Beam-type Collisional Activation Research Articles

Localizing Isomerized Residue Sites in Peptides with Tandem Mass Spectrometry.

Isomerized amino acid residues have been identified in many peptides extracted from tissues or excretions of humans and animals. These isomerized residues can play key roles by affecting biological activity or by exerting an influence on the process of aging. Isomerization occurs spontaneously and does not result in a mass shift. Thus, identifying and localizing isomerized residues in biological samples is challenging. Herein, we introduce a fast and efficient method using tandem mass spectrometry (MS) to locate isomerized residues in peptides. Although MS2 spectra are useful for identifying peptides that contain an isomerized residue, they cannot reliably localize isomerization sites. We show that this limitation can be overcome by utilizing MS3 experiments to further evaluate each fragment ion from the MS2 stage. Comparison at the MS3 level, utilizing statistical analyses, reveals which MS2 fragments differ between samples and, therefore, must contain the isomerized sites. The approach is similar to previous work relying on ion mobility to discriminate MS2 product ions by collision cross-section. The MS3 approach can be implemented using either ion-trap or beam-type collisional activation and is compatible with the quantification of isomer mixtures when coupled to a calibration curve. The method can also be implemented in combination with liquid chromatography in a targeted approach. Enabling the identification and localization of isomerized residues in peptides with an MS-only methodology will expand accessibility to this important information.

Practical Effects of Intramolecular Hydrogen Rearrangement in Electron Transfer Dissociation-Based Proteomics.

Ion-ion reactions are valuable tools in mass-spectrometry-based peptide and protein sequencing. To boost the generation of sequence-informative fragment ions from low charge-density precursors, supplemental activation methods, via vibrational and photoactivation, have become widely adopted. However, long-lived radical peptide cations undergo intramolecular hydrogen atom transfer from c-type ions to z•-type ions. Here we investigate the degree of hydrogen transfer for thousands of unique peptide cations where electron transfer dissociation (ETD) was performed and was followed by beam-type collisional activation (EThcD), resonant collisional activation (ETcaD), or concurrent infrared photoirradiation (AI-ETD). We report on the precursor charge density and the local amino acid environment surrounding bond cleavage to illustrate the effects of intramolecular hydrogen atom transfer for various precursor ions. Over 30% of fragments from EThcD spectra comprise distorted isotopic distributions, whereas over 20% of fragments from ETcaD have distorted distributions and less than 15% of fragments derived from ETD and AI-ETD reveal distorted isotopic distributions. Both ETcaD and EThcD give a relatively high degree of hydrogen migration, especially when D, G, N, S, and T residues were directly C-terminal to the cleavage site. Whereas all postactivation methods boost the number of c- and z•-type fragment ions detected, the collision-based approaches produce higher rates of hydrogen migration, yielding fewer spectral identifications when only c- and z•-type ions are considered. Understanding hydrogen rearrangement between c- and z•-type ions will facilitate better spectral interpretation.

Optimal Dissociation Methods Differ for N- and O-Glycopeptides.

Site-specific characterization of glycosylation requires intact glycopeptide analysis, and recent efforts have focused on how to best interrogate glycopeptides using tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). Beam-type collisional activation, i.e., higher-energy collisional dissociation (HCD), has been a valuable approach, but stepped collision energy HCD (sceHCD) and electron transfer dissociation with HCD supplemental activation (EThcD) have emerged as potentially more suitable alternatives. Both sceHCD and EThcD have been used with success in large-scale glycoproteomic experiments, but they each incur some degree of compromise. Most progress has occurred in the area of N-glycoproteomics. There is growing interest in extending this progress to O-glycoproteomics, which necessitates comparisons of method performance for the two classes of glycopeptides. Here, we systematically explore the advantages and disadvantages of conventional HCD, sceHCD, ETD, and EThcD for intact glycopeptide analysis and determine their suitability for both N- and O-glycoproteomic applications. For N-glycopeptides, HCD and sceHCD generate similar numbers of identifications, although sceHCD generally provides higher quality spectra. Both significantly outperform EThcD methods in terms of identifications, indicating that ETD-based methods are not required for routine N-glycoproteomics even if they can generate higher quality spectra. Conversely, ETD-based methods, especially EThcD, are indispensable for site-specific analyses of O-glycopeptides. Our data show that O-glycopeptides cannot be robustly characterized with HCD-centric methods that are sufficient for N-glycopeptides, and glycoproteomic methods aiming to characterize O-glycopeptides must be constructed accordingly.

Top-Down Characterization of Proteins with Intact Disulfide Bonds Using Activated-Ion Electron Transfer Dissociation.

Here we report the fragmentation of disulfide linked intact proteins using activated-ion electron transfer dissociation (AI-ETD) for top-down protein characterization. This fragmentation method is then compared to the alternative methods of beam-type collisional activation (HCD), electron transfer dissociation (ETD), and electron transfer and higher-energy collision dissociation (EThcD). We analyzed multiple precursor charge states of the protein standards bovine insulin, α-lactalbumin, lysozyme, β-lactoglobulin, and trypsin inhibitor. In all cases, we found that AI-ETD provides a boost in protein sequence coverage information and the generation of fragment ions from within regions enclosed by disulfide bonds. AI-ETD shows the largest improvement over the other techniques when analyzing highly disulfide linked and low charge density precursor ions. This substantial improvement is attributed to the concurrent irradiation of the gas phase ions while the electron-transfer reaction is taking place, mitigating nondissociative electron transfer, helping unfold the gas phase protein during the electron transfer event, and preventing disulfide bond reformation. We also show that AI-ETD is able to yield comparable sequence coverage information when disulfide bonds are left intact relative to proteins that have been reduced and alkylated. This work demonstrates that AI-ETD is an effective fragmentation method for the analysis of proteins with intact disulfide bonds, dramatically enhancing sequence ion generation and total sequence coverage compared to HCD and ETD.

Transformation of [M + 2H](2+) Peptide Cations to [M - H](+), [M + H + O](+), and M(+•) Cations via Ion/Ion Reactions: Reagent Anions Derived from Persulfate.

The gas-phase oxidation of doubly protonated peptides is demonstrated here using ion/ion reactions with a suite of reagents derived from persulfate. Intact persulfate anion (HS2O8(-)), peroxymonosulfate anion (HSO5(-)), and sulfate radical anion (SO4(-•)) are all either observed directly upon negative nanoelectrospray ionization (nESI) or easily obtained via beam-type collisional activation of persulfate into the mass spectrometer. Ion/ion reactions between each of these reagents and doubly protonated peptides result in the formation of a long-lived complex. Collisional activation of the complex containing a peroxymonosulfate anion results in oxygen transfer from the reagent to the peptide to generate the [M + H + O](+) species. Activation of the complex containing intact persulfate anion either results in oxygen transfer to generate the [M + H + O](+) species or abstraction of two hydrogen atoms and a proton to generate the [M - H](+) species. Activation of the complex containing sulfate radical anion results in abstraction of one hydrogen atom and a proton to form the peptide radical cation, [M](+•). This suite of reagents allows for the facile transformation of the multiply protonated peptides obtained via nESI into a variety of oxidized species capable of providing complementary information about the sequence and structure of the peptide.

Higher-energy Collision-activated Dissociation Without a Dedicated Collision Cell

Beam-type collisional activation dissociation (HCD) offers many advantages over resonant excitation collision-activated dissociation, including improved identification of phosphorylated peptides and compatibility with isobaric tag-based quantitation (e.g. tandem mass tag (TMT) and iTRAQ). However, HCD typically requires specially designed and dedicated collision cells. Here we demonstrate that HCD can be performed in the ion injection pathway of a mass spectrometer with a standard atmospheric inlet (iHCD). Testing this method on complex peptide mixtures revealed similar identification rates to collision-activated dissociation (2883 versus 2730 IDs for iHCD/CAD, respectively) and precursor-product-conversion efficiency comparable to that achieved within a dedicated collision cell. Compared with pulsed-q dissociation, a quadrupole ion trap-based method that retains low-mass isobaric tag reporter ions, iHCD yielded isobaric tag for relative and absolute quantification reporter ions 10-fold more intense. This method involves no additional hardware and can theoretically be implemented on any mass spectrometer with an atmospheric inlet.

Charge state dependent fragmentation of gaseous α-synuclein cations via ion trap and beam-type collisional activation

Ions derived from nano-electrospray ionization (nano-ESI) of α-synuclein, a 14.5 kDa, 140 amino acid residue protein that is a major component of the Lewy bodies associated with Parkinson's disease, have been subjected to ion trap and beam-type collisional activation. The former samples products from fragmentation at rates generally lower than 100 s −1 whereas the latter samples products from fragmentation at rates generally greater than 10 3 s −1. A wide range of protein charge states spanning from as high as [M+17H] 17+ to as low as [M+4H] 4+ have been formed either directly from nano-ESI or via ion/ion proton transfer reactions involving the initially formed protein cations and have been subjected to both forms of collision-induced dissociation (CID). The extent of sequence information (i.e., number of distinct amide bond cleavages) available from either CID method was found to be highly sensitive to protein precursor ion charge state. Furthermore, the relative contributions of the various competing dissociation channels were also dependent upon precursor ion charge state. The qualitative trends in the changes in extent of amide bond cleavages and identities of bonds cleaved with precursor ion charge state were similar for two forms of CID. However, for every charge state examined, roughly twice the primary sequence information resulted from beam-type CID relative to ion trap CID. For example, evidence for cleavage of 86% of the protein amide bonds was observed for the [M+9H] 9+ precursor ion using beam-type CID whereas 41% of the bonds were cleaved for the same precursor ion using ion trap CID. The higher energies required to drive fragmentation reactions at rates necessary to observe products in the beam experiment access more of the structurally informative fragmentation channels, which has important implications for whole protein tandem mass spectrometry.

Collision-Induced Dissociation of Intact Duplex and Single-Stranded siRNA Anions

A tandem mass spectrometry approach is demonstrated for complete sequencing of a model small interfering RNA (siRNA) based on ion trap collisional activation of intact single-stranded anions. Various charge states of the siRNA duplex and the individual strands were generated by nanoelectrospray (nano-ESI). The siRNA duplex anions were predominantly dissociated into the sense and antisense strands by collisional activation. The characteristic fragment ions (c/y- and a-B/w-ion series) from both strands were observed when higher activation amplitude was applied and when beam-type collisional activation was examined; however, the coexistence of fragment ions from both strands complicated spectral interpretation. The effect of precursor ion charge state on the dissociation of the individual sense and antisense strand siRNA anions was studied using ion trap collision-induced dissociation under various activation amplitudes. Through the activation of relatively low charge state precursor ions at relatively low excitation energy, selective backbone dissociation predominantly via the c/y channels was achieved. By applying relatively high excitation energy, the a-B/w channels also became prominent; however, the increase in spectral complexity made complete peak assignment difficult. In order to simplify the product ion spectra, proton-transfer reactions were applied, and complete sequencing of each strand was achieved. The application of tandem mass spectrometry to intact single-stranded anions demonstrated in this study can be adapted for the rapid identification of other noncoding RNAs in RNomics studies.

Rapidly Alternating Transmission Mode Electron-Transfer Dissociation and Collisional Activation for the Characterization of Polypeptide Ions

Cation transmission/electron-transfer reagent anion storage mode electron-transfer ion/ion reactions and beam-type collisional activation of the polypeptide ions are performed in rapid succession in the high-pressure collision cell (Q2) of a quadrupole/time-of-flight tandem mass spectrometer (QqTOF), where the electron-transfer reagent anions are accumulated. Duty cycles for both electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) and collision-induced dissociation (CID) experiments are improved relative to ion trapping approaches since there are no discrete ion storage and reaction steps for ETD experiments and no discrete ion storage step and frequency tuning for CID experiments. For this technique, moderately high resolution and mass accuracy are also obtained due to mass analysis via the TOF analyzer. This relatively simple approach has been demonstrated with a triply charged tryptic peptide, a triply charged tryptic phosphopeptide, and a triply charged tryptic N-linked glycopeptide. For the tryptic peptide, the sequence is identified with more certainty than would be available from a single method alone due to the complementary information provided by these two dissociation methods. Because of the complementary information derived from both ETD and CID dissociation methods, peptide sequence and post-translational modification (PTM) sites for the phosphopeptide are identified. This combined ETD and CID approach is particularly useful for characterizing glycopeptides because ETD generates information about both peptide sequence and locations of the glycosylation sites, whereas CID provides information about the glycan structure.

Beam‐type collisional activation of polypeptide cations that survive ion/ion electron transfer

Doubly protonated peptides that undergo an electron transfer reaction without dissociation in a linear ion trap can be subjected to beam-type collisional activation upon transfer from the linear ion trap into an adjacent mass analyzer, as demonstrated here with a hybrid triple quadrupole/linear ion trap system. The activation can be promoted by use of a DC offset difference between the ion trap used for reaction and the ion trap into which the products are injected of 12-16 V, which gives rise to energetic collisions between the transferred ions and the collision/bath gas employed in the linear ion trap used for ion/ion reactions. Such a process can be executed routinely on hybrid linear ion trap/triple quadrupole tandem mass spectrometers and is demonstrated here with several model peptides as well as a few dozen tryptic peptides. Collisional activation of the peptide precursor ions that survive electron transfer frequently provides structural information that is absent from the precursor ions that fragment spontaneously upon electron transfer. The degree to which additional structural information is obtained by collisional activation of the surviving singly charged peptide ions depends upon peptide size. Little or no additional structural information is obtained from small peptides (<8 residues) due to the high electron transfer dissociation (ETD) efficiencies noted for these peptides as well as the extensive sequence information that tends to be forthcoming from ETD of such species. Collisional activation of the surviving electron transfer products provided greatest benefit for peptides of 8-15 residues.

Ion Trap Collision-Induced Dissociation of Human Hemoglobin α-Chain Cations

Multiply protonated human hemoglobin alpha-chain species, ranging from [M + 4H]4+ to [M + 20H]20+, have been subjected to ion trap collisional activation. Cleavages at 88 of the 140 peptide bonds were indicated, summed over all charge states, although most product ion signals were concentrated in a significantly smaller number of channels. Consistent with previous whole protein ion dissociation studies conducted under similar conditions, the structural information inherent to a given precursor ion was highly sensitive to charge state. A strongly dominant cleavage at D75/M76, also noted previously in beam-type collisional activation studies, was observed for the [M + 8H]8+ to [M + 11H]11+ precursor ions. At lower charge states, C-terminal aspartic acid cleavages were also prominent but the most abundant products did not arise from the D75/M76 channel. The [M + 12H]12+-[M + 16H]16+ precursor ions generally yielded the greatest variety of amide bond cleavages. With the exception of the [M + 4H]4+ ion, all charge states showed cleavage at the L113/P114 bond. This cleavage proved to be the most prominent dissociation for charge states [M + 14H]14+ and higher. The diversity of dissociation channels observed within the charge state range studied potentially provides the opportunity to localize residues associated with variants via a top-down tandem mass spectrometry approach.

Dissociations of disulfide-linked gaseous polypeptide/protein anions: ion chemistry with implications for protein identification and characterization.

Ion trap collisional activation of whole protein anions that contain disulfide bonds results in the cleavage of one of the bonds that comprises the disulfide linkage. The disulfide linkage can break at any of three possible locations, giving rise to several products with different partitioning of sulfur atoms. A facile second-generation dissociation occurs at the polypeptide backbone from products formed from cleavage of the nearest C-S bond of a disulfide linkage. This cleavage occurs exclusively at the N-terminal side of the cysteine residue, from which the C-S bond was cleaved, thereby yielding c and z-S type product ions. This secondary reaction is apparently a relatively low-energy reaction with relatively high entropy requirements because it is not observed to be a major process under beam-type collisional activation conditions, but is a major process under ion trap collisional activation conditions. The specificity of this cleavage, as well as the ability to distinguish it from other cleavages by the sulfur atom distribution, make it useful for the identification of unknown proteins via database searching. Furthermore, the pattern of disulfide cleavages can be useful in providing information about the location of post-translational modifications. Examples using bovine pancreatic trypsin inhibitor and ribonuclease A and B are given to illustrate these points.