Bibliometric Analysis Approach Research Articles

Learning from the Past Bridging Digital and Physical Markets: A Guidelines for Future Research Agenda of Online-to-Offline (O2O) Marketing Strategy

This bibliometric study comprehensively analyses the scholarly landscape surrounding Online-to-Offline (O2O) commerce from 2006 to 2023. Through a systematic review of existing literature with a bibliometric analysis approach, this research identifies pivotal themes, methodologies, and findings that characterize the evolution and impact of O2O strategies across various sectors. The study begins by tracing the conceptual foundation of O2O commerce, emphasizing its role in integrating digital and physical consumer experiences in response to the changing dynamics of consumer behaviour and market demands. It highlights the strategic adoption of O2O models by e-commerce entities and brick-and-mortar stores, aiming to create a seamless shopping journey by leveraging the strengths of both online and offline platforms. The analysis focuses on the strategic implications for businesses, including the decision-making processes regarding market coverage, delivery costs, and inventory management to enhance profitability and sustainability. The research further delves into consumer behaviour, examining factors influencing the preference for online or offline purchasing, such as demographic characteristics, product types, price levels, and perceived service quality. The findings reveal a dynamic evolution of O2O strategies, underpinned by a growing emphasis on customer engagement, technological innovation, and the strategic management of online and offline synergies. The research underscores the transformative potential of O2O commerce in bridging the gap between digital and physical marketplaces, enhancing consumer experiences, and fostering sustainable business practices. In conclusion, this bibliometric study sheds light on the multifaceted dimensions of O2O commerce, offering valuable insights for academics, practitioners, and policymakers interested in the strategic integration of digital and physical retail environments. It calls for continued research and innovation to harness the full potential of O2O models in meeting the complex needs of consumers and businesses in the digital era.

Insights into National Park Governance based on Global Research Trends: A Lesson for Indonesia

National park governance is urgent in preserving the broadness of biodiversity, nature conservation, and supporting the lives of local communities, demanding a sustainable approach based on global knowledge. This research uses bibliometric analysis to get an idea of global research trends on national park governance and take lessons that can be used in Indonesia. This study maximizes the bibliometric analysis approach with Scopus data sources. Analysis tools are also maximized, namely Nvivo 12 Plus and Vosviewer. The main findings of this research indicate that, through global research trends, national park governance needs to be studied in future research. The tendency of use of the term in biodiversity, nature conservation, conservation management, environmental management, and community participation proved this. Understanding this issue helps create possible governance means more effectively and sustainably, which can be an idea for Indonesia. Findings from global research also provide lessons for Indonesia: They tend to encourage adopting the principle, such as adaptive and collaborative governance in addressing these complex challenges. It can flow on the resolution of conflicts, the involvement of local communities, conservation goals, protection for the environment, the empowerment of indigenous communities, policy changes for and participatory bureaucracy, and satisfying local needs and conservation.

Economic Fraud and Associated Risks: An Integrated Bibliometric Analysis Approach

This study offers a comprehensive insight into the realms of economic fraud and risk management, underscoring the necessity of adaptability to evolving technologies and shifts in financial market dynamics. Through the application of bibliometric methodologies, this study meticulously maps the relevant literature, delineating influential works, notable authors, collaborative networks, and emerging trends. It reviews key research contributions within the field, alongside reputable journals and institutions engaged in academic research. The examination highlights the logical, conceptual, and social interconnections that define the landscape of economic fraud and associated risks, elucidating how these findings inform the understanding, mitigating, and combating of the risk of fraud. Our bibliometric analysis methodology is grounded in the utilization of the Scopus database, employing rigorous filtering and extraction processes to obtain a substantial corpus of pertinent articles. Through a fusion of performance analysis and science mapping, our investigation elucidates central themes and visually represents the interrelationships between studies. Our research outcomes underscore the frequency of paper publications across diverse regions, with particular emphasis on the predominant scientific output from the US and China. Additionally, trends in academic citations are identified, indicative of the significant impact of papers on academic research and the formulation of public policies. By means of bibliometric analysis, this study not only consolidates existing knowledge but also catalyzes the exploration of future research trajectories, emphasizing the imperative of addressing these issues with heightened scientific rigor.

Research Map of Social Security for Employment: Bibliometric Analysis Approach

This study aims to examine the development of research on Social Security for Employment as published in journals focusing on this theme. This study used a qualitative method with a bibliometric analysis approach. The data used are secondary data obtained from the Scopus database comprising 201 journal articles with the theme of Social Security for Employment. Then, the data is processed and analyzed using the VOSviewer application to visualize bibliometric maps. The findings of the study reveal that in bibliometric author mapping, the author who published the most research was Drake R.E. The institution that made the most significant contribution was the Office of Retirement and Disability Policy. Additionally, the most contributing and productive country in research related to this theme is the United States. Furthermore, the most frequently used keywords were worker, benefit, employee, and health. Meanwhile, based on the bibliometric keyword mapping, four clusters can become research lines, namely (1) Social security benefits for individuals with mental disabilities, (2) Social protection and worker contributions within the social security system, (3) Job and health insurance for workers and employment social security, and (4) Government social security policies regarding unemployment and labor death.

Research Map on Marketing Law Studies Based on Scopus Database

This study aims to see the development of research on the topic of "Marketing Law" and research plans that can be carried out based on journals published on the theme. This research uses a qualitative method with a bibliometric analysis approach. The data used is secondary data with the theme "Marketing Law" which comes from the Scopus database with a total of 192 journal articles. Then, the data is processed and analyzed using the VosViewer application with the aim of knowing the bibliometric map of "Marketing Law" research development in the world. The results of the study found that in bibliometric author mapping, the authors who published the most research with the theme "Marketing Law" were Petty R. D; Yahelson Y; Pressey A. D; Renke S.; Steennot R; and Shimpock-Vieweg K. Furthermore, based on bibliometric keyword mapping, there are 3 clusters with the most used words are legislation, product, ambush marketing, strategy, change, and implementation. Then, the research path topics related to marketing law are Future trends in marketing law, Legal implications of brand advertising and EU law and ambush marketing.

Mapping the Global Academic Support for Sustainable Development Goal 7: A Bibliometric Analysis and Topic Modelling Approach

Mapping the Global Academic Support for Sustainable Development Goal 7: A Bibliometric Analysis and Topic Modelling Approach

Scientific Mapping of Chatbot Literature: A Bibliometric Analysis

The use of chatbots for customer service has gained momentum in recent years. Increasing evidence has shown that chatbots can transform the customer service landscape. Nevertheless, this topic currently lacks adequate bibliometric and visualization research. In order to review and summarise the research on chatbots, the study employs a bibliometric analysis approach to gain a comprehensive understanding of chatbots. The study uses bibliometric analysis of 798 documents sourced from the Scopus database from 2001 to 2022. The combination of biblioshiny (web interface application of Bibliometrix) and VOS viewer software was used to visualize the analysis. The study's findings reveal three prominent areas in the current research: antecedents of the adoption of chatbots, application of chatbots and behavioural & relational outcomes of the application of chatbots. The future directions and implications have been discussed in the study's conclusion.

Recent Developments in Financial Innovation Research and Sustainable Accounting Models Bibliometric Analysis approach

This study conducts a systematic bibliometric analysis to examine recent developments in financial innovation research and sustainable accounting models. The intertwining of financial innovation and sustainability reflects a significant shift in the global economic paradigm, with innovations such as green bonds and impact investing reshaping financial markets. The research aims to identify key themes, trends, and interdisciplinary connections within the literature, offering insights for academia, practitioners, policymakers, and other stakeholders. Analysis reveals a growing emphasis on the role of financial innovation in driving sustainable growth and the importance of sustainable accounting in fostering transparency and accountability. The study also highlights emerging research directions, including interdisciplinary approaches, drivers of innovation and development, microfinance impact on household economics, and the nexus between education and health. Ultimately, this research seeks to contribute to the advancement of knowledge and practices promoting both financial prosperity and environmental and social well-being.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) in the Financial Sector

This study aims to see the development of research on the topic of "AI on Finance" and research plans that can be carried out based on journals published on the theme. This research uses qualitative method with bibliometric analysis approach. The data used is secondary data with the theme "AI on Finance" which comes from the Dimension database with a total of 127 journal articles. Then, the data is processed and analyzed using the VosViewer application with the aim of knowing the bibliometric map of research development "AI on Finance" in the world. The results of the study found that in bibliometric author mapping the authors who published the most research with the theme "AI on Finance" were Bhattacharjee A; Al-Gasaymeh A.S; Arakpogun E.O; Wang X; Sharma S; Arner D.W; Yang J; Krishna S.H; Khan S; Singh R; Bansal R; Raffinetti E; and Marwala T. Furthermore, based on bibliometric keyword mapping, there are 5 clusters with the most used words are development; challenge, accounting, opportunity, economy, blockchain, and use. Then, the research path topics related to AI on Finance are AI in Islamic Finance, Enterprise AI Development in Finance, AI in Behavioral Finance, Green Finance and AI, and AI Access in Accounting.

Computational Bibliometric Analysis of Research on Bloom Digital Taxonomy and Critical Thinking

One important step towards understanding the development, trends, and effects in the context of contemporary education is to conduct a computational bibliometric analysis of research focused on Bloom Digital Taxonomy and elements of critical thinking studies. This research was conducted to perform a bibliometric analysis on the digital Bloom's taxonomy and critical thinking. The research method employed was bibliometric analysis, utilizing machine learning to map the data. The research comprised four stages of bibliometric analysis, namely: (a) data retrieval through the application of Publish or Perish, (b) data processing, (c) data mapping using machine learning, and (d) data analysis of the mapping using the R programming language. The research materials were published between 2015 and collected from the Google Scholar database in 2023. The search process involved the usage of the keywords "Taxonomy Bloom Digital" and "Critical Thinking." The results demonstrated that bibliometric analysis and mapping of 500 publications using machine learning enabled a deeper understanding of the development, trends, and crucial aspects of research in this field. By employing a bibliometric analysis approach and implementing machine learning, this study contributes to the comprehension of digital Bloom's taxonomy and critical thinking while providing an overview of research trends.

A bibliometric analysis using the VOS Viewer: Green marketing, repurchase intention, and correlations

This study uses the SCOPUS database to analyze the evolution of publications on green marketing, repurchase intention, and their relationships. The VOSviewer software program was used in this study's bibliometric analysis approach to construct and display a bibliometric network. Researchers were selected using the SCOPUS database's top keywords for green marketing, repurchase intention, and correlation between 2003 and 2022. The number of publications identified according to the keywords initially appeared to be 5.481 for green marketing, 1.658 for repurchase intention and 13 for keyword green marketing and repurchase intention. After filtering, it was discovered that there were only 5 articles containing the keywords "green marketing and repurchase intention", out of a total of 2.893 articles on green marketing and 1.117 articles on repurchase intention. Based on the findings of the VOSviewer study and the network visualization of keyword co-occurrence, 162 items were divided into 5 groups (clusters) for green marketing issues, 102 items were divided into 5 groups (clusters) for repurchase intention issues, and only 25 items were divided into 5 groups (clusters) for correlations between green marketing and repurchase intention issues. There is still limited research analyzing the correlation between green marketing and repurchase intentions, starting in 2016. However, companies must spend more of their budgets when implementing green marketing strategies; in the future, further enhanced research examining whether green marketing strategies have an impact on repurchase intentions by customers is needed.

Mapping the Literature and Future Research Agenda of Employee Engagement: A Bibliometric Analysis of the past 20 years

Purpose: The aim of this study is to highlight the intricacies involved in the conceptualization and theorization of Employee Engagement in the past twenty years. By analyzing the antecedents and, this study aims to identify the gaps in the present literature so that future research directions can be deliberated.
 Design/methodology/approach: This research applies a bibliometric analysis approach in order to synthesize upcoming themes in the area of employee engagement.
 Findings: Employee Engagement as a concept has been widely conceptualized and mainly differentiated into two dimensions – psychological or attitudinal and behavioural. Less research has taken place on the behavioural front of the topic wherein the extra-role performance by engaged employees’ discretionary behaviour should be studied. Also, factors like the nature of work and leadership, and emotional intelligence need attention.
 Limitations: The present study has only undertaken articles and has not focused on book chapters, conference proceedings and focused on English language research papers. Also, the study excluded research studies where engagement was examined as a moderator or mediator as the emphasis was on understanding the antecedents of engagement.
 Implications: Since engagement levels have dropped in the past decade, it becomes imperative for practitioners to overhaul it’s understanding and make every employee’s experience a unique one by engaging them.

PERKEMBANGAN DAN CORAK PENYELIDIKAN KOMPETENSI PENGAJARAN GURU FIZIK: ANALISIS BIBLIOMETRIK

Education is the focus of the SDG4, with special emphasis on the teaching competence of teachers, not least physics teachers. This study was conducted to delve into the development and patterns in physics teacher teaching competency research through a bibliometric analysis approach. This study involved collecting data from scientific publications with a focus on high impact publications. SCOPUS is used as the primary data source to maintain a focus on recent articles. From the bibliometric analysis shows a global concentration in institutions in the United States, Europe, and Asia. The results of the analysis also show that there is no correlation between the number of publications by an author and the popularity of his writing among other researchers. The analysis also showed that 93.78% of published articles were classified as "Social Sciences and Humanities". Moreover, the significant differences in the use of keywords indicate the diversity of strategies in research based on geographic location. The implications of this study can guide new researchers in the selection of keywords that are appropriate to the research context. By understanding diverse research strategies based on location, researchers can enrich their approaches to ensure wider absorption and greater impact in the field. Practically, the results of this study can be used to plan a more effective physics teacher development program, by adjusting teaching approaches based on global patterns in teaching competencies. In addition, an understanding of the institutional focus and geographical differences can help in the formation of international cooperation to improve the understanding and development of the teaching competence of physics teachers in a holistic manner.

Achieving sustainable development goals (SDGs) through corporate sustainability: a topic modeling-based bibliometric analysis approach

PurposeConsidering the swift adoption of innovative sustainability practices in businesses to accomplish sustainable development goals (SDGs), research on corporate sustainability has increased significantly over the years. This research intends to analyze the published literature, emphasizing the existing, emerging and future research directions on achieving the SDGs through corporate sustainability.Design/methodology/approachThis research analyzed the growing trends in corporate sustainability by incorporating 2,038 Scopus articles published between 1999 and 2022 using latent Dirichlet allocation (LDA) topic modeling, bibliometrics and qualitative content analysis techniques. The bibliometric data were analyzed using performance and science mapping. Thereafter, topic modeling and content analysis uncovered the topics included under the corporate sustainability umbrella.FindingsThe findings indicate that investigation into corporate sustainability has considerably increased from 2015 to date. Additionally, the majority of studies on corporate sustainability are from the United States of America, the United Kingdom and Germany. Besides, the USA has the most collaboration in terms of co-authorship. S. Schaltegger was considered the most productive author. However, P. Bansal was ranked as the top author based on a co-citation analysis of authors. Further, bibliometric data were evaluated to analyze leading publications, journals and institutions. Besides, keyword co-occurrence analysis, topic modeling and content analysis highlighted the theoretical underpinnings and new patterns and provided directions for further research.Originality/valueThis study demonstrates various existing and emerging themes in corporate sustainability, which have various repercussions for academicians and organizations. This research also examines the lagging themes in the current domain.

Bibliometric Analysis: Trends And Contributions of Research in The Field of Artificial Intelligence

This research aims to investigate research developments and research contributions in the field of Artificial Intelligence (AI) through a bibliometric analysis approach. Bibliometric data is obtained from various scientific reference sources including journal articles, conferences and books within a certain time period. The results of the analysis show an exponential growth in AI publications over the last few years. This study also identified a trend of strong research collaboration between researchers and research institutions in AI development. Dominant research topics include machine learning, natural language processing, image recognition, and robotics. Additionally, the study identifies the most prolific authors in the discipline and measures research impact based on the number of citations received. The results of this research provide deep insight into developments in AI research, enabling stakeholders to understand current research trends and focus. These findings can also serve as a guide for future research directions in the field of Artificial Intelligence.

Drug-eluting stents for coronary artery disease in the perspective of bibliometric analysis.

Drug-eluting stents (DES) play a crucial role in treating coronary artery disease (CAD) by preventing restenosis. These stents are coated with drug carriers that release antiproliferative drugs within the vessel. Over the past two decades, DES have been employed in clinical practice using various materials, polymers, and drug types. Despite optimizations in their design and materials to enhance biocompatibility and antithrombotic properties, evaluating their long-term efficacy and safety necessitates improved clinical follow-up and monitoring. To delineate future research directions, this study employs a bibliometric analysis approach. We comprehensively surveyed two decades' worth of literature on DES for CAD using the Web of Science Core Collection (WOSCC). Out of 5,778 articles, we meticulously screened them based on predefined inclusion and exclusion criteria. Subsequently, we conducted an in-depth analysis encompassing annual publication trends, authorship affiliations, journal affiliations, keywords, and more. Employing tools such as Excel 2021, CiteSpace 6.2R3, VOSviewer 1.6.19, and Pajek 5.17, we harnessed bibliometric methods to derive insights from this corpus. Analysis of annual publication data indicates a recent stabilisation or even a downward trend in research output in this area. The United States emerged as the leading contributor, with Columbia University and CRF at the forefront in both publication output and citation impact. The most cited document pertained to standardized definitions for clinical endpoints in coronary stent trials. Our author analysis identifies Patrick W. Serruys as the most prolific contributor, underscoring a dynamic exchange of knowledge within the field.Moreover, the dual chart overlay illustrates a close interrelation between journals in the "Medicine," "Medical," and "Clinical" domains and those in "Health," "Nursing," and "Medicine." Frequently recurring keywords in this research landscape include DES coronary artery disease, percutaneous coronary intervention, implantation, and restenosis. This study presents a comprehensive panorama encompassing countries, research institutions, journals, keyword distributions, and contributions within the realm of DES therapy for CAD. By highlighting keywords exhibiting recent surges in frequency, we elucidate current research hotspots and frontiers, thereby furnishing novel insights to guide future researchers in this evolving field.

Bibliometric analysis of leadership implementation in MSMEs

The purpose of this study is to analyze the development of research publications on leadership implementation in MSMEs over the last five years. This research used a bibliometric analysis approach with VOSviewer software to develop and visualize the bibliometric network. This research conducted screening based on leadership keywords in MSMEs in the SCOPUS database in the vulnerable years 2018-2023. Publications according to keywords initially amounted to 90 articles, after which 33 articles were filtered. The development of leadership publications in MSMEs in the last 5 years has experienced ups and downs in the number of publications per year, with an increasing trend occurring in 2023, when there were many publications in the field of business, management and accounting, with 33 documents (47.8%). The results of the analysis with VOSviewer and visualization of co-occurrence networks based on leadership keywords in MSMEs revealed 174 items with a division of 12 clusters marked with different colors. The interrelated factors include entrepreneurial leadership, entrepreneurship, entrepreneurial motivation, quality management, digital transformation, competition, and others. The results of the analysis using the VOSviewer application show that there is a relationship between leadership and MSMEs with other networks; thus, additional research could be interesting.

Bibliometric analysis of employee organizational culture

The purpose of this study is to analyze the growth of research publications on organizational employee culture using the SCOPUS online database. This research used a bibliometric analysis approach with VOSviewer software to develop and visualize the bibliometric network. This research conducted a screening based on the keywords “organizational culture” in the SCOPUS database for the vulnerable years 2018-2023. Publications according to keywords initially amounted to 11,059 articles, after which 216 articles were filtered. The development of organizational culture publications in the last 5 years has led to an increase in the number of publications per year, with an increase in 2023; these publications were published in the field of business, management and accounting, with 147 documents (48.8%). The results of the analysis with VOSviewer and the visualization of co-occurrence networks based on the keyword “employee organizational culture” revealed 29 items with a division of 5 clusters marked with different colors. The interrelated factors include motivation, performance, employee, learning, organizational innovation, job satisfaction, job performance, knowledge management, organizational culture, and employee engagement. The results of the analysis using the VOSviewer application show that there is a relationship between employee organizational culture and other networks; thus, additional research could be interesting.

The Development of Financial Statement Fraud Research: A Bibliometric Analysis

This research aims to present and explain the development of research related to financial statement fraud by reviewing bibliometric analysis taken from the Scopus database for the period 1979 – 2023. The method used is a bibliometric analysis approach using VOSviewer and Microsoft Excel to analyze data frequency. The results of this research show that the research topic of financial statement fraud will be most researched in 2023 with 60 articles, the journal that publishes the most topics related to financial statement fraud is the Journal of Financial Crime. The country that publishes the most on the topic of financial statement fraud is the United States. Variables that often appear related to the topic of financial statement fraud are corporate governance, earnings management, crime, and the fraud triangle. Brazel, Hermanson, and Jones are the authors who write most frequently or extensively about financial statement fraud.

Global Research Trends of Digital Learning Media in Science Education: A Bibliometric Analysis

This research aims to identify global research trends on digital learning media in science education through a bibliometric analysis approach. To complete this bibliometric study, four steps were used: data collection, screening, visualization and analysis. There are 915 publications related to the keywords in Scopus database. Based on these criteria, 100 documents from 2018 to 2022 were selected and analyzed. Bibliometric data was processed using VOSviewer version 1.6.17. The results show a significant increase in research on digital learning media in science education. VOSviewer mapping revealed several current themes related to digital learning media which were divided into 7 clusters; such as ICT, digital explanation, and representation in cluster in cluster 1; artificial intelligence, mobile learning, internet forums in cluster 2; educational technology, human experiment, and video recording in cluster 3; online learning, digital learning, and multimedia learning in cluster 4; gamification, social networking and YouTube in cluster 5; augmented reality in cluster 6; digital technology, distance learning, and internet in cluster 7. The results of this research provide a comprehensive understanding and can be used as a basis for further research.