Abstract Background Mitochondrial DNA (mitDNA) has similarities to bacterial DNA, which contains inflammatogenic unmethylated CpG motifs. We found that mitDNA that escapes from autophagy causes inflammatory response and heart failure under pressure overload. DNA methyltransferase 1 (DNMT1) maintains methylation patterns in somatic cells. Deletion of DNMT1 results in embryonic lethality in mice and mitotic catastrophe in cultured cells. Additional possible translational start sites (ATG1, ATG2) are located upstream of the commonly accepted nuclear DNMT1 translational start site (ATG3) and there is a conserved mitochondrial translocation signal sequence between ATG1 and ATG3. The role of mitochondrial DNMT1 in the development of heart failure remains to be elucidated. Purpose The purpose of this study is to examine the in vivo role of mitochondrial DNMT1 in the heart under pressure overload. Methods We generated HA-tagged DNMT1 constructs, 1) starting from ATG1 (termed as whole) 2) from ATG3 (nuclear) and 3) from ATG3 and mutated in the nuclear translocation sequence (mitochondrial) and transfected HEK293 cells with the constructs. Localization of HA-tagged proteins was assessed by immunocytochemistry. We also generated mitochondrial DNMT1-deficient mice by inserting mutations into the ATG1 and ATG2. The mice were subjected to pressure overload by means of transverse aortic constriction (TAC) to induce heart failure. Cardiac remodelling was assessed by echocardiography as well as histological analyses 4 weeks after operation. Results Whole, nuclear and mitochondrial DMNT1 translocated to both mitochondria and nuclei, only nucleus and only mitochondria, respectively. Mitochondrial DNMT1-deficient mice were born at Mendelian frequency and grew to adulthood. Those showed no cardiac phenotypes under baseline conditions. However, the mice exhibited severe systolic dysfunction, indicated by left ventricular fractional shortening, 2 weeks after surgery compared with control littermates (control littermates 47.9% versus Mitochondrial DNMT1-deficient mice 32.3%, p<0.05). Intermuscular cell infiltration was observed in TAC-operated mitochondrial DNMT1-deficient hearts. Conclusions Mitochondrial DNA methyltransferase 1 plays a protective role in failing hearts and mitDNA methylation might be a therapeutic target to treat patients with heart failure.