Bath-related Deaths Research Articles

Unveiling Lethal Risks Lurking in Hot Tub Baths: A Review of Tragic Consequences.

Heat therapy, including saunas, jacuzzi, and hot tub bathing, has gained global popularity. However, the escalating incidents of injuries and fatalities associated with hot tub activities are a significant public health concern. This study aims to comprehensively review and analyze the pathophysiological factors contributing to hot tub-related deaths, addressing the need for awareness and mitigation strategies. A comprehensive search of electronic databases, PubMed and Science Direct, was conducted to identify articles relevant to bath-related deaths. Eligible studies were exported to the Rayyan (Qatar Computing Research Institute, Qatar) software for data analysis. The data extracted from the 18 studies were compiled to elucidate the mechanisms underlying hot tub bath-related deaths and to advocate for the adoption of potential mitigation strategies and future directions to prevent such incidents in the future. The review revealed insights into the current trend of fatalities linked to hot tub bathing. A detailed analysis of pathophysiological aspects, encompassing hemodynamics, electrolyte disturbances, serum glucagon alterations, and the impact of alcohol and substance abuse during hot tub use, was conducted. Furthermore, we explored the effects of temperature and conducted a thorough discussion of postmortem evidence analysis concerning deaths related to bathtub usage. Finally, the paper discusses mitigation strategies to prevent fatalities attributed to hot tub bathing. In conclusion, our review highlights growing public health concerns surrounding injuries and fatalities related to hot tub activities. Through an examination of the incidence rates, pathophysiological factors, and proposed mitigation strategies, we provide crucial insights for enhancing safety and addressing the escalating risks associated with hot tub bathing.

Blood pressure, pulse rate, and skin temperature during hot-water bathing in real-world settings among community-dwelling older adults: the HEIJO-KYO Study.

Home hot-tub bathing substantially increases drowning mortality rates among older adults in Japan. Previous laboratory studies on hemodynamic responses during hot-tub bathing have been inconsistent depending on the thermal conditions. Furthermore, real-world hemodynamic changes that occur during bathing remain poorly understood. This study investigated the association between individual thermal states and hemodynamic parameters during hot-tub bathing among community-dwelling older adults. In this cross-sectional study conducted between January 2016 and April 2019, which involved 1,479 older adults (median [range] age, 68 [40-90] years), skin temperature on the abdominal surface was measured every minute. Ambulatory blood pressure and pulse rate were recorded at 15-min intervals for 24 h. Participants underwent simultaneous living room temperature measurements in their homes, and the time and methods of bathing were recorded. Associations between skin temperature and hemodynamic parameters during bathing and between the pre-bath living room temperature and in-bath maximum proximal skin temperature were evaluated using mixed-effects and linear regression models, respectively. A 1 °C increase in skin temperature was significantly associated with a 2.41 mmHg (95% confidence interval [CI]: 2.03-2.79) increase in systolic blood pressure and a 2.99 bpm (95% CI: 2.66-3.32) increase in pulse rate, after adjusting for potential confounders, including age, sex, body mass index, antihypertensive medication use, dyslipidemia, diabetes, and living room and outdoor temperatures. Significant interactions were not observed between sex and skin temperature in relation to systolic blood pressure and pulse rate (P = 0.088 and 0.490, respectively). One standard deviation lower living room temperature before bathing was significantly associated with a 0.41 °C (95% CI: 0.35-0.47) higher maximum skin temperature during bathing. Our findings suggest that pre-bath cold exposure may increase the skin temperature during hot-tub bathing, possibly resulting in excessive hemodynamic changes. This provides a framework for future interventions that utilize pre-bath thermal conditions and bathing environments to prevent bath-related deaths.

Development of prevention strategies against bath-related deaths based on epidemiological surveys of inquest records in Kagoshima Prefecture

Sudden death in the bathroom (bath-related death) occurs more frequently in Japan than in other countries. To clarify the epidemiological characteristics of bath-related deaths, we reviewed inquest records of deaths in Kagoshima Prefecture from 2006 to 2019. We identified 2689 cases of bath-related death. Of these cases, 90% were among people aged ≥ 65 years. The majority occurred in a home bathtub between 16:00 and 20:00. Most deaths (52.0%) occurred in winter (December–February), and there were extremely strong negative correlations with the environmental temperatures (maximum, minimum, and mean) on the day of death. We identified the environmental temperature during cold winter months that bath-related deaths are likely to occur in Kagoshima, although further investigation concerning the effects of other confounding factors is required. Forensic autopsies have only been performed in 29 cases and the cause of death was not diagnosed correctly in the majority of cases. Although autopsies are essential to elucidate the pathogenesis of the deaths, it is difficult to increase the rate of autopsies under the current Japanese death investigation system. Therefore, we suggest that the best way to prevent bath-related death is establishing an “Alert system” based on our results, and to have people refrain from bathing on dangerous days.

Back hemorrhage in bath-related deaths: Insights into the mechanism of bath-related deaths

Forensic pathologists often encounter difficulties while diagnosing bath-related deaths owing to a lack of specific findings for determining the cause. This study reports the characteristic findings noted during autopsy associated with bath-related deaths. The subjects included individuals found deceased in water-filled bathtubs. Originally, a “bathtub death” was defined as a case of drowning in a bathtub without a known cause despite complete investigation including a complete autopsy and examination of the death scene. We also excluded cases with ethanol and/or high drug concentrations in the blood from “bathtub death” cases. Muscular hemorrhages around the scapula were the most common in cases of accidental drowning (72.7%). The frequency of muscular hemorrhages around the scapula was low in cases involving bathtub deaths (11.1%) and natural disease. Subcutaneous hemorrhages in the back were the most frequent in cases of bathtub death (88.9%), followed by accidental drowning (81.8%). The frequency of subcutaneous hemorrhages in the back was low in cases involving suicide and natural disease. The presence of subcutaneous hemorrhages in the back without muscular hemorrhages around the scapula were strongly associated with bathtub deaths (Fisher's exact test, P < 0.0001; sensitivity, 0.84; specificity, 0.91). Subcutaneous hemorrhages were the most frequent in the waist (68.8%), followed by the upper back (50%). Subcutaneous hemorrhages in the back without muscular hemorrhages around the scapula indicated that the deceased had hit their back on falling from a standing position after experiencing disturbances of consciousness. We found the occurrence of orthostatic hypotension while getting out of the bathtub to be the most likely cause for these autopsy findings. Subcutaneous hemorrhages in the back without muscular hemorrhages around the scapula is a characteristic finding of “bathtub deaths”. Although this was a preliminary study, the presence of this finding may aid in clarifying the mechanism of bath-related deaths.

Investigation of Epidemiology and Pathophysiology of Bath-related Death: Forensic Approach

Investigation of Epidemiology and Pathophysiology of Bath-related Death: Forensic Approach

Comprehensive gene expression analysis in the lung of ‘bath-related death”: Investigation for preventing the accidents during bathing.

Comprehensive gene expression analysis in the lung of ‘bath-related death”: Investigation for preventing the accidents during bathing.

Association between sudden unexpected deaths in bathtubs and ambient temperature among elderly Japanese adults: A time-series regression study.

Sudden unexpected deaths in bathtubs among elderly Japanese adults occur predominantly during the cold season. This study investigated the relationship between these deaths and bathing day temperature among elderly adults in Tokyo. Data for 1408 cases of bath-related deaths from January 1 to December 31, 2015 were obtained from the Tokyo Medical Examiner's Office. We excluded 409 cases for the following reasons: criminal death, injury-related death, suicide, intoxication, non-sudden death, not bathtub-related death, out-of-bathroom death, subject aged under 65 years, undetermined bathing date, institutional housing, and bathing not at subject's home. Ultimately, 999 cases were analyzed. Daily mean temperature data were collected. A time-series regression study was performed to estimate the influence of sex, age, and bathing day temperature. Monthly changes in the population bathing in a bathtub were considered in the model. The relative risk (RR) of sudden unexpected death in a bathtub was 1.381 for males (95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.218-1.564) compared to females. The RRs were 4.182 (95% CI: 3.523-4.986) and 9.382 (95% CI: 7.836-11.273) among those aged 75-84 years and ≥85 years, respectively, compared to among those aged 65-74 years. The RR increased to 1.092 (95% CI: 1.082-1.102) as the daily mean temperature decreased by 1 °C. Sudden unexpected death in a bathtub correlated with bathing day temperature among elderly Japanese adults, and extremely low temperature, male sex, and older age increased the risk of such death. Our findings provide insight into preventing sudden unexpected deaths in bathtubs.

Bath-related Deaths in Korea between 2008-2015.

BackgroundThe diagnostic criteria for bathtub drownings are not standardized, and the risk factors associated with bath-related deaths are unclear.MethodsWe analyzed a Korean nationwide database of bath-related deaths that occurred between January 2008 and December 2015. Eighty-four cases were enrolled after reviewing 31,123 autopsy records.ResultsThe subjects' ages ranged from 18 to 91 years, with a mean age ± standard deviation of 61.3 ± 16.0 years. Bath-related deaths in the winter were approximately 4.6-fold greater than those in the summer. Of the 84 subjects, the primary cause of death in 57 (67.9%) was drowning in the bath; 24 (28.6%) drowned of other causes such as natural diseases, and 3 (3.6%) died of acute alcohol intoxication. We analyzed water-inhalation signs to establish criteria for bathtub drowning diagnosis. There were significantly higher incidences of hyperinflated lungs, water in the sphenoid sinus and stomach/duodenal contents, and Paltauf's spots (subpleural hemorrhage) in bathtub-drowned subjects compared to non-drowned individuals (P < 0.01). Multiple signs of water inhalation were significantly associated with bathtub drowning (P < 0.01). The two leading contributory causes of bath-related death were cardiovascular diseases and alcohol intoxication (binge drinking before bathing).ConclusionThe diagnosis of bath-related deaths could present considerable medico-legal problems; therefore, a comprehensive autopsy with a thorough scene investigation can clarify the cause of death in these situations. Preventive strategies for reducing such deaths should target alcohol drinking before bathing and long soaking times in bathtubs, especially among elderly individuals with preexisting cardiovascular diseases.

Forensic Review of Hot Bath-Related Death in the Elderly: Focused on Japanese Studies

Forensic Review of Hot Bath-Related Death in the Elderly: Focused on Japanese Studies

Postmortem computed tomography findings in cases of bath-related death: Applicability and limitation in forensic practice

PurposeBath-related deaths occur frequently in Japan, and many of these deaths are diagnosed as death from disease without autopsy in the current Japanese death-investigation system. Therefore, we aimed to examine the postmortem computed tomography (PMCT) findings of bath-related deaths to determine if PMCT can differentiate between real cases of drowning and sudden deaths not related to drowning. MethodsBath-related deaths were sampled from all autopsies conducted at the Tokyo Medical Examiner’s Office from September 2015 to August 2016. A total of 90 bath-related deaths (77 drowning cases and 13 non-drowning cases) and 50 controls (sudden cardiac deaths non-related to bathing) were included in this study. We investigated factors contributing to drowning and measured PMCT parameters (presence/density of fluid in the maxillary sinus/trachea, distance between the lungs, lung patterns [ground glass opacities, consolidation], position of the right diaphragmatic dome, density in the right atrium, stomach volume, and density of the gastric/duodenal contents). ResultsThe analysis of the factors contributing to drowning showed that alcohol intoxication was the most frequent (n=25), followed by cardiac pathology (n=22), and psychotropic drug intoxication (n=6). Radiological evaluation showed that measurements of all parameters differed significantly between the drowning group and the controls. In addition, significant differences were observed between drowning and non-drowning cases in three radiological parameters (i.e., distance between lungs, stomach volume, and density of gastric contents). ConclusionsMajority of bath-related deaths in this study showed signs of drowning at autopsy, and we observed a range of factors that contributed to drowning. By using several radiological parameters (e.g., the distance between the lungs, stomach volume, and the density of the gastric contents), PMCT for the investigation of bath-related deaths might indicate that drowning as opposed to other factors unrelated to drowning (e.g., sudden cardiac death) was the cause of death. This might allow for calculation of accurate mortality statistics on bath-related deaths.

Usefulness and limitation of postmortem computed tomography in bath-related death: Four case reports

Abstract Bath-related death occurs relatively frequently in Japan; however, there is room for improvement in the investigation of such deaths. Here, we describe four autopsy cases of bath-related death (one case of drowning; one of drowning under the influence of drinking; and two cases of sudden cardiac death without drowning) in which postmortem computed tomography (PMCT) was performed before autopsy. Based on analysis of autopsy and PMCT findings of these cases, we further discuss the utility and limitation of PMCT when applied to bath-related death. Comparison of the autopsy findings and PMCT findings between the cases suggests that combinations of several PMCT findings in bath-related death cases (e.g., signs suggestive of overinflated lungs, hemodilution, and excessive water intake in the gastrointestinal tract) can serve to distinguish drowning cases from non-drowning cases. Many bath-related deaths have been reported to have drowning signs at autopsy, although elderly victims with cardiovascular diseases tend to be diagnosed as death due to disease without employing PMCT or autopsy. Therefore, this case series suggests that implementation of PMCT in bath-related death might prevent underestimation of drowning as a cause of death. Although PMCT alone has several limitations, such as inability to evaluate toxicology or heart pathology, implementation of PMCT may trigger a more detailed investigation of the background regarding bath-related death, especially in drowning cases. Based on this case report, we emphasize that PMCT should be performed routinely in bath-related death for compilation of accurate mortality statistics of bath-related death for developing future prevention strategies.

Relationship between Bath-related Deaths and Low Air Temperature.

Objective Bath-related sudden cardiac arrests occur frequently in Japan. Although previous studies have reported that most fatal events occurr in winter, the reason why such events exhibit a seasonal variation has not been elucidated. In this study, we hypothesized that the occurrence of bath-related deaths was correlated with a low air temperature. Methods This prospective cross-sectional observational study was conducted in the Tokyo Metropolitan area between October 2012 and March 2013. Data were collected for all cases involving the activation of the emergency medical system because of an accident or acute illness related to bathing that occurred in Tokyo during the study period. In particular, elderly (≥65 years) cardiac arrest victims who had been found in a bathtub filled with water were enrolled. The relationship between the daily number of cardiac arrest events and the lowest daily air temperature in Tokyo was studied using a nonlinear regression model. Results A total of 3,624 bath-related events were registered in this study. Among these events, 1,081 deaths of elderly individuals who had been found in a bathtub filled with water were recorded. A close correlation was observed between the daily number of events and the lowest daily air temperature. This correlation was described by the following equation: y=8.38e-0.07x, where y was the daily number of cardiac arrests and x was the lowest daily air temperature. Conclusion A low air temperature was closely correlated with the occurrence of bath-related cardiac arrest.

13-2 Bath-related deaths in Kagoshima, Japan from 2006 to 2013: Differences in epidemiological factors between locations where the death occurred

13-2 Bath-related deaths in Kagoshima, Japan from 2006 to 2013: Differences in epidemiological factors between locations where the death occurred

Characteristics of sudden bath-related death investigated by medical examiners in Tokyo, Japan.

BackgroundSudden bath-related deaths occur frequently in Japan, particularly among elderly people. However, the precise mechanism of bath-related death remains uncertain, and effective prevention strategies have not been established.MethodsCases of bath-related deaths (n = 3289) were selected from all cases handled by the Tokyo Medical Examiner’s Office from 2009 to 2011 (N = 41 336). The ages and occurrence dates were examined, and major autopsy findings, including toxicological analysis, were evaluated for the autopsied cases (n = 550).ResultsMost cases occurred in individuals older than 60 years of age during winter. Analysis of autopsy findings revealed water inhalation signs in many cases (n = 435, 79.1%). Circulatory system diseases constituted more than half of the pathological findings regarding factors that may have contributed significantly to death (n = 300, 54.5%), and cardiac lesions were the most common pathological finding (n = 250, 45.5%). However, approximately one-third of the cases exhibited no remarkable pathological findings (n = 198, 36.0%). A quarter of all cases involved blood ethanol levels that exceeded 0.5 mg/mL (n = 140).ConclusionsThe results suggested that drowning plays an important role in the final process of bath-related death. Circulatory system diseases may be the primary underlying pathology; however, there were variations in the medical histories and pathologies of cases of bath-related death. From a preventive perspective, family members should pay attention to elderly people with circulatory system diseases during bathing, particularly in winter. Additionally, the notion that ill or inebriated individuals should not take baths should be reinforced.

Bath-related deaths in Kagoshima, the southwest part of Japan

In Japan, sudden death in the bathroom (what we call 'bath-related death') has been reported to occur particularly in the elderly population in the winter. This investigation aimed to obtain a better understanding of the factors associated with bath-related deaths. For this purpose, a retrospective review of the inquest records in Kagoshima Prefecture, the southwest part of Japan, during 2006-2007 was performed. There were 338 cases of bath-related death, which corresponds to a crude mortality rate of 9.7 per 100,000 persons per year. The occurrence of bath-related death was similar to that of other prefectures in Japan, despite the warm environment in Kagoshima. The victims' ages ranged from 37 to 101 years (mean 76.6 years) and 88.8% of patients were over 65 years. The associated factors included winter season (56.2%) and a medical history of hypertension (37.3%). These demographic and circumstantial factors correlated with previous studies in Japan. These results suggest that the Japanese method of bathing, in addition to cold bathrooms in winter, contributes to the high rate of bath-related death in Japan. In addition, the mortality rate of people who lived alone was significantly higher than that of those who lived with their families. Most cases occurred in the home bathroom (84.9%) at the time when elderly people usually bathe (48.7%). Our results indicate that bath-related death occurs most often during the normal daily life of the aged. Protective activities of the Japanese government and society should aim to reduce the number of these tragic deaths in the bathroom. Further, no autopsies were performed on the cases in this study. Therefore, the rate of autopsies in bath-related death should be increased in order to accumulate data based on objective evidence.