Improving the effectiveness of mating schemes for large-scale production of mice is an ongoing challenge in animal facilities. Continuous mating, which requires fewer breeding cages than intermittent mating, has traditionally been used to take advantage of postpartum estrus for efficient production. However, the continuous mating scheme lacks flexibility because it cannot immediately accommodate the reduced needs of mice when production levels are high. In this study, we compared reproductive performance, fecal corticosterone metabolite (FCM) level as a stress indicator, and mouse mortality between the continuous trio (CT) and intermittent quad (IQ) mating schemes. The weaning rates in the IQ scheme were higher than those in the CT scheme (98.8% compared with 85.3%). The FCM levels in IQ female breeders were lower during the first 5 d after parturition than those in CT female breeders. The FCM levels in postpartum females housed with 2 adult mice were significantly higher on days 1, 3, and 5 after giving birth than those of females housed alone. This suggests that the presence of cage mates may induce stress responses in postpartum females. Increasing the individual cage area did not reduce the FCM levels of female breeders when accompanied by cage mates after parturition. In addition, the incidence of dystocia and mortality was lower in IQ breeders than in CT breeders. In summary, this breeding trial suggests that compared with the continuous mating scheme, the intermittent mating scheme improves the welfare of postpartum females with normal breeding performance in the C57BL/6JNarl production colony.