ATP-dependent Chromatin Remodeling Protein Research Articles

Oncogenic functions and therapeutic potentials of targeted inhibition of SMARCAL1 in small cell lung cancer

Small cell lung cancer (SCLC) is a recalcitrant cancer characterized by high frequency loss-of-function mutations in tumor suppressors with a lack of targeted therapy due to absence of high frequency gain-of-function abnormalities in oncogenes. SMARCAL1 is a member of the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein SNF2 family that plays critical roles in DNA damage repair and genome stability maintenance. Here, we showed that SMARCAL1 was overexpressed in SCLC patient samples and was inversely associated with overall survival of the patients. SMARCAL1 was required for SCLC cell proliferation and genome integrity. Mass spectrometry revealed that PAR6B was a downstream SMARCAL1 signal molecule which rescued inhibitory effects caused by silencing of SMARCAL1. By screening of 36 FDA-approved clinically available agents related to DNA damage repair, we found that an aza-anthracenedione, pixantrone, was a potent SMARCAL1 inhibitor which suppressed the expression of SMARCAL1 and PAR6B at protein level. Pixantrone caused DNA damage and exhibited inhibitory effects on SCLC cells in vitro and in a patient-derived xenograft mouse model. These results indicated that SMARCAL1 functions as an oncogene in SCLC, and pixantrone as a SMARCAL1 inhibitor bears therapeutic potentials in this deadly disease.

A mouse model of ATRX deficiency with cognitive deficits and autistic traits

BackgroundATRX is an ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein with essential roles in safeguarding genome integrity and modulating gene expression. Deficiencies in this protein cause ATR-X syndrome, a condition characterized by intellectual disability and an array of developmental abnormalities, including features of autism. Previous studies demonstrated that deleting ATRX in mouse forebrain excitatory neurons postnatally resulted in male-specific memory deficits, but no apparent autistic-like behaviours.MethodsWe generated mice with an earlier embryonic deletion of ATRX in forebrain excitatory neurons and characterized their behaviour using a series of memory and autistic-related paradigms.ResultsWe found that mutant mice displayed a broader spectrum of impairments, including fear memory, decreased anxiety-like behaviour, hyperactivity, as well as self-injurious and repetitive grooming. Sex-specific alterations were also observed, including male-specific aggression, sensory gating impairments, and decreased social memory.ConclusionsCollectively, the findings indicate that early developmental abnormalities arising from ATRX deficiency in forebrain excitatory neurons contribute to the presentation of fear memory deficits as well as autistic-like behaviours.

Landscape of mSWI/SNF chromatin remodeling complex perturbations in neurodevelopmental disorders.

DNA sequencing-based studies of neurodevelopmental disorders (NDDs) have identified a wide range of genetic determinants. However, a comprehensive analysis of these data, in aggregate, has not to date been performed. Here, we find that genes encoding the mammalian SWI/SNF (mSWI/SNF or BAF) family of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein complexes harbor the greatest number of de novo missense and protein-truncating variants among nuclear protein complexes. Non-truncating NDD-associated protein variants predominantly disrupt the cBAF subcomplex and cluster in four key structural regions associated with high disease severity, including mSWI/SNF-nucleosome interfaces, the ATPase-core ARID-armadillo repeat (ARM) module insertion site, the Arp module and DNA-binding domains. Although over 70% of the residues perturbed in NDDs overlap with those mutated in cancer, ~60% of amino acid changes are NDD-specific. These findings provide a foundation to functionally group variants and link complex aberrancies to phenotypic severity, serving as a resource for the chromatin, clinical genetics and neurodevelopment communities.

PLK-1 Interacting Checkpoint Helicase, PICH, Mediates Cellular Oxidative Stress Response.

Cells respond to oxidative stress by elevating the levels of antioxidants, signaling, and transcriptional regulation, often implemented by chromatin remodeling proteins. The study presented here shows that the expression of PICH, a Rad54-like helicase belonging to the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein family, is upregulated during oxidative stress in HeLa cells. We also show that PICH regulates the expression of Nrf2, a transcription factor regulating antioxidant response in both the absence and presence of oxidative stress. The overexpression of PICH in PICH-depleted cells restored Nrf2 as well as antioxidant gene expression. In turn, Nrf2 regulated the expression of PICH in the presence of oxidative stress. ChIP experiments showed that PICH is present on the Nrf2 as well as antioxidant gene promoters, suggesting that the protein might be regulating the expression of these genes directly by binding to the DNA sequences. In addition, Nrf2 and histone acetylation (H3K27ac) also played a role in activating transcription in the presence of oxidative stress. Both Nrf2 and H3K27ac were found to be present on PICH and antioxidant promoters. Their occupancy was dependent on the PICH expression as fold enrichment was found to be decreased in PICH-depleted cells. PICH ablation led to the reduced expression of Nrf2 and impaired antioxidant response, leading to increased ROS content and thus showing PICH is essential for the cell to respond to oxidative stress.

On the Interaction Between SMARCAL1 and BRG1.

SMARCAL1 and BRG1, both classified as ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins, play a role in double-strand break DNA damage response pathways. Mutations in SMARCAL1 cause Schimke Immuno-osseous Dysplasia (SIOD) while mutations in BRG1 are associated with Coffin-Siris Syndrome (CSS4). In HeLa cells, SMARCAL1 and BRG1 co-regulate the expression of ATM, ATR, and RNAi genes on doxorubicin-induced DNA damage. Both the proteins are found to be simultaneously present on the promoter of these genes. Based on these results we hypothesized that SMARCAL1 and BRG1 interact with each other forming a complex. In this paper, we validate our hypothesis and show that SMARCAL1 and BRG1 do indeed interact with each other both in the absence and presence of doxorubicin. The formation of these complexes is dependent on the ATPase activity of both SMARCAL1 and BRG1. Using deletion constructs, we show that the HARP domains of SMARCAL1 mediate interaction with BRG1 while multiple domains of BRG1 are probably important for binding to SMARCAL1. We also show that SIOD-associated mutants fail to form a complex with BRG1. Similarly, CSS4-associated mutants of BRG1 fail to interact with SMARCAL1, thus, possibly contributing to the failure of the DNA damage response pathway and pathophysiology associated with SIOD and CSS4.

The chromatin remodeler Chd1 supports MRX and Exo1 functions in resection of DNA double-strand breaks.

Repair of DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) by homologous recombination (HR) requires that the 5'-terminated DNA strands are resected to generate single-stranded DNA overhangs. This process is initiated by a short-range resection catalyzed by the MRX (Mre11-Rad50-Xrs2) complex, which is followed by a long-range step involving the nucleases Exo1 and Dna2. Here we show that the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ATP-dependent chromatin-remodeling protein Chd1 participates in both short- and long-range resection by promoting MRX and Exo1 association with the DSB ends. Furthermore, Chd1 reduces histone occupancy near the DSB ends and promotes DSB repair by HR. All these functions require Chd1 ATPase activity, supporting a role for Chd1 in the opening of chromatin at the DSB site to facilitate MRX and Exo1 processing activities.

Altering mammalian transcription networking with ADAADi: An inhibitor of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling

Active DNA-dependent ATPase A Domain inhibitor (ADAADi) is the only known inhibitor of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins that targets the ATPase domain of these proteins. The molecule is synthesized by aminoglycoside phosphotransferase enzyme in the presence of aminoglycosides. ADAADi interacts with ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins through motif Ia present in the conserved helicase domain, and thus, can potentially inhibit all members of this family of proteins. We show that mammalian cells are sensitive to ADAADi but with variable responses in different cell lines. ADAADi can be generated from a wide variety of aminoglycosides; however, cells showed differential response to ADAADi generated from various aminoglycosides. Using HeLa and DU145 cells as model system we have explored the effect of ADAADi on cellular functions. We show that the transcriptional network of a cell type is altered when treated with sub-lethal concentration of ADAADi. Although ADAADi has no known effects on DNA chemical and structural integrity, expression of DNA-damage response genes was altered. The transcripts encoding for the pro-apoptotic proteins were found to be upregulated while the anti-apoptotic genes were found to be downregulated. This was accompanied by increased apoptosis leading us to hypothesize that the ADAADi treatment promotes apoptotic-type of cell death by upregulating the transcription of pro-apoptotic genes. ADAADi also inhibited migration of cells as well as their colony forming ability leading us to conclude that the compound has effective anti-tumor properties.

The Mechanism of Chromatin Remodeler SMARCAD1/Fun30 in Response to DNA Damage.

DNA packs into highly condensed chromatin to organize the genome in eukaryotes but occludes many regulatory DNA elements. Access to DNA within nucleosomes is therefore required for a variety of biological processes in cells including transcription, replication, and DNA repair. To cope with this problem, cells employ a set of specialized ATP-dependent chromatin-remodeling protein complexes to enable dynamic access to packaged DNA. In the present review, we summarize the recent advances in the functional and mechanistic studies on a particular chromatin remodeler SMARCAD1Fun30 which has been demonstrated to play a key role in distinct cellular processes and gained much attention in recent years. Focus is given to how SMARCAD1Fun30 regulates various cellular processes through its chromatin remodeling activity, and especially the regulatory role of SMARCAD1Fun30 in gene expression control, maintenance and establishment of heterochromatin, and DNA damage repair. Moreover, we review the studies on the molecular mechanism of SMARCAD1Fun30 that promotes the DNA end-resection on double-strand break ends, including the mechanisms of recruitment, activity regulation and chromatin remodeling.

SMARCAL1, the annealing helicase and the transcriptional co-regulator.

The ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins play an important role in DNA repair. The energy released by ATP hydrolysis is used for myriad functions ranging from nucleosome repositioning and nucleosome eviction to histone variant exchange. In addition, the distant member of the family, SMARCAL1, uses the energy to reanneal stalled replication forks in response to DNA damage. Biophysical studies have shown that this protein has the unique ability to recognize and bind specifically to DNA structures possessing double-strand to single-strand transition regions. Mutations in SMARCAL1 have been linked to Schimke immuno-osseous dysplasia, an autosomal recessive disorder that exhibits variable penetrance and expressivity. It has long been hypothesized that the variable expressivity and pleiotropic phenotypes observed in the patients might be due to the ability of SMARCAL1 to co-regulate the expression of a subset of genes within the genome. Recently, the role of SMARCAL1 in regulating transcription has been delineated. In this review, we discuss the biophysical and functional properties of the protein that help it to transcriptionally co-regulate DNA damage response as well as to bind to the stalled replication fork and stabilize it, thus ensuring genomic stability. We also discuss the role of SMARCAL1 in cancer and the possibility of using this protein as a chemotherapeutic target.

Regulation of ATM and ATR by SMARCAL1 and BRG1

The G2/M checkpoint is activated on DNA damage by the ATM and ATR kinases that are regulated by post-translational modifications. In this paper, the transcriptional co-regulation of ATM and ATR by SMARCAL1 and BRG1, both members of the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein family, is described. SMARCAL1 and BRG1 co-localize on the promoters of ATM and ATR; downregulation of SMARCAL1 and BRG1 results in transcriptional repression of ATM/ATR and overriding of the G2/M checkpoint leading to mitotic abnormalities. On doxorubicin-induced DNA damage, SMARCAL1 and BRG1 are upregulated and these two proteins in turn, upregulate the expression of ATM/ATR. The transcriptional response to DNA damage is feedback regulated by phospho-ATM as it binds to the promoters of SMARCAL1, BRG1, ATM and ATR on DNA damage. The regulation of ATM/ATR is rendered non-functional in Schimke Immuno-Osseous Dysplasia where SMARCAL1 is mutated and in Coffin-Siris Syndrome where BRG1 is mutated. Thus, an intricate transcriptional regulation of DNA damage response genes mediated by SMARCAL1 and BRG1 is present in mammalian cells.

RecA-like domain 2 of DNA-dependent ATPase A domain, a SWI2/SNF2 protein, mediates conformational integrity and ATP hydrolysis.

ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins use the energy released from ATP hydrolysis to reposition nucleosomes in DNA-dependent processes. These proteins are classified as SF2 helicases. SMARCAL1, a member of this protein family, is known to modulate both DNA repair and transcription by specifically recognizing DNA molecules possessing double-strand to single-strand transition regions. Mutations in this gene cause a rare autosomal recessive disorder known as Schimke Immuno-Osseous Dysplasia (SIOD).Structural studies have shown that the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins possess two RecA-like domains termed as RecA-like domain 1 and RecA-like domain 2. Using Active DNA-dependent ATPase A domain (ADAAD), the bovine homolog of SMARCAL1, as a model system we had previously shown that the RecA-like domain 1 containing helicase motifs Q, I, Ia, II, and III are sufficient for ligand binding; however, the Rec A-like domain 2 containing motifs IV, V, and VI are needed for ATP hydrolysis. In the present study, we have focused on the motifs present in the RecA-like domain 2. Our studies demonstrate that the presence of an aromatic residue in motif IV is needed for interaction with DNA in the presence of ATP. We also show that the motif V is required for the catalytic efficiency of the protein and motif VI is needed for interaction with DNA in the presence of ATP. Finally, we show that the SIOD-associated mutation, R820H, present in motif VI results in loss of ATPase activity, and therefore, reduced response to DNA damage.

SWI/SNF subunit expression heterogeneity in human aplastic anemia stem/progenitors

Acquired aplastic anemia (AA) is a bone marrow (BM) failure associated with autoimmune destruction of hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs). Although somatic mutations have been identified in AA patients, mutations alone do not explain AA pathophysiology. SWI/SNF is an evolutionarily conserved, multi-subunit, ATP-dependent chromatin-remodeling protein complex that plays an important role in mammalian hematopoiesis. Herein, gene expression analysis identified a significant loss of the SWI/SNF core component SMARCC1, along with ARID1B, ACTL6A, and SMARCD1, in human AA BM CD34+ HSCs and hematopoietic stem and progenitor cells (HSPCs) compared with normal HSPCs. However, expression of SMARCA4, SMARCB1, SMARCD3, and DPF2 remained intact in our AA cohort. PBRM1, BRD7, and SMARCA2 expression were significantly upregulated in both untreated and follow-up AA patients. Clonal hematopoiesis in AA is associated with evolution to late clonal disorders, including myelodysplastic syndromes (MDS). Apart from SMARCD1 loss, we did not observe significant alteration of SWI/SNF expression in MDS HSPCs, indicating SWI/SNF differential expression in AA and MDS. In addition, except for ACTL6A, SWI/SNF expression was unaltered in aged HSPCs. Importantly, our results provide evidence for loss of SWI/SNF in AA, and may implicate AA HSPC-autonomous defective SWI/SNF regulation as an integral component of BM failure, in addition to autoimmune destruction of AA HSCs. These findings illustrate for the first time SWI/SNF subunit expression heterogeneity in human AA HSPCs and require prognostic validation in a larger cohort.

Motif IV and V of Active DNA Dependent ATPase a Domain, a SWI2/SNF2 Protein, Are Required for Both Ligand Binding and Conformational Integrity

ATP dependent chromatin remodeling proteins use the energy released by ATP hydrolysis to alter the chromatin structure to make it accessible for fundamental processes e.g. replication, transcription and repair etc. SMARCAL1 is a distant member of SNF2 family of chromatin remodelers and has been reported to interact with RPA at the DNA damage site and exhibits reannealing helicase activity and maintain the genome integrity. Mutations in hSMARCAL cause a rare autosomal recessive disorder known as Schimke Immunoosseous Dysplasia (SIOD). ADAAD is the N-terminal proteolytic fragment of SMARCAL1 that possesses all the characteristic helicase motifs (Q, I, Ia, II, III, IV, V and VI) of SMARCAL. It can hydrolyse the ATP only in presence of a stem-loop DNA structure. Using ADAAD I created F507A and F507W site directed mutant of motif IV and S558A and T560A site directed mutant of motif V of ADAAD to investigate the function of these motifs in the ADAAD. Results showed that F507A was inactive whereas S558A and T560A had the same activity as compare to ADAAD. Kinetic studies of S558A and T560A showed that the kinetic parameters of S558A and T560A were lowered as compared to ADAAD. So these residues are important for the turnover number and catalytic effieciency of the ADAAD. Binding studies showed that F507A binding was lowered with either ligand in presence of another ligand. Circular dichroism studies showed that the conformation of these mutants were altered as compare to ADAAD. Thermal denaturation data by circular dichroism showed that Tm was almost same of all these mutants as compare to ADAAD. In conclusion, motif IV and V are required for the conformational integrity of the protein.

BAZ1B in Nucleus Accumbens Regulates Reward-Related Behaviors in Response to Distinct Emotional Stimuli.

We show that BAZ1B, a component of chromatin remodeling complexes, in the nucleus accumbens regulates reward-related behaviors in response to chronic exposure to both rewarding and aversive stimuli by regulating largely distinct subsets of genes.

The epigenetics of CHARGE syndrome

In biology, we continue to appreciate the fact that the DNA sequence alone falls short when attempting to explain the intricate inheritance patterns for complex traits. This is particularly true for human disorders that appear to have simple genetic causes. The study of epigenetics, and the increased access to the epigenetic profiles of different tissues has begun to shed light on the genetic complexity of many basic biological processes, both physiological and pathological. Epigenetics refers to heritable changes in gene expression that are not due to alterations in the DNA sequence. Various mechanisms of epigenetic regulation exist, including DNA methylation and histone modification. The identification, and increased understanding of key players and mechanisms of epigenetic regulation have begun to provide significant insight into the underlying origins of various human genetic disorders. One such disorder is CHARGE syndrome (OMIM #214800), which is a leading cause of deaf-blindness worldwide. A majority of CHARGE syndrome cases are caused by haploinsufficiency for the CHD7 gene, which encodes an ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein involved in the epigenetic regulation of gene expression. The CHD7 protein has been highly conserved throughout evolution, and research into the function of CHD7 homologs in multiple model systems has increased our understanding of this family of proteins, and epigenetic mechanisms in general. Here we provide a review of CHARGE syndrome, and discuss the epigenetic functions of CHD7 in humans and CHD7 homologs in model organisms.

Transcriptional Regulation of Atp-Dependent Chromatin Remodeling Factors: Smarcal1 and Brg1 Mutually Co-Regulate Each Other.

The ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors regulate gene expression. However, it is not known whether these factors regulate each other. Given the ability of these factors to regulate the accessibility of DNA to transcription factors, we postulate that one ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factor should be able to regulate the transcription of another ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factor. In this paper, we show that BRG1 and SMARCAL1, both members of the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein family, regulate each other. BRG1 binds to the SMARCAL1 promoter, while SMARCAL1 binds to the brg1 promoter. During DNA damage, the occupancy of SMARCAL1 on the brg1 promoter increases coinciding with an increase in BRG1 occupancy on the SMARCAL1 promoter, leading to increased brg1 and SMARCAL1 transcripts respectively. This is the first report of two ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling factors regulating each other.

Chromatin remodeling and bivalent histone modifications in embryonic stem cells.

Pluripotent embryonic stem cells (ESCs) are characterized by distinct epigenetic features including a relative enrichment of histone modifications related to active chromatin. Among these is tri-methylation of lysine 4 on histone H3 (H3K4me3). Several thousands of the H3K4me3-enriched promoters in pluripotent cells also contain a repressive histone mark, namely H3K27me3, a situation referred to as "bivalency". While bivalent promoters are not unique to pluripotent cells, they are relatively enriched in these cell types, largely marking developmental and lineage-specific genes which are silent but poised for immediate action. The H3K4me3 and H3K27me3 modifications are catalyzed by lysine methyltransferases which are usually found within, although not entirely limited to, the Trithorax group (TrxG) and Polycomb group (PcG) protein complexes, respectively, but these do not provide selective bivalent specificity. Recent studies highlight the family of ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling proteins as regulators of bivalent domains. Here, we discuss bivalency in general, describe the machineries that catalyze bivalent chromatin domains, and portray the emerging connection between bivalency and the action of different families of chromatin remodelers, namely INO80, esBAF, and NuRD, in pluripotent cells. We posit that chromatin remodeling proteins may enable "bivalent specificity", often selectively acting on, or selectively depleted from, bivalent domains.

BAZ1B is dispensable for H2AX phosphorylation on Tyrosine 142 during spermatogenesis.

ABSTRACTMeiosis is precisely regulated by the factors involved in DNA damage response in somatic cells. Among them, phosphorylation of H2AX on Serine 139 (γH2AX) is an essential signal for the silencing of unsynapsed sex chromosomes during male meiosis. However, it remains unknown how adjacent H2AX phosphorylation on Tyrosine 142 (pTyr142) is regulated in meiosis. Here we investigate the meiotic functions of BAZ1B (WSTF), the only known Tyr142 kinase in somatic cells, using mice possessing a conditional deletion of BAZ1B. Although BAZ1B deletion causes ectopic γH2AX signals on synapsed autosomes during the early pachytene stage, BAZ1B is dispensable for fertility and critical events during spermatogenesis. BAZ1B deletion does not alter events on unsynapsed axes and pericentric heterochromatin formation. Furthermore, BAZ1B is dispensable for localization of the ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein SMARCA5 (SNF2h) during spermatogenesis despite the complex formation between BAZ1B and SMARCA5, known as the WICH complex, in somatic cells. Notably, pTyr142 is regulated independently of BAZ1B and is dephosphorylated on the sex chromosomes during meiosis in contrast with the presence of adjacent γH2AX. Dephosphorylation of pTyr142 is regulated by MDC1, a binding partner of γH2AX. These results reveal the distinct regulation of two adjacent phosphorylation sites of H2AX during meiosis, and suggest that another kinase mediates Tyr142 phosphorylation.

AT-04 * TARGETING Myc DRIVEN TRANSCRIPTIONAL OUTPUT IN ATYPICAL TERATOID RHABDOID TUMOR

Atypical Teratoid Rhabdoid Tumor (ATRT) is a highly aggressive pediatric brain tumor with poor outcomes characterized by loss of the ATP dependent chromatin remodeling protein SMARCB1. We recently performed transcriptomic analysis and identified BMP signaling as an adverse prognostic marker in ATRT. We also identified EZH2 as a key epigenetic regulator in ATRT. To further evaluate ATRT biology we reexamined our patient derived transcriptomic data using bioinformatics tools. Using GSEA and Ingenuity network analysis we found that C-Myc driven transcriptional signatures are over represented in ATRT compared to normal brain. C-myc is overexpressed in ATRT patient samples and in tumor cell lines. These data are supported by previous studies that suggest Myc transcription is suppressed by SMARCB1. Genetic inhibition of C-myc potently suppresses ATRT cell growth in vitro. Importantly inhibition of C-myc strongly attenuates ATRT cell self-renewal and promotes senescence by activating cell cycle checkpoint inhibitors. We next tested a new small molecule inhibitor of Myc activity, JQ1. JQ1 inhibits BRD4 activity and thus suppresses Myc driven signaling. We show that JQ1 suppresses ATRT cell growth in vitro and decreases proliferation as measured by BrdU incorporation. JQ1 also inhibited C-myc activity as measured by luciferase reporter assays. Further JQ1 strongly suppressed the ability of ATRT cells to migrate and invade in vitro. In vivo JQ1 slowed growth of intracranial orthotopic ATRT tumors compared to DMSO control treated animals. Tumor weights were significantly smaller at necropsy in JQ1 treated animals. Most importantly JQ1 significantly increased the latency of ATRT tumor formation in vivo in a minimal residual disease model of ATRT. These data highlight the importance of c-Myc driven transcription in ATRT and provide rationale for therapeutically targeting ATRT with BET inhibitors.

Epigenetic Developmental Disorders: CHARGE syndrome, a case study.

Epigenetic events including chromatin remodeling and histone modifications have recently emerged as important contributors to a variety of neurodevelopmental disorders. This review focuses on CHARGE syndrome, a multiple anomaly condition caused by mutations in the gene encoding CHD7, an ATP-dependent chromatin remodeling protein. CHD7 exhibits pleiotropic effects during embryonic development, consistent with highly variable clinical features in CHARGE syndrome. In this review, a historical description of CHARGE is provided, followed by establishment of diagnostic criteria, gene discovery, and development of animal models. Current understanding of epigenetic CHD7 functions and interacting proteins in cells and tissues is also presented, and final emphasis is placed on challenges and major questions to be answered with ongoing research efforts.