340 SEER, 82, 2, 2004 Tsenova, Valeria (ed.). 'Exoriente. ..-II'. Nine Composers fromtheFormer USSR. Valentin Silvestrov, RomanLedenyov, FarajKaraev,Victor Ekimovsky, Nikolai Karetnikov, Alemdar Karamanov, Vladimir Tarnopolsky, Sergei Slonimsky, Andrei Volkonsky. Studia Slavica Musicologica: Texte und Abhandlungen zur osteuropaischenMusik,30. ErnstKuhn, Berlin, 2003. viii + 245 pp. Lists of PrincipalWorks.Musical Illustrations.Index. ?49.95 (paperback). Tsenova, Valeria (ed.). 'Exorienta. . .-III'. EightComposersfrom theFormer USSR. Alexander Knaifel, Sergei Pavlenko, BorisTishchenko, Alexander Vustin, Alexander Raskatov, Vladislav Shoot, PhilipGershkovich, Leonid Grabovsky. Studia Slavica Musicologica:Texte und Abhandlungen zur osteuropaischenMusik, 31. ErnstKuhn, Berlin,2003. viii + 207 pp. Listsof PrincipalWorks.Musical Illustrations.Index. ?49.95 (paperback). THIs remarkable series of articles about prominent contemporary Russian composers began in 2002 with the first collection of ten musicians, unfortunately not received by SEER:Viktor Suslin,Dmitrii Smirnov,Arvo Part,Iurii Kasparov, Galina Ustvol'skaia, Nikolai Sidel'nikov, Elena Firsova, Boris Chaikovskii, Vladimir Martynov, and Andrei Eshpai. Its predecessor, however , also edited by Valeriia Tsenova, was Underground Musicfrom theFormer USSR (Amsterdam, I997) (see SEER, 77, I999, I, pp. I62-65), and some of the articles in Kuhn's publications are reprinted from there: Iurii Kholopov on Volkonskii, Gershkovich and Karamanov; Valentina Kholopova on Slonimskii, Tishchenko, Ledenev and Shut' (who, incidentally, himself uses the transliterationShoot); Svetlana Savenko on Sil'vestrov, Grabovskii and Knaifel; Mikhail Tarakanov on Artemov; and Vladimir Barskiion Karaev. Fourteen of the composers in the three Kuhn volumes were not included in the I980 version of New Grove, but by the 200I edition they had all found a place. Many, although not all, have also had their music recorded, either by commercial companies or by themselves. The problems of performance, however, let alone entering the repertoire, is as difficult as it ever was, particularlyin view of contemporaryaudiences' continuing resistanceto new musical idioms, but none of these composers has been completely unperformed . ErnstKuhn has become a majorpublisherof workon Russianmusic, including collections devoted to just one composer, such as Shostakovich (several) or Aleksandr Lokshin (2002), for instance. Ex oriente... is a central part of this most commendable enterprise. The articles here go far beyond the New Grove entries, and are extremely valuable at the informational level. They are written, for the most part, by outstanding musicologists who have been prominent in fostering new music by their teaching and academic writing. This particularly applies to Iurii Kholopov and Valentina Kholopova; the former's death in 2003 was a sad blow indeed for the study and encouragement of contemporary Russian music. The general format of the articles is to outline the composer's backgroundand experience, before illustratingthe particularfeaturesof their writingwith analysisand musicalexamples, followedby a chronologicallist of principal works, in some cases going up to early 2003. The composers vary tremendouslyin manner and style, from the lyrical,often melodious Valentin Sil'vestrov to the challengingly uncompromising work of Vladislav Shut' or REVIEWS 341 the ludic extravagances of Viktor Ekimovskii.The latter'sBalletto(I974), for instance, contains a choreographed part for the conductor, and could be performed on any type of ensemble from a rock group to a symphony orchestra. An illustration of how this looks in the score is to be found in volume2,p. I93. The following list of the contents of these volumes should give some inkling of their nature and scope. Volume 2 contains: Kholopov, Andrei Volkonsky the initiator:a profileof his life and work';Kholopova, 'Sergei Slonimsky:the impetus to innovation and cultural synthesis';Kholopov, 'AlemdarKaramanov : an outsider in Soviet music'; Savenko, 'Valentin Silvestrov's lyrical universe'; Tarakanov, 'A drama of non-recognition: a profile of Nikolai Karetnikov's life and work'; Kholopova, 'The labyrinths of Roman Ledenyov 's creative work';Barskii,'FarajKarayev: "genug" or "not genug"'; and Tsenova, 'The "culturology"of Vladimir Tarnopolsky'.Volume 3 contains: Kholopov, 'Philip Gershkovich's search for the lost essence of music'; Kholopova, 'Boris Tischenko: striking spontaneity against a rationalistic background';Savenko, 'The magic of Alexander Knaifel's message'; Kholopova , 'Secrets of the Moscow composition school in Vladislav Shoot's "pure music"'; Tsenova, 'Alexander Vustin: the battlefield is the soul'; Barskii, 'Apologiaof Raskatov';andBarskii,'SergeiPavlenko:on thewayto simplicity'. It has never been easy to be a genuine composer, and in the Soviet Union most of the musiciansfeaturedhere had little, if any, help from the...