Phycourobilin:ferredoxin oxidoreductase (PubS) belongs to the ferredoxin-dependent bilin reductase (FDBR) family and catalyzes the reduction of the C15=C16 double bond, followed by the C4=C5 double bond of biliverdin IXα to produce phycourobilin. Among the diverse FDBR enzymes that catalyze site-specific reduction reactions of bilins, PubS lineage is the only one that reduces the C4=C5 double bond. This family can be broadly divided into four-electron reduction enzymes, which catalyze two successive two-electron reductions, such as PubS, and two-electron reduction enzymes, which catalyze a single two-electron reduction. The crystal structures of diverse FDBRs, excluding PubS, have unraveled that there are two distinct binding modes in the substrate-binding pocket. In this study, we focused on the arginine (Arg) residues that is considered crucial for substrate-binding mode in two-electron reduction enzymes. Through sequence alignment and comparison with the predicted structure of PubS, we identified a residue in PubS that corresponds to the Arg residue in the two-electron reduction enzymes. We further introduced mutations to avoid the steric hindrance associated with changes in the binding mode. Biochemical characterization of these variants showed that we successfully modified PubS from a four-electron reduction enzyme to a two-electron reduction enzyme with the accumulation of radicals. Our results provide insight into the molecular mechanisms of the chromophore binding mode and proton donation from acidic residues.