In diverse fields, machine learning (ML) has sparked transformative changes, primarily driven by the wealth of big data. However, an alternative approach seeks to mine insights from "precious data", offering the possibility to reveal missed knowledge and escape potential knowledge traps. In this context, Bayesian optimization (BO) protocols have emerged as crucial tools for optimizing the synthesis and discovery of a broad spectrum of compounds including nanoparticles. In our work, we aimed to go beyond the commonly explored experimental conditions and showcase a workflow capable of unearthing fresh insights, even in well-studied research domains. The growth of AuNRs is a nonequilibrium process that remains poorly understood despite the presence of well-established seeded growth protocols. Traditional research aimed at understanding the mechanism of AuNR growth has primarily relied on altering one reaction condition at a time. While these studies are undeniably valuable, they often fail to capture the synergies between different reaction conditions, thus constraining the depth of insights they can offer. In the present study, we exploit BO, to identify diverse experimental conditions yielding AuNRs with similar spectroscopic characteristics. Notably, we identify viable and accelerated synthesis conditions involving elevated temperatures (36-40 °C) as well as high ascorbic acid concentrations. More importantly, we note that ascorbic acid and temperature can modulate each other's undesirable influences on the growth of AuNRs. Finally, by harnessing the power of interpretable ML algorithms, complemented by our deep chemical understanding, we revisited the established hierarchical relationships among reaction conditions that impact the El-Sayed-based growth of AuNRs.