Reviewed by: The Accompaniment in “Unaccompanied” Bach: Interpreting the Sonatas and Partitas for Violin by Stanley Ritchie Peter Sheppard Skærved The Accompaniment in “Unaccompanied” Bach: Interpreting the Sonatas and Partitas for Violin. By Stanley Ritchie. [End Page 188] Bloomington; Indianapolis: Indiana University Press, 2016. (Publications of the Early Music Institute.) [xiii, 120 p. ISBN 978-0-253-02198-4. $33] For any violinist, this book is a practical delight. It deserves to join the great works by Leopold Mozart, Editha Knocker, Leopold Auer, Pierre Baillot, Joseph Szigeti, and their peers, which are on every serious player’s shelf. The fact that Stanley Ritchie confines his narrative to the consideration of the six solo violin works by J. S. Bach is incidental. As he says in his peroration “Last Words”: “There is so much to be gleaned from their careful study that can be applied to other repertoire – truths that can be applied to all music – thereby supporting one’s growth as a musician”. (p. 117) Unlike the majority of similar works, the presentation and layout of this publication are useful to the player. The softback format ensures that it can be opened on a music stand, and the paper takes pencil and pen well. A performer will want to write all over this book and (from experience), this works well! “How to” books are fascinating. Whether they are Victorian “popular educators”, Taekwondo manuals, or pedagogical works, they tell us as much about their authors and the times in which they are written, as they do of their intended audiences. Stanley Ritchie’s fascinating work does not escape from this, nor does it try to. Indeed, one of its fascinations is the author’s engagement with the time-specific, if not time-limited, nature of his dialogue with his readers. He is aware that this book stands as a personal cadenza to radical change, to which he has been contributor and witness: “[. . .] the revolution has been successful beyond any prediction. [. . .]” (p. 116) The book is very carefully structured; there is a sense that its author was keen to reflect the six-part form of the Sonatas & Partitas (it has twelve chapters). Unlike modern technical works, it begins with first “Principles of Interpretation”, from notation to ornamentation, in the way that one would expect to find in a historical work by Ludwig Spohr or Michel Woldemar. This is followed by a chapter entitled “Dance Forms”. Here one cannot get away from the fact that the author is frustrated by the modern lack of physical understanding of what it is to dance at all: ‘”I recommend to my students that they at least watch videos, if not live performances of Baroque dances [. . .], better still, that they avail themselves of any opportunity to experience Baroque dance personally in a workshop setting”. (p. 10) I cannot be alone in feeling that what he really wanted to say was, “learn to dance, and then dance!” Next comes “Analytical Methods and Exercises”. Fundamental to this is a statement with which I agree, although for very different reasons: “There is no such thing as ‘unaccompanied Bach’ ”. (p. 16) I found myself at odds with many of the suggestions in this third Chapter. Ritchie’s insistence on extracting melodic material from the simplification of figuration results in weakened readings of the music. His hierarchical approach to this “breaking down” has the dreaded “murder to dissect” effect. (p. 21) I believe that it is a mistake to pronounce, as he does, that voice-leading should emphasise the primary voice at any given time. The missing resolution in the opening of the A minor “prelude” is a powerful example of how Bach toyed with this, and made invisible voices tangible, even audible, through misdirection and suggestion. But I appreciate that mine is a personal reaction: his work is all the better for the bold stance taken on this subject. The book is full of gem-like insights; the kind of things which any player will seize on, try out, wrestle with, and never forget: “In Bach’s manuscript, many slurs are quickly and imprecisely drawn, as if to say: ‘It’s obvious what I mean – I don’t need to...