Reseeding is a primary measure to restore degraded grasslands. Numerous studies have conducted experiments to investigate how the properties of grassland ecosystems respond to reseeding in China. However, there is a lack of summary of the results of these studies. Here, we conducted a hierarchical random-effects meta-analysis on the effects of reseeding on plant, soil, and microbial properties. We collected 19 variables, including plant biomass, species diversity and richness, soil organic carbon content, soil total and available nutrients, soil water content, soil microbial biomass and diversity, and enzyme activity, from a dataset of 1363 paired observations (degraded vs. reseeded) from 75 publications. The results showed that reseeding increased aboveground and belowground plant biomass by 70.2% and 68.0% on average, respectively. Reseeding increased soil organic carbon, phosphorus, and potassium contents, but did not affect soil nitrogen levels. Reseeding increased soil microbial nitrogen under conditions of tillage and fertilization. Reseeding age was found to have a positive correlation with species richness, while planting type, fertilization, and tillage did not have a significant impact on the species richness and diversity. Under the treatments of fertilization, non-tillage, and mix-planting, the response ratio of aboveground biomass to reseeding was positively correlated with the response ratio of species diversity to reseeding. Our results concluded that current reseeding practices can significantly improve plant biomass production and soil fertility but have minor effects on plant species diversity. These findings indicate that the preservation of biodiversity should receive greater attention from both researchers and practitioners in grassland remediation in China.