical DNA lesions, i.e. type of base pair substitution mutations, deletions, insertions, involved in genotoxicity were pinpointed. Thus, these multi-endpoint analyses should, as a new approach, assist in the quantitative risk evaluation of genotoxic agents.

Prevalence of genotoxic chemicals among animal and human carcinogens evaluated in the IARC Monograph Series.

To determine whether genotoxic and non-genotoxic carcinogens contribute similarly to the cancer burden in humans, an analysis was performed on agents that were evaluated in Supplements 6 and 7 to the IARC Monographs for their carcinogenic effects in humans and animals and for the activity in short-term genotoxicity tests. The prevalence of genotoxic carcinogens on four groups of agents, consisting of established human carcinogens (group 1, n = 30), probable human carcinogens (group 2A, n = 37), possible human carcinogens (group 2B, n = 113) and on agents with limited evidence of carcinogenicity in animals (a subset of group 3, n = 149) was determined. A high prevalence in the order of 80 to 90% of genotoxic carcinogens was found in each of the groups 1, 2A and 2B, which were also shown to be multi-species/multi-tissues carcinogens. The distribution of carcinogenic potency in rodents did not reveal any specific characteristic of the human carcinogens in group 1 that would differentiate them from agents in groups 2A, 2B and 3. The results of this analysis indicate that (a) an agent with unknown carcinogenic potential showing sufficient evidence of activity in in vitro/in vivo genotoxicity assays (involving as endpoints DNA damage and chromosomal/mutational damage) may represent a hazard to humans; and b) an agent showing lack of activity in this spectrum of genotoxicity assays should undergo evaluation for carcinogenicity by rodent bioassay, in view of the present lack of validated short-term tests for non-genotoxic carcinogens. Overall, this analysis implies that genotoxic carcinogens add more to the cancer burden in man than non-genotoxic carcinogens. Thus, identification of such genotoxic carcinogens and subsequent lowering of exposure will remain the main goal for primary cancer prevention in man.

Carcinogenic potency in rodents versus genotoxic potency in E. coli: a correlation analysis for bifunctional alkylating agents

The mutagenic (M), recombinagenic (R) and SOS inducing (I) potencies of 6 bifunctional directly acting alkylating agents (mitomycin C, thiotepa, chlorambucil, nitrogen mustard, bis(2-chloroethyl)ether and bis(2-chloroethyl)nitrosourea) were measured in an E. coli test system ( E. coli multitest) as the integral under the yield-dose curve obtained for each event. This potency crresponds to the cumulative yield of the affected cell population over the entire effective dose range of the chemical treatment. A weak mutagenic activity was detected only for mitomycin C and thiotepa. Except for bis(2-chloroethyl)ether, all agents were recombinagenic and SOS inducing. When the 3 genotoxic potencies (M, R and I) of these bifunctional alkylating agents were correlated, separately or in combination, with the respective carcinogenic potencies in rodents, a highly significant correlation was obtained with both the recombinagenic and SOS inducing potencies.

Quantitative comparison of carcinogenicity, mutagenicity and electrophilicity of 10 direct-acting alkylating agents and of the initial O6: 7-alkylguanine ratio in DNA with carcinogenic potency in rodents

The quantitative relationship between carcinogenicity in rodents and mutagenicity in Salmonella typhimurium was examined, by using 10 monofunctional alkylating agents, including N-nitrosamides, alkyl methanesulfonates, epoxides, β-propiolactone and 1,3-propane sultone. The compounds were assayed for mutagenicity in two S. typhimurium strains (TA1535 and TA100) and in plate and liquid assays. The mutagenic activity of the agents was compared with their alkylating activity towards 4-(4′-nitrobenzyl)pyridine and with their half-lives (solvolysis constants) in an aqueous medium. No correlations between these variables were found, nor was mutagenic activity correlated with estimates of carcinogenicity in rodents. There was a positive relationship between carcinogenicity and the initial ratios of 7-: O 6-alkylguanine formed or expected after their reaction with double-stranded DNA in vitro. The results suggest that alkylation of guanine at position O 6 (or at other O atoms of DNA bases) may be a critical DNA-base modification that determines the overall carcinogenicity of these alkylating agents in rodents.