Reviewed by: Tragedy and Postcolonial Literature by Ato Quayson Mahruba T. Mowtushi Tragedy and Postcolonial Literature BY ATO QUAYSON Cambridge UP, 2021. 346 pp. ISBN 9781108921992 paper. Ato Quayson's Tragedy and Postcolonial Literature opens with lamentations for the hanging of Ken Saro-Wiwa by the Nigerian government in 1995 and ends with the murders of Treyvon Martin at the hands of George Zimmerman in 2012 and George Floyd by the American police in 2020. These events, separated by thousands of miles, and twenty-five years of social injustice, are not dissimilar in their tragic magnitudes for history repeats itself in real life as it does on stage and the pages of literature. The search for collective freedom and individual agency in the face of colonial hegemony, sociopolitical turmoil, and cultural oppression informs Ato Quayson's latest book. The volume reconsiders postcolonial writing vis-à-vis the history of literary tragedy from the Greek and Renaissance traditions to contemporary multicultural examples from around the world. In doing so, Quayson reassesses Western tragedy through a postcolonial paradigm. In order to comprehend Aristotelian anagnorisis, Quayson argues that we need to read Chinua Achebe and take into consideration the Akan concept of musuo, which translates as taboo or "harms to the soul." Quayson is concerned with examining questions on ethics by linking them to representations of pathos and suffering in postcolonial writing where suffering is defined as the experience of the impending annihilation of the self or the perception of imminent dangers to the self from external forces. Quayson arrives at a distinct hermeneutical interpretation of suffering, and thereby of tragedy, by way of an eclectic range of references from Eric J Castell's The Nature of Suffering and the Goals of Medicine, Cicero's Disputation on Grief, Frantz Fanon's Black Skin, White Masks, and to Akan musuo. In the second chapter on "Ethical Cosmopolitanism and Shakespeare's Othello," the author resorts to a "postcolonializing of Shakespeare" (44) that assesses how Elizabethan social ideas about race, cultural identity, and "cosmopolitan contradictions" (45) reflect on contemporary critical debates on multiculturalism, cosmopolitanism, and postcolonialism. The conditions of colonial modernity in Chinua Achebe's "rural narratives" (Things Fall Apart and Arrow of God) inform the third chapter that considers whether Okonkwo, a character imbued with ethical contradictions, is a tragic figure and if so, how does the reader evaluate ethical choice-making concerning his actions. The "dialectical assimilation of opposites" (115) in the tragic characters in Death and the King's Horseman and The Road informs [End Page 198] chapter four that interrogates elements reminiscent of ancient Greek tragedy such as anagnorisis in Wole Soyinka's dramaturgy. In Tayeb Salih's Season of Migration to the North, which is the focus of chapter five, Quayson identifies the novel's scrupulous intertextuality and "literary echoes" as enacting a mirroring effect with the tragic parameters that govern key texts in the Western literary canon. The "melancholic introjection" of Mustafa Sa'eed and his "self-authorship" (185) as a colonized self and subject enable Quayson to classify thematic and ideational parameters that make Salih's novel postcolonial but also tragic. Chapter six turns to the "terrible beauty" of Toni Morrison's Beloved where the "tragic vision" of Sethe killing her daughter incites a moment of "split anagnorisis" in the character of Baby Suggs (187). For Quayson, the rationale (if it can be called that) behind Sethe's terrible action should be interpreted in light of the novel's brutally honest delineation of the history of slavery in the United States. The case of infanticide in Beloved must be read alongside other literary examples of infanticide from sources as diverse as "the Bible, Aeschylus, Euripides, George Eliot, Eugene O'Neill, Sam Shepherd, Chinua Achebe," and others (187). The absolute certainty that governs the choices made by the tragic figures in Morrison, Soyinka, and Achebe is dissipated when one comes to J. M. Coetzee's fictional characters who, according to Quayson in chapter seven in the book, labor tragically under the constraints of ethical challenges and second thoughts, a situation that is both ontologically and epistemologically problematic. The torturous cogitations of the adult world of "Big Things" in Arundhati Roy's...
Read full abstract