The reaction of (chlorinated) phenoxy radicals with chlorophenols recently has been discussed as a source of gas-phase dioxin formation in incineration. As a surrogate for this reaction, we studied the analogous reaction (1) of phenoxy ( Φ O) with chlorobenzene ( Φ Cl) in a well-stirred reactor between 728 and 984 K. The slow combustion of phenol served as a continuous Φ O source, and chlorobenzene was used as cofuel. Stable end products and reactants were analyzed by gas chromatography (GC), in particular Φ Cl, dibenzofuran (DF), and diphenylether ( Φ O Φ ), the direct product of reaction 1. This made it possible to measure k 1 in competition with Φ O recombination, reaction (2) for which an overall rate coefficient had earlier been established in our laboratory. The Arrhenius parameters for reaction (1) are A 1 =4.8×10 8 L/mol s, E a1 =24.5 kcal/mol When these parameters are adopted for the reaction of chlorinated phenoxy radicals with chlorophenol, an agreement with an earlier kinetic analysis of Shaub and Tsang is achieved that has a meaning for dioxin formation. The given parameters render this reaction at temperatures below 1000 K too slow to contribute significantly as a gas-phase dioxin source. However, since gas-phase dioxin formation recently has been detected in a flow reactor during trichlorophenol combustion with maximum yields of dioxin around 900 K. another dioxin source must be found consequently, we suggest the gas-phase recombination of chlorinated phenoxy radicals.
Read full abstract