Reproductive isolation was examined between northern sympatric populations of Campostoma oligolepis and C. anomalum pullum. Some C. a. pullum populations are essentially isolated in upstream areas, but C. oligolepis are never found breeding in the absence of C. a. pullum and occasional interbreeding occurs. Ecological differences probably do not contribute much to reproductive isolation in areas where C. oligolepis occurs. The breeding period of C. oligolepis is shorter and ends more abruptly, although there is considerable temporal overlap between the two species. Postmating isolation through asymmetric hybrid inviability is important. Artificial crosses involving 0Y Campostoma anomalum pullum x 9 C. oligolepis showed increased embryo mortality during the tailbud stage of development. Morphological intermediates may have a higher mortality rate. INTRODUCTION The North American cyprinid genus Campostoma consists of four species and has been the subject of numerous systematic studies (Ross, 1958; Burr, 1976a, b; Burr and Smith, 1976; Buth and Burr, 1978; Rakocinski, 1980; Sewell et al., 1980; Zimmerman et al., 1980; Burr and Cashner, 1983). Buth and Burr (1978) showed C. anomalum and C. oligolepis to be closely related, and equidistant from the more primitive C. ornatum. However, their study also raised some questions concerning relationships between two subspecies of C. anomalum, C. a. anomalum and C. a. pullum, with C. oligolepis. Campostoma a. anomalum populations were genetically more similar to C. oligolepis populations than were northern C. a. pullum populations. However, geographical and morphological data do not unequivocally support this interpretation (Burr, 1976a, b; Burr and Smith, 1976; Burr and Cashner, 1983). Campostoma oligolepis is sympatric with C. a. pullum throughout much of its range (Burr and Smith, 1976), and it is also occasionally syntopic with C. pauciradii (Burr and Cashner, 1983), although it does not come into contact with C. a. anomalum. Some populations of C. a. anomalum and C. a. pullum intergrade geographically (Burr, 1976b; Trautman, 1981). Burr and Smith (1976) proposed that C. oligolepis diverged in the Ozark uplands, sometime during the Pleistocene; however, new findings of an extended range for C. oligolepis and of the previously unknown C. pauciradii may make a reconsideration of this hypothesis necessary (Burr and Cashner, 1983). Reproductive isolation between sympatric populations of Campostoma oligolepis and C. anomalum pullum is incomplete as these fishes hybridize in northern Illinois (Rakocinski, 1980). Buth and Burr (1978) also suggested the occurrence of introgression in Illinois populations. The presumption of complete reproductive isolation has also been challenged for C. oligolepis and C. a. pullum in the Ozark uplands (Sewell et al., 1980). Burr and Cashner (1983) found limited hybridization between C. oligolepis and C. pauciradii, mainly due to habitat disturbance. In spite of such interbreeding, gene pools of these species have apparently remained distinct throughout their respective ranges (Buth and Burr, 1978; Zimmerman et al., 1980). Since C. oligolepis is in secondary contact with C. a. pullum, and since interbreeding may occur, isolating mechanisms may be especially important. The purpose of this study is to examine some factors affecting genetic integrity of northern sympatric populations of these two species.
Read full abstract