Assembly Of Icosahedral Viruses Research Articles

Structures of a large prolate virus capsid in unexpanded and expanded states generate insights into the icosahedral virus assembly

Many icosahedral viruses assemble proteinaceous precursors called proheads or procapsids. Proheads are metastable structures that undergo a profound structural transition known as expansion that transforms an immature unexpanded head into a mature genome-packaging head. Bacteriophage T4 is a model virus, well studied genetically and biochemically, but its structure determination has been challenging because of its large size and unusually prolate-shaped, ∼1,200-Å-long and ∼860-Å-wide capsid. Here, we report the cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) structures of T4 capsid in both of its major conformational states: unexpanded at a resolution of 5.1 Å and expanded at a resolution of 3.4 Å. These are among the largest structures deposited in Protein Data Bank to date and provide insights into virus assembly, head length determination, and shell expansion. First, the structures illustrate major domain movements and ∼70% additional gain in inner capsid volume, an essential transformation to contain the entire viral genome. Second, intricate intracapsomer interactions involving a unique insertion domain dramatically change, allowing the capsid subunits to rotate and twist while the capsomers remain fastened at quasi-threefold axes. Third, high-affinity binding sites emerge for a capsid decoration protein that clamps adjacent capsomers, imparting extraordinary structural stability. Fourth, subtle conformational changes at capsomers' periphery modulate intercapsomer angles between capsomer planes that control capsid length. Finally, conformational changes were observed at the symmetry-mismatched portal vertex, which might be involved in triggering head expansion. These analyses illustrate how small changes in local capsid subunit interactions lead to profound shifts in viral capsid morphology, stability, and volume.

Cryo-EM structure of the bacteriophage T4 isometric head at 3.3-Å resolution and its relevance to the assembly of icosahedral viruses

The 3.3-Å cryo-EM structure of the 860-Å-diameter isometric mutant bacteriophage T4 capsid has been determined. WT T4 has a prolate capsid characterized by triangulation numbers (T numbers) Tend = 13 for end caps and Tmid = 20 for midsection. A mutation in the major capsid protein, gp23, produced T=13 icosahedral capsids. The capsid is stabilized by 660 copies of the outer capsid protein, Soc, which clamp adjacent gp23 hexamers. The occupancies of Soc molecules are proportional to the size of the angle between the planes of adjacent hexameric capsomers. The angle between adjacent hexameric capsomers is greatest around the fivefold vertices, where there is the largest deviation from a planar hexagonal array. Thus, the Soc molecules reinforce the structure where there is the greatest strain in the gp23 hexagonal lattice. Mutations that change the angles between adjacent capsomers affect the positions of the pentameric vertices, resulting in different triangulation numbers in bacteriophage T4. The analysis of the T4 mutant head assembly gives guidance to how other icosahedral viruses reproducibly assemble into capsids with a predetermined T number, although the influence of scaffolding proteins is also important.

Cryogenic electron microscopy and single-particle analysis.

About 20 years ago, the first three-dimensional (3D) reconstructions at subnanometer (<10-Å) resolution of an icosahedral virus assembly were obtained by cryogenic electron microscopy (cryo-EM) and single-particle analysis. Since then, thousands of structures have been determined to resolutions ranging from 30 Å to near atomic (<4 Å). Almost overnight, the recent development of direct electron detectors and the attendant improvement in analysis software have advanced the technology considerably. Near-atomic-resolution reconstructions can now be obtained, not only for megadalton macromolecular complexes or highly symmetrical assemblies but also for proteins of only a few hundred kilodaltons. We discuss the developments that led to this breakthrough in high-resolution structure determination by cryo-EM and point to challenges that lie ahead.

P22 Coat Protein Structures Reveal a Novel Mechanism for Capsid Maturation: Stability without Auxiliary Proteins or Chemical Crosslinks

Viral capsid assembly and stability in tailed, dsDNA phage and Herpesviridae are achieved by various means including chemical crosslinks (unique to HK97), or auxiliary proteins (lambda, T4, phi29, and herpesviruses). All these viruses have coat proteins (CP) with a conserved, HK97-like core structure. We used a combination of trypsin digestion, gold labeling, cryo-electron microscopy, 3D image reconstruction, and comparative modeling to derive two independent, pseudoatomic models of bacteriophage P22 CP: before and after maturation. P22 capsid stabilization results from intersubunit interactions among N-terminal helices and an extensive "P loop," which obviate the need for crosslinks or auxiliary proteins. P22 CP also has a telokin-like Ig domain that likely stabilizes the monomer fold so that assembly may proceed via individual subunit addition rather than via preformed capsomers as occurs in HK97. Hence, the P22 CP structure may be a paradigm for understanding how monomers assemble in viruses like phi29 and HSV-1.

Sindbis virus as a model for studies of conformational changes in a metastable virus and the role of conformational changes in in vitro antibody neutralisation

Sindbis virus has long been the prototypical alphavirus used in the study of assembly of icosahedral viruses which contain membranes. Much is known about the assembly pathway and molecular architecture of this virus, and models of mechanisms of infection and release of the viral RNA have been proposed. This review will focus on the structural aspects of in vitro antibody neutralisation of a metastable alphavirus, Sindbis virus, which results from antibody induced conformational changes. For the alphaviruses, structures of in vitro antibody induced conformational neutralisation for Sindbis virus, and receptor occlusion for Sindbis and Ross River virus (RRV) have been reported. A model is presented which could extend the mechanism of antibody induced conformational neutralisation to any metastable virus structure.

Biologic Constraints on Modelling Virus Assembly

The mathematic modelling of icosahedral virus assembly has drawn increasing interest because of the symmetric geometry of the outer shell structures. Many models involve equilibrium expressions of subunit binding, with reversible subunit additions forming various intermediate structures. The underlying assumption is that a final lowest energy state drives the equilibrium toward assembly. In their simplest forms, these models have explained why high subunit protein concentrations and strong subunit association constants can result in kinetic traps forming off pathway partial and aberrant structures. However, the cell biology of virus assembly is exceedingly complex. The biochemistry and biology of polyoma and papillomavirus assembly described here illustrates many of these specific issues. Variables include the use of cellular ‘chaperone’ proteins as mediators of assembly fidelity, the coupling of assembly to encapsidation of a specific nucleic acid genome, the use of cellular structures as ‘workbenches’ upon which assembly occurs, and the underlying problem of making a capsid structure that is metastable and capable of rapid disassembly upon infection. Although formidable to model, incorporating these considerations could advance the relevance of mathematical models of virus assembly to the real world.

The Structural and Functional Role of RNA in Icosahedral Virus Assembly

Despite tremendous advances in high-resolution structure determination of virus particles, the organization of encapsidated genomes and their role during assembly are poorly understood. This article summarizes recent insights from structural, biochemical, and genetic analyses of icosahedral viruses that contain single-stranded, positive-sense RNA genomes. X-ray crystallography of several viruses in this category has provided tantalizing glimpses of portions of the packaged nucleic acid, contributing crucial information on how the genome might be folded within the virion. This information combined with theoretical considerations and data from molecular approaches suggests mechanisms by which coat proteins interact with genomic RNA to shape it into a conformation that is compatible with the geometry of the virion. It appears that RNA, in addition to its function as a repository for genetic information, plays an important structural role during assembly and can on occasion override the ability of the coat protein to form a particle with defined icosahedral symmetry.

Heterologous expression of the modified coat protein of Cowpea chlorotic mottle bromovirus results in the assembly of protein cages with altered architectures and function.

We have developed methods for producing viral-based protein cages in high yield that are amenable to genetic modification. Expression of the structural protein of Cowpea chlorotic mottle bromovirus (CCMV) using the yeast-based Pichia pastoris heterologous expression system resulted in the assembly of particles that were visibly indistinguishable from virus particles produced in the natural host. We have shown that a collection of non-infectious CCMV coat protein mutants expressed in the P. pastoris system assemble into viral protein cages with altered architectures and function. This provides an alternative to other heterologous expression systems for production of viral structural proteins in which expression has resulted in unassembled cages. Heterologous expression in P. pastoris further enhances the development of viral-based protein cages as biotemplates for nanotechnology and for future studies examining details of icosahedral virus assembly.

Cold denaturation of an icosahedral virus. The role of entropy in virus assembly.

Assembly of icosahedral viruses is not completely understood at the molecular level. The main puzzle is to answer how chemically identical protein subunits take up unique positionally dependent conformations during the process of assembly. The stability of the ribonucleoprotein particles of cowpea mosaic virus (CPMV) to pressures and subzero temperatures has been studied. At room temperature, reversible pressure denaturation of CPMV is obtained only in the presence of 5.0 M urea. On the other hand, when the temperature is decreased to -15 degrees C, the ribonucleoprotein components denature, at 2.5 kbar, in the presence of 1.0 M urea. At temperatures close to -20 degrees C, denaturation is obtained even in the absence of urea. Whereas the denaturation promoted by pressure and urea at room temperature is reversible, virus particles denatured when the temperature is decreased under pressure cannot reassemble. Bis-ANS binding data suggest that this irreversibility may be related to protein release from RNA, which probably does not occur under denaturating conditions at room temperature. The contributions of enthalpy (delta H*) and entropy (delta S*) for the free energy of association of CPMV are calculated from the cold denaturation curves under pressure. The entropy change is positive and large, making the assembly of ribonucleoprotein components an entropy-driven process, suggesting that the burial of nonpolar side chains during the process of assembly is the structural foundation for CPMV assembly.

Local rule-based theory of virus shell assembly.

A local rule-based theory is developed which shows that the self-assembly of icosahedral virus shells may depend on only the lower-level interactions of a protein subunit with its neighbors--i.e., on local rules rather than on larger structural building blocks. The local rule theory provides a framework for understanding the assembly of icosahedral viruses. These include both viruses that fall in the quasiequivalence theory of Caspar and Klug and the polyoma virus structure, which violates quasi-equivalence and has puzzled researchers since it was first observed. Local rules are essentially templates for energetically favorable arrangements. The tolerance margins for these rules are investigated through computer simulations. When these tolerance margins are exceeded in a particular way, the result is a "spiraling" malformation that has been observed in nature.

RNA/protein interactions in icosahedral virus assembly

The pathway of icosahedral viral assembly is a poorly understood process. In this review we examine three model systems in which icosahedral viral assembly is initiated by the viral RNA. Bacteriophage R17, and the plant viruses turnip crinkle and cowpea chlorotic mottle virus have emerged as model systems because they combine biochemical, molecular and structural approaches to addressing assembly questions. In all three systems it is suggested that binding of capsid protein(s) to a specific RNA structure forms an assembly initiation complex which nucleates the subsequent addition of capsid protein subunits to form the completed shell. Detailed structures are not emerging on the initiation complex and the completed virus particle, but much remains to be learned about the process which leads from one to the other.

Bacteriophage T4 head models based on icosahedral symmetry.

In an accompanying paper, the coordinate variation in lengths of deoxyribonucleic acid molecules and head lengths in morphological variants of bacteriophage T4 is discussed. As an appendix to that report, models for the T4 phage heads, based on previously developed architectural principles for assembly of icosahedral virus, are compared with the data for the best fit.