Mercury in marine biota has been extensively studied across Inuit Nunaat because it bioaccumulates and biomagnifies in high trophic level species, such as the beluga whale (Delphinapterus leucas), or qilalugaq in Inuktut. Qilalugaait (pl) are a staple in many coastal Inuit communities, including Tuktoyaktuk, Northwest Territories and Arviat, Nunavut. We examine how total mercury (THg) concentrations in two beluga populations are influenced by biased sampling resulting from local harvester preferences. We examined historical THg in skin, muscle, and liver (1980's to 2022) together with local qualitative interviews from two beluga-harvesting communities. Age and length bins were used to compare similar sized and aged whales between locations, where males (350 - 400 cm, and 20–30 years) and females (330–400 cm, and 15–30 years) were segregated. The interviews revealed distinct preferences whereby harvesters in Tuktoyaktuk actively sought larger (length) male whales, whereas harvesters in Arviat, selected wide and even range across size and sex. These local preferences were also evident in the historical dataset, with the median age and lengths were 31 years and 389.0 cm in Tuktoyaktuk (n = 461) and 23 and 336.0 cm in Arviat (n = 146). For males, mean and median THg concentrations were higher in beluga harvested from Tuktoyaktuk than Arviat in all three tissues with age and lengths combined, yet in the selected age and length bins, there was no difference in mean and median THg in the muscle tissue, and in median liver THg. There were significant differences in mean and median skin THg and in mean liver THg concentrations between males. In female whales, THg concentrations did not differ between Tuktoyaktuk and Arviat (in ages and lengths combined and in selected age bins across all tissues), excluding median muscle THg concentration. This study indicated that differences in THg concentrations that were previously observed resulted from hunter preferences in these two communities.