Calcification Paradox Research Articles

Altered Caveolin-1 Dynamics Result in Divergent Mineralization Responses in Bone and Vascular Calcification.

Though vascular smooth muscle cells adopt an osteogenic phenotype during pathological vascular calcification, clinical studies note an inverse correlation between bone mineral density and arterial mineral-also known as the calcification paradox. Both processes are mediated by extracellular vesicles (EVs) that sequester calcium and phosphate. Calcifying EV formation in the vasculature requires caveolin-1 (CAV1), a membrane scaffolding protein that resides in membrane invaginations (caveolae). Of note, caveolin-1-deficient mice, however, have increased bone mineral density. We hypothesized that caveolin-1 may play divergent roles in calcifying EV formation from vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) and osteoblasts (HOBs). Primary human coronary artery VSMCs and osteoblasts were cultured for up to 28days in an osteogenic media. CAV1 expression was knocked down using siRNA. Methyl β-cyclodextrin (MβCD) and a calpain inhibitor were used, respectively, to disrupt and stabilize the caveolar domains in VSMCs and HOBs. CAV1 genetic variation demonstrates significant inverse relationships between bone-mineral density (BMD) and coronary artery calcification (CAC) across two independent epidemiological cohorts. Culture in osteogenic (OS) media increased calcification in HOBs and VSMCs. siRNA knockdown of CAV1 abrogated VSMC calcification with no effect on osteoblast mineralization. MβCD-mediated caveolae disruption led to a 3-fold increase of calcification in VSMCs treated with osteogenic media (p < 0.05) but hindered osteoblast mineralization (p < 0.01). Conversely, stabilizing caveolae by calpain inhibition prevented VSMC calcification (p < 0.05) without affecting osteoblast mineralization. There was no significant difference in CAV1 content between lipid domains from HOBs cultured in OS and control media. Our data indicate fundamental cellular-level differences in physiological and pathophysiological mineralization mediated by CAV1 dynamics. This is the first study to suggest that divergent mechanisms in calcifying EV formation may play a role in the calcification paradox. The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s12195-023-00779-7.

Nephrolithiasis: A Red Flag for Cardiovascular Risk.

Epidemiological evidence shows that nephrolithiasis is associated with cardiovascular (CV) morbidities. The association between nephrolithiasis and CV disease is not surprising because both diseases share conditions that facilitate their development. Metabolic conditions, encompassed in the definition of metabolic syndrome (MS), and habits that promote nephrolithiasis by altering urine composition also promote clinical manifestations of CV disease. By inducing oxidative stress, these conditions cause endothelial dysfunction and increased arterial stiffness, which are both well-known predictors of CV disease. Furthermore, the subtle systemic metabolic acidosis observed in stone formers with CV disease may have a pathogenic role by increasing bone turnover and leading to reduced mineral content and osteoporosis/osteopenia. Heart valves and/or coronary artery and aortic calcifications are frequently associated with reduced mineral density. This is known as the ‘calcification paradox’ in osteoporosis and has also been observed in subjects with calcium nephrolithiasis. Evidence supports the hypothesis that osteoporosis/osteopenia is an independent risk factor for the development of CV calcifications. In the long term, episodes of renal stones may occur from the onset of metabolic derangements/MS to arterial stiffness/atherosclerosis and CV morbidities. These episodes should be considered a warning sign of an ongoing and silent atherosclerotic process. The evaluation of cardiometabolic risk factors and MS components should be routine in the assessment of renal stone formers. This would allow for treatment and prevention of the development of CV complications, which are much more severe for the patient and for public health.

Extracellular vesicles signal from bones to vessels: an answer to the 'calcification paradox'?

Extracellular vesicles signal from bones to vessels: an answer to the 'calcification paradox'?

Circulating Monocytes Act as a Common Trigger for the Calcification Paradox of Osteoporosis and Carotid Atherosclerosis via TGFB1-SP1 and TNFSF10-NFKB1 Axis.

BackgroundOsteoporosis often occurs with carotid atherosclerosis and causes contradictory calcification across tissue in the same patient, which is called the “calcification paradox”. Circulating monocytes may be responsible for this unbalanced ectopic calcification. Here, we aimed to show how CD14+ monocytes contribute to the pathophysiology of coexisting postmenopausal osteoporosis and carotid atherosclerosis.MethodsWe comprehensively analyzed osteoporosis data from the mRNA array dataset GSE56814 and the scRNA-seq dataset GSM4423510. Carotid atherosclerosis data were obtained from the GSE23746 mRNA dataset and GSM4705591 scRNA-seq dataset. First, osteoblast and vascular SMC lineages were annotated based on their functional expression using gene set enrichment analysis and AUCell scoring. Next, pseudotime analysis was applied to draw their differentiated trajectory and identify the key gene expression changes in crossroads. Then, ligand–receptor interactions between CD14+ monocytes and osteoblast and vascular smooth muscle cell (SMC) lineages were annotated with iTALK. Finally, we selected calcification paradox-related expression in circulating monocytes with LASSO analysis.ResultsFirst, we found a large proportion of delayed premature osteoblasts in osteoporosis and osteogenic SMCs in atherosclerosis. Second, CD14+ monocytes interacted with the intermediate cells of the premature osteoblast and osteogenic SMC lineage by delivering TGFB1 and TNFSF10. This interaction served as a trigger activating the transcription factors (TF) SP1 and NFKB1 to upregulate the inflammatory response and cell senescence and led to a retarded premature state in the osteoblast lineage and osteogenic transition in the SMC lineage. Then, 76.49% of common monocyte markers were upregulated in the circulating monocytes between the two diseases, which were related to chemotaxis and inflammatory responses. Finally, we identified 7 calcification paradox-related genes on circulating monocytes, which were upregulated in aging cells and downregulated in DNA repair cells, indicating that the aging monocytes contributed to the development of the two diseases.ConclusionsOur work provides a perspective for understanding the triggering roles of CD14+ monocytes in the development of the calcification paradox in osteoporosis- and atherosclerosis-related cells based on combined scRNA and mRNA data. This study provided us with an elucidation of the mechanisms underlying the calcification paradox and could help in developing preventive and therapeutic strategies.

Aged bone matrix-derived extracellular vesicles as a messenger for calcification paradox

Adipocyte differentiation of bone marrow mesenchymal stem/stromal cells (BMSCs) instead of osteoblast formation contributes to age- and menopause-related marrow adiposity and osteoporosis. Vascular calcification often occurs with osteoporosis, a contradictory association called “calcification paradox”. Here we show that extracellular vesicles derived from aged bone matrix (AB-EVs) during bone resorption favor BMSC adipogenesis rather than osteogenesis and augment calcification of vascular smooth muscle cells. Intravenous or intramedullary injection of AB-EVs promotes bone-fat imbalance and exacerbates Vitamin D3 (VD3)-induced vascular calcification in young or old mice. Alendronate (ALE), a bone resorption inhibitor, down-regulates AB-EVs release and attenuates aging- and ovariectomy-induced bone-fat imbalance. In the VD3-treated aged mice, ALE suppresses the ovariectomy-induced aggravation of vascular calcification. MiR-483-5p and miR-2861 are enriched in AB-EVs and essential for the AB-EVs-induced bone-fat imbalance and exacerbation of vascular calcification. Our study uncovers the role of AB-EVs as a messenger for calcification paradox by transferring miR-483-5p and miR-2861.

The Role of Gut Dysbiosis in the Bone-Vascular Axis in Chronic Kidney Disease.

Patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) are at increased risk of bone mineral density loss and vascular calcification. Bone demineralization and vascular mineralization often concur in CKD, similar to what observed in the general population. This contradictory association is commonly referred to as the ‘calcification paradox’ or the bone–vascular axis. Mounting evidence indicates that CKD-associated gut dysbiosis may be involved in the pathogenesis of the bone–vascular axis. A disrupted intestinal barrier function, a metabolic shift from a predominant saccharolytic to a proteolytic fermentation pattern, and a decreased generation of vitamin K may, alone or in concert, drive a vascular and skeletal pathobiology in CKD patients. A better understanding of the role of gut dysbiosis in the bone–vascular axis may open avenues for novel therapeutics, including nutriceuticals.

Osteoporosis Entwined with Cardiovascular Disease: The Implication of Osteoprotegerin and the Example of Statins

Beyond being epiphenomenon of shared epidemiological factors, the integration of Osteoporosis (OP) with Cardiovascular Disease (CVD) - termed "calcification paradox" - reflects a continuum of aberrant cardiometabolic status. The present review provides background knowledge on "calcification paradox", focusing on the endocrine aspect of vasculature orchestrated by the osteoblastic molecular fingerprint of vascular cells, acquired via imbalance among established modulators of mineralization. Osteoprotegerin (OPG), the well-established osteoprotective cytokine, has recently been shown to exert a vessel-modifying role. Prompted by this notion, the present review interrogates OPG as the potential missing link between OP and CVD. However, so far, the confirmation of this hypothesis is hindered by the equivocal role of OPG in CVD, being both proatherosclerotic and antiatherosclerotic. Further research is needed to illuminate whether OPG could be a biomarker of the "calcification paradox". Moreover, the present review brings into prominence the dual role of statins - cardioprotective and osteoprotective - as a potential illustration of the integration of CVD with OP. Considering that the statins-induced modulation of OPG is central to the statins-driven osteoprotective signalling, statins could be suggested as an illustration of the role of OPG in the bone/vessels crosstalk, if further studies consolidate the contribution of OPG to the cardioprotective role of statins. Another outstanding issue that merits further evaluation is the inconsistency of the osteoprotective role of statins. Further understanding of the varying bone-modifying role of statins, likely attributed to the unique profile of different classes of statins defined by distinct physicochemical characteristics, may yield tangible benefits for treating simultaneously OP and CVD.

WITHDRAWN

The document associated with this DOI has been withdrawn.

WITHDRAWN

The document associated with this DOI has been withdrawn.

Role of NFATc1 in the Bone-Vascular Axis Calcification Paradox.

Nuclear factor of activated T cell cytoplasmic 1 (NFATc1), a crucial member of the transcription factor NFAT family, is indispensable in the immune system and the morphogenesis of cardiac valves and septa and is also vital in osteoclasts and atherosclerotic calcification. Currently, osteoporosis and vascular diseases are severely hazardous to health and quality of life, and the 2 conditions always coincide with each other. The bone-vascular axis calcification paradox serves as a bridge between bone and vascular diseases, linking these 2 seemingly separate diseases, and the receptor activator of NF-κB (RANK)/receptor activator of nuclear factor kappa-B ligand (RANKL)/osteoprotegerin (OPG) system may be the common mechanism of the bone-vascular axis calcification paradox. NFATc1 provides a new therapeutic target for bone and vascular diseases. However, the specific mechanism by which NFATc1 acts on the bone-vascular axis calcification paradox, whether NFATc1 is related to the RANK/RANKL/OPG system, and how to use NFATc1 as a therapeutic target to avoid its side effects in other systems requires further study.

Bone-Vascular Axis in Chronic Kidney Disease.

Patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) are at increased risk of osteoporosis and vascular calcification. Bone demineralization and vascular mineralization go often hand in hand in CKD, similar to as in the general population. This contradictory association is independent of aging and is commonly referred to as the "calcification paradox" or the bone-vascular axis. Various common risk factors and mechanisms have been identified. Alternatively, calcifying vessels may release circulating factors that affect bone metabolism, while bone disease may infer conditions that favor vascular calcification. The present review focuses on emerging concepts and major mechanisms involved in the bone-vascular axis in the setting of CKD. A better understanding of these concepts and mechanisms may identify therapeutics able to target and exert beneficial effects on bone and vasculature simultaneously.

Ligand trap for the activin type IIA receptor. The long-sought drug to overcome the calcification paradox in CKD?

The chronic kidney disease-mineral and bone disorder syndrome illustrates the association between a disturbed physiological bone turnover/mineralization and pathologic vascular mineralization; the so-called calcification paradox. This implies that treatments aimed atcuring bone disorders might have serious implications for cardiovascular health and vice versa. Hence, there is an urgent need for treatments that are able to break through this cross-talk. Hereto, compounds such as those interfering with activin type IIA receptor signaling and acting upstream of the Wnt-β-catenin pathway are of particular interest.

Dual Action of Zinc in Bone and Vascular Calcification

Osteogenic calcification is a normal physiological process in bone tissue, anywhere else like the blood vessel, it is a pathological process which is so‐called calcification paradox. The retarded skeletal growth in animals and man is the major sign of zinc inadequacy, which implies the involvement of zinc in osteogenic calcification.Our previous studies showed that inadequate zinc level in osteoblasts decreased osteogenic activities by decreasing extracellular matrix calcification, mainly through the inhibition of alkaline phosphatase (ALP) expression and activity, and by down‐regulation of osteoblast differentiation marker genes (osteopontin, osteocalcin and collagen type I), which is regulated through the reduced and delayed expression of bone‐specific transcription factor Runx2. Therefore, it seems zinc can be a stimulator in bone formation which includes osteogenic bone matrix calcification.Meanwhile, there is emerging evidence that zinc can protect against vascular damage and therefore may decrease the incidence of atherosclerotic plaque calcification. Our recent study using rat aortic smooth muscle cell line (A7r5) and rat primary vascular smooth muscle cells (pVSMC) showed that inadequate zinc level in VSMCs increased VSMC calcification and this calcification is paralleled with VSMC apoptotic pattern, rather than osteogenic calcification mode. In mice study using atherosclerotic model (ApoE null mouse), zinc deficiency promotes aorta Ca and P deposition (vascular calcification), while it decreases Ca and P contents in femur (bone calcification). The findings from our in vitro (osteoblasts and VSMCs) and in vivo (atherosclerotic ApoE null mouse) studies suggest that zinc may have a reciprocal role for calcification in bone (hard tissue) and blood vessel (soft tissue). It can be suggested that zinc may have a potential for therapeutic strategy for atherosclerosis as well as osteopoprosis, both of which involve the process of calcification.Support or Funding Information(Supported by the National Research Foundation of Korea, NRF‐2011‐0014535)

From skeletal to cardiovascular disease in 12 steps-the evolution of sclerostin as a major player in CKD-MBD.

Canonical Wnt signaling activity contributes to physiological and adaptive bone mineralization and is an essential player in bone remodeling. Sclerostin is a prototypic soluble canonical Wnt signaling pathway inhibitor that is produced in osteocytes and blocks osteoblast differentiation and function. Therefore, sclerostin is a potent inhibitor of bone formation and mineralization. Accordingly, rodent sclerostin-deficiency models exhibit a strong bone phenotype. Moreover, blocking sclerostin represents a promising treatment perspective against osteoporosis. Beyond the bone field novel data definitely associate Wnt signaling in general and sclerostin in particular with ectopic extraosseous mineralization processes, as is evident in cardiovascular calcification or calciphylaxis. Uremia is characterized by parallel occurrence of disordered bone mineralization and accelerated cardiovascular calcification (chronic kidney disease - mineral and bone disorder, CKD-MBD), linking skeletal and cardiovascular disease-the so-called bone-vascular calcification paradox. In consequence, sclerostin may qualify as an emerging player in CKD-MBD. We present a stepwise review approach regarding the rapidly evolving field sclerostin participation in CKD-MBD. Starting from data originating in the classical bone field we look separately at three major areas of CKD-MBD: disturbed mineral metabolism, renal osteodystrophy, and uremic cardiovascular disease. Our review is intended to help the nephrologist revise the potential importance of sclerostin in CKD by focusing on how sclerostin research is gradually evolving from the classical osteoporosis niche into the area of CKD-MBD. In particular, we integrate the limited amount of available data in the context of pediatric nephrology.

Inverse relationship between body mass index and coronary artery calcification in patients with clinically significant coronary lesions

AimsMounting data support a ‘calcification paradox’, whereby reduced bone mineral density is associated with increased vascular calcification. Furthermore, reduced bone mineral density is prevalent in older persons with lower body mass index (BMI). Therefore, although BMI and coronary artery calcification (CAC) exhibit a positive relationship in younger persons, it is predicted that in older persons and/or those at risk for osteoporosis, an inverse relationship between BMI and CAC may apply. We sought to explore this hypothesis in a large group of patients with coronary artery disease undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Methods and resultsWe accessed our single-center registry for 07/01/1999 to 06/30/2009, extracting data on all patients that underwent PCI. To minimize bias we excluded those at the extremes of age or BMI and non-Black/Hispanic/Caucasians, leaving 9993 study subjects (age 66.6±9.9years). Index lesion calcification (ILC) was analyzed with respect to BMI. Comparing index lesions with no angiographic calcification to those with the most severe, mean BMI decreased by 1.11kgm−2; a reduction of 3.9% (P<0.0001). By multivariable modeling, BMI was an independent inverse predictor of moderate–severe ILC (m-sILC; odds ratio [OR] 0.967, 95% CI 0.953–0.980, P<0.0001). Additional fully adjusted models identified that, compared to those with normal BMI, obese patients had an OR of 0.702 for m-sILC (95% CI 0.596–0.827, P<0.0001). ConclusionsIn a large group of PCI patients, we identified an inverse correlation between BMI and index lesion calcification. These associations are consistent with established paradigms and suggest a complex interrelationship between BMI, body size and vascular calcification.

Vascular Calcification Is Associated with Cortical Bone Loss in Chronic Renal Failure Rats with and without Ovariectomy: The Calcification Paradox

Background: Increased bone loss has been associated with the development of vascular calcification in patients with chronic renal failure (CRF). In this study, the effect of impaired bone metabolism on aortic calcifications was investigated in uremic rats with or without ovariectomy. Methods: CRF was induced by administration of a 0.75% adenine/2.5% protein diet for 4 weeks. In one group, osteoporosis was induced by ovariectomy (CRF-OVX), while the other group underwent a sham-operation instead (CRF). A third group consisted of ovariectomized rats with normal renal function (OVX). At regular time intervals throughout the study, bone status and aortic calcifications were evaluated by in vivo micro-CT. At sacrifice after 6 weeks of CRF, bone histomorphometry was performed and vascular calcification was assessed by bulk calcium analysis and Von Kossa staining. Results: Renal function was significantly impaired in the CRF-OVX and CRF groups. Trabecular bone loss was seen in all groups. In the CRF-OVX and CRF groups, trabecular bone density was restored after adenine withdrawal, which coincided with cortical bone loss and the development of medial calcifications in the aorta. No significant differences with regard to the degree of aortic calcifications were seen between the two CRF groups. Neither cortical bone loss nor calcifications were seen in the OVX group. Cortical bone loss significantly correlated with the severity of vascular calcification in the CRF-OVX and CRF groups, but no associations with trabecular bone changes were found. Conclusions: Cortical rather than trabecular bone loss is associated with the process of calcification in rats with adenine- induced CRF.

Do cytokines induce vascular calcification by the mere stimulation of TNAP activity?

Vascular calcification occurs during aging in the general population and is increased in the intima by atherosclerosis and in the media by diabetes type 2. In both intima and media, calcification may lead to the formation of a tissue very similar if not identical to bone, with bone cells and bone marrow. Since vascular calcification is associated with cardiovascular complications, a better understanding of the inducing mechanisms could lead to the development of new therapeutic strategies. Many studies have provided evidence for a role of inflammation and inflammatory cytokines such as tumour necrosis factor (TNF)-α and interleukin (IL)-1β in the vascular calcification process. TNF-α and IL-1β have indeed been shown to stimulate in vitro the expression by vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMCs) of tissue-non specific alkaline phosphatase (TNAP), a key enzyme in the mineralization process, and to trigger the trans-differentiation of VSMCs into osteoblast-like cells, expressing the master transcription factor RUNX2. These data are however somewhat contradictory with the known inhibitory effects of inflammatory cytokines on bone formation. TNF-α for instance dramatically decreases RUNX2 RNA expression, protein stability and activity, and as a consequence, is a potent inhibitor of osteoblast differentiation and bone formation. In the present article, we propose a new hypothesis to explain this calcification paradox. We propose that cytokines block bone formation by decreasing RUNX2-mediated type I collagen production in osteoblasts, whereas they induce vascular ossification by the mere stimulation of TNAP by VSMCs, independently of RUNX2. We propose that this stimulation of TNAP in VSMCs in vitro and in vivo may be sufficient to induce the calcification of collagen fibrils, and that the absence of crystal clearance, in turn, induces the differentiation of VSMCs and/or mesenchymal stem cells into bone-forming cells, eventually leading to formation of a bone-like tissue. In case future experimental studies support this hypothesis, the early stimulatory and late inhibitory effects of inflammation on vascular calcification will have to be taken into consideration in the development of new therapeutic strategies.

Coagulation Meets Calcification: The Vitamin K System

Morbidity and mortality are massively increased in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD) and patients with end-stage renale disease (ESRD). Bone disease (renal osteodystrophy) and vascular disease (accelerated arteriosclerosis) are two typical entities contributing to this excess morbidity and mortality. Vitamin K and vitamin K-dependent-proteins play pivotal roles in the physiology of mineralization and in preventing ectopic calcification: two of these vitamin K-dependent-proteins are osteocalcin (regulating bone mineralization) and matrix-Gla protein (MGP, local calcification inhibitor in the vessel wall). Vitamin K deficiency impairs the physiological function of osteocalcin and MGP and, therefore, presumably contributes to bone demineralisation and vascular calcification (the so-called calcification paradox). In this context, the usage of vitamin K antagonists for long-term oral anticoagulation therapy might be risky especially in CKD patients exhibiting a high background level of vascular calcification. We present a summary of data describing the potential role of vitamin K deficiency and supplementation in bone and vascular disease in patients with CKD or ESRD.

Osteogenic PTHs and vascular ossification—Is there a danger for osteoporotics?

Inflammation in vascular (mostly arterial) walls and heart valves triggered by the trans-endothelial influx of LDL particles and the action of subsequently modified (e.g., by oxidation) LDL particles can trigger true bone formation by valvar fibroblasts, by a subpopulation of re-differentiation-competent VSMCs (vascular smooth muscle cells) or by vascular pericytes. Vascular ossification can lead to heart failure and death. Elderly osteoporotic women who need osteogenic drugs to restore their lost skeletal bone are paradoxically prone to vascular ossification-the "calcification paradox." The recent introduction into the clinic of a potently osteogenic parathyroid hormone peptide, Lilly's rhPTH-(1-34)OH (Forteotrade mark), to reverse skeletal bone loss raises the question of whether this and other potently osteogenic PTHs still in clinical trial might also stimulate vascular ossification in such osteoporotic women. Indeed the VSMCs in human and rat atherosclerotic lesions hyperexpress PTHrP and the PTHR1 (or PTH1R) receptor as do maturing osteoblasts. And the evidence indicates that endogenous PTHrP with its NLS (nuclear/nucleolar localization sequence) does stimulate VSMC proliferation (a prime prerequisite for atheroma formation and ossification) via intranuclear targets that inactivate pRb, the inhibitory G1/S checkpoint regulator, by stimulating its hyperphosphorylation. But neither externally added full-length PTHrP nor the NLS-lacking PTHrP-(1-34)OH gets into the VSMC nucleus and instead they inhibit proliferation and calcification by only activating the cell's PTHR1 receptors. No PTH has an NLS and, as expected from the observations on the externally added PTHrPs, hPTH-(1-34)OH inhibits calcification by VSMCs and cannot stimulate vascular ossification in a diabetic mouse model. Encouraging though this may be for osteoporotics with their "calcification paradox," more work is needed to be sure that the skeletally osteogenic PTHs do not promote vascular ossification with its cardiovascular consequences.