Brain-computer Interface System Research Articles

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Design of Brain-Computer Interface Systems Utilizing Electroencephalography as a Means of Measurement: A Survey

A Comprehensive Analysis of the Design of Brain-Computer Interface Systems Utilizing Electroencephalography as a Means of Measurement: A Survey

A Wireless Bi-Directional Brain–Computer Interface Supporting Both Bluetooth and Wi-Fi Transmission

Wireless neural signal transmission is essential for both neuroscience research and neural disorder therapies. However, conventional wireless systems are often constrained by low sampling rates, limited channel counts, and their support of only a single transmission mode. Here, we developed a wireless bi-directional brain–computer interface system featuring dual transmission modes. This system supports both low-power Bluetooth transmission and high-sampling-rate Wi-Fi transmission, providing flexibility for various application scenarios. The Bluetooth mode, with a maximum sampling rate of 14.4 kS/s, is well suited for detecting low-frequency signals, as demonstrated by both in vitro recordings of signals from 10 to 50 Hz and in vivo recordings of 16-channel local field potentials in mice. More importantly, the Wi-Fi mode, offering a maximum sampling rate of 56.8 kS/s, is optimized for recording high-frequency signals. This capability was validated through in vitro recordings of signals from 500 to 2000 Hz and in vivo recordings of single-neuron spike firings with amplitudes reaching hundreds of microvolts and high signal-to-noise ratios. Additionally, the system incorporates a wireless stimulation function capable of delivering current pulses up to 2.55 mA, with adjustable pulse width and polarity. Overall, this dual-mode system provides an efficient and flexible solution for both neural recording and stimulation applications.

Thought-Controlled Computer Applications: A Brain–Computer Interface System for Severe Disability Support

This study introduces an integrated computational environment that leverages Brain–Computer Interface (BCI) technology to enhance information access for individuals with severe disabilities. Traditional assistive technologies often rely on physical interactions, which can be challenging for this demographic. Our innovation focuses on creating new assistive technologies that use novel Human–Computer interfaces to provide a more intuitive and accessible experience. The proposed system offers four key applications to users controlled by four thoughts: an email client, a web browser, an e-learning tool, and both command-line and graphical user interfaces for managing computer resources. The BCI framework translates ElectroEncephaloGraphy (EEG) signals into commands or events using advanced signal processing and machine learning techniques. These identified commands are then processed by an integrative strategy that triggers the appropriate actions and provides real-time feedback on the screen. Our study shows that our framework achieved an 82% average classification accuracy using four distinct thoughts of 62 subjects and a 95% recognition rate for P300 signals from two users, highlighting its effectiveness in translating brain signals into actionable commands. Unlike most existing prototypes that rely on visual stimulation, our system is controlled by thought, inducing brain activity to manage the system’s Application Programming Interfaces (APIs). It switches to P300 mode for a virtual keyboard and text input. The proposed BCI system significantly improves the ability of individuals with severe disabilities to interact with various applications and manage computer resources. Our approach demonstrates superior performance in terms of classification accuracy and signal recognition compared to existing methods.

A brief survey on human activity recognition using motor imagery of EEG signals.

Human being's biological processes and psychological activities are jointly connected to the brain. So, the examination of human activity is more significant for the well-being of humans. There are various models for brain activity detection considering neuroimaging for attaining decreased time requirement, increased control commands, and enhanced accuracy. Motor Imagery (MI)-based Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) systems create a way in which the brain can interact with the environment by processing Electroencephalogram (EEG) signals. Human Activity Recognition (HAR) deals with identifying the physiological activities of human beings based on sensory signals. This survey reviews the different methods available for HAR based on MI-EEG signals. A total of 50 research articles based on HAR from EEG signals are considered in this survey. This survey discusses the challenges faced by various techniques for HAR. Moreover, the papers are assessed considering various parameters, techniques, publication year, performance metrics, utilized tools, employed databases, etc. There were many techniques developed to solve the problem of HAR and they are classified as Machine Learning (ML) and Deep Learning (DL)models. At last, the research gaps and limitations of the techniques were discussed that contribute to developing an effective HAR.

Towards imagined speech: Identification of brain states from EEG signals for BCI-based communication systems

BackgroundThe electroencephalogram (EEG) based brain-computer interface (BCI) system employing imagined speech serves as a mechanism for decoding EEG signals to facilitate control over external devices or communication with the external world at the moment the user desires. To effectively deploy such BCIs, it is imperative to accurately discern various brain states from continuous EEG signals when users initiate word imagination. New methodThis study involved the acquisition of EEG signals from 15 subjects engaged in four states: resting, listening, imagined speech, and actual speech, each involving a predefined set of 10 words. The EEG signals underwent preprocessing, segmentation, spatio-temporal and spectral analysis of each state, and functional connectivity analysis using the phase locking value (PLV) method. Subsequently, five features were extracted from the frequency and time-frequency domains. Classification tasks were performed using four machine learning algorithms in both pair-wise and multiclass scenarios, considering subject-dependent and subject-independent data. ResultsIn the subject-dependent scenario, the random forest (RF) classifier achieved a maximum accuracy of 94.60 % for pairwise classification, while the artificial neural network (ANN) classifier achieved a maximum accuracy of 66.92 % for multiclass classification. In the subject-independent scenario, the random forest (RF) classifier achieved maximum accuracies of 81.02 % for pairwise classification and 55.58 % for multiclass classification. Moreover, EEG signals were classified based on frequency bands and brain lobes, revealing that the theta (θ) and delta (δ) bands, as well as the frontal and temporal lobes, are sufficient for distinguishing between brain states. ConclusionThe findings promise to develop a system capable of automatically segmenting imagined speech segments from continuous EEG signals.

Artificial intelligence for brain disease diagnosis using electroencephalogram signals.

Brain signals refer to electrical signals or metabolic changes that occur as a consequence of brain cell activity. Among the various non-invasive measurement methods, electroencephalogram (EEG) stands out as a widely employed technique, providing valuable insights into brain patterns. The deviations observed in EEG reading serve as indicators of abnormal brain activity, which is associated with neurological diseases. Brain‒computer interface (BCI) systems enable the direct extraction and transmission of information from the human brain, facilitating interaction with external devices. Notably, the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI) has had a profound impact on the enhancement of precision and accuracy in BCI technology, thereby broadening the scope of research in this field. AI techniques, encompassing machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) models, have demonstrated remarkable success in classifying and predicting various brain diseases. This comprehensive review investigates the application of AI in EEG-based brain disease diagnosis, highlighting advancements in AI algorithms.

Joint hybrid recursive feature elimination based channel selection and ResGCN for cross session MI recognition

In the field of brain-computer interface (BCI) based on motor imagery (MI), multi-channel electroencephalography (EEG) data is commonly utilized for MI task recognition to achieve sensory compensation or precise human-computer interaction. However, individual physiological differences, environmental variations, or redundant information and noise in certain channels can pose challenges and impact the performance of BCI systems. In this study, we introduce a channel selection method utilizing Hybrid-Recursive Feature Elimination (H-RFE) combined with residual graph neural networks for MI recognition. This channel selection method employs a recursive feature elimination strategy and integrates three classification methods, namely random forest, gradient boosting, and logistic regression, as evaluators for adaptive channel selection tailored to specific subjects. To fully exploit the spatiotemporal information of multi-channel EEG, this study employed a graph neural network embedded with residual blocks to achieve precise recognition of motor imagery. We conducted algorithm testing using the SHU dataset and the PhysioNet dataset. Experimental results show that on the SHU dataset, utilizing 73.44% of the total channels, the cross-session MI recognition accuracy is 90.03%. Similarly, in the PhysioNet dataset, using 72.5% of the channel data, the classification result also reaches 93.99%. Compared to traditional strategies such as selecting three specific channels, correlation-based channel selection, mutual information-based channel selection, and adaptive channel selection based on Pearson coefficients and spatial positions, the proposed method improved classification accuracy by 34.64%, 10.8%, 3.25% and 2.88% on the SHU dataset, and by 46.96%, 5.04%, 5.81% and 2.32% on the PhysioNet dataset, respectively.

Wearable EEG-Based Brain–Computer Interface for Stress Monitoring

Detecting stress is important for improving human health and potential, because moderate levels of stress may motivate people towards better performance at cognitive tasks, while chronic stress exposure causes impaired performance and health risks. We propose a Brain–Computer Interface (BCI) system to detect stress in the context of high-pressure work environments. The BCI system includes an encephalogram (EEG) headband with dry electrodes and an electrocardiogram (ECG) chest belt. We collected EEG and ECG data from 40 participants during two stressful cognitive tasks: the Cognitive Vigilance Task (CVT), and the Multi-Modal Integration Task (MMIT) we designed. We also recorded self-reported stress levels using the Dundee Stress State Questionnaire (DSSQ). The DSSQ results indicated that performing the MMIT led to significant increases in stress, while performing the CVT did not. Subsequently, we trained two different models to classify stress from non-stress states, one using EEG features, and the other using heart rate variability (HRV) features extracted from the ECG. Our EEG-based model achieved an overall accuracy of 81.0% for MMIT and 77.2% for CVT. However, our HRV-based model only achieved 62.1% accuracy for CVT and 56.0% for MMIT. We conclude that EEG is an effective predictor of stress in the context of stressful cognitive tasks. Our proposed BCI system shows promise in evaluating mental stress in high-pressure work environments, particularly when utilizing an EEG-based BCI.

Enhancing learning experiences: EEG-based passive BCI system adapts learning speed to cognitive load in real-time, with motivation as catalyst.

Computer-based learning has gained popularity in recent years, providing learners greater flexibility and freedom. However, these learning environments do not consider the learner's mental state in real-time, resulting in less optimized learning experiences. This research aimed to explore the effect on the learning experience of a novel EEG-based Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) that adjusts the speed of information presentation in real-time during a learning task according to the learner's cognitive load. We also explored how motivation moderated these effects. In accordance with three experimental groups (non-adaptive, adaptive, and adaptive with motivation), participants performed a calibration task (n-back), followed by a memory-based learning task concerning astrological constellations. Learning gains were assessed based on performance on the learning task. Self-perceived mental workload, cognitive absorption and satisfaction were assessed using a post-test questionnaire. Between-group analyses using Mann-Whitney tests suggested that combining BCI and motivational factors led to more significant learning gains and an improved learning experience. No significant difference existed between the BCI without motivational factor and regular non-adaptive interface for overall learning gains, self-perceived mental workload, and cognitive absorption. However, participants who undertook the experiment with an imposed learning pace reported higher overall satisfaction with their learning experience and a higher level of temporal stress. Our findings suggest BCI's potential applicability and feasibility in improving memorization-based learning experiences. Further work should seek to optimize the BCI adaptive index and explore generalizability to other learning contexts.

A shared robot control system combining augmented reality and motor imagery brain–computer interfaces with eye tracking

Objective: Brain-computer interface (BCI) control systems monitor neural activity to detect the user's intentions, enabling device control through mental imagery. Despite their potential, decoding neural activity in real-world conditions poses significant challenges, making BCIs currently impractical compared to traditional interaction methods. This study introduces a novel motor imagery (MI) BCI control strategy for operating a physically assistive robotic arm, addressing the difficulties of MI decoding from electroencephalogram (EEG) signals, which are inherently non-stationary and vary across individuals.
Approach: A proof-of-concept BCI control system was developed using commercially available hardware, integrating MI with eye tracking in an augmented reality (AR) user interface to facilitate a shared control approach. This system proposes actions based on the user's gaze, enabling selection through imagined movements. A user study was conducted to evaluate the system's usability, focusing on its effectiveness and efficiency.
Main results:Participants performed tasks that simulated everyday activities with the robotic arm, demonstrating the shared control system's feasibility and practicality in real-world scenarios. Despite low online decoding performance (mean accuracy: 0.52 9, F1: 0.29, Cohen's Kappa: 0.12), participants achieved a mean success rate of 0.83 in the final phase of the user study when given 15 minutes to complete the evaluation tasks. The success rate dropped below 0.5 when a 5-minute cutoff time was selected.
Significance: These results indicate that integrating AR and eye tracking can significantly enhance the usability of BCI systems, despite the complexities of MI-EEG decoding. While efficiency is still low, the effectiveness of our approach was verified. This suggests that BCI systems have the potential to become a viable interaction modality for everyday applications
in the future.

Motor imagery with cues in virtual reality, audio and screen

Training plays a significant role in motor imagery (MI), particularly in applications such as Motor Imagery-based Brain-Computer Interface (MIBCI) systems and rehabilitation systems. Previous studies have investigated the intricate relationship between cues and MI signals. However, the medium of presentation still remains an emerging area to be explored, as possible factors to enhance Motor Imagery signals..
Approach: We hypothesise that the medium used for cue presentation can significantly influence both performance and training outcomes in MI tasks. To test this hypothesis, we designed and executed an experiment implementing no- feedback MI. Our investigation focused on three distinct cue presentation mediums -audio, screen, and virtual reality(VR) headsets-all of which have potential implications for BCI use in the Activities of Daily Lives.
Main Results: The results of our study uncovered notable variations in MI signals depending on the medium of cue presentation, where the analysis is based on 3 EEG channels. To substantiate our findings, we employed a comprehensive approach, utilizing various evaluation metrics including Event- Related Synchronisation(ERS)/Desynchronisation(ERD), Feature Extraction (using Recursive Feature Elimination (RFE)), Machine Learning methodologies (using Ensemble Learning), and participant Questionnaires. All the approaches signify that Motor Imagery signals are enhanced when presented in VR, followed by audio, and lastly screen. Applying a Machine Learning approach across all subjects, the mean cross-validation accuracy (Mean ± Std. Error) was 69.24 ± 3.12, 68.69 ± 3.3 and 66.1±2.59 when for the VR, audio-based, and screen-based instructions respectively.
Significance: This multi-faceted exploration provides evidence to inform MI- based BCI design and advocates the incorporation of different mediums into the design of MIBCI systems, experimental setups, and user studies. The influence of the medium used for cue presentation may be applied to develop more effective and inclusive MI applications in the realm of human-computer interaction and rehabilitation.

The Development of a Multicommand Tactile Event-Related Potential-Based Brain–Computer Interface Utilizing a Low-Cost Wearable Vibrotactile Stimulator

A tactile event-related potential (ERP)-based brain–computer interface (BCI) system is an alternative for enhancing the control and communication abilities of quadriplegic patients with visual or auditory impairments. Hence, in this study, we proposed a tactile stimulus pattern using a vibrotactile stimulator for a multicommand BCI system. Additionally, we observed a tactile ERP response to the target from random vibrotactile stimuli placed in the left and right wrist and elbow positions to create commands. An experiment was conducted to explore the location of the proposed vibrotactile stimulus and to verify the multicommand tactile ERP-based BCI system. Using the proposed features and conventional classification methods, we examined the classification efficiency of the four commands created from the selected EEG channels. The results show that the proposed vibrotactile stimulation with 15 stimulus trials produced a prominent ERP response in the Pz channels. The average classification accuracy ranged from 61.9% to 79.8% over 15 stimulus trials, requiring 36 s per command in offline processing. The P300 response in the parietal area yielded the highest average classification accuracy. The proposed method can guide the development of a brain–computer interface system for physically disabled people with visual or auditory impairments to control assistive and rehabilitative devices.

Enhancing Motor Imagery Classification in Brain–Computer Interfaces Using Deep Learning and Continuous Wavelet Transform

In brain–computer interface (BCI) systems, motor imagery (MI) electroencephalogram (EEG) is widely used to interpret the human brain. However, MI classification is challenging due to weak signals and a lack of high-quality data. While deep learning (DL) methods have shown significant success in pattern recognition, their application to MI-based BCI systems remains limited. To address these challenges, we propose a novel deep learning algorithm that leverages EEG signal features through a two-branch parallel convolutional neural network (CNN). Our approach incorporates different input signals, such as continuous wavelet transform, short-time Fourier transform, and common spatial patterns, and employs various classifiers, including support vector machines and decision trees, to enhance system performance. We evaluate our algorithm using the BCI Competition IV dataset 2B, comparing it with other state-of-the-art methods. Our results demonstrate that the proposed method excels in classification accuracy, offering improvements for MI-based BCI systems.

E-FNet: A EEG-fNIRS dual-stream model for Brain-Computer Interfaces

With the rapid advancements in Brain-Computer Interfaces (BCI) and multimodal technology, researchers are actively exploring the intricate domain of multimodal BCI. The integration of electroencephalography (EEG) and functional near-infrared spectroscopy (fNIRS) in BCI systems has garnered significant attention due to the combination of strengths from both modalities and the overcoming of limitations inherent in standalone systems. In this study, the E-FNet architecture is introduced, a (2+1)D dual-stream model explicitly designed to process multimodal EEG and fNIRS data for brain-machine interface applications. By leveraging the (2+1)D architecture and adopting a bias-free design, E-FNet efficiently processes multimodal data. A unified 4D tensor representation enables the achievement of both temporal and spatial alignment of EEG and fNIRS signals. For Motor Imagery (MI) and Mental Arithmetic (MA) tasks, the early integration of EEG and fNIRS signals yields remarkable accuracy rates of 95.86% and 95.80% respectively, outperforming the accuracy obtained with EEG signals alone. Moreover, the minimal variability in results across subjects underscores the complementary effects achieved through the integration of different signals.

Brain-computer Interaction in the Smart Era.

The brain-computer interface (BCI) system serves as a critical link between external output devices and the human brain. A monitored object's mental state, sensory cognition, and even higher cognition are reflected in its electroencephalography (EEG) signal. Nevertheless, unprocessed EEG signals are frequently contaminated with a variety of artifacts, rendering the analysis and elimination of impurities from the collected EEG data exceedingly challenging, not to mention the manual adjustment thereof. Over the last few decades, the rapid advancement of artificial intelligence (AI) technology has contributed to the development of BCI technology. Algorithms derived from AI and machine learning have significantly enhanced the ability to analyze and process EEG electrical signals, thereby expanding the range of potential interactions between the human brain and computers. As a result, the present BCI technology with the help of AI can assist physicians in gaining a more comprehensive understanding of their patients' physical and psychological status, thereby contributing to improvements in their health and quality of life.

Analysis of Electroencephalographic Signals Using the Root Mean Square (RMS) Fluctuation Function: Applicable Sample Test

Brain signals extracted through brain-computer interface systems (BCI2000- http://www.bci2000.org) allow researchers and computer scientists to cooperate with techniques, mathematical models and statistical inferences that allow the interpretation of a variety of signals provided by people with conditions that significantly affect the ability to move or perform motor activities due to limitations in muscles, bones or nervous system. For this study, we propose a preliminary test with the root mean square (rms) fluctuation function, with EEG data, whose task was the response given to real/imaginary motor stimulus. To validate the model and all the steps up to the configuration of the rms function, we chose the information contained in the EEG of subject S003, available in the public database https://physionet.org/content/eegmmidb/1.0.0/. Considering the distribution of electrodes in the brain (lobes: frontal, parietal, temporal and occipital) and given the data availability conditions (10 - 10 system, EDF format and 160 samples per second), we analyzed 12 of the 64 channels and four stimuli, namely: opening and closing the left or right fist, imagining opening and closing the left or right fist, opening and closing both fists or both feet and imagining opening and closing both fists or both feet. We evaluated their fluctuations individually and the amplitudes of channels 32 and 37 in relation to the others (11, 22, 24, 43, 44, 49, 54, 61, 63 and 64). We observed quantitative similarities when the brain performs the same real/imaginary motor task and that the time of the amplitude changes with the increase of the scale n (time scales). In all experiments (S003_R3, S003_R4, S003_R5, S003_R6), channel 32 x 24, for n > 20 (15 seconds) was smaller than the others, showing that channel 32 (left hemisphere) has the largest fluctuation. From data processing (.EDF) to visualization of F<SUB>DFA</SUB>/∆log curves, we conclude that it is possible to replicate the study for more channels, as well as to investigate other types of activities in the human brain adapted to potential variations (DDP) generated by neurons via signals extracted from the EEG device.

Integrating Electroencephalography Source Localization and Residual Convolutional Neural Network for Advanced Stroke Rehabilitation.

Motor impairments caused by stroke significantly affect daily activities and reduce quality of life, highlighting the need for effective rehabilitation strategies. This study presents a novel approach to classifying motor tasks using EEG data from acute stroke patients, focusing on left-hand motor imagery, right-hand motor imagery, and rest states. By using advanced source localization techniques, such as Minimum Norm Estimation (MNE), dipole fitting, and beamforming, integrated with a customized Residual Convolutional Neural Network (ResNetCNN) architecture, we achieved superior spatial pattern recognition in EEG data. Our approach yielded classification accuracies of 91.03% with dipole fitting, 89.07% with MNE, and 87.17% with beamforming, markedly surpassing the 55.57% to 72.21% range of traditional sensor domain methods. These results highlight the efficacy of transitioning from sensor to source domain in capturing precise brain activity. The enhanced accuracy and reliability of our method hold significant potential for advancing brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) in neurorehabilitation. This study emphasizes the importance of using advanced EEG classification techniques to provide clinicians with precise tools for developing individualized therapy plans, potentially leading to substantial improvements in motor function recovery and overall patient outcomes. Future work will focus on integrating these techniques into practical BCI systems and assessing their long-term impact on stroke rehabilitation.

Filter bank temporally delayed CCA for uncalibrated SSVEP-BCI.

The uncalibrated brain-computer interface (BCI) system based on steady-state visual evoked potential (SSVEP) can omit the training process and is closer to the practical application. Filter bank canonical correlation analysis (FBCCA), as a classical approach of uncalibrated SSVEP-based BCI, extracts the fundamental and harmonic ingredients through filter bank decomposition. Nevertheless, this method fails to fully leverage the temporal feature of the signal. The paper suggested utilizing reconstructed data with temporal delay in the computation of the canonical correlation coefficient, and the different combinations of the time-delayed embedding and FBCCA were discussed. We selected the data from seven participants in the Benchmark dataset for parameter optimization and evaluated the method across all participants. The experimental results showed that only embedding the time-delayed version into the first subband (FBdCCA) was better than embedding it into all subbands (FBdCCA(all)), and the accuracy of FBdCCA surpassed that of FBCCA significantly. This suggests that the approach of time-delayed embedding can further enhance the performance of FBCCA.

From Science Fiction to Reality: Exploring Brain-Computer Interfaces and their Human Applications

Direct control of mechanical or electrical equipment through mental activity is made possible by brain-computer interfaces (BCIs), often referred to as brain-machine interfaces (BMIs). Using only brain signals, users of BCIs can operate external systems without using neurostimulators, which trigger neural tissues. This allows users to avoid using peripheral neurological and muscle systems. The brain's ability to incorporate and regulate mechanical devices as extensions of its own physiological processes is demonstrated by this capability.When it comes to helping those with severe impairments, BCI systems have a lot of potential uses. For people who suffer from neurological conditions like amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, brainstem stroke, or spinal cord injury who are completely paralyzed or "locked in," they provide a substantial benefit in terms of communication. By directly converting brain intent into executable commands, BCI technology aims to enable communication. This is especially helpful for those who are unable to speak.Neuroprosthetics, which attempt to restore lost motor and sensory functions, have been the main focus of BCI research and development. These systems make use of artificial devices to treat brain-related illnesses, take over for faulty nervous system functions, and compensate for compromised sensory organs. As this science develops, brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) have the potential to improve cognitive capacities and the quality of life for people with severe disabilities.

An auditory selective attention brain-computer interface system based on auditory steady-state response

Auditory steady-state response (ASSR) is a brain steady-state response induced by periodic sound signals, which can be used to build an auditory brain-computer interface (BCI), thereby providing a pathway for visually impaired patients to communicate with the outside world. Most of existing ASSR-based BCI studies use linear discriminant classifier (LDA) and spatial coherence to detect ASSRs. Therefore, there is an urgent need for efficient electroencephalogram (EEG) decoding methods to improve the performance of ASSR-based BCI systems. In this study, we elicited ASSRs using sinusoidal amplitude modulated (SAM) tones that simultaneously delivered different modulation frequencies (i.e., 37 Hz for the left channel and 43 Hz for the right channel). Subjects were asked to focus their attention on the auditory stimulation on one side according to the auditory cue. Filter bank common spatial pattern (FBCSP) algorithm was innovatively introduced to detect the ASSRs. Offline results showed that the brain region with strong ASSRs was the central forehead area, and when subjects paid attention to the auditory stimulation at 37 Hz or 43 Hz, the ASSR response of 37 Hz or 43 Hz on the corresponding side would be enhanced compared to the no attention condition. Online results obtained from twelve healthy subjects showed that the mean recognition accuracy of the proposed ASSR-based BCI system achieved a mean accuracy of 82.22 ± 3.11 %. Moreover, the present study further verified that weak auditory stimuli with low stimulus intensity (i.e., 40 dB SPL) could also be used to build ASSR-based BCIs, and achieved an online mean accuracy of 78.89 ± 2.54 %. These results verified that the FBCSP algorithm could be used for detecting ASSRs and the feasibility of the proposed ASSR-based BCI system, providing a great idea for building a high-speed ASSR-based BCI system.