This study uses a phenomenological approach to examine consumption patterns of counterfeit goods by Bottom of the Pyramid (BOP) consumers in West Bengal, India. Forty-seven semi-structured interviews conducted with BOP consumers were subjected to thematic analysis. The study revealed four central themes for counterfeit consumption by BOP consumers: counterfeit purchasing patterns, brand recognition and purchase-point selection criteria, and counterfeit brand purchase criteria. Furthermore, this study contributes to the literature by revealing four counterfeit consumption patterns based on the awareness and willingness of BOP consumers. This study has critically analysed the role of neighbourhood retailers in counterfeit consumption at the BOP. Interestingly, this study also pioneered identifying the zone of awareness-indifference formed by normative influence and bounded rationality as coping strategies against vulnerability in the context of BOP counterfeit consumption. The implications of counterfeit consumption for marketers targeting the BOP have been discussed.