Reviewed by: Canada’s Jews: In Time, Space and Spirit ed. by Ira Robinson Dana Herman (bio) Canada’s Jews: In Time, Space and Spirit. Edited by Ira Robinson. Brighton, MA: Academic Studies Press, 2013. 501 pp. With the approach of Canada’s sesquicentennial in 2017, the time is ripe for Ira Robinson’s edited volume, Canada’s Jews: In Time, Space and Spirit. It surveys the myriad ways in which Jews have contributed to the fabric of Canadian society from its origins to the present day—not only in the well-known urban centers of Montreal, Toronto, and Vancouver, but in smaller cities and towns scattered across the country. Robinson’s aim for the volume is straightforward but difficult to achieve: to present “a comprehensive, if necessarily imperfect, portrait of Canadian Jewry in time, space, and spirit” (11). The book includes the contributions of twenty-five academics, archivists, and journalists. As is typical of edited volumes, the quality of the articles and the treatment of topics is uneven. [End Page 355] The book consists of three parts. The first, “In Time,” is a history of the Jews in Canada. It recounts the Jewish presence in New France, moves regrettably quickly through the eighteenth century, and covers the eastern European migration through two articles, one on Jewish farming colonies and the other on the immigrants’ impact on the communities of Canada’s two major provinces, Quebec and Ontario. The section ends with two excellent essays by Jack Lipinsky and Franklin Bialystok on Canadian Jewish history in the twentieth century and the first decade of the twenty-first. Lipinsky’s article, “In Search of Unity: Anti-Semitism, Zionism, and the Canadian Jewish Congress to 1945,” traces organizational growth of the community on both the local federation level as well as the national level with the establishment of the Federation of Zionist Societies of Canada and then with the Canadian Jewish Congress in 1919 and its subsequent revival in 1934. Bialystok breaks with current scholarship by presenting the history of Canada’s Jews from 1945–2011 as the “postwar period” and shows how many Canadian Jews still “cling to the legacy of the Holocaust” through their unconditional support of Israel and their fear of antisemitism in Canada (117). The second section, “In Space,” combines history with sociology and political science in offering an assessment of “Jews in Contemporary Canada.” Each of the articles—with the exception of quick and insufficient surveys of Jews in Atlantic Canada and Winnipeg—offers readers a window onto the current makeup of Canadian Jewry, with particular focus on its three largest population centers. Yolande Cohen’s outstanding piece on Sephardi Jews of Montreal—mostly of Moroccan origin—really captures what Robinson was aiming for with this volume: It provides a succinct history of Sephardic Jewry with its large migration to Quebec in the late 1950s and 1960s and weaves a rich narrative through the decades of the twentieth century, showing how these French-speaking Jews established a firm and lasting hold in Quebec society. Her bibliography also helpfully points readers to up-to-date sources that speak to the transnational nature of Sephardic Jewish life. Michael Brown focuses on three changing areas of Jewish life in Toronto: education, governance, and antisemitism—more specifically, the antisemitic events and fallout surrounding the February 2009 press conference called by a group of mostly Jewish student members of Hillel who were opposed to pro-Palestinian actions taken by York University’s Federation of Students. As Brown points out, we are still learning the lessons from the “battle of York University.” The last section dealing with the “spirit” of Canadian Jewry is the most uneven, perhaps because it tries to cover too much material. Rebecca Margolis is an expert on Yiddish in Canada and she explores [End Page 356] the strong connections among Yiddishists on both sides of the border. Richard Menkis’s excellent articles on Reform and Conservative Judaism (with attention paid to Reconstructionist Judaism and the Jewish Renewal movement) as well as William Shaffir’s piece on Hasidim should have been complemented by an equally strong article on Orthodoxy in Canada, but unfortunately that is not the case. Alexander Hart...
Read full abstract