While microvascular cerebral capillary networks are known to be highly heterogeneous, previous computational models have predicted that heterogeneous cerebral capillary flow patterns result in lower brain tissue partial oxygen pressures. Moreover, as blood flow increases, the flux among capillaries homogenizes. This homogenization of flow is expected to improve the efficiency of oxygenation extraction from the blood. In this work, we use mathematical modeling to explore a possible functional role for the high degree of heterogeneity observed in cerebral capillary networks. Our results suggest that heterogeneity allows for a greater response of tissue oxygen levels to local changes in vessel diameters due to neuronal activation. This result is confirmed for a full 3-dimensional model of capillary networks that includes oxygen diffusion within the tissue region and a reduced model that accounts for changes in capillary blood flow.